Curious about upgrading?
Wondering where to start?
Complex questions that need answers?
Is there a better structure for you?
"They managed to navigate my complex expat income and even got my Google RSU income approved as well."
"I highly recommend Alcove to anyone looking for a mortgage broker who is responsive, trustworthy, and truly cares about their clients. Thanks again to the whole team for making the process such a positive experience!"
"As founders, we're constantly jumping between things so having a partner that handled the details & made the process super clear made the buying process breezy for us. Very happy with the experience!"
“It almost felt like it was his responsibility to make it clear to me, not my responsibility to understand it.”
“I've been pretty much fully leveraged the whole time. So the sounding board on that, in terms of what was achievable, what wasn't — I think trust is just built along that.”
"Alcove has been a great partner. They look after my audience properly, keep things simple, and deliver real value. I’ve got full confidence referring clients knowing they’ll get honest, straightforward advice."
"Property is one of the biggest financial decisions people make. Alcove stood out because they take a strategic approach to lending - helping clients structure property and debt decisions in a way that genuinely supports their broader financial plans."
Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.


Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
PropTrack's senior economist explains why Sydney prices rose every month of 2023 even as affordability hit the worst level on record. The answer is largely about who was able to keep buying.
In this episode, we're talking with senior economist Paul Ryan from REA Group's PropTrack, and we're going to discuss how can it be that prices are rising even though it's well accepted that we have an affordability problem? What does housing unaffordability even mean and how is it measured?
And why is it that we have a shortage of housing with declining approvals and yet what is being built is not being built where we want to live?
Welcome to the elephant in the room. This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about.
I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, recently ranked number five in Australia out of over 18,000 brokers in the annual MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Award. Before we get started I need to let you know that nothing we say here can be taken as personal advice.
We always recommend you engage the services of an appropriate and experienced professional.
Our guest today is Paul Ryan. Paul is a senior economist at REA Group, specialising in housing finance, market forecasting and big data analysis.
And before joining REA in December 2020, he spent a decade at the Reserve Bank of Australia conducting research on the Australian economy, focusing on housing markets, lending risks and regulatory effects on property markets. Paul is based in Sydney and this is the second time we've had the pleasure of his company.
Thank you so much for joining us today, Paul.
Thank you very much for having me again.
Paul, thanks so much for coming on on this 38 degree day. I just want to wind you out a bit more. But, you know, I absolutely love talking to yourselves and Domain and throw them in there straight at the start.
But, you know, just because the amount of data you guys get access to and the quality of that is just so enticing for someone like myself. Before we go in a bit of a conversation around affordability and the overall picture that REA is sort of seeing, I mean, what's your take on
The property market in 2023 and coming into 2024, I always like as an economist to sort of see what you guys are thinking under the hood.
Yeah, it's been, I mean, it's been a few years of very interesting property market occurrences. But we started the year very, very slow in terms of particularly activity. So we came out of the second half of 2022, prices falling quite persistently.
And prices falling quite persistently, particularly at the top end of the market. We saw Sydney and Melbourne seeing declining prices. I think this time last year... Prices in Sydney were down 6.4% over the prior 12 months, and particularly in the more affluent parts of the market.
So we saw, I think, a really persistent trend where the most expensive regions were seeing the biggest falls. And that seemed to be consistent with really constrained borrowing capacities as the Reserve Bank raised rates at the fastest rate on record. Then we came into 2023 and things started to change.
They started changing prices first. So we saw in Sydney prices start to rise in January and we actually saw prices rise every month this year. And then it wasn't until kind of May in Sydney that activity started to take off and activity picked up in Melbourne at the same kind of time.
So we've seen kind of a year of two halves. The first year, first half of the year, Slow activity, second half of the year, actually quite solid activity.
In Sydney and Melbourne, we actually saw more activity in August in 2023 than we saw in 2021, which was, you know, the biggest year for transactions in a decade.
Yeah, and that's what you mean by activity.
Yeah.
Being transactions, so properties selling. Transactions, sorry, yes. Transacting, yes. Prices can rise and activity can be low or vice versa, I guess.
And that's what we're seeing at the start of the year is rising prices, but people not listing properties, people not transacting.
And do you think, why are you talking about activity days? Is it... You know, at REA, I reckon activity and listing numbers matter a lot, right? Like that's your revenue stream.
And, you know, I guess when you look at longer term trends around listing numbers and turnover rates and, you know, and all, like you want to look at your housing report, property market outlook report here, you know, total monthly listings are at 10 year low, right?
Like how does REA feel around this on a personal side, but also what do you think's driving this you know, very low amount of activity that's decade lows.
Obviously, at REA Group, we care a lot about turnover because it's important for our financial performance. But if we take a step back as a housing economist,
turnover is one of those things that signifies that households are doing something, right? When households sell properties and move home, it's for a number of reasons.
And we've seen over the past decade that people are less likely to sell homes and upgrade or sell homes for whatever reason. So there's a number of reasons for that. And I think one of them is transaction costs. Stamp duty has become a bigger burden as prices have increased.
So, I mean, that's a simple incentive structure there. It's much more expensive to transact property than it used to be. The other one is demographics. People tend to transact properties when they're in the prime of their lives. You get this... housing upgrade cycle.
So people buy homes when they're starting a young family, they outgrow the house, their incomes rise as they kind of come into those prime working years and they move into bigger homes.
And then ideally, if it's not too expensive, kids move out of the home, they sell their large home and move into something that's more appropriate for their twilight years. So as demographics shift, we kind of expect as people age, maybe a bit less turnover.
It's hard to disentangle all of those pieces.
Do you think people are doing that though?
Do you think that that dream of, hey, I'm going to get this apartment, I'm going to buy a house and I'm going to get a beer house and then I'm going to get the house with the view and then I'm going to get the house with the view and the pool and then I'm going to downsize and I'm going to get this...
Do you think that that dream is dead to some extent at REA?
Do you think that that ability to do that with transaction costs and borrowing capacities and the affordability and the mortgage that it costs to do that, the people are actually forced to, even the demographics should say, hey, I'm at an age where my kids are bigger and I need more space, but we've got to make it work now in a three-bed house because that's just all we can afford.
