Posted
1 November 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
May 4, 2024
Episode
331
 ·
61
 min
The show

The Elephant in the Room

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with Veronica Morgan. It's a deep dive into what really goes on in the world of real estate.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Veronica Morgan
Veronica Morgan
Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor

Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

Guest
Peter Tulip
Peter Tulip
Chief Economist, Centre for Independent Studies

Peter Tulip, Chief Economist at the Centre for Independent Studies, joins us to explore this issue and dispel some popular myths around housing affordability along the way.

Peter Tulip on Whether 1.2 Million Homes Is Achievable

Economist Peter Tulip joins Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates to test whether 1.2 million new dwellings in five years is realistic. The conversation covers the New South Wales rezoning push, heritage overlays, construction capacity, immigration and where the big affordability effects sit.

Transcript
Veronica Morgan

In this episode, we're talking with economist Peter Tulip, and we're going to explore whether the target of 1.2 million new dwellings over the next five years is feasible. If so, where should we be building these new housing? And what else can be done to ease the pressure? Is cutting immigration the answer?

Welcome to the elephant in the room. This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about.

I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, recently ranked number five in Australia out of over 18,000 brokers in the annual MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Award. Before we get started I need to let you know that nothing we say here can be taken as personal advice.

We always recommend you engage the services of an appropriate and experienced professional.

Our guest today is Peter Tulip, Chief Economist at the Centre for Independent Studies. He's previously worked in the Research Department of the Reserve Bank of Australia and before that at the Federal Reserve Board of Governors.

His recent research focuses on housing and monetary policy and he's very vocal about the merits of high-density living. In fact, he might well be Australia's oldest yimby. Now, welcome back, Peter. We always have a spirited, thought-provoking conversation whenever you come onto the podcast and we really appreciate you joining us again today.

Peter Tulip

Glad to be with you, Veronica. Hi, Chris.

Chris Bates

Peter, hi.

Last time we chatted, I just should have checked exactly what it was, but it was before, you know, some of the drastic action that, you know, Chris means is sort of, and please give us your update on, you know, a lot of listeners may know about this, but, you know, it's real time, right?

It's happening right now. And what's your take on it? You know, is it going to get watered down? You know, there's already talk that that's happening. And is it a good thing? And have they done it the right way?

Peter Tulip

So as background, okay, great. As background, the National Cabinet met last year and they had a target of 1.2 million homes over the next five years, which we should talk about, because some people don't think that that's feasible.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah.

Peter Tulip

That's a good quote. But everyone does agree it's a very ambitious target.

and it involves pretty much producing at our peak level of construction over an extended period of time. Against that background, New South Wales, where the housing affordability problems are worse and where there's most need for more building,

The New South Wales government has been announcing a whole series of new housing policies with the aim of greatly increasing housing construction, especially in Sydney.

And one of them is that they want a lot of medium density housing around train stations. They've named 39 specific areas where they want a very substantial uplift.

But more broadly, they're wanting much greater access to granny flats, dual occupancy, townhouses in what previously was low-density housing.

So that's what they've announced, and it's extremely controversial that a lot of the local councils are strongly opposed to what the government is doing. Partly... Because of the process that local councils don't like being told to do by the state government.

They don't think that there's been adequate consultation. But also just in terms of the outcome, that a lot of people do not like the idea of apartments and townhouses in their suburb.

Chris Bates

What do you think, Peter? Have the locations and the size, do you think it's enough? Do you think it's been a little bit heavy handed, you know, and they haven't really been engaging with the councils enough and it's been a little bit too prescriptive?

Peter Tulip

Right, so a few questions there. Yes, I think it is heavy handed and there hasn't been much consultation and ordinarily you would like these things to be much more consultative. But the process of asking councils to do this by themselves, in my assessment, has failed.

That the previous government was setting targets for councils and hoping that they would adhere to them. They haven't been. The previous process is just failing. And the most clear evidence of that is just the affordability problem keeps getting worse and worse and worse. We're just not building enough.

So...

I think some urgency is both understandable or even necessary. And the government has said that councils can come up with their own plans if they have a similar level of uplift.

So it is free for councils to do better if they think they can. Yeah. But I think it is appropriate for them to give the whole process a quick push along and move quickly. I think, Chris, you also asked whether it's enough. And I think the answer to that is no.

