Posted
7 November 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
July 3, 2021
Episode
183
 ·
64
 min
The show

The Elephant in the Room

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with Veronica Morgan. It's a deep dive into what really goes on in the world of real estate.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Veronica Morgan
Veronica Morgan
Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor

Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

Guest
Jeremy Sheppard
Head of Research, Select Residential Property

What makes prices go up and what data sources can you use to predict the movements?Jeremy Sheppard is the Head of Select Residential Property. Before joining SRP, Jeremy created a suburb scoring algorithm called the DSR (Demand to Supply Ratio).

Jeremy Sheppard on What the Data Says About Capital Growth

Jeremy Sheppard has spent years testing which property indicators actually predict capital growth. He tells Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates that most of the ones investors chase did not show up in the data, and only three findings held over the long run.

Transcript
Veronica Morgan

What is the secret to capital growth? Can data give us the answer? And if so, what data?

Jeremy Sheppard

New properties have been shown to underperform older properties and it's because of the depreciation. I mean... It's amazing that in the industry, there can be a term called depreciation benefits. There's nothing beneficial about depreciation.

What we're after is appreciation, the complete opposite of depreciation. So I think that investors get really mucked up. They read the glossy brochures from developers. They should definitely steer clear of new.

Veronica Morgan

Welcome to The Elephant in the Room. This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about. I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent, co-host of Foxtel's Location Location Location Australia and author of Auction Ready.

Chris Bates

And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker. Before we get started, I need to let you know that nothing we say on here can be taken as personal advice. We always recommend you engage the services of a professional.

Veronica Morgan

Don't forget that you can access the transcript for this episode on the website as well as download our free full or forecast report, Which Experts Can You Trust to Get It Right?

Today, we're exploring big data to see if we can uncover trends and patterns that will help us pinpoint exactly where to buy in order to increase the probability of investment success. I must say, this sounds like the holy grail. We're joined by Jeremy Shepard, the Head of Research at Select Residential Property.

And before joining SRP, Jeremy created a suburb scoring algorithm called DSR, which is Demand to Supply Ratio. As we all know, demand and supply really is fundamentally what drives the property market. More recently, he's been working on decision-making tools such as location score, suburb growth and buy and hold.

Jeremy is also a property investor and one of his claims to fame is that seven properties in his portfolio were bought sight unseen based purely on data. Now, I must admit to being a little sceptical about how good these properties are.

So stay tuned as we will ask you more about that through our discussion. Thank you for joining us today, Jeremy. We're really looking forward to hearing about the underlying secrets of capital growth.

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, thanks very much, guys, for having me on your show.

Chris Bates

Awesome, Jeremy. Thanks for coming on. I guess capital growth is probably one of the hardest things and the most important things to sort of pick longer term. How do you sort of think about it in terms of you think about it long term, do you think about it short term?

What's your sort of goal when you're thinking about property investing?

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, for me personally, I do think about it over the short term. I think one of the great forgiving things about property investment over the long term is it's great. It's very hard to make long-term mistakes in property. Time is a great leveler.

The more distant your mistakes are, the less relevant they are. But my focus is definitely over the short term. And that's because I have access to some relevant data that helps me make good investing decisions. When I was first starting out, it was drummed into me by all the books and mentors and

experts of the day that you buy and never sell. And I think that's a great fallback. If you fail to target a market that is going to have excellent capital growth, just stay the course and sooner or later you'll go through a boom.

But nowadays with more advances, more data in this information age, I believe it's getting a lot easier for investors to actually trade property. If they know what they're doing, you can get better gains from trading property. You can recognize... this has been a great boom that I've had.

It's now levelling off, possibly correcting. I want to exit the market and find the next market. And I think that's something we'll see more prevalent amongst investors into the future. But right now it's sort of pioneering days.

Veronica Morgan

There's massive costs involved in getting in and out of property though. I guess, are you sort of anticipating that a broad-based land tax is going to make this activity more appealing and more actually lucrative?

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, when I saw this announcement by the New South Wales state government that they were going to change how they address stamp duty, my eyes lit up. I thought, oh, that's great. That's going to make trading easier.

But even in the case where stamp duty is preserved in its current form, there's still the opportunity. It really comes down to looking at the numbers. you've got to assess how much am I going to lose by selling this property? I've got to pay capital gains tax.

I've got to pay an agent their commission. There's legal fees. And then when I reinvest those funds, I've got to pay stamp duty. There's more legal fees. Can I actually recoup those? Is the opportunity that I'm missing out on really bigger than the cost of those transactions?

And that's where estimating the capital growth forecast of the current properties, Joan, versus the alternative you're planning on replacing it with, that's where it comes in really important. And it's so difficult for investors to estimate that, that it makes perfect sense to just sit tight and hold for the long term.

But the technology to forecast capital growth, at least over the short term, is improving. And we are at a stage, I believe right now, where we can do those sort of estimations.

I mean, a great example was Sydney's boom, which sort of ended around the end of 2016, started 2017. It started in 2012, so it had about a five-year massive capital growth gain there.

But the ideal move for investors at the start of 2017 would have been to sell up out of Sydney and move those funds into Hobart and you would have been much better off now. And the data was certainly indicating that Hobart would have that sort of double digit growth.

It was also indicating around the same time in early 2017 that Sydney was going flat.

But it would have been, I admit, a brave investor who would have sold out of Sydney, paid a huge amount of capital gains tax and moved their money to Hobart. And I think it's probably a case of investors seeing this sort of technology over the years to come and gaining confidence with it.

But we are moving towards this in the data age.

Veronica Morgan

Hindsight's a wonderful thing, isn't it? I mean, because the thing is that those buyers that held, those owners that held tight, and if they're selling now, I think the numbers would show that they'd be better off holding.

Because the growth here is better than in Hobart right at the minute and they wouldn't have incurred all those costs.

And I think, too, the fact that you then have to pay capital gains tax and so then you're reinvesting less money as opposed to having all that money, that tax liability effectively leveraged, you know. So there's those additional costs as well.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, I mean, it all comes down to coming up with actual figures for those costs rather than just thinking, well, I've got to pay capital gains tax, so let's just not do it. What is the capital gains tax? What is the stamp duty?

And I've put together those calculations and there are definitely circumstances around the country where investors would have been much better off selling. So... I got involved in property investing with the ardent belief that I should buy and never sell.

And it's only because I've seen since then that there have been definitely times where I would have been better off if I had sold. And I've calculated the numbers. And, I mean, Perth's another example. Towards the end of 2015, demand withdrew from that market because of the downturn in the resources sector.

and it didn't really matter where you owned property in perth you would have been better off shifting your money elsewhere unless you had let's say you'd owned property for say 20 years and then we're talking about a massive capital gain and your capital gains tax would would be significant enough to to knock that concept in the head and that's why it's a case of each individual circumstance you've got to calculate what is the capital gains tax that i'm going to be spending

I've owned the property for more than 12 months, therefore I get a 50% CGT discount straight away. My marginal tax rate is blah, therefore I'm going to spend this much in capital gains.

So it is never as much as a quarter of the capital gain that you've got because there isn't a marginal tax rate above 45%. So it's a case of doing the numbers rather than just having a broad sort of opinion about a strategy, this will never work.