Yeah.
I think it's increasingly difficult. There is a very clear trend that people are buying their first home and getting into a home ownership later. Now, is that housing affordability? I would suggest that that's a big part of it. But we also have seen culture change.
More people go to university than they used to. People get married later. People have children later. All of these are intertwined. Part of that, you know, people having kids later is partly because houses are more unaffordable. Yeah. But partly it's just a cultural shift that's happened.
So, yeah, if people are getting into the housing market later, there's just naturally less of that stepping up and stepping down throughout time. The difficult question is, like, what's normal housing turnover? We often look back to, say, the early 2000s, for instance.
There was a lot of housing turnover then, but that also followed a lot of financial deregulation that opened up credit to a lot more people, particularly second earners and women, for instance.
There was a period where women of childbearing ages weren't lent money because banks said, you're going to leave the workforce and have a child. And so that changed. And so people could borrow more money and that supported people basically moving into the homes that they wanted to be in.
um and that maybe was just a temporary boost so it's hard to get a a feel for what what is the kind of what's the the the new normal or uh since those changes it's interesting because you hear a lot of very simplistic uh explanations for you know for where why we are where we are and i and i love sort of you bringing in the nuances here and
Talking about demographics, but also talking about affordability and talking about the change in societal changes in terms of how we partner up when we have children and who's allowed to borrow money and how many incomes are actually contributing towards the family home, et cetera, et cetera.
You know, I once heard Alan Kohler say that the reason housing is expensive in Australia is not because it's unaffordable. It's actually precisely because people can afford it that make it expensive. So what would be your take on that?
So there's an aspect to that. I mean, if we look across countries, housing looks very, very expensive in Australia compared to elsewhere.
And that's partly because Australians are one of the wealthiest, highest income societies in the world. We had until the COVID-19 pandemic avoided recession for the longest run of history than any country. We set a record just before that.
just before the pandemic, Australia has had a very long run of prosperity and living standards have risen quite rapidly in Australia. Geographies matter for that, obviously, as well.
You know, Australia is a large country, but we can't actually build or we don't build in very much of the country. And our cities tend to be geographically constrained. Sydney, for instance, by water and mountains. These things all matter.
Households have beat up prices because they're optimistic about the future and because incomes are high. But it is still the case that if we had more homes, if we built more homes, if we densified our cities, housing would be more available and more affordable.
That's the reality here is people are bidding for what is a scarce resource in our country.
I think there will always be certain types of housing that will be scarce, you know what I mean? If we go for density and upzoning, then we're going to have lots and lots of, you know, small apartments and that won't make the house any less desirable.
In fact, it'll probably make it even more desirable. So, and it'd be interesting to see how that all plans out. But you sort of touched on something there about Australia being one of the most expensive countries in the world for housing. Yeah.
And there are a number of different ways to measure affordability and to make that calculation. Can you sort of give us the insights as to, you know, it's often commented and I would say that I'm guessing there's not one single metric that is relied upon by all commentators.
And so I'd be keen to understand your insights there. and what light you can shed on that. How is affordability measured? How is it, you know, on what metric are we one of the most expensive countries in the world to live in?
So affordability is one of the passion projects of mine. It's one of the kind of main reasons I kind of jumped into housing specifically. And we actually released this year our inaugural PropTrack Housing Affordability Index. And that's something we developed recently.
Exactly to answer this question is how do we think about measuring housing affordability? Because I think one of the ones that's been used for a long time has been house prices compared with incomes. Yeah. And I think that has some downsides.
And the main downside there is that as interest rates have fallen, you expect housing prices to increase as a share of people's income because you can support more debt on a given level of income.
But also, isn't it a sort of got a flaw in the sense that it is, you know, if everybody was a first home buyer at an account, but because a lot of people are not first home buyers, you know, they're buying, they're upgrading, they've got equity that they've had by virtue of growing crisis.
So it sort of loses its connectivity, you know, the correlation to income sort of falls away a bit at that point, doesn't it?
Yeah, the problem is always matching. What you really want to get sense for is you've got some people who want to buy a home and they have some income and then you've got homes that are for sale and that costs them something.
But looking across, you know, if you look at just average incomes or median incomes, obviously that's taking in a big group of people, people who are very young, people who are very old and own their home outright. And what you really want to do is narrow in on that group of buyers.
How tough is it for them? And measures that I think are quite good is looking at the burden of mortgage serviceability. So how much if you were a prime age worker and you went to buy a typical home, how much of your income would you have to devote to mortgage repayments?
That's a good starting point. The index that we constructed actually looks at people's incomes all across the spectrum, so across the distribution of incomes.
And we basically took, hey, if you're a household with a median income, if you're a household with an income at the 80th percentile, how many homes that transacted, that sold throughout the year, could you afford to buy under normal assumptions? Current mortgage rates, a 30-year loan term,
and what we think a lender would lend you. And the end result was that is that we actually found that housing affordability in Australia in 2022-23, so the last financial year, was the worst on record, the worst since at least 1995.
As a kind of data point here, we calculated is if you were a typical household in Australia, you had the median income, you could afford just 13% of all homes that sold over that year. And I think what this tells you is that you're exactly right, Veronica.
Wealth matters hugely for housing in Australia. People predominantly, even first-time buyers increasingly now, rely on wealth to get into the market because the price levels are so high. If we go back to, say, the mid-'90s, the late-'90s, things were more even.
Someone at the middle of the income distribution could afford half of all homes that sold. And that was, you know, the old Joe Hockey remark, right? Get a good job and a good income and you can buy a home. That was what things were like in the 1990s.
And things have slowly changed as prices have increased. So interest rates have decreased. That's a really important thing that has boosted borrowing capacities and boosted people's ability to pay. But that's meant with higher prices that the deposit burden has become more and more difficult for first-term buyers, but not for upgraders.
And to bring it to more recent developments, data, we're seeing upgraders make up a bigger part of the market this year. And I think that's part of the reason why prices have been so resilient to higher interest rates is that upgraders are less affected by constrained borrowing capacities.