What they have been announced...

So it's hard to know how many dwellings these proposals will deliver. But some of the estimates that are out there suggest that it falls. So, I mean, we've got a national contribution of...

A national target of 1.2 million, I think that means a five-year target in New South Wales of, I think, 280,000, no, 370,000, I think, through ICAR.

Veronica Morgan

A few hundred thousand.

Peter Tulip

Yeah. But I think that means about 75,000 a year in New South Wales. Currently, we're only doing about 40,000, depending on exactly how you measure it. So we're falling. very badly short.

Whether what they've announced will bring us up to that 75,000, I don't think it will, but then there are a lot of other things that they still could announce, like we don't know what's happening with Greenfield's developments in the western suburbs of Sydney. We don't know what's happening in regional New South Wales.

There's scope for a lot more housing.

in many of our rural towns and there hasn't haven't been any announcements on that yet so so the short answer your question is what they've announced so far is not enough but i expect there is more coming in so announcing it's one thing rezoning is one thing putting you know impositions on councils and and whatever is is one thing

Veronica Morgan

But you've got to have developers, builders, supply, the wherewithal. As you said, you know, we've got to be building at peak levels of construction for the entire five years to achieve something we've never achieved before.

And that, you know, given the ramp-up time, given it seems to be that New South Wales is being the most aggressive in terms of the state government's approach to this and other state governments aren't quite so aggressive from what I can understand,

So the ramp up to getting to peak approvals, let alone peak construction, is, you know, fairly long. And that means that that sort of puts more pressure on the back end of this five years, doesn't it? I mean, does all this mean that it's not really feasible? Absolutely.

Peter Tulip

certainly is not feasible under the old regime and previous policy would not deliver it um to get a substantial a big increase in construction so that our housing stock grows substantially faster than our population requires a change in policy so in new south wales we are seeing that um

being announced at least, as you say, yet to be implemented, yet to be enforced. And we're definitely not seeing the construction numbers turning up yet. And we probably won't see that for several quarters at least. It may even be measured in years.

Veronica Morgan

Do we have capacity, though, when it does?

Peter Tulip

That's a good question.

And the only way we find out is by trying, isn't it?

Veronica Morgan

Yeah.

Peter Tulip

If we attain that recent peak level, then we hit the target. I mean, if we can keep doing that for five years. So all of those plumbers and carpenters and bricklayers haven't gone away. Well, yeah, a tiny number of them were retired and everything.

But in fact, the construction workforce seems to have increased since then. One of the problems is a lot of them are doing small household jobs, you know, renovations and things like that. And because there is not the high volume work that

might otherwise occupy them and what I think will happen is if we do start putting up apartments and we start seeing more cranes arising over the horizon that a lot of the workers will come off you know fixing up back decks or you know mending fences and they'll start working on the really high value projects and a change in wages may be necessary for that

And a change in immigration may be necessary for it also.

Veronica Morgan

We will definitely get to immigration.

But while we're talking about sort of peak construction levels, the thing that sort of popped into my mind when you talked about the times at which we were at peak construction is the legacy of that and the defects and the problems that the owners of a lot of these buildings, a lot of the lots within these buildings are now grappling with.

And so, you know, do we, I mean, how can we manage this whole thing in an orderly fashion that then doesn't create a knock-on effect for the people that sort of pile in because they're desperate for somewhere to live and then they end up with worse off effect?

Peter Tulip

So my outfit, the Center for Independent Studies, is what's often called a libertarian outfit. We like, we believe in free markets and limited government, but

We're not, and certainly I'm not a zealot, that I think there are some regulations in the housing sector that are very bad and harmful. I mean, in particular, the zoning regulations we've discussed.

But there are other regulations, and in particular, the building code, where I think there's a lot of scope for tightening things. So you can change the planning code, which determines the quantity of housing, to allow for a greater quantity.

while at the same time tightening up the building code, which to improve the quality. So, I mean, that's a principle argument. I mean, in terms of specifics, I actually don't think that the building code needs to be changed very much. What needs to be changed is the enforcement.

And in particular, I think private certification has not worked well. And a lot of the problems we're seeing is because the incentives for certifiers to properly check that work is done up to code have not been there.

