Posted
2 November 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
July 20, 2024
Episode
342
 ·
62
 min
The show

The Elephant in the Room

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with Veronica Morgan. It's a deep dive into what really goes on in the world of real estate.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Veronica Morgan
Veronica Morgan
Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor

Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

Guest
Simon Kuestenmacher
Simon Kuestenmacher
Director, Research of The Demographics Group

Welcoming back Director of Research of The Demographics Group, Simon Kuestenmacher. Simon was a guest back in Episode 40 where he outlined the potential problems of Australia's aging population and the current population growth.

The Next Decade in Property: Simon Kuestenmacher on Wealth Transfer, Gen X and Density

Simon Kuestenmacher returns to map the demographic forces shaping Australian property over the next decade. The conversation covers the intergenerational wealth transfer, why lenders now watch Gen X, and where the next generation of housing might go.

Transcript
Veronica Morgan

In this episode, we're talking with Simon Kustamaka from The Demographic Group. We're going to explore new demographic trends with wealth transfer and how that will shift over the next decade or so. What's up with Gen X? Where banks are starting to view them as the risky generation.

We've also had record immigration numbers in recent times, which has exacerbated our housing crisis. But what are the downsides of changing the population policy? And when it comes to state government housing policies, many consider that New South Wales is leading the way. Does Simon agree?

Welcome to the elephant in the room. This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about.

I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, recently ranked number five in Australia out of over 18,000 brokers in the annual MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Award. Before we get started, I need to let you know that nothing we say here can be taken as personal advice.

We always recommend you engage the services of an appropriate and experienced professional.

Our guest today is Simon Kusamaka, the co-founder of the Demographics Group, together with Bernard Salt. This group provides specialist advice on demographic consumer and social trends. And Simon writes a weekly column for the New Daily and a monthly column for the Australian newspaper, and he's a sought-after media commentator.

In his spare time, it's something I didn't know, Simon has authored three books on maps and runs what is now the world's largest Twitter account dedicated to maps and data. His social media posts reach over 25 million people every month. And he ranks as one of the world's top 10 influencers in data.

So I actually did not know that. That's very impressive, Simon. Thanks for joining us again. It's been a while since we last caught up with you and we've got lots to catch up on.

Simon Kuestenmacher

There's always, always things happening in the world of demographics.

Chris Bates

So always happy to be back on. As you know, Simon, you and I can chat for hours and absolutely love every conversation with you. The demographics in the property market is so interlinked. And so these are always really valuable conversations.

Where we want to start today is, as a broker, it's very clear that the wealth transfer is happening earlier and bigger and faster than I ever thought. And you can see that that's supporting property prices from not just parents and grandparents.

So from a demographics point of view, this sort of wealth transfer and what we're seeing today was probably always predictable. But is it surprising you? And what are you seeing?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Yeah, well, it's great to see the intergenerational wealth transfer taking place already because it's occurring when people are still alive. So your financial advisor would probably tell you stuff like, yeah, hand over wealth to the younger generation while you're still alive. You have control over what you do with the money.

You still get to see the benefits of handing over wealth and you can do it in tax advantageous ways. But that's also a bit awkward for many people because you need to come to terms with your own mortality.

You need to talk about your own mortality with your kids or your kids need to talk about your death with you. That's super awkward. So while this is what we should be doing, many of us don't do it.

And then wealth only gets transferred from one generation to the next when the last parent dies. And that tends to be mom because mom is four years younger than dad and she has four years longer life expectancy.

So that means from a demographic perspective, it is actually very easy to time and to predict when the vast majority of wealth is being handed over. Because all I need to do is count the number of baby boomer women year after year. And I see this number decline.

And instead of calling this instances of baby boomer women deaths, that's a bit morbid. We call them instances of intergenerational wealth transfer. It's so much more clean. Yeah.

Chris Bates

Demographics trends there, but you've also got like changes in society's beliefs and attitudes and, you know, and that can shift, I imagine, I don't know, like, and so with events like COVID or events like house prices running or I don't know. So how is that changing things as well?

Simon Kuestenmacher

The thing that from a societal perspective that is already changing is of course, um, stupendously high house prices.

So therefore, the parents are very tempted, if they have the spare cash, to help their kids to get onto the property ladder by giving them a couple of hundred thousand dollars, depending on what they have, towards their mortgage.

And that is actually, financially speaking, an absolutely marvelous decision if you think about the family unit as a whole. I know interest rates are higher than this at the moment, but if you get an interest rate on your loan of 5.3%,

over 30 years. That means you pay exactly twice the amount of the loan to your bank. At the moment, you pay more than that. But so a $500,000 mortgage becomes a million dollar to the bank. That means in this scenario, if mom and dad give you $100,000 towards your mortgage,

they actually give you $200,000 worth of money. So you double the bang for your buck. You more than double it at the moment. So it's an absolute no-brainer that within the family unit, you should utilize the bank of mom and dad. It's absolutely clear.

That said, that is advice on the individual family unit. On a societal basis, that of course has a couple of implications because we know that even though a particular couple, couple A and couple B, they might be just as educated. They might be just earning the exact same income.

And one couple has a bank of mom and dad to draw from, the other one doesn't. The economic advances that one couple makes over the other are quite significant. So therefore, we are dividing society increasingly into an asset-owning and non-asset-owning cohort.

That, of course, means, yes, aspire to become part of the asset-owning class, but it's very hard for people who cannot be helped onto the property ladder at the moment.

Chris Bates

So, I mean, I guess in past wars or something like that, I'm just curious on this sort of, you know, when people have gone through something, then they have changed their view, right?

And so, do you think that the baby boomer generation, though, for example, their parents have held on to the money, right? They haven't passed it down stereotypically in the past till death because, like you say, those conversations are awkward, et cetera.

But the kids have been sitting there a little bit frustrated and saying, give it to us earlier. It actually can help us. You've got to give it to me when I'm retired. And do you think that their frustration with not getting it passed down has flipped their beliefs?

And so it's kind of catacyclical now. you know, 60, 70% of people didn't get the money earlier. Now they're saying, well, I'm going to give it down earlier if I do get it. Like, I think there's a, that appetite to give it down is what has changed. I don't know.

What do you think?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Absolutely. So that's, that's what would happen on an individual basis. So if you, if you realize that, you know, you only inherited money when, when mom died after many years, um, and then you go, well, I saved money just there now. And I, I do see that my kids need it.

So, of course, you're willing to help out, you want to help out.

For some people, this wealth isn't as easily accessible because for many baby boomers, the wealth does not sit there in terms of cash, even though as a cohort where baby boomers own the vast majority of cash savings, but many individual baby boomers, for them, the wealth sits there in the shape of a family-sized house.

Hmm. And so they are not then immediately encouraged to reverse mortgage it or to sell it, to downsize.