There are circumstances where it definitely does work.

Veronica Morgan

Is it different to hotspotting?

Jeremy Sheppard

I think it's exactly hotspotting. And I think that that technology is improving. In the past, we've been burnt, I've been burnt myself by picking a hotspot and had prices go the other way.

And you look back 20, 30 years, and the amount of data that was available back then is insignificant to here we are in the data age. I mean, yields don't go back prior to the turn of the century.

So you've got no idea on things like auction clearance rates, vacancy rates, yields, percentage stock on market, even bedroom counts and things like that. We are privy to an enormous amount of data now, which simply wasn't available decades ago. And that is revolutionising investment and suburb selection.

Veronica Morgan

So what are the things that, and I'm guessing you're using AI to sort of find out really what the drivers are. Is that fair to say or you actually? Yeah. So what is, I guess, what are the surprising things that are throwing up, that's throwing up for you?

Jeremy Sheppard

One that surprised me was wages and wage growth. There's been a belief that if you target suburbs with high wage earners, that you will outperform the benchmark of say the national average growth rate.

And actually historical data looking at household income data from censuses conducted over the last couple of decades show that there isn't that relationship. that low-income earners can actually be in suburbs that outperform high-income earners.

And if this is the only data that you've got to make a decision about wages and wage growth, historically it has shown that it's a misleading indicator. It won't actually help investors.

Chris Bates

With that point, though, I mean, if you had a choice of two suburbs, one with low-wage growth and people in that suburb

were not getting pay rises and people who were buying properties were on average or lower incomes versus a suburb where you've got people moving to the suburb on higher incomes and are borrowing, being able to borrow more money, like longer term fundamentally, the demand is different because their capacity is different.

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, that's what you'd think but the data suggests that that wouldn't have helped you in the past and I think the reason behind that is because the people that are actually living in the suburb aren't necessarily the people that you want to know their wages.

So who is actually buying a property can be from outside the suburb and it's their wages that are more important and we just simply don't know what their wages are. All we know is the wages on census night for this particular suburb was X, Y, Z.

Veronica Morgan

Okay. So I just need to cut in here.

Just in the news this week, this is interesting because there's a correlation here for me. There's a federal government funding change to private schools. And private school funding has been previously tied to the incomes of the location, like census data, the incomes of the location where the school is located.

And now they're arguing that they're actually going to base it on the incomes of the parents of the students that go to the school, which probably don't or may not live anywhere near the school. Yeah.

So it's effectively what you're saying is the same thing, that if there's an area where there's a lot of absentee owners, a lot of investors, then that is actually something that's money attracted to an area by investors rather than the intrinsic desire of people with higher incomes to live there.

So they're two very different drivers, aren't they?

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, and the other thing is that, I mean, I'm speculating on the cause. All I can do is look at the correlation in the data. But what I'm thinking is there's some other driver of demand which attracts a suburb to buyers.

And if the prices have gone up significantly, then the only buyers, and I'm talking about owner-occupiers here, that can afford to buy have the wages required to buy there. And then they move into the suburb and that indicates growth. wage growth.

That comes up as the wage growth, but it's not people getting a pay rise. You don't come home from work, honey, I got a pay rise, ring up CoreLogic and say, hey, my property should be worth more now simply because I got a pay rise.

There's something else in the suburb that is appealing to buyers that's driving demand. Prices are pushed up. And from then on, the only people that can afford to buy obviously have higher wages. So it could be that price growth is pulling up wages, not wages pushing up price growth.

Chris Bates

Well, it's the people at the auction who are desirability and attractability of that suburb to those, say that market. And I guess that market, you would ideally want it to have high income. So you wouldn't really want it to take one income. You want it to be double income.

You'd want it to be double high income. And so if a suburb attracts a high income, double income family, even if say we're only 5% of the properties are selling each year, but that 5% is selling to that market.

It doesn't really matter what the other 95% of people in that suburb are earning because those properties aren't for sale.

Jeremy Sheppard

That's right.

Chris Bates

It's just, if there's only five properties for sale and there's 10 high income young families wanting them, then arguably that suburb is going to get more high income young families because that's who's buying these properties. Maybe the suburb isn't getting wage growth, but ultimately it is an apportion.

Those five that are selling are selling to people that are earning more than the current suburb incomes.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah. And where do those buyers live or where did they live on census night when the data was recorded? They might not have been living in that suburb. It might have been an adjacent one or it might have been on the other side of the city. We just don't know.

But that would be probably a lead indicator is what are the wages of the people that turn up at the auction?

Veronica Morgan

But I mean, it's measuring that.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah. Ask around. Yeah. But I mean, the thing, what you're talking about effectively is gentrification. So in examples of gentrification, rising wages are a lag indicator, right? And then they become a lead indicator. Yeah.

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, I mean, if you're an investor and you're picking a suburb, you're going to have a look at this sort of data if you believe that this information is of use.

So the only way you can get this information of the income of occupants or residents of a suburb is from this census data. And it's only published once every five years. And all I did was analyse this historically going back to censuses from 1991, 96, etc. And

to see if there is a correlation. Have they had outperforming capital growth if they had above average wages? And the data says, well, no. So if this is the only data we have available, then that's what we've got to use. And we've seen that it doesn't work.

Chris Bates

Interesting. You can also argue that some areas have high percentages of self-employed, which potentially on paper can have lower wage growth than assets in business owners and other trusts and things like that.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, what are you going to put on the census? Maybe you don't want the ATO to know where your real income is.

Chris Bates

I mean, what are some of the other things that you think that a lot of property investors focus on that may not be a good idea?

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, one of the real obvious ones is population growth. And this is relevant at the macro level. So by macro, I mean Australia-wide or even a major state capital like Sydney, Melbourne. When we have international migrants, obviously not having many at the moment, they don't bring with them a house or any land.

So they require somewhere to live and that places pressure on housing accommodation. So there is an increase in demand at the macro level. But at the micro level, like a suburb or local government area or postcode, people don't move into the suburb and wander the streets looking for a place to live.

They don't live in a cardboard box under the freeway bridge. They move into an already vacant dwelling. So there's an oversupply if there's a vacant dwelling. So all that demand is doing is it's matching supply when they move into that property.

And population growth at this micro level of a suburb is not a lead indicator of demand. It's actually more likely an indicator of supply. And the best example of that is... these population growth forecasts.

You've probably heard someone saying, oh, the population is due to grow by 10,000 more people over the next five years or whatever, and this is a – I'll call it a growth corridor. But the way in which you come up with those forecasts is council and developers –

they have plans for development of new properties. It's really a case of if we put two and a half people in each one of these extra properties that we're planning on approving and building, then the population will grow by X amount.

So the forecast is purely based on supply and supply is the enemy of capital growth. So investors want to avoid those sort of what they call growth corridors. They're really supply corridors.

Veronica Morgan

That's hilarious. It's nicely explained. We've discussed this on the show before that, you know, if an agent or a developer is saying a high growth area, then run like the clappers.

Chris Bates

Yeah, avoid those areas. It's a really interesting point because if it has to have high population growth, it has to have high supplier growth because otherwise the people are going to be, you know, unless they're moving in with other people, there's nowhere for them to live.