And so we've had a lot of dodgy projects approved that should not have been. And that is really awful and means buyers don't trust new apartments.

Chris Bates

move peter i've been tracking this story quite tightly because i think it's a massive story right it's happening in new south wales and it's a bit of a canary in the coal mine what could happen in other cities around uh the country right uh

But there's been sort of a talk on the wall, our accounts are right, being some heritage overlays on buildings that probably don't deserve heritage overlays. You know, what's your sort of... You're a feel-my-dumber. Ah, there you go. I mean, the other sort of, you know, the Haberfield, the Haberfield area. Yeah.

You know, you look at like around Balmain and the Bays Precinct, right? Like...

yeah you can build up to nine stories around that i mean in all like two million dollar terraces are going to have to come down like it you know that have been there for 100 plus years like what's your you know thoughts on the heritage aspect to these and and the blanket rezoning and you know is that going to be are we going to come back in the future and say we've or should we just sort of protect heritage in real heritage pockets like

You know, like where the streets are perfectly all heritage rather than, you know, across whole suburbs. Like, should we just let go of a little bit of heritage to do this or do we need to think about heritage over the top of it?

Peter Tulip

I think heritage has been greatly overused. Right. I think... I don't think anyone disagrees with the idea of preserving buildings that are unusually old or unusually attractive.

But what's happened with our heritage listing is this lanky classification of almost entire suburbs. I don't know how many of you mentioned, but...

Most of Glebe or Balmain or Willara or Paddington, I think it's half of the city of Sydney and about 30 or 40% of the inner west council area. Similar areas in other old, the old parts of Sydney.

And a lot of it is pretty ordinary housing. You get streets of just...

regular suburban houses. And the owners don't want to be heritage listed. It means they can't do renovations. In some cases, they can't even choose their own paint colour. And it's really harmful in terms of housing affordability.

It really restricts our ability for people to live in areas where they want to live.

Veronica Morgan

There's very few areas that have that level of heritage restriction, though. I mean, Haberfield is one rare example of a suburb that has, you know, heritage overlay because it was the first planned suburb in Sydney.

And Hunters Hill has a heritage overlay over the entire suburb as well, and it's a peninsula and there's a particular type of architecture there. Yeah.

You know, Glebe and Balmain and suburbs like that, they've got conservation areas and it doesn't have the same onerous responsibilities or conditions placed on owners and their renovations. But it will impact things like, you know, going up into the attic and putting dormer windows in and floor space ratio and stuff like that.

And streetscape, you know, the idea is you almost do whatever you want behind the front wall as long as you can't see any change from the street.

Peter Tulip

Well, that's a really big condition.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, well, it is. But when you've only got a 120-square-metre block of land, you know what I mean, there's constraints created by sheer size of the property in the first place. And that's not uncommon, say, in Balmain.

But the thing is that, you know, with all these rezoning, when you're looking at, say, that obviously hit the news, it was something like a 1.2-kilometre radius, you know, redevelopment or rezoning.

I mean, there's got to be some sheer economic limitations on that all being knocked down and suddenly turning to high rise. I mean, those individual houses on their little tiny blocks of land, each one is going to cost a significant amount to buy. So, therefore, the site value is extraordinarily high.

You know, there's got to be lower paying fruit, surely, for developers, right?

Peter Tulip

No, I think the reason a lot of this land is so incredibly expensive is because it's incredibly well located and incredibly effective.

And it's actually, it's a pretty inefficient use to have land which is within walking distance of the CBD being reserved, but in many cases, single story, detached out. Well, okay, a lot of it isn't detached, a lot of it is terraces.

but it's pretty low density housing on some of the most valuable real estate in the country.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, but my question around that is that how feasible is it going to be if you rezone it? How feasible is it going to be for developers to be able to come in, make enough of a profit, find enough willing owners to part with it? You know what I mean? So after...

Peter Tulip

Mins and Scully announced their transport-oriented development with 39 stations having big developments.

In particular, they're allowing up to about six stories within 400 metres of these 39 stations.

People that were living within that circle, within the 400 metres, have just been absolutely inundated with office.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah.

Peter Tulip

But there is a complete opposite of a shortage of willing builders.