But I would argue that if you were to make it more easy for people to downsize, if you were to make more downsizer type apartments available near where those people own their family sized homes, they would be considering to actually downsize in place.

in place and then utilize part of the windfall from the profit the sale to hand over to the kids right now because they are people very intuitively understand that their kids need the money now rather than later because the way that demographics fall with birth rates you know with first dates of first birth is that millennials now stand to inherit money in their late 50s to early 60s

Which is, and I'm being facetious here, but you don't need money at that point in your life because your kids already left the house at this point and you can actually downsize. So it's a bit of an awkward period to inherit the money.

So you might actually then skip the millennial generation, hand over wealth right away to your own kids so that they have it easier. But it's... It's weird. And millennials would then probably say, I could have used a couple of tens of thousands of dollars of your inheritance a decade earlier.

That would have made things much easier.

Veronica Morgan

As a member of Gen X, I can relate because I think that's the situation. A lot of Gen Xers have been getting their inheritance if they're going to get one in their late 50s to 60s when they're kids. possibly could use it more.

The other thing too, I was reading an article recently that said that one in six baby boomers doesn't own their own home. So there's some perceptions out there about boomers that is sort of a little unfair and they're not all property investors either, are they? Of course not all of them.

Simon Kuestenmacher

So we always need to remember that when we talk about stuff like generation, the boomers that, the genetics that, we talk about millions of people in one hit. So obviously the

The narrative doesn't fit all of them. But as a cohort, we talk about probability clouds here, it's actually surprisingly correct. But that said, if you look at the Gen Xers now, they're the small cohort, poor forgotten Gen X, that are now in the roughest decade of their life.

from a housing perspective, because they still have financially dependent kids. So they have a lot of costs associated with that.

They probably, over the last three to four years, were tempted to upgrade their home in order to make sure that there's enough space so that you push the annoying, loud, stinky teenage kids to the other end of the house.

And now you're starting as a Gen X to have either financially or care-dependent parents. So you're really burning the candle from three ends. It's a weird candle. So you have three weeks and your big mortgage. And for a Gen Xer, there isn't much wiggle room for stuff to go wrong.

So if one partner gets sick overwhelmingly to income households, one partner gets sick. or needs to care only goes down to one and a half incomes, something needs to give. There is not much wiggle room. And this is why you hinted at it at the introduction.

The banks are actually much more nervous at the moment about the Gen X homeowners rather than the first home owners, which I thought would be the case that you give mortgages to young folks who have actually no money. But that's not it because they still are on an increased income.

Millennials earn more money for the next little bit, whereas Gen Xers start to earn a bit less money. And things can go wrong there.

Chris Bates

I would have hit the nail on the head about the income, but I was just going to finish that, like, because it was going through my head and I was thinking about our clients and you're absolutely right.

The ones that did leverage up and then, you know, the income hasn't come like they thought it would, you know, they leveraged up and then they've hit this sort of ceiling and To go to that next ceiling means a lot more risk, right?

And you can't make that risk when you've got a big mortgage and you've got the kids at private school and you've got, like you say, supporting families, et cetera, like that.

And so to make that, you know, maybe it's a lower base for a bigger bonus or maybe it's starting a business or maybe it's investing in the business and a lot of their risk profiles.

isn't there to match their current situation so they haven't got much wiggle room with their job as well and they're sort of stuck because they can't afford to take a new job and go on probation and so I can see that that would play into a lot of the banks and they are stuck because you know to sell their home is a big call right and you know they've got a lot of pressure on

You know, the kids schools and they're integrated into the community and there's not enough properties and they won't walk away with that much after transaction costs and it's a rental crisis. And so it's extremely stressful for that person, particularly when there's a lot of obligations. A very little wiggle room on their income.

Simon Kuestenmacher

Yeah. And you'll see what people will be doing. So people will be hopefully looking beyond the horizon and they kind of understand that, okay, I have a lot of costs right now. The costs will minimize once the kids turn 18 and get out of high school.

And then hopefully the HECS system takes care of the university costs too. And so my child-related costs go down. Maybe if things get really tight, I'll jump on an interest-only

a mortgage repayment scheme for a couple of years these are the things that we'll be seeing and the banks will become much more flexible in making those arrangements they of course like it because then your mortgage lasts longer so it's great for the banks it's not good for you as an individual because you don't accrue as much wealth and you burn more money through the mortgage but that's what families will be doing because we

We're now tackling housing affordability on a structural basis, but not in a way that we can say we drive down house prices. So we're slowing down house price growth. That is the best you can hope for from a housing affordability perspective. So I don't see...

It is a reasonably safe bet to sell your house because there's stamp duty involved. So changing houses is actually quite expensive. You have moving costs associated. So you can't make that much more money with it moving to a smaller property, especially since those smaller properties are also not available.

So it's not that easy to downsize. It's not that easy to upgrade. So people feel a bit stuck and people will just trying to do... It also feels a bit like Australian. This Australian stubbornness, depending on what kind of thing hits you, just you go straight through it.

Yes, yet another fire burned down the town. We'll rebuild. We'll go at it again. I think that is a bit of resilience in there that can also turn into hardheadedness.

Veronica Morgan

Peak-headedness.

There's a couple of things there too. I mean, the thing is, and I've been talking to a number of my cohort who, you know, we sort of went, and I probably fall in this category too, of being a mortgage prisoner.

And so this is effectively, I've got lots of asset, I've got lots of equity, lots of equity, but I've also got more borrowing and I could probably re-borrow, you know, given the current rates, et cetera, et cetera, right? And so I'm like, you know, I can't.

I haven't actually gone through this exercise, but I suspect if I did, that I wouldn't be able to easily refinance. And I know a lot of others that are in a very similar situation. And they've got good assets, good homes. I've got a number of properties.

And if I don't want to sell any of them down, then I've got no freedom to change my borrowing structure.

Simon Kuestenmacher

Unless you find somebody really good like Chris who can help you out with it.

Veronica Morgan

Even then, I'm, you know... Even then, you can't wait miracles.

Simon Kuestenmacher

No, but you are right. You are right. There's a certain point where you get stuck in the system and either something needs to give, you sell an asset, and then all of a sudden there's wiggle room again, or you just kind of push. Find a way to push through.

Follow the RBA announcements for lower interest rates. But now this is the most dangerous part of this podcast where the demographer talks about economics.

Don't worry, plenty of economists want to talk about demographics, so don't worry. That's right. So demographically speaking, interest rates will struggle to go down because the RBA is fighting an uphill battle against demographics.

What I mean by this is the RBA wants us to spend less money, you and I and the business community, because that is deflationary. And so it got cool. That makes sense. You drive up interest rates, then you don't spend as much.

The problem, though, is that demographically speaking, for the next decade, we have the biggest generation that ever lived in Australia, the millennial generation, moving through the highest spending phase of the life cycle, the mid-40s. In the mid-40s, you already had all the kids that you ever will have. and you're spending on them.

You have a lot of money because you had a couple of promotions, but your kids consume a lot of Weet-Bix, cricket bats, and you have this big fat mortgage. At 43, 44, 45, every penny that you earn, straight out the door back into the economy. And so that is baked into the system.