So who's buying the upgraders' homes then? Is it downsizers? Because if it's circular in that way, if you don't have new entrants or you've got less new entrants into the marketplace, then people must be trading within it. Is that fair to say?
A little bit. We have seen a pickup in investor activity. Investors are kind of back to about a third of new credit. So, despite mortgage rates obviously constraining investor cash flows, we've seen rents increase really, really strongly this year. Rents are up 15% nationally. I think...
What we're seeing is first-time buyers, obviously, they're still in the market. And we had a huge bring forward of first-time buyer activity throughout the pandemic. First-time buyers have pulled back a bit because of these affordability constraints. Investors have kind of taken their place a bit at the bottom end of the market.
And we're seeing upgraders propping up, very much the top end of the market. We're seeing the expensive parts of Sydney and Melbourne have all performed well. In Sydney, for instance, the east and north are up 10% in the past 12 months.
do you think though that uh a bit like climate change that you know the worst year affordability on record is this year the next year it's going to be like the worst year of all record affordability is this year like like ultimately there's a structural problem right and and inequality um is getting worse and it will get worse because absolutely intergenerational wealth and the baby boomers over the next 10-15 years are starting to shift that wealth down and
Not everyone's got that luxury, right?
And do you see that affordability metrics that based on someone's income is going to really lose its value because it's going to go off the charts and because the people entering the market are going to be the people with money that's coming down from their parents and their grandparents.
or people who have already been in the market for some time who are transacting with big deposits. The first-time buyer that's entering the market typically is going to get pushed out because it's going to favor people who are cashed up.
Yeah, I think that's the societal concern here, right? When you say first-time buyers are pushed out, fundamentally you mean... pushed out and not able to buy, or they have to wait longer, or they're physically pushed further and further peripherally in cities.
And we see where new suburbs are built very, very far away from CBDs at the moment, which is why I'm a big fan of densification. Smaller, cheaper homes that are in better locations, they're easier to provide services to, they're kind of where first-time buyers want to live.
But yeah, I think... this will increasingly become like a political problem. It is who do we want? How do we want,
housing to be owned in the country um and i think increasingly even people with a huge amount of housing wealth are recognizing um you know we go i've talked i did a forum in the eastern suburbs of sydney a very affluent area and you know people there often own their homes but they were worried about you know where's my child can't live here um without significant um input in in funds so you
I think this is becoming people recognizing that it's not just kind of like, hey, I've got mine, so good luck everyone else. There is a broader issue when people are locked out of the market in the way that they are at the moment.
So I think that definitely will be the case. People won't want their property values to fall in value, right? And I'm happy to help, but only if my property value goes up still. I'm happy to go a slower rate, but it still needs to go up.
And so what other things do you think that, how is the government going to navigate that sort of soft landing of, you know, solving the pressures of society and the issues of growing, you know, the first-time buyers and, you know, affordability? You know, do you think it's going to be bank innovation?
Do you think we're going to see, you know, big densification? Do you think we're going to, what, what? Do you think it's on the roadmap over the next five, 10 years? Because a big part of this is also the rental crisis, right?
They've gone and blamed investors for eight years on reason why house prices are unaffordable. Investors have left the market and now we've got a worse rental crisis on history. So what do you think is going to be some of the solutions that they have to do?
Yeah, I think that's another impressive trend this year is how the narrative has shifted on housing affordability. And increasingly, the, like, yes, in my backyard, the YIMBY movement has gained, has kind of come from nowhere in 12 months to be...
really at the forefront of all of these discussions. It used to be the case that a development was proposed and media reports would be, and these brave locals are fighting against greedy developers who want to build homes in this area. And now there's a bit of balance from, you know,
generally younger people saying, actually, if this is an area that we are ever going to be able to afford, we need to be able to accept some development. So that's shifted and also government policy has shifted. So we've seen in Victoria and New South Wales in particular, moves towards densification.
There's a general recognition that that is the overall solution here. It's not just throwing more money in terms of grants or stamp duty concessions at first home buyers. We need kind of more wholesale solutions. But I do agree, Chris. I think there's a lot of room here for innovation in the financial sense.
How can we lower that deposit burden for first-term buyers? The 20% deposit kind of requirement that fundamentally comes through APRA, basically banks have higher capital charges for loans that have smaller than 20% deposits.
Um, that's something that was, as far as I'm aware, it dates back to kind of the 1970s when prices were significantly lower. Um, so I don't think that's kind of. performing the role that it's intended to.
What it's intended to do is show that if you are going to be credit worthy, you need to have shown that you can save a certain portion of the home before you get into the market. I think that's probably a little over egged at the moment.
So yeah, I think there's at the margin there on financing, I think there's things we can do, but the solution here is to just let's let people borrow more and more money. The solution here is working on housing abundance.
Yeah, I mean, and obviously inherent in that is you have to be thinking about proper planning and creating good communities and environments and that sort of stuff rather than just whacking up lots and lots of shitty apartments, which we've already seen in many, many places.
Because the thing is, and I guess in a way this gets to another article that you've written, a number of articles, but you have written an article about the shortage of homes Um, and yet where supply is concentrated, uh, isn't necessarily where we people want to live.
And so there's sort of this, um, argument that, okay, you've got to build more in order to make housing affordable. But if it was built and it was nice place to live, and it was built in a nice location where it's a nice place to live.
and suddenly it's affordable, then people are going to go, yay, and then you're going to get heaps of demand and that's going to push up prices, right?
So therefore, I sort of read your article about this shortage of homes in the right locations and I thought to myself, what would happen if lots more homes were built in the right locations that were attractive, right?
But you also talked about a significant amount of well-located spare housing. that policy changes could unlock. What do you mean by that?
So there's two kind of parts there. So one is like where we build homes.
And if we look at what's been approved for development across cities, if we look at detached housing, particularly in case, if we think about Sydney and Melbourne and Brisbane in particular, they're very far from the city, which makes sense. Where can we build new suburbs? They're quite far away.