Veronica Morgan

Hang on a minute. I'm not sure that's the case in the inner city areas. I've heard that. Absolutely, I've heard that in the upper North Shore. Yeah.

Chris Bates

And that's where I live, yes.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah.

Chris Bates

Yeah. Is that around the – is it Gordon? Is it where – Roseville is my – Roseville, yeah.

Peter Tulip

That was actually a story in the Sydney Morning Herald, I think it was maybe a month or so ago, how the local residents who fortunately could then live a bit closer to the train station than I do, they're just getting enormous numbers of incredibly lucrative offers for their –

Veronica Morgan

But it's also different because each of those lots are bigger, you know what I mean? So you can buy fewer houses and you're actually still going to be able to build a block of units or townhouse or whatever you're going to build.

Peter Tulip

Typically what's happening is the residents are joining together. And to sell in their properties in consolidated sale, which increases the value substantially.

And I mean, yeah, so developers want to put up big apartment buildings and to do that, that's most profitable when you can consolidate it.

Chris Bates

Peter, just out of curiosity.

Peter Tulip

I think there was a story in the Sydney Morning Report about focusing on Glebe also. Yeah. That where similar things are happening. Yeah. So there was one of my old economics professors, in fact, had his photo on the paper because he was offered several million dollars for his property.

Chris Bates

How far away? Just out of curiosity. Just like as a discussion point. How far away are you from the station, Peter? Oh, no. I'm a kilometre from Rose. Okay. Yeah. So like, if you think about this though, like, okay, so you're inside that 400 buffer zone, right?

Like that's, and you're getting these offers. Assuming people take it up, right? The amount of houses in Roseville decreases, right? Quite significantly, right? Because they get knocked down and they get turned to apartments and et cetera.

Unless those owners then go buy one of those apartments and they get built on their land, which may actually happen, actually, because the reality is they probably will target the downsizing market with those developments.

But ultimately, people who do want to stay in rows are going to go, hey, I just want to buy outside that 400-meter buffer zone.

right because people don't really want to change their suburb and and they want to cash in because look if they don't cash in they're going to get a high rise next to them um and it makes sense so you know you could still find that you're an amenity the suburb will go up right because you know you're going to get some more cafes you're going to get some commercial you're going to get a whole new you know the suburbs going to get a new lease of life do you think do you think that's going to be good for people like you a kilometer away or do you think that

You know, it's not going to be great for your suburb. How do you take it?

Peter Tulip

It'll be great for us. We'll get the hokers with more people. We'll get a butcher, a grocer and a pub. All the which Roseville is lacking at the moment. Because it's all low density housing, so there's just not the demand. A lot of

My, well, I'll call them neighbours, other people that live in Roseville, I mean, have been living here for decades. Yeah. And there are a lot of empty, you know, so I think the median age in the suburb is something like 50, just a decade or two above the national average.

And there are a lot of empty nesters. And in fact, I think the Herald story I mentioned earlier featured one of them who'd been living in her house for 50 years. And, you know, she now had this five-bedroom house. The fountain is all left.

And this has actually been a real social problem in suburbs like mine, that empty nesters, when the children's gone, they find they're living in these huge houses with big gardens, but, you know,

It no longer suits their lifestyle. They don't need the rooms. The garden actually becomes a pain. They don't use the swimming pool and they hate the stairs. So for a lot of reasons, they would like to downsize or move to an apartment close to the shops in walking distance of places.

But in suburbs like mine, that's just not an available opportunity. Because it's all detached houses, there hasn't been the choice for people who would like to stay in the same neighbourhood to find more appropriate accommodation.

And in fact, if we were just to facilitate that, there'd be a substantial increase in the supply of housing.

These pensioner retirees living with multiple spare unused bedrooms moving to a smaller apartment means there's a lot of space for

Veronica Morgan

So what you're talking about there is it's a different affordability conversation, isn't it? I mean, you're talking about a very affluent area where there are a lot of, as I was talking to somebody up there only a couple of weeks ago, he said, well, there's no Labor voters up here.

That's why it's happened, you know. So the Liberal voters don't want it there. The NIMBYs, not like you, you're a NIMBY. They don't want it. Mind you, you're a K out, so you're not really going to be affected. You're going to get all the positives and none of the negatives.