Millennials will not stop spending. At the other end of the spectrum, you have this big baby boomer cohort moving into retirement. Traditionally, this would have been good news because then you turn into a poor penny-pinching pensioner and you stop spending money. Baby boomers won't.

They're all asset rich, meaning through the high house prices, they feel rich. This is where we talk about this wealth effect taking place. You spend more money and they own the vast majority of the Australian cash savings, meaning they actually get richer in the process. So why would baby boomers stop spending money?

Makes no sense. So therefore, you need to keep the interest rates relatively elevated. I'm not saying there won't be any rate cuts or anything, but interest rates needs to be structurally speaking more elevated to stop us spending money. And who will suffer the most?

Let's call it the bottom third, bottom quarter of society, something like this. So we're further increasing the economic divide. If you do this under a labor government in particular, you will see more generous social nets. That is again inflationary, so you prolong the high interest rate scenario.

That is the end of me talking about economics, I promise. And there is more than just the consumer to the interest rates because how much businesses invest is much more important in terms of driving inflation than consumer behavior. But that element, of course, I'm not all that optimistic.

So I would say interest rates are probably not going to fall all that much.

So those pressures that we just discussed, they are probably going to be with us for longer than we would enjoy.

Chris Bates

Right. And do you think that that'll lead, so if we are in this environment though, where there is a spending more than our resources and things like that, that'll then lead to wage increases? Or do you think that, you know, and also the attack on, you know, overseas migration, right?

The changes to our universities, et cetera. So how do you think that that then plays into that? Because

Ultimately, then if we see an undersupply of labor, right, skill shortages, you also see cost of living pressures, and we're having to spend more for what we buy because inflation's high and interest rates are high, then you're going to ask for more wage increases. So how do you see all that playing out?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Well, so if we talk about the wage increases, that is going to be pretty much baked into the system because what is happening over the next decade is that we have this big court of baby boomers leaving the world of work. There's a big cohort moving into retirement.

They are, of course, allowed to retire. They worked hard. It's fine. It's not a new phenomenon. But previously, when one bunch left the workforce, you had a bigger bunch entering at the other end. This time around, it is big cohort out, relatively smaller cohort in, because the folks that are now entering

The world of work is the small Gen Z cohort. These are the kids of the tiny Gen X cohort. And yes, we're amping them up with migration, with international students. And so if you look at a chart, you've got to go, now there are plenty of people in their 20s.

Surely they'll make up the gap, but they won't. Because despite the narrative about international students just coming here to drive Ubers and not contributing, not being students, overwhelmingly international students are international students and they're not contributing to the workforce.

And plus, half of Australians now go to university, meaning they're not really contributing to the Australian workforce at scale before the mid-20s because they hang out in the university system for just one more degree, one more degree, because education also became inflationary.

So instead of just doing a bachelor, which is now half of a year 12 cohort will go to uni. We don't need that many, to be quite honest. So that drives the value of degrees down.

So in order to then get this pay increase, the bang for your buck, you stay for a master's. The number of PhD students in Australia is stupendous. They're much to be, traditionally speaking, to be feeding into the university system as expert educators. We have way too many.

So yes, from a knowledge perspective, the PhDs are great. They increase the pool of knowledge in this planet. It's wonderful. But from a workforce perspective, it's stupid. Anyways, those people, that means they don't contribute to the workforce right away. So we have a shrinking pool of workers.

As if this wasn't bad enough news. We have millennials continuing to make babies for the next 13, 14 years, meaning they go on parental leave, leave the world of work at least temporarily. So we are running out of workers, structurally speaking. What do you do when you run out of workers?

Well, wages go up. And you work your existing staff to death. You also do that. But so you'll be working more, you'll be getting more money. For work-life balance has gone awful. It's great that you have more money.

Well, as long as the cost of living stays roughly the same, then more money is cool. If cost of living goes up more than your wage, you haven't gained much. You probably lost stuff. And that will continue for the next decade. Pretty rough prediction.

Chris Bates

Do you think though that, you know, you said that the baby boomers are going to keep spending, right?

But if they then see that their Gen X kids and their kids and their grandkids really struggling, you know, like you said, with cost of living and, you know, entering the property market and they're slogging themselves out at work and things like that, that... that will only increase the wealth transfer earlier.

And that money will most likely go into property. Do you see that that's where it's going to go? The whole intergenerational wealth transfer

Simon Kuestenmacher

will be used on property. It is hilarious. So if you think about this, so either if you transfer wealth right now from one generation to the next, two things, one is much more common. The first one is the bank of mom and dad to help out with housing. That's the biggest one.

The second one is paying for your grandkids' childcare. These are two big things. Yeah. Yeah. The vast majority of that goes into property.

If you inherit money or the wealth when the last parent, when mom dies, the two and a half kids of her, they will inherit a quarter acre block, maybe a smaller block with a family-sized home.

You either sell this block, which happens to be mostly located in the middle suburb of big five cities, statistically speaking. You either sell this house as is to a relatively rich family that can afford this,

They probably then take the population density of this particular lot from one person to four persons. But most likely and more commonly than not, we will bulldoze the quarter acre block and we'll put two, three, 28 shitty townhouses, whatever we can squeeze onto the lot.

And we then take the density of this lot from one person to 10 people. And so this already money entered the property market. The two and a half kids, they will share the profit and they will do exactly what you do when you get money.

you will pay off the mortgage, property market, you'll buy an investment property, a property market. The 2030s, because this is when we will see the intergenerational wealth transfer speed up throughout the 2030s, it'll reach the crescendo in 2041. It'll then stay elevated throughout most of the 2040s. That's when baby boomer women die.

And So we know what's happening. So if you are the property game, do not exit. Do not retire before the 2030s and 40s because that's when things will get absolutely wild.

So as a mortgage broker, as an auctioneer, as a real estate agent, the amount of work that will come through you is crazy. So much turnover there because... Who is going to move into those newly developed townhouses in the middle suburbs?

It is not the young folks that are right then looking to start their families because they are not rich enough to afford this.

It is the millennials that just right now over the last couple of years moved to the urban fringe, to the cheapest suburbs where they could afford the three and four bedroom. They can then upgrade and move back to the middle suburbs.

And so you, statistically speaking, the thing that happens is you shorten the average length of time spent in a house. So you increase the number of property transactions. So anyone who is having a finger in the pie of a property transaction is making a killing.

From a state perspective, we say we do not care about making a profit. If we just care about right-sizing the property market, you get rid of stamp duty before that happens. That allows people to turn over homes at an even higher rate and right-size at a higher rate.

Then you could actually use the dying out of the baby boomers as a catalyst to make sure that everybody moves into a house that roughly fits their needs.

That would work beautifully if there wasn't such a stupid thing as politics where everybody might agree that this would be a good thing to get rid of stamp duty. But what do you do instead? You introduce a land tax.

And a land tax will be absolutely beloved by absolutely everyone who doesn't own a house. It will be absolutely hated by everyone who owns a house. And still the majority of voters own their house. So it is political suicide to attempt this.