And so to get high population growth, you need high supply growth. And like you said, Jeremy, that's the issue with any type of property investment is high supply growth is high risk. If there's no cap on supply, then how is there a a shortage in how you're going to get price growth.

So is that sort of what your research shows, is that high population growth leads to high supply growth, which then leads to low capital growth?

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, it does. But the research I just need to point out is a little difficult to do with these sort of greenfield estates because

So picture a fringe suburb where there's some houses on really large blocks and you might sell off some of those to developers. They divvy them up into extremely small blocks and then sell them.

So you might have an old house selling for $400,000 and then in come these new brand new double brick on tiny blocks selling for $500,000 because they're new. it looks like the median has grown by 25% from $400,000 to $500,000. But the old properties are still selling for $400,000.

The new property is still selling for $500,000. There's been no capital growth at all. It's just an anomaly in the median. And it's very difficult to calculate the capital growth for these high population areas based on medians.

You need to look at repeat sales, and that means you've got to wait until one of those new properties sells again. And so it becomes very difficult to get an accurate read on. them.

Veronica Morgan

It's so true. And yet, yet the developers are saying high capital growth, 25% median house price growth. And you go, Oh my God. So sad. It's not a lie, but it's not the truth either.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, that's right. It's median growth. If they say that it's median growth, yes, it's spot on, but it might not be capital growth. So you can have massive median growth and zero capital growth.

Chris Bates

Or negative. But what you do want to have though is a population growth at a society level or a city level, but then no supply growth in your area. And that appeal to a certain subset of that population growth. So, you know,

If Sydney's population goes from five to 10 million, that's 10 million more people buying things, running businesses. And part of that, there'll be more people who are subset that are doing well financially. And that's potentially up 50% than what it was before or it's doubled.

But they're all wanting to live in certain areas where they're not building any more houses.

And so population growth is needed because there's no sort of population growth and no, you would still get population growth through, you know, just families, kids who are, you know, zero today in 25 years time, they want to buy a house.

So you still get that demographic growth, but you do need population growth to support longer term demand for property.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, yeah. And the thing that I do when I'm looking for, well, avoiding those sort of the risks of those growth corridors, and this is really easy for investors to do, you just jump on Google Maps, switch to satellite view and look for vacant blocks of land.

If you buy a house in a built up area, then there's very little risk of oversupply. It's those fringe suburbs that Or if you buy units, units can pop up anywhere. There's always a risk of oversupply at some point in the future.

Even if you go to the council website, you can categorically state there are no development applications lodged with council. So oversupply is an issue. And then next month, There's a development application sitting with council and within a few years, there's oversupply.

But if you can see from a satellite view, this is just houses. They're all built up. There's no vacant land. There's no greenfield estates. And it's a house that you buy. Then you have effectively avoided that risk of oversupply. And that's a really easy piece of research that investors can do.

Chris Bates

So we've got population growth at a suburb level is dangerous because of supply growth. You said wage growth is a bit of a hard indicator to sort of measure. You've got to be careful with the ones who are actually at the auction.

So what are some of the other things that you find investors, you know, chase, go up the wrong road?

Jeremy Sheppard

New properties, this will antagonize a lot of developers, unfortunately, and those that get paid commissions from developers. New properties have been shown to underperform older properties, and it's because of the depreciation.

It's amazing that in the industry, there can be a term called depreciation benefits. There's nothing beneficial about depreciation. What we're after is appreciation, the complete opposite of depreciation. So I think that investors get really mucked up. They read the glossy brochures from developers.

They should definitely steer clear of new. If you claim $10,000 in depreciation in a year,

and let's say you're on a 40 cents in the dollar marginal tax rate, then you're going to pay $4,000 less tax, but you're not better off by $4,000. You're actually worse off by $6,000. So you've actually incurred a $10,000 loss, but after tax, it's only as bad as a $6,000 loss.

But investors are looking at that and thinking, no, I'm getting $4,000, but you're not. You're actually worse off by $6,000. So my advice to investors is steer clear of new.

They have been shown to underperform, but eventually new properties become old and they start to perform in the same way as older properties do.

Veronica Morgan

Now, have you done research on how long that takes? Because, I mean, you already talked about your capital growth timeframe really is sort of one, two, three years. You know, we're talking decades really before that happens, particularly when you've got new subdivisions after new subdivisions and endless land supply.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, although the data that I'm looking at is to try and identify property markets that will have good short-term capital growth. I have done a significant amount of research on long-term.

And unfortunately, because I was saying before that we're in the data age now, long-term, the only data I've got to look at is fairly limited. And there's really only three things that I've come up with for outperforming the national average over the long-term. One of these is don't buy new.

And that is an examination of new properties, how they have resold, how much capital growth they've had. And again, there's limited data available for that. The other thing, as I mentioned, was you buy a house, not a unit, because houses have outperformed units by about 0.9% per annum over the last 30 years.

And the other thing is to avoid vacant land where there can be additional supply. And that's really all there is to it. In fact, when people ask me, Jeremy, I don't have the access to the database that you have. What sort of research can I do as a novice?

I think the best bang for buck you can get, the easiest research you can do is ask yourself, is this property I'm thinking of buying new? I mean, it's so easy to see. You'll just look at it. And there you go. That's going to give you a great start in property investing.

You simply avoid buying anything new.

Chris Bates

But, I mean, is that enough? If that's your sort of goal that you're aiming for, don't buy something new, buy a house and don't buy in an area where they're building lots of houses. Yeah. Surely we can go deeper than that.

I mean, we can go to areas that have great lifestyle benefits or great schools or have, you know, very limited sort of development of, you know, apartments, which could be, you know, you could have better streets versus other streets. Can't we go a lot deeper than that? Right.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah. Great question. And the problem with something like lifestyle is it's subjective. So I can't look at a database and plug in some numbers and see how that would go. So it's not saying that it would be irrelevant.

It just means that I can't do any research on it to see whether it is a long-term indicator. But can't the bot do that? Well, there just wasn't a lot of information 30 years ago in order to assess that.

Chris Bates

Could you just live in the city? Like in Melbourne, you would say, where's the best place to live in Melbourne? Well, it's going to be around the east or around the bayside because you can get access to water. You've got parklands. You've got easy access to the city.

And you can pretty much do that in any city, like just through the livability of knowing where's a great place to live.

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, there was some research that I did a couple of years ago on proximity to amenities. So you're close to good schools or transport hubs like train stations and beaches. Beaches are great lifestyle attractions.

So it was schools, beaches, train stations, shopping centres and airports. Airports can be quite a negative, but it's the same sort of concept. And I was looking at this outperformance over the long term.

So I examined all the train stations in Sydney that have been there for something like 50 years, at least 50 years, and compared the growth of those suburbs with suburbs that don't have a train station. And over that 30-year period, there was no difference.

And I did the same with beaches and the same with good schools, particularly in Melbourne. And Time and time again, there was no difference. And I suspect the reason why is because let's say you've got a drawcard to a suburb like a beach. Well, how long has that beach been there for?