So you're not going to sort of have to uproot your life and watch your house get demolished. You're also not going to have to live next door to a new block of apartments if you decide to stay put.

And you can see the lifestyle benefits that could potentially come to your area by more diversity of housing, the opportunity for people to downsize and stay close to where their networks are, but also just increased recreational options.

So that can all be seen as real positives, but there's been certainly some areas where density hasn't brought, despite all the promises, hasn't brought that. Like a lot of density, I was reading an article about sort of

apartment, the vacancies of shops underneath these modern apartment buildings. I see them even just walking around inner Sydney where I am and quite often I'm walking past buildings that have got empty shops. They've never been occupied.

There's some areas, whole suburbs that have this sort of problem. They've got lots and lots of people and yet the promise of this lifestyle and the community centres and everything actually has not been fulfilled. Where do you think they've gone wrong?

They have not delivered those vibrant community centres that has been the big promise.

Peter Tulip

So there are lots of issues there. Vacant shops is, I think, primarily an issue of rents that partly... relating to the pandemic, that there have been huge changes in the demand for commercial space.

And in particular, there's a lot more working from home. And partly related to that, the demand for a lot of commercial space has fallen off. especially in the CBD, less so sort of out in the suburbs.

And a lot of rents just haven't adjusted to that yet. The rents tend to be very sluggish on the way up and very sluggish on the way down.

So part of the problem with these vacant shops is that the retailers have found much more attractive options elsewhere. And the landlords are yet to adjust. I mean, they're hoping that if they advertise long enough, they'll find a new tenant.

And it tends to take people a long time before they realize, no, we need to cut the rent. But yes, eventually that'll happen and the places will be filled up again.

Chris Bates

Yeah, I mean, it's not really our time and you want to really start a business, really. Consumer confidence is really low, interest rates are high, there's talk of recessions, like, you know, it's hard to get talent and staff and, you know, it's cataclysmic, it could be, right, if no one else is opening.

But ultimately, I think that's, it's not usually the right environment to encourage people to take risk, I guess. I mean, hey, what's your take on the RBA stance right now and the global inflation story? It's a bit of a different tact.

But, you know, even just today, the US numbers of inflation are sort of surprised to the upside. And those guaranteed rate cuts that we thought with 2024 would happen apparently won't happen now. Right. You've been there, you've been on the front in both of those, here and overseas.

What do you think?

Peter Tulip

So in the past, I've been very critical of the Reserve Bank, the settings of monetary policy. I've often been very different to the ones I would like. But now I think it's about right.

I mean, it's hard to judge where the economy is going, that inflation is too high, but it's coming down.

The unemployment rate is probably lower than we think can be sustained, but will probably be increasing substantially. So I would... be a bit more inclined to tighten than to loosen.

In particular, I worry about the inflation numbers that it's not coming down to 2.5%, which is the midpoint of the target for several years, which I think is too long. It's too risky. There's something, shocks will come along to blow them off target and that becomes a problem.

um but i don't want to be strident or angry about this that yeah so it's a close call and and when they're talking about differences of 25 or 50 basis points so it's not yeah huge difference if you go back to pre-covid though we were going to this lower interest rate environment all around the world and negative interest rates and

Chris Bates

Do you think that those days of that bond rally and the depressing of interest rates and, you know, really struggling to get growth and inflation, do you think those days are done or are we going to go back to those days and we're on a new path now?

Peter Tulip

Every time someone says those days are done, we repeat it. It's... Who knows? The...

Yeah, I mean, no, it's very difficult to tell. And it's certainly a contingency that we need to be better prepared for than we were last time. So when interest rates fell to zero in 2020, the Reserve Bank was scrambling. It didn't really know what to do.

And it ended up doing things that just a few months earlier it had said were off the scale. Yeah. So, there was an understandable lack of planning, and they changed tactics.

um fairly seriously over the course of 2020 um so they need to think more about what happened but that's a very active area of research in the central banking community and people are reviewing those experiences closely with a view to distilling what the lessons are and i don't think there's agreement on that yet but um people are thinking it through

Veronica Morgan

I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions. And you can find out all about what I'm working on at veronicamorgan.com.au.