Because if one party, doesn't matter whether it's the red party, the blue party, agrees on, yeah, we should do this, let's get rid of stamp duty and introduce land tax, all the other party needs to do is sit there quietly and say, how about we don't do that thing?

and then they will be in power. It's guaranteed. So without absolutely bipartisan support from the get-go, this policy cannot happen within the next 10, 15 years. It's utterly unthinkable.

Who knows whether this will be the case? Maybe in a power broker situation where the Greens, who are the biggest third party and who are, of course, overwhelmingly being voted in by renters, to be honest, from a housing perspective, they could operate as a power broker there.

But I think still, without Labour and Liberals working together, stamp duty is difficult to get rid of.

Chris Bates

You've been tracking the work from home chain. I mean, a pandemic, I mean... demographer's dream scenario, right? Putting the people to the side and all the health issues, like to watch the change to society through that and how we changed.

What's your thoughts on where we're at in this debate of, you know, working from home versus hybrid work versus five days back in the city? And, you know, how do you see this? You know, because it's going to go through stages, right? And where do you think we are in that?

And where do you think that we might end up?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Well, so a couple of thoughts here. First one is that we probably will end up with some sort of hybrid mix. You cannot turn back the clock and pretend that we completely go back to pre-pandemic levels where we go into the office five days a week. That is unthinkable.

What also turned out not to be the case is that we work fully remotely. Very, very few people do this. Most people work at least one day per week in the office.

What that already means, and one day is enough to do this, is that it means you need to be somewhat connected to the CBD, to the office district of your city. And that means we stay within a magical two-hour drive time radius of the CBD.

If you draw, and you can do this across every city, every capital city in Australia, it is hilarious how much it works. Draw a two-hour drive time radius, and you see that everything within this two-hour drive time is boomtown. Outside of this, it is crickets.

So from a property perspective, draw this two-hour drive-time radius, you'll get the benefits of the commuters. If you happen to be in a city that is located outside of the two-hour drive-time radius, if you're a lifestyle town, you're fine. Then people move there for lifestyle. It could be a retirement town.

People still find you an attractive enough destination. That's fine. But most of those towns are actually regional towns that then in order to grow their population base, they need to have three things. That is jobs, housing and schooling. If they have those three, they can continue to grow its population base.

But many don't. And so they all of a sudden struggle. So all those regional towns boomed during the pandemic. You know, health fears and concerns drove people there. Now we are undoing these things. So those regional towns are very, very much in the need for job stimulus.

And quite often when you get those jobs and you have regional employers say, cool, no worries, we give you the jobs. And these tend to be agricultural or manufacturing jobs where you need relatively low income workers. Right. and they have no housing.

So why would a low-income earner relocate to a place where they can't afford housing? They won't. So in a regional area, you definitely need to provide housing as well. And so sometimes those towns are stuck. Every now and then I've been to towns where you have jobs available.

The local business elite swears that they could hire more people. The council does their bit of actually making land available.

And then they all of a sudden say, yeah, but these areas, they need to be linked into sewage, into electricity, and the state doesn't build it. And so they just sit there. And you don't want to invest in a town like this before you know that there's investment from infrastructure perspective coming.

Veronica Morgan

I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions. And you can find out all about what I'm working on at veronicamorgan.com.au.

And there you'll find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program, access to suburb help for investors, or if you're looking to buy your dream home or an investment property in Sydney's inner west, eastern suburbs, or lower North Shore, you can connect with my team at Good Deeds Property Buyers.

If you're thinking about buying your first home, upgrading to a new one or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Please reach out via our website, wealthful.com.au.

Chris Bates

So Simon, there's a bit of a swinging ball, right? So I think at the moment from what we're seeing is that fear around a recession, fear around higher interest rates, fear about losing your job, fear about asking for a wage increase, right? Like fear about not getting promoted.

You know, workers, productivity's dropped, right? So they're like, get back in the office. They've got their commercial space. They want to... And so there's that. The employee is a little bit nervous. So they're going back to the office probably more than they want because they don't want to be seen.

Like, they're not going. And then the employer also wants that. So there's really this suction back to the city right now. But...

What you're saying earlier in this conversation basically says that that worker doesn't need to worry long-term because ultimately they're going to be coming highly, particularly if they're educated and they're a knowledge worker, there's going to be an undersupply of those. Exactly.

And so they can actually go, well, right now because of the economy and where we're at, I have to go back to work. But if I bet five years down the line, as soon as those things go, they're going to want me and they're going to need to give me flexibility.

Is that your take? Yeah.

Simon Kuestenmacher

Very much so. So you'll time this. And structurally speaking, one of my main truisms about the future of Australia is that we are running out of workers. Because this ever-growing aging population, while they do not contribute to the workforce, they create jobs. Aged care, for example.

We all heard stuff a million times like, oh, Australia is aging. But we're not even nearly aware of how many jobs we're creating by this, how much demand. We're doubling the 85-plus population in the next 14 years. Wow. From 580,000 people to 1.2 million people.

That's happening guaranteed because we're not importing all people. They're already here. And half of the 85 plus cohort need care on a daily basis. This could be delivered by a professional carer or by a family.

But so, you know, it might not be exactly this because you could even say, yeah, the new retirees, the new elderly of tomorrow, they're healthier than previous court. Cool.

So we might not completely need to double the amount of aged care workers, but we easily need to increase it by 80% or something like this.

Veronica Morgan

So we circle back around to immigration then, don't we?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Exactly. Immigration, which is why after the budget a couple of weeks ago, there was a lot of strong talk by a liberal opposition leader and by a Queensland state labor premier about needing to cut back migration. And this is all what is done under the umbrella of housing affordability.

migrants are just humans like everyone else and there's no racist narrative here but these humans need to be housed so we minimize the migrant intake and all of a sudden we need to house fewer people that takes pressure off the housing market this is a good policy and we do this to make sure that Australians get more affordable housing because that is truly what they need that's the narrative and they always make very sure that there's no racist emphasis in these statements cool fair enough

But it's also an outrageously convenient narrative because housing affordability in that context happens to just be linked to a non-voting cohort. Migrants, very, very convenient. It also means that you already, by talking about this, you tick the box of tackling housing affordability.

You do then not need to mention that you as a government are very complicit into high house prices. Queensland stamped you that drives up house prices, period. No discussion about it. Queensland operates first home buyer grants.

There is not a single economist in this country, on this planet, who would claim that first home buyer grants make housing more affordable. They drive up house prices. Because it is, you give, you know, a couple of people, let's call it 10, 20,000 people, you give them 20,000 additional dollars,

And you then hope that the market doesn't notice and doesn't price this in. That is stupid. The only dumber policy than wasting public money on this is what the liberals said in wasting your own money, your own $50,000 worth of superannuation on it.

