Posted
20 October 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
November 9, 2024
Episode
358
 ·
53
 min
The show

The Elephant in the Room

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with Veronica Morgan. It's a deep dive into what really goes on in the world of real estate.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Veronica Morgan
Veronica Morgan
Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor

Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

Guest
Cathie Crampton
Cathie Crampton
National Head, Property Management Growth At Belle

In this episode, we sit down with Cathie Crampton, National Head of Property Management Growth at Belle Property Corporate, to break down how these new laws are reshaping the roles of landlords, property managers, and tenants alike.

Cathie Crampton on What Rental Law Reform Has Done to Rent Rolls

Belle Property's Cathie Crampton walks Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates through the tenancy changes reshaping property management state by state. The figures she cites point to shrinking rent rolls and landlords deciding the cost of holding is too high.

Transcript
Veronica Morgan

In this episode, we're talking with Cathy Crampton from Bell Property Corporate, and we're going to explore the changing landscape of property management across the country. We'll look at which states have had the most amount of legislative change. I think we all know that Victoria tops that list.

And how these laws are impacting property managers and landlords, otherwise known as rental property providers in some states. And we'll discuss the unintended consequences, how tenancy legislation can backfire and ultimately hurt the people it's designed to help. Welcome to the elephant in the room.

This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about. I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, recently ranked number five in Australia out of over 18,000 brokers in the annual MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Awards. Before we get started, I need to let you know that nothing we say here can be taken as personal advice.

We always recommend you engage the services of an appropriate and experienced professional. Our guest today is Cathy Crampton, the National Head of Property Management Growth and Performance at Bell Property Corporate.

Cathy's property management career has spanned two decades across all national markets and in her current role, she works with agency principals at the business level to help them optimize and grow their property management businesses. She is truly passionate about real estate.

I've met her at a number of conferences and events, and she has forged a successful career as a highly respected member of the industry.

It's unusual to come across somebody in the property management space who has both a broad exposure to national markets as well as the understanding of what's happening on the ground. So we're really looking forward to this discussion. Kathy, welcome. Thanks for coming on The Elephant in the Room. Thank you, Roderick.

I appreciate being here.

Chris Bates

Kathy, I mean, it's been a roller coaster for renters over the last few years, everything all the way winding back to COVID and all the rules that have changed and the rental crisis in terms of the difficulties of rent and rent increases. But the property managers are often forgotten about here.

How tough has it been for them over this period going over the last few years?

Cathie Crampton

Yes. Well, I mean, I think the rental crisis encapsulates all aspects. There is clearly a chronic or has been, you know, and we'll talk about some of the stats that are suggesting a change here, but there's been a chronic shortage of housing for people who need it. And that is terrible.

And everybody, most people who are practitioners are empathetic to that. But for the poor property manager, I mean, they genuinely have been the piggy in the middle. Like they have been caught up in this on so many levels. They initially, I think there was some anxiety within our communities.

You know, we had COVID. So let's think about COVID. So that created all this anxiety. The poor old property managers in almost every state were not given guidance in a timely fashion. I mean, at that moment, I was actually running a, a rent roll in Brisbane, we had about 6,000 properties.

And, you know, we were making it up as we went along. And I don't mean that badly. I mean, I was producing videos, pushing out to my team because they weren't sure what they needed to be doing and say.

So I think not only was there a lack of guidance, but equally people just became so unfortunately demanding of what they wanted to try and understand because there was this anxiety with our clients, both owners and tenants. So you've got massive anxiety around, massive challenges for the PMs.

At that point in time too, they were not well paid and often not well educated. I am not suggesting our PM community are unintelligent. By educated, I mean there wasn't a lot of, you know, specific requirements around licensing and that. Okay.

So, you know, they were challenged in terms of problem solving and, you know, their ability to articulate. And, you know, I just think they had it super tough and there was massive, massive exodus out of the industry.

I think at one point, Victoria lost 35% of its workforce in, you know, sort of a nine month period. So it's, You know, and I can remember, and I'm going to put the stage that only a working at place group in Brisbane.

And I remember a study tour coming up from Victoria, just, I think it was just after COVID. And I mean, these were, I won't say who, but these were very seasoned people sitting at the table running massive rent rolls, like 15,000, that sort of thing. Okay. Massive.

And they had head in hand going, we just don't know what to do about it. Like, I just think if everybody was so adversely affected.

And I don't think, I think we've had to, you know, we can talk about this, but we've had to massively rethink and reshape how the property management businesses work in order to create a new type of PM. Yeah. That's gone.

Veronica Morgan

Definitely want to get into that because that sort of change, you know, challenges result in change across industries, of course, and that's one of the things that's, you know, structure of businesses and all sorts of things are being impacted there and a lot of experimentation, I think, too.

But let's just firstly discuss some of the recent legislation and compliance requirements that have come into place across the country. I mean, we can start with Victoria. You could probably go to Queensland, New South Wales and then elsewhere. And in fact, we're recording this at the end of October.

We'll be going to air in November. And even just today or yesterday, the Victorian government's come out announcing even more tenancy legislation, which is quite astounding.

Cathie Crampton

Absolutely.

Veronica Morgan

So do you want to hit us with sort of, I guess, a synopsis of what challenges, what's been imposed? And some of this obviously, yes, I'm not to say that tenant-friendly legislation shouldn't be enacted, but let's be real about it. Let's have a good look.

Cathie Crampton

Yeah. So there are... You see it nationally and some states in Australia are more legislatively orientated than others. So, for example, you tend to see the wave usually actually start in WA or SA and they were actually the first to have the requirements around licensing and that sort of thing.

They're highly regulated markets. The eastern coast is slower or it's more entrepreneurial typically and so you don't see those legislative requirements as quickly. However...

A couple of years ago, post-COVID, I think the government, I'm not a political person, but I think the government has been quite woeful in their ability to foresee and take responsibility for housing requirements for the mass population.

As a result, they have pushed regulation and the responsibility of housing all to the private landlord. Okay, so the mum and dad investor who in most cases are just trying to create something to their future. So we're seeing regulations such as

You know, you effectively can't say no to a pet in a property without good reason. That good reason typically is around whether or not it's a suitable pet for the property. But there's very strict timelines around when you have to respond to the request by, which in most markets is 14 days.