And there you'll find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program, access to suburb help for investors, or if you're looking to buy your dream home or an investment property in Sydney's inner west, eastern suburbs, or lower North Shore, you can connect with my team at Good Deeds Property Buyers.

If you're thinking about buying your first home, upgrading to a new one or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Please reach out via our website, wealthful.com.au.

It's funny. I mean, I was actually listening to Stuart Williams' podcast this morning and he was just reviewing the last 20 years of property prices versus the previous 20 years.

And a lot of us talk about the shocks we've had in the last 20 years versus... And he said, well, actually, there was lots of systemic change and structural change and shocks that happened actually the previous 20 years as well, which is either we weren't alive or we've got short memories.

And I think that, like you said, these things just... Is this unprecedented? Maybe not.

I think the pressure on, you know, the cost of living pressures that are happening and sort of back to the affordability, I guess, you know, they're very real in many cases and in many quarters across the country at the moment.

And obviously with interest rates where they are currently, there's a segment of our community that are more impacted than others and bearing the brunt. And I don't know, it's totally...

It's definitely off the property tangent, but I'm looking at the amount of events that are being cancelled, you know, and you can really see the disposable income going, yeah, is that important to me now? No.

And, you know, you can argue there's lots of delayed shocks, I guess, from COVID and from stimulus and from, you know, people's bank accounts being full and bad business practices, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. There's lots of discussion around all of that. But the fact is...

Sorry, if you can hear my dog barking in the background there. The fact is that this is all going on. This is pressure that we are all experiencing and it's starting to feel real, you know.

And so how does that, I mean, from the Reserve Bank's point of view, they've only got one lever here. How does it have to get, I guess, before they will find pressure to put rates down?

Peter Tulip

What is needed is convincing evidence that inflation will head towards 2.5% and the unemployment rate will head to a sustainable level, which we think might be around 4.5%.

And if it looks like we'll – and that's what the Reserve Bank is hoping for in maybe two years' time, getting something like that maybe in two years' time.

And if that does happen, they will –

Reduce interest rates gradually.

If it looks like we get there quicker, they'll raise drop rates quickly. If it progress towards those goals slows, then it's quite likely they'll increase rates. So it depends on how the economy evolves.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, so I guess, you know, your answer there is a very measured answer in terms of what the Reserve Bank's goal targets are and we've all got to stop spending money, but that's really hard when rents are going up and, you know, the inflation is largely driven by services at the moment, et cetera, et cetera.

So just buckle up. Is that what you're saying? We just have to be patient? Yes.

Peter Tulip

So things are going to be especially difficult if you've got a large mortgage. I mean, interest rates have risen very substantially. And that's good for a lot of retirees, people who live on. Yeah.

And people forget that when people are talking about interest rates for every loser, there's a gain. Every dollar that is paid in higher mortgage payments tends to go to, I mean, either someone with a certificate deposit at the bank or shares in the bank.

So it's a redistribution. It doesn't overall reduce living standards. So they're doing it tough. Unemployment will probably increase.

So they're the people that will most suffer, the people that lose their jobs and can't find others.

Veronica Morgan

Particularly if they've got a big mortgage.

Peter Tulip

Yeah, for most other people, well, most of us are getting big tax cuts in two months' time, three months' time, so beginning of July. So things will be easier for everyone else.

Chris Bates

What's your thoughts on immigration, Peter? You know, we have a very desirable country. We could import talent from all over the world and maybe they don't want to move here when they look at our property market. But what's your take on the catch-up we've had post-COVID?

Has that really been an increase or has it just been a catch-up? And is it sustainable at the current levels and should we increase it or decrease it? What's your take?

Peter Tulip

So it's a huge issue for a lot of reasons, one of which is what we were talking about before, the housing market. The reason rents are going up so incredibly quickly at the moment is because vacancies are extremely low.

And the immediate reason for that is the immigration numbers have rocketed up significantly.

Though, to put that in context, a lot of that is just making up for the big shortfall in immigration we had while the orgs were closed during the pandemic.

And there's a sense in which we're just getting back to the level of population that we would have had if it hadn't been for the pandemic. Yeah. On immigration. So I've done a paper estimating the effect of immigration on housing costs.