Because there's a very good chance that the benefit of that amenity is already well and truly factored into the price of properties. And Queensland University of Technology did this excellent study on the expansion of Brisbane Airport to go international back in the mid-80s.

They wanted to see how did the new flight path negatively impact the capital growth of property markets under that flight path. And they found that over the four-year period from the start of that new flight path, there was reduced capital growth in those suburbs, understandably because of the aircraft noise.

But then after that, from then on, capital growth was business as usual, just like the rest of the city. So it took four years for a negative amenity to adjust prices, but from then on, it was business as usual. And this is the same with train stations, beaches, schools –

All of these sorts of amenities, if they have been there for a long period of time, it's unlikely that they will affect capital growth because it's already factored into the prices. If it's a new amenity, however, then that might impact capital growth. I haven't done research on that.

Veronica Morgan

If you like what you're hearing here, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit. And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars, please. Every review helps make it easier for other people to find us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.

We love hearing your questions and we're planning more listener Q&A episodes. Please send your questions in. You can send them via the website, which is theelephantintheroom.com.au or directly via email to questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au.

Okay. So I've got two questions here. So the first thing, compounding, right? If you're starting off with a larger value property and the growth rate is the same, you're going to do better, right, over time than if you buy something cheaper with the same growth rate, right? Because the benefit of compounding.

So if it's already priced in and growth is somewhat the same, then That's still a good investment decision, but you're talking short term, right?

So therefore, does your research sort of highlight those areas that are about to be negatively impacted by, say, a big infrastructure project that you know that after four or five years or whatever is going to come out in the wash?

And so buying when it's sort of underperforming effectively, it's like value investing, you know, it's like it's undervalued. That's the time to buy and then you take something upstream and sell. Is that some of the things that you're talking about doing?

Jeremy Sheppard

That's a separate topic. I mean, the research that I did was over the long term, long term proximity to trains, train stations, shops and so on. How do they impact things?

But just on that thing about the compounding, if you buy a million dollar property in one suburb and it has 6% per annum growth over the next 10 years, that's exactly the same as having two $500,000 properties that have exactly the same growth rate.

Veronica Morgan

But it's not the same as buying a million dollar property in a different suburb with only a 5% annual growth rate.

Jeremy Sheppard

That's right. Yeah. So over the long term, I was trying to see, is there a benefit in buying in these better suburbs, suburbs that have more amenities like train stations, shops and schools? And there wasn't anything that showed up in the data over the long term that they'd outperform.

Veronica Morgan

Sorry, I'm just curious on this because say you had $500,000 and you couldn't afford a million dollar property on those properties that's going to go up 6% per annum and you had your $500,000.

Are there really suburbs that you can go and spend $100,000 in and get the same growth rate because of the actual lesser, you know, the values, as you said, it's built into the price already. Are there areas where it's not built into the price where you can actually get that same growth?

Jeremy Sheppard

Yes, but for it not to be built into the price already, you would have to assume that it is a new amenity. So it takes time for people to realise, oh, there's a bridge over the river now. I can get to the other side. Why don't I live on the other side?

It takes time for home buyers to realise that sort of thing. So there can be infrastructure projects that affect capital growth in suburbs. But after a while, it's going to become factored into the price of properties and then the capital growth will just revert back to the mean, the normal.

Chris Bates

If that amenity, though, becomes more desirable, as in more people want it and there's only a limited amount of supply, then that potentially hasn't been factored into prices. That's right, yeah. Because over time, more and more people want it. So there's five chairs and now 10 people want those five chairs. Yeah.

Well, those five chairs get priced on the five people who've got the most money. And so even if something's factored into prices today, it doesn't mean it's always going to be factored in at the same degree. That's right.

If the means of a population grow and there's limited supply, then things could keep on getting more expensive. And so, for example, things can change. Demographics, lifestyle preferences can change. You look at, say, regional areas, you say the beaches, you know, Central Coast or Wollongong, work from home.

That wasn't factored in, but now it is factored in.

Jeremy Sheppard

That's right. Yeah. So what we're talking about then is you are trying to forecast people's perception of a particular amenity in the future.

Veronica Morgan

Mm-hmm.

Jeremy Sheppard

So – and that's relevant. That's relevant for picking a good location. But in the past, all we could do was look at this is the amenity. How have suburbs performed based on having that amenity? So it's a little bit of crystal ball gazing to say –

I believe the beaches are going to become more popular in the future or proximity to CBD is considered beneficial. So that's why properties are more expensive closer to CBD. But have people valued being close to the CBD

the same 20 years ago, 30 years ago, 40 years ago as right now, will they still value it the same degree in the future? So it's not a case of I am close to CBD, therefore I'm going to have better capital growth.

I have a beach, therefore I'm going to – you've got to somehow forecast how perceptions of those amenities will change in the future in order to benefit from them.

Veronica Morgan

So if population growth's not the lead indicator, if all the things, wages aren't the lead indicator, if you can't predict lifestyle because basically you're taking a view on what the future demand is going to be and also there isn't enough rich data going back far enough to be able to sort of look at past patterns, what are you using?

Yeah.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, great question, Veronica. It all comes down to supply and demand. So that's the only two things that affect price change is supply and demand. Now, rather than try and forecast what demand is going to be in the future or what supply is,

I'm trying to identify markets in which demand currently exceeds supply because that's an imbalance. So property markets are much like homeostatic organisms.

Like our skin sweats when we're hot to try and release heat and bring us back to a constant temperature or it will get goosebumps and it will thicken to protect us from the cold. So property markets are in this continual tug of war between supply and demand, trying to maintain balance.

And the vast majority of property markets around the country are in a state of relative balance. As investors, we want to find markets that are out of balance, where demand is absolutely clobbering supply. And the way in which the market rebalances is prices in those suburbs go up.

They go up too far and that subdues demand and balance is restored to the cosmos. So what I'm trying to identify is markets in which demand exceeds supply. And I know that's only going to be short term.

I can't pick anything over the long term because there's no historical data other than don't buy units, don't buy new and avoid vacant land.

But over the short term, I'm just trying to measure things like auction clearance rates, vacancy rates, percentage of stock on market, how many open inspections, are auctions going real crazy, that sort of thing. is only going to give me an angle, an edge over the short term.

And over the long term, the only other three things I can fall back on is houses rather than units and nothing new and away from vacant land.

Chris Bates

So can you give us an example of a suburb or something that you would think an investor should look at now? And I'll pick a budget. Let's say we go $500 or whatever. What budget would you prefer to use? I mean, can you give us an example?

We can just talk through like how this would actually work for someone.

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, for a price of $500,000, you're limited probably to right now, some suburbs to the north of Brisbane. There's also some elsewhere around Brisbane, but I think Adelaide would give you the most options, especially if you needed some sort of margin for error there.

Not everywhere in Adelaide, but there are loads of suburbs where demand exceeds supply. And by that, I mean Auction clearance rates are very high. Selling times are very fast. There's very little discounting, so a vendor would perhaps not need to be negotiable in order to get a sale.

You've got very little stock on market. Vacancy rates are chronically low. A lot more properties are being sold by auction rather than private treaty because there's so much demand. There may be a large percentage of open inspections rather than, hey, book an appointment if you're interested.