I think in one market might be 21. That I would say to you is probably a reasonable request. Again, I'm not trying to alienate any owners who may be listening. I am an owner as well of a rental property, so I understand.

But the reality is that most people now are moving with pets and there are a mass number of people who will never purchase a property. I had a conversation with someone last night who runs a rent mall in Brisbane about $1,300 property. She said, I'll never buy a property.

But she's got a good job and so on. So I think pets is probably a normal one. Things that are really difficult for landlords are things around these minimum housing standards.

And places like Victoria and the ACT have very wrong positions on that, which are actually financially such an encumbrance for the clients. That's why we're seeing the selling.

When they brought those standards into the ACT, for example, they lost 3,000 rental properties within a space of 12 months. And that is a highly transient market, right, that a lot of people need to rent there.

In Victoria, I'm sorry to say I can't give you the exact number, but I know that most rent rolls, because I just did a recent benchmarking study within Victoria, have shrunk between 5% and 12%, some as much as 20%.

So if you extrapolate that out to the number of available rental properties, it's shrinking. And then reading an article that came out today, I thought it was very insightful. And that was around these proposed changes the Victorian government want to add yet again.

And I am concerned for people and the viability of them owning a rental property. So I think what the government has done, unfortunately, with their lack of taking responsibility for this matter before and their vote self-serving sort of behaviour, is that they are alienating the very people that they need.

Not strategic at all. The mum and dad investor keeps the backbone of the country going.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, it's an interesting one because I wonder about the actual, the state government's own housing stock.

So, you know, they do provide social housing and I wonder how much of their own stock actually fulfills those, you know, inhabitability standards that they impose on individual landlords. The other thing too is that, and it was something that I picked up at the PIPA conference, which was only last week, that the

And a lot of commentators will say, well, so what? If investors are selling and a first home buyer buys, then so what? Or if an upgrader buys it and then a first home buyer buys their house, so what? It's just dwelling for dwelling, whether it's an owner, occupier or a tenant, who cares?

But I think what they're forgetting is that some tenants will never, ever buy. Correct. And so they are competing for an ever-shrinking amount of stock.

But not only that, the actual formation of tenants, of rental dwellings, so the amount of people that live in a rental dwelling, is actually higher than the amount of people that live in an owner-occupier. I didn't actually really tweak to that until last week.

Cathie Crampton

We've seen that trend now. So this affordability pinch. Yeah. This is impacting both tenants and owners. Okay. So from a tenant perspective, this affordability pinch really hit about nine months ago. And as we're already now seeing inflation start to drop, I think it came out yesterday, about 2.8%.

When it comes out like that, I'm not an economist, but When it comes out like that, I can tell you everyone's out of money. You know, like this is not a good place to be. So what we are seeing, though, is we've seen that consolidation of households now for a good nine months.

We've seen anecdotally, because as much as I'm in a corporate role now, I actually go into businesses every day and... We are seeing that there are less people attending open homes. The rate of rental increases now is dropped back.

I saw some information on the weekend where the average rent in the majority of Sydney southerners now has come back in percent. Okay. Whilst it's risen 39% 2020, now we're seeing that reduction, the affordability peak.

So this is coming at a time, because it's not evil landlords, but this is coming at a time when owners have got all this additional obligation, particularly what they're bringing in Victoria, and they don't actually have the freedom to manage the tenancy in terms of the occupancy in a way that is serving the equation at hand.

So they can't, they've removed, you know, the no-ground removal, the no-grounds... Eviction. Eviction, and...

And again, I'm not anti-tenant at all, but then, so this is the owner has all the risk and the owner has all of the responsibility, but has no rights under the property that they're paying for at a time when some properties are devaluing, where rents won't now continue to go up at the rate that they have.

We've had that correction. So I think it's a really tough set of circumstances and the government needs to lay more accuracy on it.

Chris Bates

Kevin, can you look at your, you know, obviously the rental books across the whole Bell Network? I mean, you've got the place experience. You probably know what's going on there as well. But, you know, have you seen a huge reduction in, you know, the turnover rate?

I mean, yes, there's new investors entering and absolutely you might be increasing your market share and things like that.

But if you had to sort of do a like for like that the people who had the properties, you know, pre-COVID and the people who have still got them hosed, is there a huge reduction?

reduction in people that are you know instead of selling the home they've sold their investment properties can you oh yes oh yes look um i don't like to

Cathie Crampton

past data that's probably not my data to broadcast, but in a previous role, let me put it that way, we had a reduction of 5% across the group. This was 18 months ago, and I think it's been worse.

And in the flagship office of that group, we sold, of the turnover in sales for that office, which is a flagship office, 25% of their revenue came off the rent roll. So that kills people are selling off their investment property.

Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

And even in Bell, we see that. And I know that there's not a huge amount of sympathy out there for real estate agents. You know, I am one. I put my hand up when I say that, but I am one, people. But, you know, they go, oh, that's a shame.

The reality is, though, that if a business has a rent roll, that's its asset, right? And you're selling off your 20%, 25% of the sales revenue is rent.

effectively cannibalizing your assets. Absolutely. Selling the farm, we call it. Yeah. So it's not good for business. I mean, it's, you know, yes, you prefer to sell it rather than have one of your competitors sell it.

But at the end of the day, you don't want to see that rent roll shrinking like that.

Cathie Crampton

No, no.

Veronica Morgan

And look, you're talking about, yes, that there's now less people going through open houses and rental growth has slowed. And we know that. It's come out in the national data as well. It's different jurisdictions, obviously, different amounts. Sure. And some people will be going, well, that's a good thing. That's a good thing.

Rental growth is slow. That's an excellent thing, you know. But I guess you're coming at it from increased pressures on landlords and you're suggesting that more will sell as a consequence.

Cathie Crampton

Is that what you're saying? Yes, I think there'll be more selling. I think what's masked The impact of it till recently is that we had these increasing rents. We hadn't had this market correction for a while.