And we estimated that the big increase in immigration rates over the past decade or two increased the cost of housing by about 9%. So it definitely does put upwards pressure on rents and housing prices.

And a lot of people think that rather than Okay, my proposal for dealing with the housing shortage is to allow more building to change the sign-on regulations. A lot of people would prefer that we cut the immigration numbers.

My disagreement with that is not over-effectiveness. I mean that, yes, if you reduce the immigration numbers, that would help reduce the housing shortage and would take some of the pressure off rents. My disagreement is over desirability.

In turn, if you're going to reduce the housing shortage, it's much better off doing it on the supply side than the demand side. They'll both work, but lower immigration tends to reduce living standards, whereas increased supply improves living standards.

To get a bit more detailed than that, I mean, you need to talk about what kind of immigration you're changing because the story, the effects are very different depending on whether you're talking about skilled, unskilled, refugees, permanent, temporary, all of those variations.

The simplest case is, and the topical case, the government has just been announcing restrictions, is on student immigration. Well, they've substantially tightened up the student visas.

In particular, by tightening, they're just not processing the visas.

The problem with that is those university students from overseas pay very lucrative fees to our higher education authorities.

And so education is our third biggest export industry.

That export revenue we get from education is how we as a society pay for our TVs and clothes and shoes and cars and so much of the way we live.

relies on purchasing imports and that will be harder if we stifle one of our most successful export industries. In contrast, if you solve the housing problem by boosting supply,

then people are better off. Instead of having to live a two-hour commute away, people would find housing within a 10, 15-minute commute from their work. People wouldn't have to be living in their parents' basements as much. We wouldn't have to be overcrowding.

We wouldn't have so much homelessness.

In all sorts of different ways, extra supply makes us better off, whereas cutting demand in particular through reducing immigration makes us worse off.

Veronica Morgan

It always makes me laugh when they talk about reducing students. If you're going to pick a segment of immigrants... Because I've been in properties that are rented to students and sometimes up to four of them sharing a bedroom.

Like in terms of the actual impact on the bedrooms available for the rest of Australians to rent or to purchase, then I would say that as a segment, they have to have the smallest amount of impact in terms of turning off the tap.

But I guess also you're talking about supply and demand there. I mean... I would imagine it's more responsive to turn the tap on and off on the demand side there in terms of...

you know, in terms of immigration versus we already discussed how long it takes to build a dwelling, you know. So how does that, I guess, the change or difference in pace of those two aspects, how does that factor into the argument on this?

You know, because I guess there's going to be people saying, well, we should turn off immigration now because we can do it quickly and then that's going to ease the pressure and give us time to catch up. I mean, is that a reasonable argument?

Peter Tulip

Yeah. I think that is true, that if you need to solve the housing crisis by June, then immigration is a leave you can pull on, whereas housing construction is not.

But this housing shortage has been bad and getting worse for decades now.

it's a very long problem. And so being told that I need to wait a few more months to solve it is, yeah, if I can get a solution that I have to wait a few months for it, I'd be delighted. Yeah.

Chris Bates

Peter, I guess when you look at the low-hanging fruit, right, so you're talking about supply, right? I think we're getting some action there, right? The government's talking about it. There's, you know, Chris Min's.

There's been a little bit of an attack on land tax as well, right, in Victoria, for example, trying to free up. When you've done all your research in your papers, what are some of the other low-hanging fruit where you really, if you want to move the needle,

You know, you can change some tax settings or, you know, like, I don't know, maybe making the home capital gains tax, you know, maybe after, you know, you don't get the pension if your home's included, like, you know, or, you know, you pay land tax on your home.

Like, what do you think some of the big... things that would really encourage people because you can create more supply but what would actually create more supply is like you say that moving people into better places that you're forcing people to downsize really the empty nesters what do you think um so

Peter Tulip

Many of my other researchers that operate in my turf are fond of drawing up long lists of housing reform that often will be 10 or 20 point programs for things that need to be done.

And My view of that is that one of them is a huge one, is the elephant in the room, if I can use that phrase. You can. And pretty much everything else is tiny.

So the big thing is supply and, in particular, zoning regulations that we need to allow more building. Other things, well, I wouldn't say trivial, but a tiny. And if I can pick one example, because a lot of people are talking about it at the moment.