So there's about 17 metrics that I look at to try and gauge demand and supply for a property market. And those are sort of bundled up into that demand and supply ratio that you mentioned in my bio, Veronica.

So investors can use that as a gauge to see, hey, is there something going on? It doesn't tell you what's going on in that suburb. It's just saying demand is exceeding supply.

Chris Bates

And so what's the strategy there? So let's say we go by this place in Adelaide. It ticks all the metrics at 500,000.

what would you consider to be an adequate growth rate or oversight? And what period are you aiming for? Are you aiming for three years or five years? And how do you decide to sell?

Jeremy Sheppard

Right. Well, deciding to sell is looking again at that demand-to-supply ratio because if it has come back to a balanced point where demand and supply are equal, then you wouldn't expect much in the way of capital growth from then on. And then you would be looking at other suburbs where

around the country, anywhere else, that you could move your money to. If you sold, you figure out what's your sale proceeds. That's the deposit stamp duty to buy an alternative, a replacement. And then you've got to somehow forecast what the capital growth is going to be in the alternative.

And if that capital growth would greatly exceed the market that you're currently invested in by a larger amount than the cost to transact, then there'd be an argument to sell and buy elsewhere.

But even if you just hold, so long as you enter the market, get some good capital growth up early, then you've got equity to buy a second property, assuming that you can service an additional mortgage.

Chris Bates

So what sort of growth rate are you wanting though? Like whatever, what period?

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, right now, I don't think it's too hard to find double digit growth around the country because we've got such low interest rates and we're in the middle of a boom.

But I believe that almost any time in the last 30 years has been a good time for a property investor to buy somewhere in Australia. And it's about finding those locations.

I think that if investors are getting anywhere close to double digit, that's pretty good to hang on to that for say three years. There you go. You've got your equity for a second property. And so that really helps you.

Chris Bates

So let's rewind that. So let's say 10% double digit over three years. Let's say 30% over three years. Now there might be a compounding benefit. If we minus off 10% for transaction costs, Now we're down to 20%. Then we minus off 25% for capital gains tax. Well, let's do 20.

So that's another 4%. So now we're down to a 16% amount on your money potentially if it grows 30%, you know, because of costs.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, well, I've done these sort of calculations before and if there is a difference of around about 12% or more in the capital growth over that period of time, say three years, then there is an argument for selling and buying elsewhere.

It really comes down to how long have you held that property for prior to coming up to that decision to sell? Because if there has been a 20-year holding period and you are paying a phenomenal amount in capital gains tax, then that would be triggered at, well, no, just keep holding that one.

Don't worry about that. But if you've only owned it for, say, three years and you've got your, say, 33% capital growth, you're not paying a huge amount in CGT. So first of all, you've got your 50% CGT discount. So you're down to 16.5%. Then there's your marginal tax rate applied to that.

And the actual, out of that 33%, you might only be paying 6% or 7% in CGT.

Veronica Morgan

What's the end game though?

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, I guess it's financial independence that comes up dependent on every investor. That's what you mean for the individual, isn't it, Veronica, the end game?

Veronica Morgan

Well, yeah, because what we haven't been talking about is risk, risk that the next one you buy doesn't do that well, risk that the market actually isn't very nice to you and actually sits on its haunches for another 10, 15 years.

As people who might have invested in purse, you'd be ruining the fact, yes, sure, they should have sold, but at some point they bought with hopes. And they're probably bought with data and all sorts of reasons why investors buy in areas that they don't know.

And also, I mean, the very fact that you've got to pay tax and that means that money isn't actually then invested and growing for you if you've got a good asset. And I guess the other question I've got for you is, does it matter what they buy?

Jeremy Sheppard

You mean the type of asset?

Veronica Morgan

Yeah. You know, like as long as it's not new and as long as it's not near vacant land and as long as it's not an apartment, does it actually matter what they buy? Yeah.

Jeremy Sheppard

I think it probably does, but it's very hard to measure by how much, especially over the long term. But this whole approach about trading property, it's not for the faint heart and you would need a lot of experience in interpreting the data.

But if you try and time entry into a property market and things didn't work out as planned, then you can always just fall back on the long-term hold. It's really the decision to sell.

And if you've been sitting on a property for five years and it just hasn't moved, it's a little bit easier to make that decision. It might be harder if you've seen excellent capital growth and you're wondering, well, is this really going to trail off? Is there going to be a flat period?

Can I capitalize elsewhere? If you got it right the first time, you'd have more confidence in selling and buying elsewhere just by using the same approach. But if you got it wrong the first time, you can always fall back on the long-term hold.

Veronica Morgan

Well, yeah, assuming that you bought a decent asset, that's the problem. Now, we're not actually talking about asset quality here. We're just talking about location choice. But the seven that you bought unseen, I'm curious, do you still own them?

Jeremy Sheppard

No, I've sold all of those.

Veronica Morgan

You traded all of them. And what metrics did you use to choose a property without seeing it? And were there any things, I guess, you know, things that you would do differently next time?

Jeremy Sheppard

Definitely, there'd be things I'd do differently. The metrics that I was looking at back then, and we're going back to 2006, there were six properties that I bought and they were in New Zealand, actually, all houses in the same suburb. And I've sold all of those.

But there was one in Western Australia that I bought. Actually, I can't remember when that was. I paid a visit to New Zealand and I did look around and I went with a real estate agent to look at an enormous number of properties. And I said, I don't like this. I like this.

I don't like this. Then when I came back to Australia, they had a very clear idea of what I was looking for.

So I was able to buy sight unseen, but I had visited a lot of properties previously to make it clear to the one real estate agent that I wanted to work with. Here's what I'm looking for. So, it's a little, perhaps a little misleading that it was entirely sight unseen.

I did buy properties without ever visiting them, but I visited the location and I visited very similar properties. Yeah. But the one I bought in Western Australia, I didn't even go there and that wasn't really a good one. Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

Is this the Dumbo you've saved up for us?

Jeremy Sheppard

I've got heaps of Dumbos. I've got a baker's dozen of Dumbos, mistakes that I've made in the past. Do you want me to go on to Dumbos now?

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, give us one.

Jeremy Sheppard

Why not?

Seems like a good time. Yeah. Okay. So that one in Western Australia was all about the financing. I thought I was really clever here because I was able to get an 80% mortgage from a lender and 20% from the vendor.

The person selling the property was going to lend me the other deposit. So all I had to pay was stamp duty and legal fees. And I calculated that that property only had to grow by 4% per annum. Because of the extreme leveraging, it would be my best performing asset.

But it didn't grow by 4%. It went backwards by 14%.

Veronica Morgan

I was about to say only 4%. Yeah, only 4%.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, that's all I needed. And yeah, that was not one of the better investments. But those ones in New Zealand were fantastic. They were growing by about 1.5% per month.

for a good 18 months or so. And this leads to one of my other mistakes. Because I was always buy and hold and then just move on to the next, I took my eyes off properties that I already owned and I had no idea what was going on in various markets.

And some of those markets tanked And I would end up with negative equity if I've refinanced and then they've gone backwards. And that's never a good position to be in, especially when the GFC hit. My cash flow was strained and I had to sell properties which had since come down.