And that meant that most business owners were realizing more revenue, but not probably paying that detailed attention to the size of the asset. That has stopped now. But the selling is continuing because it's too expensive to hold it.

You know, you speak to a lot of savvy financial investors and they're like, you know, the yields out there and now you've got yields of one and a half or 2% instead of three and a half, 4%.

I think the average nationally is still about three and a half, but, you know, that's including all your regional markets and all your more, you know, investor orientated sort of markets. So, yes, I think there is increasingly likely that we will see more selling off of those assets.

That decreases the opportunity for tenants to have somewhere to call home. You know, it is, when you're talking about property managers too and the retention of property managers, what really taxes the PMs is the constant in and out of property.

So when people move in and out, you know, the ingoings, the vacates, the bonds. That sort of thing. So you're going to see that kind of pressure sitting on people that are already, in a lot of cases, relatively new to the industry.

And I think that's putting increased pressure on business owners as well to go, look, I want an asset, but how do I create a steady team, you know, to keep running that asset?

Veronica Morgan

Yeah. I mean, look, there's obviously those financial pressures on agencies. You've had rising property management wages, staff shortages, increased compliance. There's costs involved in that, shrinking rent rolls due to investors selling. I mean, how can a business owner respond in a way that really makes good business sense?

What is changing in terms of the structure of these businesses?

Cathie Crampton

Absolutely. I think it's pretty important for business owners to educate themselves around what makes a good rent roll. Okay. So at different sizes, you need a different staffing level. And the thing to understand about your rent roll is what we call the capacity of the rent roll.

And that means the capacity that sits in there that the team member can manage. Okay. Because it is an expensive, it's a high volume, low margin type of business. Good rent rolls will run at about 25, 30% sometimes in excess of that.

So a good, a solid business and they have the asset value. But the businesses that I see that run like that measure absolutely everything. and they make all their decisions in essence around whether or not the business can support it.

So I think that understanding first of all what makes a good rent roll. I think that getting the BDMs operating for your organic engine needs to be operating so that it's replacing your churn.

The churn is where, not to get too detailed, but churn is where you lose managements, not necessarily to another agent, but generally you can sell them, move in, whatever. So if you can get your BDMs replacing that, then of course, Any acquisitions you might make are strategically orientated. Because acquisition is expensive now.

We're running commercial rates 7% to 9%. You've got to pay them back. The average tenure of a management in a business is typically about 18 months at the moment. So you typically haven't paid it off in 18 months. You know what I mean?

So you need to be pretty savvy with your measuring and your nurturing and those sorts of things. And as I said, the capacity piece. The best way to improve or optimize the capacity in your business is to utilize your technology well. And that doesn't mean don't have a human.

That just means, you know, in every business I've stepped into so far without, I think there's only one business I've stepped into where they were using their platform well. And have a look at what's costing you money in the business. You know, maybe trust accounting is a big expense for you.

Do you actually need a trust account? That's a big question. Yeah. You know, and there's lots of ways to run them so that they're running more lean. I always say, you know, keep them lean, keep them clean. You know, that's kind of, that's a great role usually.

Veronica Morgan

There's a lot of prop tech in that space trying to come up with lovely solutions for the property management industry. I know it's a highly populated space.

Let's talk, I think Chris had a question there that I jumped in. Did you have a question on that?

Chris Bates

Oh, I was just curious. You mentioned very early about the new property manager and what you've sort of had to really improve, I guess. How big has been the improvement been over the last few years?

And as a consumer using it by a property manager, what are some of the things they're going to see that are working much better for them as investors?

Cathie Crampton

Yeah, well, I want to say everything's working better. I'm going to say to you I think it's still an exception rather than a rule. Okay. So there are apps out there that will give – there's two things.

There's probably two – there's three massive shifts I've seen, and there's an area that I think we still have massive improvement needed, okay? The three big shifts are around how money is moving. Okay. And even whether – I mean, whether you're a tenant or whether you're an owner –

having access and transparency to your money, so instant access and transparency over the money journey is really important. You know, that, and so, you know, there's products like ALO and Colmy and someone that are doing trustless type solutions, you know, property me as their me pay solution, which is fabulous.

Like they're, they're out there, they work. Okay. So I think that's the big shift and I would love to see more shift in that direction. The second thing that I think is working really well is, technology that can utilize AI to do things like your inspections and your vacates and ingoings.

Because if you speak to any property manager, they say, oh my God, it takes me six hours to do a four bedroom ingoing. And it's like, well, how about we just get a camera and flip it around and AI writes scripts and you check it over and loves your uncle.

I mean, there's things, I see some businesses working like that. I've seen the rise of the professional property manager since COVID in particular. And that PM who is largely an in-office PM, they're probably earning $120,000 a year. That's not uncommon now.

And they are the ones who speak to the client and essentially guide the client. Now, on that note, unfortunately, I don't think at the moment that is still the majority of our PM fraternity. Not necessarily their fault.

I think the educating that we've been doing, we have a big line between the kind of business education we do at places like Business and Real Estate. I don't know, Veronica, if you went to that one. Yeah, I did.

It's a very big difference between the kind of conversation we're having there and the typical conversation at a PM level conference. Okay. Which is still largely, you know, here's a new product and, you know, how do I manage my time? And you know what I mean? It's a little bit more pedestrian.

I'm not, again, trying to be critical. I just think we have still a long way to go in educating people. the people that we employ to have the right conversation with the client.

So they should, for example, none of us are economists, but all of us are reading information around what's trending at the moment in the market, and we can apply that to clients. how somebody should operate their investment.

In other words, I could have told you six months ago that rents were coming off the peak because I could see and anecdotally I'm hearing affordability, that sort of thing. You've seen the inflation rates start to come down. Those things tell us there's not as much money going out.

You will like my stuff. So my advice, had I been a senior PM to a client would be, We don't have time here to put the rent at market rank because we, and I would advise that we have a 12 month lease and you know what I mean? And buy them that surety.

Does that make sense?