This will also be affected in that you're eating into your own nest egg in retirement. So these are criminal policies if you want to make housing more affordable. So we shouldn't do this. And then, of course, you have ranking credits that could be discussed. These are all topics that are very, very iffy.

And ask Bill Shorten, you know, he talked about this when he lost the unlosable. So politically speaking, you don't do this. And so housing affordability is never really honestly talked about because housing affordability is the result of two factors. One is your income. The other one is the price of the house.

So either if you want to make housing more affordable, you need to say, hey, I give you all more money or I make this house worth less money. That's the two things that you have to deal with.

And since the majority of Australians still own their house, which politician would be bold enough to say, I understand it's tough for you to see your biggest asset lose wealth, but this is what we need to do in order to have a successful future Australia operating.

It's for the greater good and we all are willing to take that bullet collectively. So tell me that qualification.

Veronica Morgan

But even if we did that, even if, which is never going to happen, but even if everyone says, oh, yeah, you're right. You know, my kids can't get in the market. So let's just do the Etch-A-Sketch and basically wipe the slate clean and let's start again.

Let's just get it down to a manageable level. Let's just do this one-off massive hit. Guys, it's just a lot of pain. Just rip the Band-Aid off. It's going to then, the market will then start to perform in however way it's going to perform and we'll end up back where we started, right?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Exactly. You can play this thought experiment any day of the week. Let's just say house price in your capital cities fall by a quarter million dollars tomorrow. That's cool. So first of all, you go like, great, I'll go out and buy a house. It's so much cheaper.

But then all other people go like, yeah, it's awesome. It's so much cheaper. I'll buy it too. It drives up. Exactly. And at some point you... This goes up again. And so you say, well, yeah, so we do need to increase the housing demand like crazy.

And this is when I talk to people, Max Schiffman, for example, from ex-UDIA managing Interpac property.

I learned a lot about how much it costs to build different housing. So the cheapest way of building a three bedroom is to bulldoze land on the outskirts of town. That's the cheapest way.

It's actually more expensive to build this three bedroom as an apartment or as a high rise because high labor costs, high material costs. And so you go, well, that's why we're not building those apartments. This is why we're still trying to operate on the greenfield because that's where housing is more affordable.

And then if you then have a property on sale, a three bedroom property, it's just so much more expensive as an apartment than a greenfield box.

It's not worth it. My argument against this, though, is that this is only the point in time that you sell it, that this is cheap. We still want to remember that Australian cities are a bit awkward looking. Australian cities from a population perspective, from a population density perspective, are on average around...

three to four times lower than a comparable European city. In some cases, it's much more extreme. Like Berlin, for example, fits seven times into Melbourne from a size perspective. They're roughly comparable cities.

And so you go, that's not good because that means that you and I, as taxpayers, we pay for about... Let's call it four times the number of sewage pipage, of electricity lines, of rail, of road. It's expensive to be a sprawled out city.

So if we somehow found a mechanism of financing property, medium density, high density property in a long term perspective, it would ultimately be cheaper in the long run. And that is, by the way, what people try to do with the built-to-rent sector.

Because this is a property that is not meant to be sold ever. This is meant to be, somebody builds it, they own this property forever onwards, and they get a continued income through rent. And this, for the first 30 years or forever, how long you finance this thing, isn't that sexy.

You know this with your own property, that it's very expensive for the first 30 years that you pay down the mortgage. And once you paid it down, the housing is essentially for free. Yes, 1% maintenance costs, whatever. But it's dirt cheap.

And if you had a long-term property investor, this could be a state, this could be a super fund, any kind of institutional investor really, you could create the type of housing that the planners want and you could finance it. At the moment, that doesn't work.

Chris Bates

Do you know with the Chris Min stuff that's going on, though, in New South Wales, that this is really a good insight of the direction we should be going. And it's really pretty brave policy to upset councils and say, we're going to overrun you and this is what you must do.

So it's finally some accountability there. Are you a massive fan of what they're doing? Yeah.

Simon Kuestenmacher

Absolutely. First of all, I'm an absolute massive fan, but I'm also seeing a couple of risks there. So what we've been seeing for decades is that councils, particularly councils in the middle suburbs of Melbourne and Sydney, to be quite honest, blocked development.

because they were not incentivized to okay development. As a local council, as a self-interested local council, you're actually stupid to give the green tick to any development because somebody hates it. And this somebody could be the neighbor, could be whoever, but they will be voting for you.

And so they will not be voting for you if you're okay. So you just veto everything. And then if it's really important, VCAT or NCAT or wherever pushes it through and you are good to go. But that slowed development. That made sure that we continued urban sprawl.

Because instead of building apartments in the middle suburbs of Melbourne, Sydney, we build it on the outskirts of town. So we support out the cities. The states now kind of had enough of this. And they say, hey, how about we set really strict housing targets for each local government area?

And if you don't hit those targets, you get consequences. At the moment, they're still using the carrot. At the moment, it still operates largely that there is an additional magic pile of money and you get handed part of this money if you fulfill your housing targets. That's the first step.

We'll be very soon be seeing the stick. So you withhold funding from local councils or you put them under administration. that is happening.

And you do this because so you can centralize planning functions and you can say, we need that many people here, that many people there, we need that kind of dwelling stock here.

So it's a bit more like SimCity where, you know, the computer game, where you have the centralized power deciding where something goes. That's what the states and what the Minsk government is doing at the moment. That's cool. That works.

The downside of this is that you lose local intelligence, is that you do dumb centralized Soviet-style planning without taking the local concerns into place because there's a reason to begin with why we had three levels of government.

And we cannot completely kill off local government and hope that there are no negative consequences.

Veronica Morgan

There's a couple of things here, right, for starters, like Soviet-style development. Well, they actually built higher housing for people, ugly, but it was built, right? And it was built by the state, right?

And so that's what it seems to be our states are still trying to avoid building housing themselves across the board, right? Like Chris Minns recently came out saying, right, well, I've resumed all these areas. Where are all the new dwellings? Oh, they're not being built. I tell you what.

We'll help because we'll buy them off the plan. So the government will buy them off the plan to help give developers confidence to go forward and lenders, a lot of us, to go forward to get these things commenced.

And it's like so the reality is zoning these areas doesn't actually naturally translate into commencements for all the reasons that the government themselves are not the developers, right? And so even with the state government starting to use a stick, How's the local government going to make a developer develop their site?

They're going to start handing out another stick to the developer to say, you must develop your site, right? But the other thing too, I'm observing this at the moment in some of the leafy North Shore suburbs of Sydney, where you've got the rezoning within, I think, 400 kilometres. meters of train stations, right?

And there's this standoff happening because all these properties, all these owners, they're sitting within this zone. They've been approached by developers and agents to say, right, if you buddy together with your friends, let's put together a development site and let's put it to market.

Now, anecdotally, the stories that I've come across, not one of them have actually sold. Because their expectations are a lot more than what a developer is prepared to commit to.

But not only have they not sold, the opposition came out and said, well, if we get back into government, we're going to revoke all that rezoning change. So immediately you've got a situation where it's a standoff. So anybody who actually wants to sell their house in these zones, they can't.