And so I've learned to keep my eye on property markets that I'm exposed to and to...

Never believe that I should always hold for the long term or if I do plan to hold for the long term, set up a significant cash flow buffer so that I can wait out those bad times and not be in a position where I'm forced to sell.

Veronica Morgan

So being an active investor, that's what that's all about really, isn't it? As opposed to a past investor, which is that whole set and forget, buy and hold is often the case. But then if you are selecting A-grade assets in A-grade locations, you can relax a bit.

So, if you're actually aiming for short-term capital growth, you definitely can't relax. And I guess, is that what you're saying there?

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, just on those, I'm not entirely sure when you say A-grade. Everyone has a different idea of what is an A-grade. But CoreLogic... They produce this report every now and then. They call it a decile report.

And what they've done is they might split an entire city up into 10 groups where you've got in the first decile, you've got the real cheapies. And in the 10th decile, you've got the most affluent and most expensive suburbs.

And it's interesting to see at different points in various growth cycles for that city, you can see affluent areas and how they have performed versus the cheaper areas. And historically, the more expensive affluent towns,

potentially A-grade areas have greater volatility. In the good times, they tear up and in the bad times, they plummet, whereas the cheaper areas are far more stable.

And looking over the last, say, 20 years, there have been cases where some of the lowest decile, the cheapest areas, haven't actually had negative capital growth. They've been so stable. They haven't had fantastic positive growth like the

the affluent areas but they haven't had the negative growth so to suggest that it's more risky buying in those outer areas or cheaper areas historically the data suggests the opposite that you can benefit from buying in these cheaper a-grade areas but you might actually be better off selling once once their boom has has come to a close you certainly don't want to be in a position where you've got to sell during the bad times because they're the ones that that fall the most

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, we got, I think it was one of our very early episodes in the 30s even, Frank Gelber from Biz Oxford Economics, and he talked about that. And I remember that he's talked about the volatility of the upper end of the market can triple and then crash and then triple again.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, and volatility is an indicator of risk. It certainly is. That's how they look at it in the share markets.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, absolutely. But when I talk about A-grade, I'm not talking about most expensive. I'm talking about areas where high demand, high consistent demand for quality property, regardless of what market's doing. And there are definitely areas that will perform like that.

And they do tend to be expensive areas relative when you're comparing to lower socioeconomic areas. However, they're not the upper echelon areas. Right, yeah. It's not your Vaucluse, your Point Pipers, Mossmans, it's not those sorts of suburbs.

But that's fundamentally what you're talking about though really is it has to be an active strategy because you're talking about capital growth but really, yes, it is growth of the capital but... In my mind, I think capital growth is much more of a long-term view when you're buying property rather than trading.

You know what I mean? So it's using words and the words, I guess, take on different connotations depending on how you're applying them.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, well, I don't encourage any investor to trade property because I just don't believe that the technology is sufficient at this stage to do that well, to do that easily. But there are cases where I'll have a client come to me and they've bought something that's, you know, an off the plan unit.

And I know that there's going to be more of those units over coming years. Things aren't going to improve and they should exit and they will be better off for it. And I do the analysis. I try and forecast the capital growth and even factoring in a significant margin for error there.

they're actually better off selling. So there are definitely cases to sell, but I would say as a general rule, investors should probably just buy and hold.

Chris Bates

Right. I mean, I guess there's definitely, there's 1.5 million property investors out there. And I would argue that most of those should be looking at their investment properties and saying, is this really the right decision for me long-term? Should I sell it? Should I buy something else?

Because you're right, Jeremy, a lot of them have bought assets that haven't got the right fundamentals long-term and they could do something better with their money, even just paying off their mortgage or putting money into super, but I was confused.

I thought that your ultimate view was for other property investors that is to buy, hold for three or four years, make your 30% potentially, lose 10, 15% of that in tax and costs,

potentially only make 15% at the end of it and then try to buy in another market and make another 15%, which is very difficult to do because you need significant growth at all times. And you may find it in strong markets with a collapse in interest rates

and a very positive 20 to 2023 maybe, but when there's say the GFC or where there's the 9-11 or when there's a credit crisis or you may lose four or five years where you can't do this trading strategy.

And so, yes, it can work at certain points in the cycle, but you then have to minus off the growth you would have got if you just went and bought something and held it over 10 years because you didn't have to trade.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah. And I think that for most investors that they would be at significant risk of being worse off if they were to trade. I think that it's more than just an advanced strategy. It's something that's probably out of reach of the vast majority of investors, certainly at this stage anyway.

But I see in the future that that it will be quite commonplace, and that might be more than a decade away. But to me, it seems inevitable, and that's because of the information age and better ability to analyse that data.

Chris Bates

I think if costs go down, so if stamp duty goes and we move to land tax, if the real estate agent costs go down, if you can potentially do renovations cheaper and you can potentially – buy a property, renovate it and sell it with very minimal costs.

Absolutely, I think trading becomes much more desirable. But in the current situation where you've still got to pay agents, you've still got to pay stamp duty, renovations is definitely not cheap. It's hard to trade and make money because you need... 30, 40% growth.

Jeremy Sheppard

That's right, yeah.

Chris Bates

It's very hard to get that because that type of strong environment, you need all the fundamentals behind you. You need low interest rates. You need super high confidence. You need a real scarcity, people not to be concerned about their jobs. And so those markets aren't always.

It is at the moment, but it wasn't, say, in 2018. And so... It's hard to continue the trade. It's just a certain point in certain cycles.

Veronica Morgan

It just, I think, actually ran a stepping stone strategy workshop with Megan on your first homebuyer guide the other day, actually. And, you know, that's when you're using the stepping stone strategy to buy your first property, you know, you're thinking basically I can't afford my dream home first up.

So whatever I buy now has to get some good growth in it so I can build my equity and then I can actually upgrade and get closer to where I want to be ultimately.

And certainly when you're not paying out any tax, when you sell the property, that makes this idea of trying to choose a short-term capital growth play much more sensible. Certainly that's something I think that they should definitely look to.

You've got to look to an area that's going to have potentially a greater upside than other areas, but even then it's risky. You've got to be happy that you're

You know, but certainly from that point of view, the risks are a little less because A, you're going to live in it and B, you're not going to be paying CGT when you sell.

Chris Bates

And potentially no stamp duty. So a lot of first-time buyers, you know, there is stamp duty concessions. It might be, you know, I know that is price limits and, you know, there might be changes.

But if you don't have to pay stamp duty, you don't have to pay capital gains tax, then your costs are dramatically lower than you've only got selling costs. And then you've got the rent saving versus the interest cost. So then your cash flow is maybe not much different. And so, yeah, absolutely.

For those sort of first time buyers, potentially then doing nothing and leaving the money in the bank, maybe the stepping stone works, but for investors, it's even harder when you sort of take out capital gains.

Veronica Morgan

Interesting stuff, Jeremy. We really appreciate you coming along. And I know I've been quizzing you because of course there's some many things we agree with you on, obviously the new and the oversupply and everything and some of the other stuff we're sort of quizzing you on.

But ultimately you've come out and said basically what we sort of think to be a good way to look at investing property. You've actually said, look, you really should be looking for the long-term anyway. So Sort of an interesting circle we've taken here today. Yeah.