Veronica Morgan

Yeah. And on that, because that's an interesting one because that, those conversations around where the rent sits and managing that and coming to the end of the lease and et cetera, are becoming more and more important, aren't they? Because when you've got no grounds. Oh yeah.

abolishment of no grounds terminations and also in Queensland where you've got the rents can only be increased once a year per property it's not even like if you had a six month lease and then somebody vacates you can then reset to market rent

And John Cunningham said this to me when we were debating around the no grounds eviction legislation. He said it's going to take kindness out of property management. Yes. And so you obviously get what he meant there.

Cathie Crampton

Do you want to elaborate on what that means? Yeah. I think that it will become absolutely a mercurial or a financial transaction. That actually isn't serving the interests that was intended by more tenant-friendly legislation. It's actually become the reverse.

What's happened is there's too much interference in what's actually traditionally been an agreement. Supply and demand is the agreement. we accept the terms and we operate to those terms for this period. Because there's so much interference, I think it is taking the kindness out.

There won't be the latitude because they've got, the owner and or the PM have got such defined grounds now on what they can and can't do that they just, You can't be malleable around it. The piece that a lot of people miss in property management is it's not black and white.

You can't legislate for every dynamic that sits in PM. In fact, the best businesses, the best PMs navigate the grey. And their ability to navigate that, have the right conversation around it, come to resolution. And this legislation removes it, doesn't it? The more we're restrictive.

Veronica Morgan

One of the instances where that might apply is quite often here that my clients in particular are like, I like to keep the rent low when I know I've got a great tenant and I'll happily have them on below market rent because I want them to stay. Yeah.

The problem is then if ever it gets too far away from market rent, they're in a real problem. If they can't actually, it's, no, they're not able to bring it up to market rent at any point in an easy way when it gets too far away.

And also they can't actually terminate that tenant and remarket because to reset that. Right. So that's one of the areas where kindness and discretion will be, will not, it'd be bad practice to do that.

Cathie Crampton

Absolutely. And there were instances previously too, where people would stagger rent increases. Okay. Now you can't do that, can you? Like you can't even accommodate somebody's circumstances to try and elevate that. And you know, the other challenge is that it actually devalues the asset before the owner. And that's a problem.

Because, you know, you go and get new value. If you want to refinance your property, you know, off your 7% interest rate, you know, as they start, very difficult because your assets kind of slightly devalue based on that rent. Value is look at that as well as a component.

So it's a real challenge for everybody. I think that... I think the legislation has genuinely gone too far across all of the states. Poor old New South Wales, they don't even have the grounds that Queensland's got to finalise tenancies.

Veronica Morgan

Really? And Queensland, they've put some interesting legislation. I think that one increase per property a year shows a real lack of understanding of the way the market works. And who is that?

protecting oh no watch this face though they just got a liberal government so we'll see yeah i guess but you know but that's sort of weird too because currently the way it is you know somebody could sign up for a lease where the rent is you know this much today and built into the lease is is a is a is a rental increase which may not actually be fair market rent at that point of time if rents go down so it's sort of a bit of a strange way of looking at it as well they don't always think everything through up there there's always a little bit of retrospective adjustment in queensland um i found the

There's another one that's changed up there, the two-week maximum holding deposit. So, you know, again, I think there – but I was at the PIPA conference and Corinne Bowen from Image Property was saying on that one that that actually hurts people who are –

Who don't have references, like if they just sold a house, for example, or perhaps they're moving here from overseas, they don't have a, you know, a nice bank of past property managers that will give them a reference.

So often they might have actually said, look, you know, I'm prepared to prepay three months rent as a gesture of showing my goodwill here. But they will no longer be able to do that.

Cathie Crampton

Correct. Yeah. So I think this is, I mean, this is this constant lack of navigating of the grades, lack of understanding of the dynamics of the industry. And in many cases, when legislative changes have been made in recent times, there's been very poor consults with representation of the industry.

You know, Antonia Merserella did an amazing job when the first lot of reforms came through, you know, her and the REIQ. In Queensland, I was just operating a rent roll up there at the time, and they really made so much noise that, you know, the industry got a voice at the table.

But unfortunately for Coral Victoria, they weren't even invited to the table. So it's just very difficult circumstances. I think it'll be interesting to see, you know, they talk about governments changing on the voice of crime, but I think we will see a lot more challenge now.

I think the housing space, tenants are definitely challenged, as I said earlier, around housing. scarcity of supply and around opportunity. And nobody's disrespecting that at all. And owners are increasingly challenged around the cost and potential and viability of holding an investment.

So what they've done is they've broken up the equation that actually holds the fabric together. So I think we'll see a lot of change still.

Veronica Morgan

I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions and you can find out all about what I'm working on at veronicamorgan.com.au. There you will find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program, information about my newest project, Preferrental,

proactive property management in sydney or if you're looking to buy your dream home or investment property in sydney's inner west eastern suburbs or lower north shore you can connect with my team at good deeds property buyers and if you'd like a 30 discount plus free postage my book auction ready how to buy property at auction even though you're scared shitless and yes i'm a potty mouth use the code elephant at the checkout

Chris Bates

If you're looking to buy your first home, thinking of upgrading to a new home or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Please reach out to myself and the team at flintgroup.au. Kathy, is there any certain pockets?

I mean, you've got a bigger, almost a national network, I guess, and certain pockets where, you know, from a renter's point of view, things are looking quite rosy, right? There's a lot of new investors, for example, the first and the Adelaides and Yeah, perhaps would. Yeah.

Is there any pockets where the opposite's happening though, where really the agent's saying, hang on a sec, every day I'm just getting a call, another house off the rent roll, another house off the rent roll, which might be good for their sales, right? They're getting the listings because the investor's bailing.

Ultimately, if you fast forward and if that trend continues, you're going to see some real pockets around the country where renting is much harder than it was, say, five, 10 years ago.

Cathie Crampton

Yes, we're not seeing that. So to your first point, absolutely, Perth, Adelaide, and particularly Perth, everybody wants to invest in Perth at the moment, you know, and that's typical. Okay, so it tends to come over from WA and then it goes back. Okay, so that all can each do.