Because who's going to buy it?

Simon Kuestenmacher

You need to have the confidence for the private sector to be able to say this zoning, these laws, they stay in place. Otherwise, investing a thing because very much it's still the case that it takes forever to get this thing off the ground.

Veronica Morgan

Or alternatively, what I was speaking to someone else and hoping to get on the podcast in Victoria, we've had situations where rezoning where the developer's gone, fantastic, I'm going to go and get an approval for, you know, an extra 20 stories or whatever.

Now my sites were so much more than it was before. They're trading the sites and they're still not developing them.

Simon Kuestenmacher

Exactly. And so they're discussing things in the background about how can we incentivize fast development? What kind of staged taxation scheme or whatever could there be that you want to get people into the market as soon?

We, of course, have the issue, generally speaking, that there is demand for housing across the full income spectrum from the multi, multi-million dollar, super wonderful, sexy billionaire homes to affordable homes. just like social housing stuff.

Development is a low margin industry, 25% or thereabouts to begin with. We do not have enough developers to service the full spectrum of the market. So it's anyone's guess which end of the market the developers will service first. It makes no sense to play on the bottom end of the market.

And so this, the bottom end of the market is what of course worries me because this is where we have the most economic suffering anyways. And this end of the market could be serviced by a state-owned property developer.

And this would mean that you actually have to have a company that the state owns, that develops the stuff. And we don't have that.

And I, to be honest, I secretly predicted that an Albanese government might come up with something like this because this is somebody in commission housing who kind of got used to the benefits of that. So I had it on my policy prediction radar and it didn't work.

appeared just now. No sign of it, hey? Yeah, not at all. It's nowhere to be seen.

Veronica Morgan

And it's fascinating. I find it's like at what point is everyone going to stop and go, okay, come on, governments, the time, the rhetoric has to stop. It's the time for action. Like their target, the five-year target at 1.2 million dwellings, how are they tracking?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Quite obviously, if you just look back at the last year or so and then you look project this forward, you know, this is a big miss. But you want to go, okay, an ambitious target is always needed. So it's always the goal. We've got no shortage of ambitious targets.

If you also are serious about structural change. So if you want structural change, you need to have a very ambitious target, otherwise you're not doing it. And you go, this is my old line of, if you go to a greenfield site,

anywhere in australia you look at the way they're building the house you go is this the best way to build a house we've taken all the intelligence and technological advances that mankind created up to today is this the best way and you can't possibly say yes no apparently apparently we had manufacturing for prefabricated houses after world war ii um

Veronica Morgan

And now we no longer have the capacity or capability for it.

Simon Kuestenmacher

And I think that's where things need to move to, is to move part of the big chunk of construction from the construction sector into the manufacturing sector. Not everything. So we talk about...

We talk about greenfield sites, we talk about medium density blocks that can easily be legoed together on site. There's lots of infill development where you operate on awkwardly shaped lots, and this will be construction.

There might be prefab wall elements that can be shipped to site as well, but overwhelmingly, this will be the construction sector. So the traditional construction sector, as we think of it as the moment, that'll continue to operate.

But there is plenty of space to completely rethink the way we do housing in a manufacturing sense. The problem is that every big player is already playing with it. But they're doing what I would consider piecemeal.

Because if you think about this, just imagine, you could build a massive factory with crazy machines where you built pre... This is individualized walls. This is not just a wall where every house looks the same. You design it on plan, you take the materials, you individualize... Lego blocks.

It has all the things, the wiring... The pipes spilled into it. You can build it with machines at relatively fewer laborers on site. And then you just ship it to site and build it there. You could completely eliminate material waste issue.

You have about, what is it, a quarter of material gets wasted on a construction site, something dumb like this. You do not have any bad weather. Because you build it under a roof. You utilize your labor better.

We run out of tradies and they spend an awful lot of time in a car driving from A to B. They're wasting productivity there. You could minimize this in a factory. So there's plenty of stuff that could be done better in a factory setting. But who is setting up this factory?

Setting this up, finding, driving the innovation is stupendously expensive at first. In the long run, we know that it will be cheaper, but who's financing this in the long run?

Even a big player like a Lendlease, like a Mervic, they are not rich enough, as dumb as that sounds, to pull this off at scale. So where does the money come from? And I would always point to super funds, but we'll see.

Chris Bates

Yeah, I mean, it's interesting. So I follow the prefab space, you know, Modscape and Archie Blocks, and there's been so many places. Ultimately, they need cash buyers to buy their properties. And that's only a subset of the market that, you know, is a bit older who want to do that.

And then they get a council approval, et cetera. And it's the banks that are holding the tin there. Ultimately, if they were allowing people to borrow for a prefab build, then they would.

They'd create a whole demand for it and the banks just won't do it because they have no control over the assets. So, you know, Modscape, for example, they're building this thing, you know, they want progress payments.

They're not going to build it all and then say, give me the money once it's on the site. They want to get paid along the way. It's too risky for them. And then when it's that they go under, the bank could be completely go lose their money because they've given it.

And that's, I think the thing that the missing ingredient, like it all makes sense, but they can't get funding. Yeah, but the developer could,

Simon Kuestenmacher

There are so many financial innovations that need to come as well. So we think about technological things, we think about demographics, but there is just ways of where the financial incentives don't work. We just have no way of financing this in the right way.

And I look for those banks for super funds, for, you know, how could a state finance this kind of stuff in the long run? There is innovation that I would want people, be it super funds, be it states, be a bit more innovative and just risk it. Risk it with one project.

All you waste is, potentially waste, is a couple of millions, couple of tens of millions. This is nothing considering the size of those players. But we do need to get rid of this, what is being called a CMA, you know, the cover my ass mentality where people are risk averse.

We want to take risks. Otherwise, we're not getting rid of this wicked problem. It is a complex problem and we do need bolder, more innovative players in the field. Absolutely.

Veronica Morgan

I think we need longer than a four-year election cycle then if that's the case because there's not a lot of boldness and innovation coming from our leaders because what's the point?

We talked about it earlier with the tax settings that we have that we're stuck with because they're politically unpalatable and so there's no real reform. It's just we try to band-aid everything without changing anything.

Simon Kuestenmacher

Or even just a couple of industry bodies or whatever to get together and really lobby hard for bipartisan support for a thing. This is also the whole idea that you just give money that you must. And we have frameworks in place already in Australia with the Royal Commission, for example.

This is a marvelous institution where you think we actually have a mechanism that says there's a certain issue with something like child sexual abuse that is bigger than politics. So we give this issue into the hands of experts. And they can then draw those decisions.

And so why couldn't we use the kind of spirit that is associated with something like a Royal Commission to a certain issue like housing, which is why some people call for a Royal Commission for housing.

Veronica Morgan

Well, every commission, I mean, commissions are regularly called, but they're not Royal Commissions. Maybe that's the difference. You know, the last affordability, you know, The Felinski report, same shit, different shovel. You know, been there, done that, heard it all before. Nothing changes. Yep, yep, yep, yep, yep, yep, yep, yep, yep.