Jeremy Sheppard

Well, I mean, the use of the technology was really just for those people who are probably questioning whether they've bought the right asset to begin with rather than trading. That's just for me. I mean, I assumed you were asking me. Yeah, I don't advise others.

Chris Bates

I think the sell versus hold is a question that most investors unfortunately just take the hold because it's all a bit too confusing. The fear of making that decision wrong. It's the same as shares. We get this anchoring bias and they'll go, oh, I can't.

what happens if I sell it and I should have kept it? And so what people do is it's like cancelling and subscription to something you never use.

You don't cancel it because you think, oh, maybe we'll need it in the future rather than just cutting the cord, making a decision and moving on to something better.

And so to give a sort of data analysis to that and then provide, you know, real accurate information around future supply, the problems with demand and stock on the market and clearance rates. And the costs. It's super valuable.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, absolutely.

In fact, you know, going back to our first ever episode, we interviewed behavioural scientist Simon Russell and he talked about loss aversion and I went off and did quite a bit of research on that and wrote an article on it, which I'll include in the show notes because it is about that idea that people will hold and they're sort of fingers in the ears, la, la, la, I don't want to know about it.

If you don't actually sell it, you're not realising the loss and so you're not then feeling the loss, but the reality is you are experiencing the loss, you just haven't noticed it. Exactly.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, it takes a lot of character, doesn't it, to say, all right, I got it wrong. Where to from here?

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, especially with property because, you know, at the barbecues, everyone's running around telling you their success stories. No one's running around telling you how they lost money on property.

Chris Bates

I think the danger though is once you've lost money though, your natural tendency is to want to make that money back. And so what ends up happening is you end up compounding your problem because you end up taking a higher risk strategy to get that money back.

And then you can potentially even lose more money. And that's a common financial mistake that people make is they're always looking for short-term returns because they always feel like they're trying to play catch up rather than sort of accepting that the past is the past.

Right now, I've got to make a good decision for the next 20 years. I don't want to repeat my mistakes. And whether it's shares or whether it's, you know, other high-risk investments, you know, that compounding of trying to catch up never really works because you can't go back in time.

Jeremy Sheppard

Yeah, I pride myself on never making the same mistake more than half a dozen times.

Veronica Morgan

Well, you did buy half a dozen properties in one suburb in New Zealand. Did you say one street? But it doesn't sound like it was a mistake. It sounds like you actually did that very well.

Jeremy Sheppard

Oh, that one worked out okay.

Chris Bates

Awesome, Jeremy. I really appreciate your time for coming on and, yeah, we've got all your links in the show notes.

Jeremy Sheppard

Thanks very much for having me on the show, guys. It's been great. Thanks, Jeremy.

Chris Bates

We want to make you a better elephant rider and this week's elephant rider training is...

Veronica Morgan

Let's talk a little bit further about some of the things that Jeremy was talking about, you know, commonly understood to add to capital growth in areas or make an area a desirable area. And you talked about the research you did on train stations, for argument's sake, or shopping centres and airports.

And I guess the thing that I would want to add to this conversation and to have you thinking about is that you do need to drill down further to say, well, does the suburb have a train station? Has that impacted its capital growth over time?

Because the reality is, think of the North Shore of Sydney, right? It's commonly known amongst real estate agents that it's East Side Walk Station. It's a little acronym they use because that side of the suburbs as they run up that North Shore line are...

more desirable than the west side or the other side of the Pacific Highway, and buyers will pay a premium to be on the better, inverted commas, side of the tracks.

So if you're looking at the suburb data, then that's all going to be blended into an amalgam of all the suburb data and not going to be specifically pointed at or targeted at the specific areas and points within that suburb that actually do very, very well as a result of having that transport.

Same with a big shopping centre, you know, like you don't really want to be in the shadow of the big shopping centre, you know, with all the hassles of parking and traffic, et cetera, et cetera.

But if you are, you know, further away from that suburb, you know, but still within walking distance, that may impact on your capital growth potentially or the desirability of your property, right?

So it really is about understanding that, you know, the broad brush statements are on a train line, you know, do those suburbs do better or not? Well, Balmain, for instance, in Sydney's inner west, doesn't have a train station, but it is commonly seen to be the most desirable inner west suburb.

So, it's true that these generally hold concepts need to be challenged, but I think we also need to drill a lot deeper into the suburb itself before we sort of make calls on whether these things are valuable and contribute to capital growth or not in the long term, particularly when you're trying to aim to get an A-grade asset.

Chris Bates

Yeah, I think the real challenge is if you can look at the data at a macro level or you plug it in, it's not deep enough when you're looking to buy one asset, one property, one street in one suburb and then hold it for a long period.

Fundamentally, yes, you want certain sort of rules to sort of what not to buy, but then what to buy. That's the real challenge and that's that local approach.

area, knowledge, the things that people in that area are going to desire more than other things, you know, and that's access to lots of different things. You know, I believe you've got to go super deep rather than sort of super macro.

And maybe on those macro numbers, you could say, you know, those figures don't prove that that works. Well, absolutely. If you look at a micro level and you look at some of the better properties in better suburbs,

over longer term, that gap or how much more expensive they are than the other property gets bigger and bigger. And so you've just got to be super careful sort of taking a broad view and just buying something on the numbers. I just think that's an extremely dangerous strategy.

Veronica Morgan

The other thing too I'd want to add is that the macro data is very important in starting that process of really sort of narrowing down where you want to buy, particularly as an investor.

But certainly it does come a point where you do need to have developed that sort of really deep local knowledge as we're talking about here. But the location, it's sort of commonly accepted in property circles it does 80% of the heavy lifting, right?

It's not enough all by itself because you can buy in a location and lose money. Even in a good location, I've seen people lose money over periods of time when others have made money in the same location.

So that begs, what is it that somebody who made money did differently to the person who lost money? And the obvious thing people will say, oh, well, they must have overpaid. The person who lost money must have overpaid. It's not necessarily the case. It's what they bought.

It's the actual property they bought that makes a difference. And that's really where the cherry on top is. That really is what makes the difference between your capital growth. It's not the entire suburb because that saying a rising tide lifts all ships, it's not true.

There is a vast variety of capital growth and performance from one property to another in the very same suburb. So it really, really does pay to understand those nuances because that's the difference between a successful investment and an unsuccessful one. assuming you've got the location right in the first place.

So that data will help you get to the location, but beyond that, you've got to go deeper.

Please join us for our next episode. We're doing another Q&A, so keep them coming thick and fast, listeners.

We'll be covering how to maximise borrowing on a low income, what agents mean, and they say expressions of interest, borrowing from overseas and the challenges, extra challenges those borrowers face, the research needed when buying your first investment property, dealing with best and final offers in a hot market, and what due diligence do buyers agents do that regular buyers don't do.

If you're looking to buy your dream home or an investment property in Sydney's inner west, eastern suburbs or north shore, my team and I can help you buy without regrets. Reach out via my website, gooddeeds.com.au.

Chris Bates

If you're looking to buy your first home, thinking of upgrading into a new one or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, my team would love to carefully guide you on this journey. And most importantly, get the finance right. reach out via our website, wealthful.com.au. Thanks for joining us.