But the pockets, particularly pockets of New South Wales, northern beaches, we're seeing a lot of people, it's not viable. The yields aren't there. So you're seeing those types of environments where, yes, people don't buy back in. They're moving there. They don't rent them out. A little bit of that.

I'm not seeing any rent rolls yet within the Bell Group where the assets shrinking to the point that They're half the size. I did see that in a rent roll in Brisbane, actually, about 18 months ago where it halved within 18 months. I saw another one at South Brisbane.

It wasn't one of ours at the time, but another one in South Brisbane lost 25% of the size of the rent roll. I think we will definitely see that in different pockets. I just haven't seen it yet.

But, you know, it would logically be going to say, well, there's pockets of Sydney, you know, Lower North Shore, perhaps some of the eastern suburbs, those northern beaches, those lifestyle areas where we'll see that because it's too expensive to buy back in. It doesn't make sense.

Veronica Morgan

Well, I think a lot of those houses that have been offered for rent in those areas haven't necessarily always been or were purchased with the intent of being an investment property. They might have been accidental investments.

And yeah, the new investor is not going to shell out the amount of money that's required to buy one of those just to put it on at a 2% or 3% rental yield. Right.

we encourage investors to buy for growth, capital growth. And there's not a lot of investors that are prepared to, that's effectively land. I mean, it's not exactly land banking, but you're buying a chunky asset and you're able to hold it with very minimal income from that asset. That's an unusual investor, right?

And I think that that type of, you know, the family home on the rental market is going to be a dying breed, I would think.

Cathie Crampton

Absolutely, because they say the biggest transfer of wealth is generational wealth. But if we think about these housing standards that have come in now, it's actually not practical for people to hold a number of these assets in that form.

So even buying it to rent for a period of time until you renovate it or something like that. Unfortunately, they're not going to be able to do that anymore. So that's going to remove a percentage of stock again.

Veronica Morgan

And that's important because what that's going to do is take out a stock that has been affordable. We know that our state governments have had a declining investment in social housing for the last seven decades. And so, therefore, people on those growing waiting lists have been forced, if they are

low incomes have been forced to rent pretty shitty properties. And I'm not justifying the fact that that's what's happened.

But the reality is that where are they going to, if those properties then have to afford, the owners are forced to actually invest in improving and upgrading them, those properties will then appeal to a tenant who's got more money to pay rent.

And it's not about even the landlord saying they're going to charge more. It's just simply the fact that previously that didn't appeal to that affluent sort of tenant before. And that's going to change. That's going to actually put more pressure on people that really need housing, I would think. Absolutely, it will.

Cathie Crampton

And I think that the pressure we also haven't considered aside from availability of stock is that You know, like every market, it's a bit like the cigarette market. They put all these taxes on it, I think, and then suddenly we had this underground cigarette market.

You know, there was an article on it recently. I can't smoke, by the way, but just FYI.

But I watch the news. But anyway, even from a rental perspective, even these homes that, you know, are perhaps...

you know they're fitting a particular market segment you know somebody's buying it renovate it later perhaps they're going to move it into three years you know yeah they're adequate but perhaps they're not eating every standard like you know the cycle aircon and controlled eating and whatever those properties too will go to an underground rental type market like it'll become that private landlord which is very difficult to regulate oh my god yes i'm not anti-private landlord

But often, a lot of those stories you see on the news, let me put it to you like that, which is very commercial, are not typically agent situations. They're often these private landlord situations. And I think we'll see a little bit more of that too. You know, that's more dangerous for a tenant.

I just don't really know how it's serving these four tenants.

Chris Bates

Catherine, there was a big disruption. Every industry has gone through this, right? Yes. I think the property management, oh, you don't need a property manager. Oh, yes. What a value to that. Let's just play some tech platform. Do you think you've seen the death of that sort of prop tech? Oh, yeah.

They all went broke. Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

It's like that.

Chris Bates

No, a lot of them did, to be honest. And a lot of them, you know, they've taken the tech approach to, you know, I've come from the tech industry and I'm going to come in and disrupt property management. You know, they're worth four times the rent roll. You know, they're a great asset.

Banks will lend on it. You know, how hard could it be? Do you think that that's sort of been proven now with these companies coming in? Because it's actually a really tough business. But a lot of people think a bit naive.

Cathie Crampton

Okay. I still think there is a market for self-managing via these platforms. They're like the Yabonzas and, you know, those two things that came in. I think there is a market segment that loves that. I mean, I have a good friend of mine that just recently purchased a house.

I appreciate this sale lot, right? But he said his selection of bank was based purely on the fact he only wanted to deal online. He didn't want to deal with a person. And there are that segment of the market who don't, you know, find time wasting communicating.

There is absolutely a market for it. I think that property management needed disrupting. You know, I still think it needs a level of disruption because we, I still don't think at this point, and I'm talking, collectively, that we are delivering all of the advice that a client needs, wants, sees value in.

Okay? So I still think there's a lift up we need to have. So I think that we're the piece that that Puritan approach, as in all tech approach, in other words, no human, no person,

is probably not the best scenario it's a combination of a good advisory orientated person with well optimized tech like to go and physically you know i'm not saying you know even to coordinate repairs well why can't somebody just jump on a portal send their own photographs why can't the tech just automatically pump out the you know quote request to the trade

The trade can then go back and offer three times that they can visit the property via the tech. All of that is just so logical, it makes sense to me. And keep it transparent, it automatically can add to the property in terms of the flow, the ledges. To me, that seems quite straightforward.

So the answer to the question, Chris, is I don't think we've seen the end of the pure tech solutions in PMs.

I think most of the time those companies come into Australia to test their products in our market, we're not actually intended as the end game. We're different when a bit astray, unfortunately, is that they tried to operate an on-the-ground model.

I think they just went too hard too quick, you know.

like that Uber style model that they were trying to do, but they were definitely disrupting there for a while, you know, and people were, I was running that all the time and there were people in my environment that were kind of looking up going, oh, I've just lost this property, you know, this page is different and what have you.

So there's a place for it. I'm not saying they're the answer. I think they are a good education piece for the traditional PM to say, hey, how do I need to up my game and have a different type of conversation with the client.