But even if we look at high density, so we're talking about townhouses, you know,
Apartment blocks, yes, but also all kind of forms of high-density dwellings. They also tend to be quite far-flung, particularly in Sydney, less so in Melbourne and Brisbane, who have done quite well in locating new homes close to CBD where there are services with their transport links.
But is that really because of the cost of land though? You know, like if the ground field site or the sort of infield sites are located in areas where there's high land values when it's residentially zoned, particularly if you've got high density there.
then that automatically leads on to the cost to the developer of the site is going to be higher. That's going to be a knock-on cost to the individual dwellings. You know what I mean?
Like, so it sort of, you know, it sort of stands to reason if you're going to create affordable housing unless the government's chipping in some of the costs, some of the, you know, tipping in some of the money, that affordable housing is not going to exist in areas that are highly in demand.
Right.
No, it's not. But the situation at the moment is that where development is allowed, so where someone could say an apartment block is a good example, where you can build an apartment block in Sydney is only really ex-industrial areas.
There's very little scope at the moment for upzoning any existing residential areas. So that narrows the number of available sites across the city to such a small area where only... really, you know, large developments can make sense for the developer. And that's why you get those, you know, in certain pockets.
And if you look at the development profile across Sydney, you get these pockets like Ryde, like Parramatta, where you get really big towers because there's very few sites. And when they can get a site that you can do it, you try and maximize the number of dwellings on there.
And what I think densification as a concept, as I think about it, is if you make...
More areas across the city available to be up zoned and not to the extent of enormous towers, but say, you know, three or four storey or even just townhouses, you know, a three storey townhouse amalgamate two or three large house blocks. But you do that everywhere.
It means that developable land falls in price. More and more of these developments become possible for developers. And we're not just cramming people. You're either in a detached house on 400 or 600 square metres right next to a big tower.
We're spreading that burden out across the city too. I think that's...
that's kind of the type of city that people want to live in. If we go overseas, people love places like Barcelona, places like Paris, where you see exactly that kind of medium density profile across the whole city.
But that's like built in a way that, you know, Barcelona is a fantastic example. You've got this really cleverly designed sort of hexagonal blocks, you know, and there's entire city blocks built that way.
Um, whereas if you're talking about sort of the middle ring and the missing middle ring, a lot of people are referring to and thinking, okay, well, there's all these suburban house slots and maybe they're all 400 square meters or 500 square meters or whatever.
And a whole bunch of people band together and then sold them off to a developer, did a row of townhouses sympathetic with the.
fits in with the other houses, isn't it going to result in the remaining houses either being massively, I guess they could be massively devalued depending on the sort of the type of development that could happen next to them or massively increased in value because their scarcity suddenly, you know, their scarcity skyrockets.
So, you know, I don't want to buy the, and so then your availability of those sites is going to go down because once again, the prices are going to go up because for three people with houses all next to each other to bandy up to sell to developers, suddenly the costs go crazy because their land value has gone up.
Is that feasible? You know, like, I mean, is the only way around that to basically increase density or up zone so much that it becomes really unattractive to be one of those remaining houses? Yeah.
I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions. And you can find out all about what I'm working on at veronicamorgan.com.au.
And there you'll find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program, access to suburb help for investors, or if you're looking to buy your dream home or an investment property in Sydney's inner west, eastern suburbs, or lower North Shore, you can connect with my team at Good Deeds Property Buyers.
If you're thinking about buying your first home, upgrading to a new one or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Please reach out via our website, wealthful.com.au.
Don't forget that you can download our free full or forecaster report. Which experts can you trust to get it right? Theelephantintheroom.com.au.
I think quite the opposite. I think this is part of the way that we sell this is that by upzoning, if you have a house that's 800 square metres and you have the opportunity to upzone, you personally stand to financially benefit from that because the value of your land's increased.
But if your home gets sold and it gets made into three townhouses, the total cost for those three homes is less than it would have been otherwise. So we have, you know, slightly smaller homes, but there's more homes.
And that will, in general, push the average price for a home down, but the upzoning will increase the prices of those homes that can be developable. So...
Like I kind of see this as a win-win there's at the moment you don't have this like you've got to either have you got to jump from an apartment that you can afford to a freestanding house and there's not a lot in between there and what if you don't need a whole freestanding house like what if you're happy with a townhouse there isn't that option.
Yeah, there's lots of suburbs in Sydney, I think, say, you know, around Canada Bay, you know, Five Dot, Rod Point, those sort of suburbs where there's heaps of these, you know, original bungalows being knocked down and a mansion basically being built in its place.
So you can see that there's no heritage overlay in these areas. You can see there's obviously great demand to live in them. And I could certainly see that if council had managed to be a bit more forethinking
back when they started allowing that to happen, you could see that that could have been in a really great way to densify those areas.
One of the other things that I noticed in one of your articles, and tell me if I got this wrong, but I sort of read it that you are saying that a home builder, so that was that government initiative that came out in COVID that basically has led to the profitless boom for builders and a lot of people going broke.
that by virtue of stimulating more house construction, as in single dwellings, individual dwellings, it's actually diverted trades, resources, et cetera, away from building higher density dwellings and thereby actually contributing to our housing shortage?
That appears to be, yeah, that's a simplistic reading of the data is that we saw on first glance throughout the COVID pandemic, obviously, if we think back to 2020, there were huge concerns about basically the economy cratering.
And one of the easiest industries to stimulate is the building industry. And so HomeBuilder was designed to keep people in the building industry in work. And it provided grants basically to build new homes and also to do renovations.
But it was harder to tick the boxes to get a renovation across the line to get the grant. So it ended in a lot of detached building in new suburbs, but so much so that there's been huge capacity constraints.
And obviously the increase in building materials costs that's happened throughout the pandemic constrained that as well. But we've got this situation at the moment where, yeah, we boosted detached housing a little bit. We had quite strong construction of detached homes. We've still got a lot under construction.
I think something like twice as many as we normally have under construction. There's a lot of half-built homes that are waiting for trades and waiting for materials and so on.