We'd love to see you again.

Veronica Morgan

And remember, don't be a dumbo.

Click any timestamp to jump.

Key takeaways

  • Over the long term Sheppard said only three findings beat the national average: do not buy new, buy a house rather than a unit, and avoid land where more supply can be built.
  • Houses have outperformed units by about 0.9 per cent per annum over the last 30 years on his data.
  • Census income data back to 1991 showed no relationship between high wage suburbs and above average capital growth, and he suspects price growth pulls wages up rather than the reverse.
  • Suburb-level population growth reads as supply rather than demand, because growth corridor forecasts are built from the dwellings councils and developers plan to approve.
  • Sydney suburbs with train stations of at least 50 years standing showed no growth advantage over 30 years, and a QUT study found flight path suburbs near Brisbane Airport recovered after four years.
  • About 17 metrics feed his demand to supply ratio, and he said a growth difference of about 12 per cent or more over three years is needed before selling and rebuying stacks up.

What Does the Data Say About Capital Growth?

Jeremy Sheppard, Head of Research at Select Residential Property, built the suburb scoring algorithm behind the DSR, or Demand to Supply Ratio. Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates asked what big data can tell an investor about capital growth, and the long-run answer was short.

There were three findings. Do not buy new. Buy a house rather than a unit, because houses have outperformed units by about 0.9 per cent per annum over 30 years. And avoid vacant land, where extra supply can arrive. Updated: over the year to 31 August 2026 national house values rose 2.9 per cent against 2.0 per cent for units, though Sydney and Brisbane units ran ahead (Cotality Home Value Index).

His objection to new stock is depreciation. Claim $10,000 at a 40 cents in the dollar marginal rate and you pay $4,000 less tax, but you are $6,000 worse off, not $4,000 better off.

It's amazing that in the industry, there can be a term called depreciation benefits. There's nothing beneficial about depreciation.

Jeremy Sheppard, 23:12

Do Wages and Population Growth Drive Capital Growth?

Wages surprised him most. Working through household income from censuses back to 1991, he found no relationship between high income suburbs and above average growth, and cases where low income suburbs outperformed. He suspects the causation runs the other way: something lifts demand, prices rise, and from then on only higher earners can afford to buy in, so the wage figure is what price growth leaves behind.

Chris Bates pushed back on borrowing capacity, and Sheppard agreed: those wages belong to the buyers, not the residents.

Population growth was the second casualty. Nationally, migrants arrive without a house and add pressure to demand. At suburb level, people move into an already vacant dwelling, so the number reads as supply. Growth corridor forecasts are built by councils and developers multiplying planned dwellings by two and a half people each. Supply, he said, is the enemy of capital growth, which makes a growth corridor a supply corridor.

Comparison Table: Indicators Against What the Long-Term Data Showed
IndicatorCommon ExpectationWhat Sheppard Said the Data Showed
High wages and wage growthHigher income suburbs outperformNo relationship across censuses back to 1991; low income suburbs sometimes outperformed
Suburb population growthMore people means more demandReads as supply; forecasts built from dwellings councils plan to approve
New propertyDepreciation benefits improve the returnNew has underperformed older property until it ages
UnitsGrowth similar to housesHouses ahead by about 0.9 per cent per annum over 30 years
Long-standing stations, beaches, schoolsA growth premiumNo difference over 30 years where the amenity was already established

As discussed at 10:11, 16:25, 23:12, 25:03 and 27:36. Figures as stated on air.

Does a Train Station Add to Capital Growth?

He tested amenity directly, comparing Sydney suburbs with train stations of at least 50 years standing against suburbs with none, over 30 years. There was no difference, and beaches and good schools in Melbourne gave the same answer. A drawcard that has been there for decades, he reasons, is long since in the price.

His counter-example was Queensland University of Technology work on the mid-1980s Brisbane Airport expansion. Suburbs under the new flight path had reduced capital growth for four years, then performed like the rest of the city. A new amenity might still move growth, but he has not researched that.

Veronica Morgan's caution was about resolution. Suburb data blends a suburb's good side with its bad, and Balmain has no train station yet is widely seen as the most desirable inner west suburb. The hosts have answered listener questions on what actually makes a property A grade, and how company title and land tax bite.

There is a vast variety of capital growth and performance from one property to another in the very same suburb.

Veronica Morgan, 62:55

How Do You Measure Demand Against Supply?

What Sheppard does use is present imbalance. Property markets behave like homeostatic organisms, he said, a tug of war that keeps most near balance; the task is to find the ones that are not.

About 17 metrics sit behind the ratio: auction clearance rates, vacancy rates, percentage of stock on market, selling times, vendor discounting, and the share of sales at auction. It does not explain why a suburb is running, only that demand is beating supply.

Asked for an example at a $500,000 budget, he named suburbs north of Brisbane and said Adelaide offered the most options. Updated: median dwelling values are now $1,080,142 in Brisbane and $937,207 in Adelaide, well past that budget (Cotality Home Value Index, as at 31 August 2026). The same ratio governs the exit: once demand and supply equalise, he would not expect much further growth. For oversupply risk he offered two free checks: Google Maps satellite view, and the council's development applications.

Should You Sell and Rebuy for Better Growth?

Bates ran the arithmetic out loud. Thirty per cent growth over three years, less about 10 per cent in transaction costs and capital gains tax, leaves roughly 16 per cent. Sheppard's threshold was a growth difference of about 12 per cent or more, and the holding period decides it: on a three year hold tax might take 6 or 7 per cent of the gain, on a 20 year hold it kills the idea.

He was candid about his own record. A Western Australian purchase financed with an 80 per cent mortgage and a 20 per cent vendor loan needed only 4 per cent per annum to be his best asset; it went backwards 14 per cent. Six houses in one New Zealand suburb grew about 1.5 per cent a month for 18 months, and all are now sold.

The costlier lesson was inattention. Believing in buy and hold, he stopped watching the markets he owned, and when the GFC strained his cash flow he sold into weakness. By the end he had talked himself back towards the hosts' position: he does not encourage trading, and says investors should probably buy and hold.

Fee Breakdown: What Selling and Rebuying Takes Out of a Three-Year Gain
StepEffect on the Gain
Capital growth over three years30 per cent
Agent commission, legal fees and stamp duty on the replacementLess about 10 per cent
Capital gains tax, after the 50 per cent discount, at a 20 per cent marginal rateLess about 4 per cent
Left of the original gainAbout 16 per cent
Growth gap Sheppard said would justify the moveAbout 12 per cent or more

As walked through by Chris Bates at 40:00 and Jeremy Sheppard at 40:30. Figures as stated on air.

Weighing an Investment Purchase?

This episode is about how much of a growth story turns out to be supply in disguise, and what it costs to change your mind later. Alcove works through the structure and serviceability of an investment property loan before that decision is locked in.

Investment Property Mortgage Broker

Sources referenced: The Elephant in the Room Property Podcast, episode 183, "Jeremy Sheppard | The Secret to Capital Growth", released 2021-07-04. Hosts: Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Jeremy Sheppard, Head of Research, Select Residential Property. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 10 September 2026.