Veronica Morgan

It is interesting because a lot of these tech solutions seem to be born out of one person's poor experience. I can do a better job and the next minute they're investing a lot of money and other people agree with them and then it's like, well, it doesn't really work. But what about...

Within a business, because typically you've had portfolio managers. Oh, yes. One property manager that runs, you know, X amount of, what, 200 managements, 250 managements. And now some businesses are going for this sort of the assembly line, you know, the task-based structure.

So it's like, you know, you build a model Ford in a factory. Yes. What? What are your thoughts on reorganising, I guess, the way which property management is done? Forget about tech for a minute, and obviously tech enabled in many cases, but what are your thoughts on that? Yeah.

Cathie Crampton

Look, I've run lots of those models, and as your businesses get bigger, to keep them efficient, to keep them profitable, but also to offer your team areas to grow.

You need a career path to retain people and to expand their skill sets and so on. You actually need to run scalable models. So those part-task, part in-office, out-of-office models

I'm a big advocate for them.

Veronica Morgan

Now, the assembly line piece you're referring to, this all, like they...

Cathie Crampton

So they build workflows and think that it's a linear process. It's tricky because it really is reliant on the workflow. And nothing going wrong. Superb. And it's also relied on a communication level that is seamless. Okay.

Now, that's such rare air. You see it, but it's rare air. And what tends to happen, whether you have a portfolio style or not, is the client is frustrated when they are dealing with somebody who doesn't have the information. Yeah.

And unfortunately, most of the products that we all use require you to enter the information. So there's a little bit of all of that.

But the answer to it is that as you scale to offer opportunity for team, to offer profit back to the business and to offer a client experience that is effective, you do need to segment that.

the tasks um i like in office out of office and i like you know i call it growing my own babies which clearly i don't grow now but um you know i like growing you know people up and bringing them in as cadets and you know sort of starting them in like a field service capacity and then you can start to grow them up you know the career pathway and um so i'm quite strong with that yeah so it ends up being in office out of office cadet sort of model

Veronica Morgan

And it does take a, property management is a different beast to say a sales agent. And I know a lot of people seem to think that property management is the babies for sales agencies, but they don't necessarily possess the same skills or demeanor, do they?

Cathie Crampton

No, there's a lot of talk. You still hear a lot of talk on both sides, but, you know, a lot of principals will still say, I just want to hear them get on the phone.

But the problem with the level of regulation and things is that people unfortunately have to document things and it's pretty rare still to find that property manager who'll get on the phone, have the conversation and then document it effectively via confirmation.

So that's still a bit of a challenge for the industry, but they're not the same mindset. They're not wired the same as the typical salesperson. And yeah, so there's a lot of that kind of challenge. But as I said, the more that the industry becomes professionalized,

You know, I said earlier about the rise of a professional PM. The better the wages we see, the better the education expectation, the more that we see clear career pathways for property management personnel. I think that the less that disconnect will be evident.

Veronica Morgan

Okay.

Cathie Crampton

Because they, they operate like a professional person. You know, I just ran a BDM session today. We have about 110 there, you know, from across the group, just for BDM. So people are, there's definitely passion.

And I think whilst we would like to earn more money, the wage is 25% higher than they were four years ago. So, you know, it's definitely lifting. Yeah. So I think there's great opportunity. I mean, I've been really fortunate. Yes, I've worked hard, but I've had great opportunity in my career.

You know, so you can, And create a pathway.

Veronica Morgan

I think a lot of property managers sort of at that, I guess, well, owners of property management businesses, shall we say, at that sort of higher end of professionalism, certainly when I've been talking to them, they're really focused on building up that skill level of property managers, being an advisor.

And it is actually quite interesting because certainly a lot of them seem to be going into their property investment advice space, which is unregulated.

And it does concern me actually quite often I hear some of the advice that these people give. And I'm, oh, Jesus, that's not good advice. That's actually really bad advice.

So as the industry matures and as the people within it sort of seek to lift their game and be able to provide better advisory role or advisory service to their clients, I'm hoping that they start to recognise that. that they don't actually know much about property investment.

They might know how to manage a property in their area. But, you know, in terms of overall investment advice, that's a danger zone. And equally, when you ask a sales, you know, you go looking at a property and sales agents will say, oh, it's a great investment.

And I'll be like, tell me, tell me more about that. What makes it a great investment? Oh, because of the rent well. And they don't even talk about yield. They just put evil rent well. And it's like, well, that's...

Cathie Crampton

interesting because that's sufficient look it's you know there's um Because we're talking about a consumer. We're a consumer sees value. And then we're talking about the capability of the person who's delivering the experience.

We have a responsibility probably as an industry and perhaps as leaders in the industry, and I'm talking about business owners as well, to provide that type of education. I remember years ago getting what was then my accountant in Brisbane, and he runs quite a big business, supports a lot of real estate agencies.

So I had him come in. and teach us about yield and teach us about what does capital appreciation mean and, you know, those sorts of things. So does it need to become a requirement in CPD that you do a course of that nature?

Do we need to have – because there's not even a component in the registration or in the license that you do any of that, right?

Veronica Morgan

I know. And buyers, they just do the same course and they don't know. They don't learn it either.

Cathie Crampton

There's some – I just think there's definitely some opportunity there. If we as a business owner know that you know, our clients are expecting us to have a different type of conversation.

We need to train our property management professionals to have a conversation to the point that is reasonable. Okay. And then we need to have some relationship with somebody that perhaps can take the conversation to another level and perhaps do that, you know, assessment of a property. Like it would just be a formula.

Okay. Like it's, You know, whether the property suits investment or doesn't suit investment, what's the rate of capital appreciation of that, you know, location or that product in that location. It's fairly, you don't need to get fancy for it.

You've just got to have sort of three or four key things that we dropped in a template and, you know, a bit of a disclaimer. But I do think we aren't taking responsibility though to even educate people. in what the client would like to see and where they see value.

And the other danger that we haven't highlighted around that, because we don't do it at the moment well, is that we are seeing still a little bit of a reduction in management fee averages across the country. For those that might not know, management fee is what the agency collects as gross revenue.