But both that boom in detached construction as well as the other thing that the government did to stimulate things, which was bring forward public work, so public infrastructure, diverted a lot of resources that could have been in higher density construction.
We've had quite a depressed amount of units, townhouses, those kind of things being built. Now, that's not entirely the full story because as we talked briefly about before, Part of the issue with high-density construction has been getting those projects off the ground in terms of financing.
And a big input to that is getting investors to sign on the dotted line because mostly it's investors who are willing to say, yes, I want to buy an off-the-plan apartment that I'm not going to be able to see for three years or something like that.
that's a key pathway to getting those projects built is getting investors in at an early stage. And that has been difficult really, really since kind of 2015, 16.
Paul, what's your take on the, back to the last conversation around that heritage overlay. There's,
You know, do you think that we should sort of just take this as a casualty of growing our city that, you know, the beautiful old heritage home on the great street in the trees and that tree, that beautiful street that's a hundred meter walk from the train station and is surrounded by lots of other streets of heritage homes that we just have to say these.
this land's more productive for our city to, to densify. Um, and we just let go of the desire for keeping that architectural sort of streetscape, um, within, and we have to take down these homes to densify. Or do you think heritage matters more? Like there's that real battle, right?
Because, you know, some of the areas where people want to live the most is where it's the most heritage overlays. You think about low and offshore of Sydney, right? And, and so... What's your take on that? Like, is this just the way it is? We have to densify and heritage overlays don't matter.
It's a really emotional argument for lots of people.
Like, there are a lot of suburbs that are lovely and they're lovely because they are low density, lovely tree lined streets.
And I think there has to be a balance.
You know, Australia is growing, cities are growing, and that's the reason, you know, part of the reason why Australia has been so prosperous, if we go back to the earlier discussion, why has Australia performed so well economically since the 1990s is partly because it's a young, growing country. We...
pulling people from all across the world, the smartest people from elsewhere. If we're going to continue that, then there needs to be balance in terms of building new homes.
And where I stand on this is that we absolutely need to retain elements of heritage and the past and how homes have been built in the past is super important to that and how suburbs were in the past are important to that.
But areas that are close to, say, new train lines and are well serviced by schools, hospitals, roads, projects like that, then that is where I would start that trade-off. I think it's...
I think it's a travesty to have a large single-family home that is 100 metres from a new train station when it could be 12 apartments or three townhouses and have young families in there and close to work and taking advantage of the Australia that people grew up with.
It's not the houses, right? It's the culture and all the amenity that we get from it.
It's true that, you know, and I often though I walk through various older areas and you see some ugly red brick block of units or some horrible old 1970s skyrise and you look at the surrounding homes and you think, oh, what they knocked over to build that.
So even though I don't live in one of those big grand old homes, I still feel the loss of it. So maybe I'm one of those sort of nostalgic, romantic types, although I normally would view myself as a pragmatist, so I'm glad you think there should be a balance.
There's also some of the research you've done, I thought was quite interesting as well. It seems to show that on one hand, households close to the CBD are the most crowded because you've got a lot of workers' cottages in these areas as well, right?
But also the spread of spare bedrooms seems to follow the same pattern. So how can those two things sort of coincide? So can you, have I read that correctly?
Yeah. Yeah. So this is an interesting feature of the topology and demographics of cities.
If you look particularly among renters or households that have non-off bedrooms, so what happens is everyone fills in the census and the ABS calculates, well, there's four people in this house and there's only one bedroom. This is an overcrowded house. And it's
It'll be people staying in the same room and so on and so forth. And then by contrast, you'll have houses where it's a five bedroom house and there'll be two people living in it. And so what we see is that particularly for younger households, there is quite a lot of overcrowding.
And, you know, you can think of a classic like uni share house as an example here. And where people choose to overcrowd houses are those expensive inner city areas where
And at the same time, due to the development profile where we've got huge big bungalows that are, you know, five kilometers from CBD, five, 10, 15 kilometers from CBD, we have a ton of empty nesters with three, four, five bedroom homes who are using one bedroom of their, of their homes. And, um,
So on one hand, that's entirely fine. I think that people should be able to stay in their family home as long as they want.
But at the moment, not only is there no incentive to downsize or to make those large homes available to kind of young families, you're disincentivized and you're mainly disincentivized by stamp duty because it'll cost you tens of thousands of dollars to sell your home and buy a new one.
But it's also there's lots of other structural financial constraints. So the family home is not included in the pension assets test. So you can keep your pension. You can live in your four bedroom home on the lower North Shore.
And, you know, there's a huge financial cost for you to make those housing resources available to someone else. So I think... if we look across our cities, we've actually got a huge amount of housing that we're not using.
So rather than having these uproarious discussions about heritage and knocking over homes, we could just start to use the homes we already have in a more efficient way. And all that requires is to make it easy for people to move to a home that suits their circumstances. We've got
Yeah, thousands and thousands, tens of thousands of spare bedrooms. And again, it's perfectly fine to have a spare bedroom. But I think there's lots of people out there who, if it wasn't so financially disadvantageous, they would love to downsize. And that would bring down housing prices.
Do you think that that's the missing ingredient here is if we said, hey, no stamp duty if you want to downsize. I mean, it's not going to be very politically popular that you're giving baby boomers a free kick.
But there's a lot of other things that they care about rather than stamp duty, like the pension, you know, the home in the pension test. Is there actually something they want to downsize into? Exactly.
Are there townhouses, right? Are there bigger apartments?
And that stuff they want exactly. And they want that in premium locations. You're not going to download stuff from a big house into something a bit tiny. Like it has to be sexy, right? You've got the kids involved here.
They want to stay in the same area too. Same area. Yeah.
Like, and you've got to think about the inheritance here as well. Like it's a bit, you know, the kids are watching their parents in their home. They're going, hey, mom and dad. Why don't you stay in his home for the next 20 years?
Because I know that money's coming to me rather than you downsizing, putting money into your super fund and spending it.
But that would be part of it. I do think there's that element as well where the kids want their parents to stay in their home and they say, hey, we want to come here for Christmas every year and yours is the house that we come to. We've never even got an apartment, right?