Chris Bates

On that though, though, Simon, you said about like Royal Commissions. I do wonder though, the Aged Care Royal Commission, like, you know, obviously there's major issues there. And that's when you said that the 85 plus, particularly it's going to be women. Like you said, they're four years younger.

They live four years longer, right? Yeah. that they're in this cohort, and that cohort's going to double, right? But that cohort don't want to go into aged care, right? They don't want to go to... They want to stay in their homes. They don't want to have that change in those lifestyles.

So how is that big failing also contributing to our property market troubles?

Simon Kuestenmacher

Yeah, oh, beautiful. Yeah, so there is this whole idea of, yes, we do need to build more stock, but also what can we do to optimise the existing stock? And we know that... Yeah, we talk about downsizing a lot, but ultimately people want to be carried out of their family home.

That's the ultimate Australian dream, which is one way of downsizing into the box, but more than anything, we are going to die in our home. That's the thing. And so we're not going to downsize. So what can we do to encourage downsizing?

I can guarantee you that now with the oldest baby boomer is 78 years of age at the moment. 79, whatever it is. And that means they are soon going to hit the care age.

they do not want to move into a retirement home, not at all. They will want to live independently. So we do know that there's a lot of innovation coming in terms of home, aged care delivery, ambulance care services, absolutely guaranteed. But that doesn't help the improvement of the housing stock.

One thing that we know though, from now that we have incredibly beautiful mental health data. We know that one thing that makes you absolutely depressed in old age is your partner dying. That's hardly a surprise. You spend decades with them. Your mental health declines when the partner dies.

But your mental health goes absolutely down the drain if you find yourself as a widower in a car-dependent suburb, in a non-walkable neighborhood. Wow. Because you increasingly stay isolated, socially isolated, and you... don't drive anymore that often. Your friends are the same.

They either die or they don't visit you. Your kids are very busy. They don't come. And so life just gets worse. So what I always encourage people in their 70s, couples in their 70s is move into a car-dependent neighborhood. to a walkable neighborhood in your 70s.

This could be a retirement village if this is in your playbook, but make sure you're in a walkable community. Establish a new set of friends, a new social network in this neighborhood in your 70s because the partner that outlives the other one, they will definitely thank them.

So staying in your family house might sound like the great place, like the ideal thing for you, But it might just be a lack of imagination because the data so far tells us that it is actually not the best choice.

Veronica Morgan

That's actually fascinating. And I know I'll talk to a lot of people about this and they tend to leave it too late.

But there's also, like you referred to it earlier, there's often not the suitable properties for them to downsize to in the same location. Right. Literally, I was on Martin North's show the other night, and he brought up a scenario.

It was a woman recently widowed in a four-bedroom family home in the Burbs, and she's looked around and can't find anything to downsize to because she didn't want to go to an apartment. Now, once she opened, she ended up actually buying an apartment because he got her to challenge that assumptions around apartments.

But it was just interesting that her perception was that there was nothing to downsize to because there's no gap. You've got big family homes, big blocks, and then you've got apartments.

Simon Kuestenmacher

Exactly. And we're now slowly trying to fix this. But if you want to explain why Australian cities look the way they do and why we now have this lack of housing mix, you go back to when baby boomers got car keys in the early 50s and 60s.

By then, Australian cities were roughly comparable in size and make up to European cities. Because you were commuting by a tram and bicycle and you walked because cars were the mass phenomenon before the 50s. And then the family, they made babies in the early 20s.

They moved from the inner city to the newly opening up suburbia. So you buy a quarter acre block. You drive up the road until you can afford a quarter acre block. You put on your brick veneer. If you're Greek, you put up a couple of columns, life as well.

The next family did the exact same thing, but they drove 10 meters further. The next family, another 10 meters further. And this is essentially how we built out our Australian cities for the next 60 years. So we have this crazy urban sprawl.

We have New York City in the center of town, big fat skyscrapers. And then we move into suburbia. And we don't have the, what we call Euroblocks, those four-story blocks with a courtyard in the middle with lots of family-sized apartments in it in Europe, historically speaking, and we can't fit them in now.

Because in order to build one of those euro blocks, you need 10 consecutive quarter acre blocks. And they are not available because grandmas don't die in such a coordinated fashion that you get them all in the same way. So the best we can do when we densify is townhouses.

We can't do this big scale. And of course, you can do things what the Minsk government is doing in New South Wales. You say, hey, around the rail hubs, we...

We now really encourage large-scale development. That's the best you can do. And we're inching around along like this. That said, that's how the big existing cities do it.

If we were to take completely the big-picture perspective about Australia in 71 years, because in my best estimate, in 71 years, Australia will double in size from 27 million people to 54 million people.

And this is the computer game challenge to you and everyone listening here. Imagine Australia with twice the number of population. You've got Australia handed right now, 27 million people and a box of 27 million new Australians. Where do you put those new Australians? Where? You could double every city times two.

Now that'd be dumb because Melbourne and Sydney stopped functioning at around four and a half million people. So you don't want to double Melbourne and Sydney. You want to grow them. You need to double Perth. It's a purely functional city. Times one and a half is enough.

So that means though that smaller cities like in Adelaide times two and a half easily. That means a Newcastle, a Wollongong, a Townsville times three. So what would a town like this? And this is very confronting to quite a few people listening to this.

What would a Townsville, well Townsville has the table lands, but like a city like a Wollongong in Newcastle where you have more wiggle room. What would this city look like at times three the population? Well, first and foremost, the outskirts of town right now are the middle suburbs of tomorrow.

So this is where we could build the missing middle right now. It would look a bit awkward right now to build density on the outskirts of town, but it will catch up with it. In the long run. So that's the super long-term perspective that we're not taking into account.

And if we were to take this into account, we could even build smart infrastructure. You know, this fast rail corridor that is always being discussed along the eastern seaboard? Right now, that's financial suicide. It's a dumb thing today. But at double the population, it is an absolute must.

So it's just a matter of timing when we build it.

Veronica Morgan

So, Simon, this is fascinating. I reckon we should get you back to sort of plan out what the future looks like. Look, this has been a really great chat. And I hate to have to wind it up, but we have to wind it up because time is up.

And we'll have to get you back a lot sooner than we took to get you back this time because it's always fascinating speaking to you and thinking through, you know, the challenges that we have, but being a bit more creative about it. Wish more people listened to you, perhaps. So thank you.

Really appreciate your time, Simon.

Simon Kuestenmacher

It's been an absolute pleasure and always happy to jump back onto a call. Thanks, Simon. Talk soon, mate. Cheers. All the best.

Veronica Morgan

If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website, theelephantintheroom.com.au, or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au. If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit.

And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great. I know that sounds a bit cringy but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.

Click any timestamp to jump.