Obviously, it's not their profit. The challenge with that being reducing Yes, rents have gone up a little bit. Remember, that's stopping now. That's going to stop now for a few years and probably see a little bit more correction and then it'll normalise.

But that just means that the revenue is starting to also decrease. So then how do we keep everybody employed? How do we keep them all?

their pay how do we support that provision of housing so there's sort of a we need to be able to substantiate value and you know it's one thing for people to over regulate the industry but how about they support regulation in a way that also adds value to the industry yeah

Chris Bates

Kathy, have you got a property dumbo to finish us off with today?

Cathie Crampton

Oh, I have got a dumbo, yes. Excellent. I can never forget this. In fact, I was in Brisbane just the other day and went past the very property where this happened and I still think about this situation. So I had a situation where we were managing a property on the Brisbane River.

It was worth, you know, it was a nice substantial property and we the TenantMate application, which was fine, normal process. I didn't cite this level of detail typically, but TenantMate application.

The tenant was on remand for armed robbery and was wearing a, what do you call it, you know, around their ankle. Ankle bracelet. That's the one. It looks like a mobile phone to anybody who hasn't seen one of those ankle monitors. And again, everybody should be treated respectfully and fairly.

But when this particular applicant put in their, you know, bracelet, it was a forged bracelet. And it was evident that it was a forged bracelet because it didn't have an accruing I'll announce when you get paid and you've been paid X amount in the spirit.

So the short of it is that the tenant made that application fraudulent pay slip, the references were his sister and somebody else. The particular person who approved everything was a very young person and didn't. probably see those alert signals. Does that make sense? Yeah. The red flags weren't seen.

Veronica Morgan

The red flags weren't there.

Cathie Crampton

Anyway, the tenant went in. First I knew about it was when the lawyer for the owner's corporation was sitting downstairs in the office going, we're going to sue you for not taking due care. And as I'm walking down the stairs, I'm going, what's going on here? What happened?

I'm trying to ready myself for this conversation. So I, well, anyway, we managed to unwind that, but it took a conversation I had to have with the tenant. We had to cover obviously on the moving costs, the bond, like we were able to, you know, move them on.

But I think the, it was a bit frightening because this person was a drug dealer. So anyway, the challenge around that, I think that the Dumbo Act that you like is that if, you know, just Keep your, like, stay looking, keep a clear head about what you're dealing with.

You know, if it doesn't seem right, ask a question, elevate it to get more clarity. You know, I'm not suggesting that the person in that situation, the young person who processed everything, you know, is to blame per se.

I think it, you know, there was, it touched three sets of hands in the index league and there were other people who probably should ask the question. But that to me was... I really, that was just people just rubber stamping something and moving it on to the next stage.

And I think that was not a smart way to operate. Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, you know, encourage people to consider using a proactive property manager when you've got someone who's just, yeah, a bit blasé and you want someone who's really got a bit of a nose for, you know, what may or may not be a great tenant.

Cathie Crampton

Like people, yeah.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, and we could have a huge conversation around tenants as well because, you know, it's almost like tenants are the untouchables at the minute. You can't talk about where tenants do things badly and they do. Absolutely. But equally, the majority, I would think, wouldn't.

And likewise with landlords, there seems to be a lot of rhetoric around about how bad landlords are around. But again, there are some bad landlords, absolutely. But it's certainly not the bulk of landlords or rental property providers, as we're meant to be calling them now.

Cathie Crampton

We remember that name, don't we? No, it's not the majority. The majority of situations... You know, they're professional, they're respectful and they're conducted within the realms of reasonableness. I think where it's becoming super challenging now, unfortunately, is because it is just so difficult for both parties to operate in a way that's reasonable.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah.

Cathie Crampton

It's really difficult. So I think in terms of the future of PM, unfortunately, we will see it become somewhat more clinical because unfortunately it's not being given a choice and that doesn't serve the interest of either party. So it's a bit of an unfortunate state of affairs.

So I'm not trying to be doom and gloom, but there's always a way through these things. And I expect that we'll see a little bit of moderation of the regulations. At the end of the day, they have to be enforced. I think that the market is going to moderate the cost of things.

That will take noise away. That's what's creating the noise. And, you know, maybe we'll see some of these advocacy bodies that are a little bit one-dimensional.

Veronica Morgan

They diminish in their, you know, the strength of their voice.

Cathie Crampton

So it leaves reasonableness for everybody.

Veronica Morgan

So it appears the pendulum has yet to return to the middle, into middle ground. It's shifting.

Cathie Crampton

It's not middle yet, but it is shifting back. When you see triggers like unemployment rates and inflation rates, and I don't want to see someone unemployed. I've got two very close friends who have both lost jobs in recent weeks. I don't like to see that.

But when you start to see that little bit of correcting, you know that things are becoming a little bit more moderate. That serves everybody.

Veronica Morgan

Cathy, that's been a really fascinating chat. I don't think we've tackled enough this property management side of things in this podcast, actually, and it's been really good. So I really appreciate you coming along. Thank you. We'll have to get you back at some future point with a bit of an update.

So thank you. You're welcome. Thanks for having me. Cheers. Cheers. If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website, theelephantintheroom.com.au or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au.

If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit. And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great.

I know that sounds a bit cringy but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.

Click any timestamp to jump.

Key takeaways

  • Crampton says the legislative wave usually starts in WA or SA, with the eastern states following more slowly, and that post-COVID the responsibility for housing has been pushed onto the private landlord.
  • The ACT lost 3,000 rental properties within 12 months of minimum housing standards arriving, and Victorian rent rolls have shrunk between 5% and 12%, some as much as 20%.
  • Selling is driven by holding costs, with investors weighing yields of 1.5% to 2% against a national average near 3.5%.
  • Removing no grounds terminations and limiting rent increases removes discretion, which she argues takes the kindness out of property management for good tenants too.
  • Rent roll businesses are being rebuilt around capacity, margins of 25% to 30%, business development replacing churn, and technology handling inspections and money movement.
  • Clients want advice the industry has not been trained to give, with property investment sitting outside registration and licensing courses entirely.