And so... Do you think this downsizing thing, and also the people are living a lot longer, right? Like even, not even going to aged care homes because, hey, why don't you stay at your home and we'll bring care to your home. So. Yes. Like, how does, how do we navigate this?
Because it's, it's like they tried the $300,000 into super and I think that's just, it's not enough, right? Because then on one side you're saying, hang on a second, you can only have so much in your super anyway before we tax you.
So it's usually people who are usually on the more affluent area. So. How do we get these downsizes to downsize? Because if you could create turnover there, and I'm sure REA are thinking about this problem, then you're right.
You can get people to move up into these homes and then it creates much more homes for other people.
Yeah, all of those family things matter. People should be able to stay in their homes if they want to. I think my concern is that there's so many disincentives.
Even if people want to downsize or want a more manageable yard, I think the... The pattern of development matters here, right? If suburbs have diversity of housing stock, like you say, right? If a suburb is all single family homes, you've got nowhere to downsize to without changing location.
And that's really important to people staying in their communities.
Is there only building two bedroom apartments?
In some suburbs, you go from single-family dwelling to one or two-bedder apartment. Those are your two options. I think increasingly going forward, having that diversity of dwelling stock is really important to give people choice. No one should be kicked out of their homes by any means at all.
I think what we need to do is just make it a little easier. Whether that is concessions on stamp duty would be a big one.
I'm obviously, as an economist, very much in favor of land tax replacing stamp duty because then if you're staying in your large home, your large multimillion-dollar home, and it starts to actually cost you money because there's so much of that home that you're not using, that's one of the big things that will nudge people in the right direction.
That's all I think we need to do. As opposed to putting a big barrier in front of people downsizing, let's nudge them into doing a thing that's just more efficient for everyone.
Now, one of the other things that you've written on, which did surprise me along the affordability side of things, is that you're saying it's cheaper to buy than rent in more than a third of cases across the country. Now, I found that quite surprising, especially given interest rates have been on the rise.
So what conditions need to be in place before buying is cheaper than renting?
So what we did for that analysis is we crunched. So we've got an estimated REA of the purchase price of every home in Australia and similarly the current rental price of every home in Australia.
And compared those two and kind of projected forward what happens as rents continue to grow at kind of not the pace we've seen because that pace has been very, very strong. Prices grow at kind of average pace over the next few years.
There's obviously lots of fixed costs of purchasing, stay out duty and so on. And found that particularly because of the really strong rent rises we've seen at the lower end of the market, we've seen rents for units grow quite a bit faster than for houses over the past year.
There's a lot of kind of units, for instance, and entry-level homes that are cheaper now to buy than rent. Now, this is part of the reason why... We're seeing investors come into the market.
And I think it also shows that there's a lot of people that are in, say, in a rental and would love to buy the rental they're in, but are facing these kind of financial barriers, namely the deposit, to get into the market.
We're probably likely to see affordability conditions improve over the next year. I mean, particularly so if interest rates fall. I'm not sure where my forecast for interest rates are over the next year. Are you game?
I was expecting at the, you know, until a few weeks ago, I was expecting another interest rate hike in February. I'm less kind of certain about that now. Looks like the economy is kind of slowing in line with where the Reserve Bank wants it to be.
Interest rate expectations in the US have changed markedly just recently. It came down quite significantly. So, yeah, we could be seeing interest rates fall late next year. Yeah. in an optimistic scenario. So that would obviously help affordability quite a bit.
You were in the RBA, I think, for 10 years, right? What's your take on, you know, you've been out there for a few years, obviously there's a change of governor and blah, blah, blah, and like a whole review and all that sort of stuff, but just internally, like...
what's your take on what's happened over the last three or four years and you know what's going to be their mindset you know coming into you know a slowing economy slowing inflation um and rates being a bit contractionary right and housing affordability and how's it rent up home loan affordability mortgage affordability probably the the thing that's really weighing the economy down like
Is there going to be a real appetite to give that free kick back to mortgage holders on a significant way? Or do you think that even though they've gone up so fast, they want to go down much slower?
Or do you think their snapback is going to be quite big and everyone's going to be surprised how fast they fall rather than just as much as they were surprised how fast they rose?
So there's been a lot of changes at the Reserve Bank and obviously I haven't been involved. But I think revamping institutions that are so important is a good thing.
A lot of the pushes are towards transparency and more information being provided about how the RBA is making decisions. And I think that's all really welcome. Yeah. The challenge at the moment is, as you say, there's been a lot of change.
There's your new governor, new deputy governor, new head of your chief economist, a new monetary policy board that will start next year. This is kind of everything all the way down to the top is all kind of a new structure. So what does that mean for how the RBA conducts monetary policy?
And by and large, I would expect actually very little change in how the RBA tries to conduct monetary policy. Right. I think they will try and be deliberate and slow in the reduction in interest rates.
If the RBA does its job and its forecasts perform okay, they will want to be reducing rates kind of as the economy slows rather than kind of ratcheting it down quickly. Of course, you know, anything could happen.
We could see another big economic shock, financial crisis of some kind, and that would necessitate rates falling quite sharply.
Yeah, so far, so good, I think. The economy is still performing really well. We just saw unemployment rates just tick up a little bit. The RBA so far has done a really good job of conducting its kind of soft landing, which means that they have...
gotten the economy to slow without crashing the economy. The economy is slowing, doesn't seem to be crashing. Importantly, people are staying in jobs.
And really, if we're worried about, say, like housing risks and housing affordability, the biggest issue for housing affordability is all those people with mortgages making sure they still have a job.
Yes, very important. Well, there's been, you know, and this is not really the topic for this discussion, but, you know, there was all the talk about the mortgage cliff that was going to happen in 2023, and let's face it, it didn't.
And that's not to say some people have not really copped a hiding and really, really having a terrible time of it, but It hasn't transpired into this sort of avalanche of sales.