Key takeaways

  • Wealth mostly moves when the last parent dies, usually the mother, so the timing is unusually predictable: Kuestenmacher expects the transfer to accelerate through the 2030s and peak in 2041.
  • An early gift is worth more than its face value. At 5.3% over 30 years a borrower repays roughly twice the loan, so $100,000 from parents offsets about $200,000 of repayments.
  • Gen X, not first home buyers, is the cohort he says lenders are most nervous about, because dependent children, ageing parents and a large mortgage leave almost no wiggle room.
  • Demographics work against rate cuts: millennials are moving through their highest spending years while asset-rich boomers show little reason to stop spending.
  • Hybrid work has tethered demand to a two-hour drive time radius of each capital city CBD, with regional towns beyond it needing jobs, housing and schooling to grow.
  • Australian cities are three to four times less dense than comparable European cities, which he argues makes sprawl expensive for taxpayers over the long run.

When Does the Intergenerational Wealth Transfer Happen?

Chris Bates opened by saying he sees the intergenerational wealth transfer arriving earlier, bigger and faster than he expected, and supporting prices. Kuestenmacher agreed. Handing money over while alive keeps you in control and can be tax advantageous, but it forces a conversation about your own mortality, so most families never have it.

So the bulk of wealth still moves at the end of one particular life. On average, he said, mum is four years younger than dad and lives four years longer, so the transfer happens when the second parent dies. That makes the timing measurable: count baby boomer women year after year and watch the number fall.

Instead of calling this instances of baby boomer women deaths, that's a bit morbid. We call them instances of intergenerational wealth transfer.

Simon Kuestenmacher, 3:45

He also ran the arithmetic on why an early gift beats its face value. At 5.3% over 30 years a borrower repays about twice the amount borrowed, so a $500,000 mortgage costs a million dollars and $100,000 from parents does the work of $200,000. Across society, he said, two couples with the same education and income diverge when only one has a bank of mum and dad, splitting the country into owners and non-owners.

Why Are Banks Worried About Gen X Homeowners?

Kuestenmacher described Gen X as the small, forgotten cohort now in the roughest decade of its housing life. They still have dependent children, many were tempted in the last three or four years to upgrade for space, and their own parents are becoming financially or care dependent. Add a large mortgage and, as he put it, they are burning the candle from three ends.

The banks are actually much more nervous at the moment about the Gen X homeowners rather than the first home owners.

Simon Kuestenmacher, 10:52

His reasoning was about income trajectory rather than deposit size. Millennials are still on rising incomes; Gen X incomes start to flatten. Bates saw the pattern in clients who leveraged up on income growth that never arrived. Morgan called herself a mortgage prisoner: plenty of equity, little freedom to restructure without selling down.

He expects families to manage rather than move. Costs fall once children finish school, and in the meantime he expects more interest-only arrangements, which suit lenders and slow the borrower's wealth accumulation. Stamp duty and a shortage of smaller homes make both moves harder than they sound. Both are policy levers, picked apart in a recommendation by recommendation read of the Falinski housing affordability report, which argued the biggest lever was left out.

Scenario Matrix: How Each Generation Was Described on Air
CohortPosition describedPressure point named
Baby boomersMoving into retirement, asset rich, holding the majority of Australian cash savingsWealth often sits in a family-sized house rather than cash
Gen XSmall cohort in the roughest decade, dependent kids plus ageing parentsFlattening incomes and a large mortgage, little room for error
MillennialsBiggest generation ever in Australia, moving through the mid-40s spending peakOn track to inherit only in their late 50s to early 60s
Gen ZSmall cohort now entering work, the children of the small Gen X cohortHalf of Australians attend university, so few contribute at scale before their mid-20s

As described from 7:55 to 20:19. Descriptions as stated on air.

How Do Demographics Affect Interest Rates?

Warning that a demographer talking economics is risky, Kuestenmacher argued the RBA is fighting demographics. It wants households to spend less, but the biggest generation Australia has produced is moving through its mid-40s, the highest spending phase of life: kids at home, a large mortgage, every dollar straight back out. Retiring boomers feel wealthy on high house prices and hold the bulk of cash savings.

His conclusion was that rates need to be structurally more elevated, with cuts possible but not a large fall, and that the bottom quarter to third of society carries most of the cost. He noted that more generous social supports are themselves inflationary. Updated: the cash rate target was 4.35 per cent when this aired in July 2024 and, after falling through 2025 and three rises in early 2026, is 4.35 per cent again as at 12 August 2026 (RBA).

The labour market runs the same way. A large boomer cohort is leaving work while a smaller Gen Z cohort arrives, and millennials will keep taking parental leave for another 13 or 14 years, so wages rise and existing staff get worked harder. Meanwhile the 85-plus population is set to double within 14 years, from 580,000 to 1.2 million, about half of them needing daily care.

Where Does Hybrid Work Push Housing Demand?

He expects a hybrid settlement rather than a return to five days in the office or a shift to fully remote work. One office day a week keeps a household tethered to the CBD, and that has a geographic consequence.

Draw a two-hour drive time radius, and you see that everything within this two-hour drive time is boomtown. Outside of this, it is crickets.

Simon Kuestenmacher, 27:56

Towns beyond that radius need jobs, housing and schooling to grow, and he has visited places with jobs and zoned land but no services. On density, he said Australian cities average three to four times less dense than comparable European ones, with Berlin fitting into Melbourne roughly seven times, so taxpayers fund several times the pipes, wires, rail and road.

Should Older Australians Downsize While They Can?

He also pointed to mental health data on later life. Losing a partner is hard everywhere, but he said outcomes are far worse for a widow or widower left in a car dependent suburb, so he encourages couples in their 70s to move somewhere walkable while they still can.

His longest view was a thought experiment: on his estimate Australia doubles from 27 million to 54 million people in 71 years, and he asked listeners where they would put them. Updated: the ABS put the population at 27,801,023 at 31 December 2025, up 1.5 per cent over the year (released 18 June 2026).

Scenario Matrix: Growth Multiples Discussed by City
CityMultiple discussedReason given
Sydney and MelbourneGrow, do not doubleDescribed as stopping functioning at around 4.5 million people
Perth1.5xCalled a purely functional city, so a smaller lift is enough
Adelaide2.5xSmaller city with more capacity to absorb growth
Newcastle, Wollongong, Townsville3xMore wiggle room, with today's outskirts becoming tomorrow's middle suburbs

As discussed at 59:16, against his estimate of 27 million to 54 million people in 71 years. Figures as stated on air.

Thinking About Your Next Move?

This episode is about the squeeze on households carrying dependent children, ageing parents and a large mortgage at the same time. If you are weighing an upgrade against the cost of staying put, part of that decision is whether a bridging loan makes buying before selling workable.

Mortgage Broker for Upgraders

Sources referenced: The Elephant in the Room Property Podcast, episode 342, "The Next Decade in Property Demographics: Simon Kuestenmacher Explains", released 2024-07-21. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Simon Kuestenmacher, Director of Research, The Demographics Group. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 2026-09-10.