Why Are Property Managers Leaving the Industry?

Cathie Crampton works with agency principals across the Belle Property network on rent roll growth, and her read on the past few years is that nobody got off lightly. The housing shortage has been chronic, she says, and most practitioners are empathetic to that. The people administering tenancies, though, were left holding a job that changed faster than the guidance did.

Her example is COVID. She was running a rent roll of about 6,000 properties in Brisbane, and in almost every state property managers were not given timely direction. She was producing videos for her own team, who were not sure what to do or say. They were also not well paid, with few licensing requirements then.

I think at one point, Victoria lost 35% of its workforce in sort of a nine month period.

Cathie Crampton, 4:03

What Did the New Rental Laws Change?

Crampton says the legislative wave usually starts in Western Australia or South Australia, highly regulated markets that were first to require licensing. The eastern states have been slower and more entrepreneurial. Post-COVID, in her view, government has pushed regulation and the responsibility for housing onto the private landlord, usually the mum and dad investor.

Some of the changes she considers reasonable. You effectively cannot refuse a pet without good reason, usually whether the pet suits the property, and there are strict response timelines, commonly 14 days and in one market 21. The harder ones are the minimum housing standards, which she calls a financial encumbrance in Victoria and the ACT, and the removal of no grounds terminations.

She also points to consultation. In Queensland, industry representation made enough noise during the first round of reforms to get a seat at the table. In Victoria, the equivalent body was not invited.

Scenario Matrix: How Recent Rule Changes Are Landing by Market
MarketChange DiscussedEffect Described on Air
ACTMinimum housing standards3,000 rental properties lost within 12 months
VictoriaMinimum standards, plus further changes proposedMost rent rolls shrunk 5% to 12%, some as much as 20%
VictoriaCumulative compliance load through COVIDAbout 35% of the workforce lost in roughly nine months
QueenslandOne rent increase per property per yearRent cannot be reset to market when a tenant vacates mid-year
QueenslandTwo-week maximum holding depositApplicants without local references lose a way to show goodwill
New South WalesNo grounds terminations abolishedFewer grounds than Queensland to finalise a tenancy

As described between 4:03 and 26:54. Figures as stated on air.

What Makes a Landlord Sell a Rental Property?

The clearest number is the ACT, where 3,000 rental properties left the market inside 12 months of minimum standards arriving. In Victoria, a benchmarking study Crampton ran found most rent rolls had shrunk between 5% and 12%, and some as much as 20%.

When they brought those standards into the ACT, for example, they lost 3,000 rental properties within a space of 12 months.

Cathie Crampton, 8:00

Selling is driven by the cost of holding rather than by rent growth. She describes investors looking at yields of 1.5% or 2% where they used to see 3.5% or 4%, with the national average still near 3.5% once regional markets are counted. Updated: Cotality put the national gross dwelling yield at 3.7% in June 2026, up from about 3.5% at the end of 2025, with annual rent growth running at 5.9% rather than slowing (Cotality Rental Review Q2 2026, released 9 July 2026). Where the sums stop working the owner sells, and the exit is not always clean, as CoreLogic's read on which properties resell at a loss shows, with 9.7% of two-year resales losing money in a June quarter.

Agencies feel it too, because a rent roll is the asset. In a previous role Crampton saw the group shrink 5%, and a quarter of its flagship office's sales revenue came off that office's rent roll. Veronica Morgan calls it selling the farm. Crampton has seen a Brisbane rent roll halve within 18 months.

How Do You Grow a Rent Roll Business?

Crampton's answer for business owners starts with capacity, how much one team member can actually manage. It is a high volume, low margin business, the good ones run at 25% to 30%, and those businesses measure everything.

Growth then has to come from the organic engine. If business development replaces churn, acquisitions become strategic rather than necessary, which matters because acquisition is expensive at commercial rates of 7% to 9% while average tenure of a management sits at about 18 months. Technology is the other lever: money movement with instant transparency, and AI handling inspection write-ups that can otherwise take six hours for a four bedroom ingoing. She advocates task-based models with in-office and out-of-office roles and a cadet pathway, warning that assembly line workflows rely on nothing going wrong.

Rate Sheet: Rent Roll Economics Cited on Air
MeasureFigure as Stated
Operating margin on a good rent roll25% to 30%, sometimes more
Rent roll acquisition, commercial rates7% to 9%
Average tenure of a managementAbout 18 months
In-office professional property managerAbout $120,000 a year
Property management wages versus four years ago25% higher
Gross yields being weighed by investors1.5% to 2%, against a national average near 3.5%

As described between 14:54 and 42:40. Figures as stated on air.

Should You Take Investment Advice From a Property Manager?

Hosts and guest circle the same problem: clients now want advice the industry has not built training for. Crampton says property investment sits outside registration and licensing courses altogether, and she once brought her accountant in to teach a team what yield and capital appreciation meant. Morgan says some of that advice is genuinely bad: managing a property in your area is not the same as knowing how to invest in one.

Her broader argument is that removing discretion removes the goodwill with it. Staggered rent increases and tenants held below market get harder to manage when there is no way to reset later, and a below-market rent can weigh on a valuation at refinance. She also expects stock that no longer meets standards to move to private, unregulated landlords, which she considers more dangerous for tenants.

What they've done is they've broken up the equation that actually holds the fabric together.

Cathie Crampton, 28:21

She does not finish on doom. She expects some moderation of the regulations, and thinks the market will moderate costs and take the noise out. The pendulum, as Morgan puts it, is not at middle ground yet, but she believes it is shifting back.

Weighing Up Whether an Investment Property Still Stacks Up?

This episode is about the numbers behind holding a rental property while the rules change around it, from yields to compliance costs. Where the sums have shifted, the terms of an investment property loan are one of the costs still open to review.

Investment Property Mortgage Broker

Sources referenced: The Elephant in the Room, episode 358, "What Are the Nationwide Impacts of Recent Legislative Changes on Property Management?", released 2024-11-10. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Cathie Crampton, National Head, Property Management Growth at Belle Property Corporate. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 10 September 2026, against Cotality Rental Review Q2 2026, released 9 July 2026.