And in fact, total transaction, like you talked about, activity in the second half of the year was much greater than the first half of the year. But even so, I was looking at some CoreLogic data that said for November that said something like, I think, $475,000.
properties had transacted in the previous 12 months, if I've got that right. Now, there's plenty of times when I've seen that up to $600,000. So, that's a lot less, significantly less. That's about 20% down, isn't it, on what normally happens in a given year. So,
You know, there definitely hasn't been a mortgage cliff or a sudden sell-off when you're looking at total transactions so small. And also, I mean, we've got to understand transactions and listings are two different – there's stock levels, there's listings, there's transactions. But it's not like stock levels have been climbing and swelling.
It's not like listings have necessarily swollen either. They're now back under the five-year averages. So it is interesting just to see that the market's been remarkably resilient, right?
Resilient is, I think, the best word. We've seen, yeah, listings increase second half of the year, prices have kept, you know, have kept growing. So, the market's kind of absorbed that new stock that's come on the market, despite, yeah, higher mortgage rates, concerns about affordability and people selling out.
And undoubtedly, there will be some people that... It's been a really tough year financially for people. We've got really high inflation, putting pressure on all the things that people need to afford. Rents are growing really strongly. Mortgage rates are up at the fastest rate ever.
In kind of that scenario to have, you know, the market performing well and the economy performing quite well. No, no, go figure. This is all... Yeah, taking a step back, this is a pretty good outcome given, you know, the huge kind of real rollercoaster we've had over the past few years.
Paul, I mean, I think on that RBA research, a lot of people were banding it around, you know, negative cash flows for 40% of households and that's going to cause all this forced selling. Like, how have they got through this, though? Like, what, like... What means do you reckon?
Because on those metrics, everyone would have said, oh, hang on, so 40% of negative households cashflow, that means they're going to run out of money in three months time. They're going to have to start selling their properties. That hasn't happened. Why do you think that's the way?
What's the missing ingredient that a lot of people haven't factored in? Yeah. Yeah.
So I did quite a bit of that analysis, actually, when I was at the Reserve Bank. And I think one of the big things is that households have had a lot of time to respond to higher rates. A huge number of households were on fixed rates.
And that's, although this created this cliff scenario where people were jumping from what was a very low rate to quite a high rate, it meant that people knew it was coming, right? You knew when your fixed rate was coming off, you had time to repair.
So you had that time to either reduce your expenses or increase your income, whether that be like more hours or overtime or a new job.
Also, we've seen the incomes that that analysis was based on was based on the incomes when people took out loans. And we know when people take out loans, it's usually when they're in that part of their life when incomes are growing quite quickly.
So people take out loans, they're having young families, they're kind of in those most productive years of their working lives. And so just naturally, their incomes have increased at faster than average. So, people often, after four or five years into a loan, those are the hard times.
You know, if you can get through the first five years of a loan, in general, you're going to be fine because your income's risen, you've paid down a bit of the loan, you can refinance, you know, the remainder...
I think that's the situation a lot of households are in. A lot of belt tightening, a lot of looking at, is my income where it should be? Are there other options for me? But households are resilient, right? People are smart.
People know what's coming around the corner and they've adapted.
I think you're right. I call it the danger zone when people go, the first time buyer that goes from, um, quite a lot of cash in the bank account, you know, not being in debt for a number of years. Uh, I feel like they're totally in control of their finances.
Um, yeah, going on holidays, you know, still saving and living the good life. And then bang, there's 5,000 left in their bank account and they're stressed when their first mortgage repayment is going to come out and how they're going to pay for the legal fees and, um,
uh and and try to get through that danger zone and and you know sometimes doing the hard yards just after you purchase as you've done the hard yard savings well um because you're right over time you build a bit of equity you get on top of your mortgage your buffer increases you get that wage increase you didn't factor in the bonus you um and then you start getting on top of things and um you start feeling more comfortable again so i think you're right i think it's that
that danger zone. And I think families have been preparing for it. I think there was a bit of, people were just not thinking about their mortgage till it goes up. Well, I don't think that's the case.
We've had clients come to us for, you know, multiple years now when my fixed rate's finishing, what's my repayments going to be? I think they're leaning on family more than ever. I think families are helping him out with mortgages and repayment. They know that extra thousand is keeping him in their homes.
That's a good bet for the parents and grandparents. And they, so, Yeah, I think they've got other resources. They've got other assets. They've got savings. They can sell their car. They're doing things. They're taking second jobs. They're not just selling their homes.
I think that surprised a lot of people that just assume that high mortgage repayments are going to lead them to rush to sell.
Yeah, it's a bit naive, isn't it? Have you got a proper Dumbo for us? Yeah.
Oh, I do. Excellent. Ah, this is a good one. This comes from, I was speaking to an agent and they were exasperated and saying that it was, who was it?
Someone, they listed their home, weren't happy with the price because they had been reading the papers and said, hey, well, Sydney prices are up, you know, 8% over the past year. My property should be up. And they were in the Central Coast and the South Central Coast is part of the Sydney area.
And the Central Coast obviously went through a huge COVID increase and has been moderating a bit. I think things are still performing okay there, but not as strongly as Sydney, inner Sydney in particular. And so they had anchored themselves to Sydney prices. They were expecting their home to also have gone up.
They went, I think,
dumped their agent got a new agent listed the property and then listed it with the new agent dumped that agent went back to the original agent so i just you know wasted a huge amount of time um because they didn't basically get get the data uh look at your local area how's your local area what would have um
nearby homes been selling for, nearby similar homes. It's all that information that really like, you know, an agent, that's their bread and butter to help you out with. Yeah. But not being, yeah, being a bit more precise in what your comparison is.
Yeah.
expectations the other thing too is that you know if they said well mine should have gone up 8% you know over the year because Sydney prices have and then what's to say their realistic expectation or their expectation of what it was worth a year earlier was realistic in the first place so it's 8% on already inflated expectation
Paul, it's been a great chat. It's always interesting to get into your mind. So we really appreciate you coming along and sharing your knowledge with us. And we have to get you back again a little bit quicker than the last time. I think it took a bit long.
So we shall certainly want to get you back again and talk to us again later in the year. Brilliant.
Thanks, Paul. Cheers, mate. Excellent.
If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website theelephantintheroom.com.au or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au. If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit.
And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great. I know that sounds a bit cringy, but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.
Paul Ryan, senior economist at REA Group, opened with a 2023 the previous year had not pointed to. The market left 2022 with prices falling persistently and hardest at the top: Sydney down 6.4% over 12 months, the most expensive regions falling furthest, consistent with borrowing capacities squeezed by the fastest run of rate rises on record.
Then prices turned and activity followed. Sydney prices rose every month from January, but transaction activity did not pick up until around May, with Melbourne moving at the same time. By August, Ryan said, both cities saw more activity than in 2021, the biggest transaction year in a decade.
Chris Bates pushed on the other half: total monthly listings at a 10 year low. Ryan separated turnover from prices, and behind the decade long drift lower put transaction costs, stamp duty growing heavier as prices climb, and demographics.
Veronica Morgan asked which metric puts Australia among the world's most expensive countries, and Ryan was blunt about the familiar one's flaw. Price to income has a built in problem: as rates fall, a given income supports more debt, so prices should rise as a share of income. Median incomes also sweep in the very young and outright owners.
PropTrack's inaugural Housing Affordability Index asks, across the income distribution, how many homes that sold in a year a household could buy on current mortgage rates, a 30 year term, and what a lender would lend. On that measure, Ryan said 2022-23 was the worst since at least 1995.
If you were a typical household in Australia, you had the median income, you could afford just 13% of all homes that sold over that year.
Paul Ryan, 13:48
In the mid to late 1990s, the middle of the income distribution could afford about half of all homes sold. Ryan tied the change to wealth: buyers, increasingly including first timers, now rely on it to get in, and the deposit is the constraint that bites first home buyers rather than upgraders.
That composition explains prices proving resilient to higher rates. Upgraders were a bigger share of the market and less affected by constrained borrowing capacity, which showed up in expensive parts of Sydney and Melbourne. Investors were back to about a third of new credit, with rents up 15% nationally.
REA analysis comparing estimated purchase price with current rent for every home in the country found buying cheaper in more than a third of cases, mostly units and entry level stock. Plenty of renters would buy the home they are in, he said, held back by the deposit.
On supply, Ryan argued the problem is not only how many homes get built but where. In Sydney the only places an apartment block is really allowed are ex industrial areas, and narrowing the sites that far means only very large projects make sense, which is how pockets of towers appear.
His preference is wider upzoning at three or four storeys across more of the city, pushing developable land prices down and spreading density rather than concentrating it. Heritage is worth keeping, he said, but the trade off should start near new train lines.
I think it's a travesty to have a large single family home that is 100 metres from a new train station when it could be 12 apartments or three townhouses.
Paul Ryan, 35:27
The other half is the housing already standing: inner city overcrowding alongside empty nesters using one bedroom of a five bedroom home near the CBD. Nobody should be pushed out, he said, but the disincentives are stark: stamp duty costing tens of thousands, the family home excluded from the pension assets test, and often nothing local to move into. Some families skip the move and build on the block instead, which raises what a granny flat for an ageing parent does to the title, the pension and the estate.
Bates raised the Reserve Bank research on negative cash flows for around 40% of mortgaged households, and asked why forced selling never followed. Ryan, who worked on it at the RBA, said households had time to respond: fixed rate borrowers knew what was coming and could cut expenses or lift income, and the incomes in the analysis dated from when the loans were written.
Morgan noted CoreLogic data showing roughly 475,000 properties transacting in the 12 months to November, below the 600,000 of other years. Ryan's word for the year was resilient, and he put the biggest housing risk plainly: whether the people with mortgages keep their jobs.
Updated: some numbers here have moved. The cash rate was 4.35% when the episode aired, was cut back to 3.60%, and after three rises in the first half of 2026 sits at 4.35% again (RBA cash rate target, effective 12 August 2026). Investors are now a larger share than the third Ryan described, at 38% of the value of new housing loan commitments in the June quarter of 2026 (ABS Lending Indicators). The ABS also put the mean price of a New South Wales dwelling at $1,304,900 that quarter, with the total value of Australian housing down 0.3% over the three months (ABS Total Value of Dwellings, released 8 September 2026).
| Buyer group | What Ryan described | Figure as aired |
|---|---|---|
| First home buyers | Pulled back after a large pandemic bring forward, with the deposit the binding constraint | 13% of sold homes affordable on a median income |
| Investors | Moved into some of that space at the lower end of the market as rents rose | About a third of new credit |
| Upgraders | A bigger share of the market and less exposed to constrained borrowing capacity, propping up the top end | Sydney east and north up 10% in 12 months |
| Downsizers | Disincentivised by stamp duty and the pension assets test, and often with nothing to move into locally | Tens of thousands of dollars to sell and rebuy |
As described at 13:48, 15:36, 16:11 and 38:13. Figures as stated on air.
| Measure | Figure | Period as stated |
|---|---|---|
| Share of sold homes a median income household could buy | 13% | 2022-23 financial year |
| Same share for a household mid income distribution | About half | Mid to late 1990s |
| Sydney prices, most affluent regions falling hardest | Down 6.4% | 12 months to early 2023 |
| Sydney east and north | Up 10% | 12 months to late 2023 |
| National rents | Up 15% | Year to late 2023 |
As stated at 2:29, 13:48, 14:06, 15:36 and 16:11. Figures are quoted as aired and have not been re-checked.
This episode describes a market where upgraders were less constrained by borrowing capacity and the most expensive pockets kept rising. If you are weighing buying before you sell, a bridging loan is one of the structures worth understanding before you commit.
Mortgage Broker for UpgradersSources referenced: The Elephant in the Room Property Podcast, episode 317, "Why Are Housing Prices Rising Amidst an Affordability Crisis?", released 2024-01-28. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Paul Ryan, senior economist at REA Group. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 2026-09-10 against the RBA cash rate target, ABS Lending Indicators (June quarter 2026) and ABS Total Value of Dwellings (June quarter 2026).