Actually, I think, Chris, you just mentioned it. Negative gearing and the capital gains discount. Yeah. Alan Cole just did a high-profile paper. Yeah. I'm saying that. Researchers have looked at this, the effect of the tax concessions on housing prices.

And they've done a lot of good research in a lot of different ways. And they've all estimated that the effects are tiny. That if you were to... Okay, so they look at it in different ways.

But if you were to do something like what the Labor Party took to the 2019 federal election...

They estimate that that would reduce house prices by, again, there's one estimate of 1%, there's another estimate of 2%, another estimate of 4%, and there are other estimates up here that are similar.

And you compare that with the effect of zoning reform, where we're talking changes of 40 or 50%. Boo.

Extra supply just has enormous effect on affordability. Tax concessions.

I mean, there are good arguments for changing the tax code. And I don't think, in particular, the capital gains discount. I mean, I think there are good arguments for reforming that and changing that. But they relate to equity and tax policy design.

In terms of housing affordability, it's just not an issue.

Veronica Morgan

So, I mean, we're sort of in agreement with you. We've pulled apart a lot of those arguments.

So it's interesting, though, that you say that increased supply could impact that property values by 40%. Now, what exactly do you mean by that? Because anything, because it's political, all is political, right?

So anything that's going to reduce the values of how many of us own property in this country or the 11 million properties that exist, you know, anything that's going to reduce the value of those properties owned by individuals, owned by voters is not palatable, right? you

So what do you mean by a 40% reduction of value? Right.

Peter Tulip

So to be concrete, one simple example of what we're talking about is what's happened in Auckland. Back in 2016, Auckland used to be overwhelmingly low-density detached houses everywhere.

And they had a big plan in reform there, which essentially allowed medium-density housing for about three-quarters of the city. And as a result of that, construction doubled.

And the housing stock last times that, you know, there have been several detailed research papers on this. The last time one of the most thorough of them looked at it, it had increased the housing stock in Auckland by about 4%. And

And the effect of that was to substantially improve, reduce housing costs.

In particular, if you look at rents in Auckland, then they've fallen relative to inflation, whereas in all the other cities in New Zealand, they've risen quite substantially. So if you take other cities like Wellington and Hamilton as examples,

as a counterfactual for what might have happened to Auckland rents, the cost of housing has fallen about 20%. And that's not allowing high density, that's not transport-oriented development, that's just fairly broad scale.

A lot of it is just townhouses and four or five storey apartments.

Veronica Morgan

So that's saying... There's a lot more that can be done in those areas. And so what you're saying there, if I can paraphrase it, tell me if I got it right, is that the composition, there's more housing, the composition is different, there's more sort of medium density.

And so the cost to get in or the, you know, the medium price view and look at it has come down. But the values of those individual houses that are less standing, I would imagine they've gone up.

Would that – because, you know, all of a sudden the scarcity value, if you can afford to buy a freestanding house on its own block of land.

Peter Tulip

Well, in particular, the land that's now zoned for median density housing tends to have increased.

Veronica Morgan

So there's a one-off increase there, obviously.

Chris Bates

Because there's the –

Peter Tulip

Yeah, demolition and rebuilding flats on us. So that's increased. But what's most relevant in terms of housing affordability is the cost of floor space. And that's fallen very substantially relative to what it would have been otherwise.

Veronica Morgan

Because of an increase in supply and a different type of stock that wasn't there before.

Chris Bates

Peter, when there's this upzoning, do you think that the council or the state government should capture that in a tax at all? And, you know, because they've got a lot of costs, right? When you upzone, you've got to replace roads, you've got to replace sewerage, you've got...

You know, a lot more demands on the town and the council success.

So do you think that there should be like an up zone tax that, you know, captures the over, like you sell your $2 million place for three or four mil because of the rezoning, you should pay a tax on that even though it was your home?

Peter Tulip

Yeah, so... Yes. The short answer is yes. The longer answer is that we already have some measures that partially do that. And so infrastructure charges vary from state to state. I think in New South Wales tends to be about $12,000 per apartment.

that you know when a new block of flats is coming in the developer needs to pay um a substantial charge which um finances a lot of the infrastructure that you're talking about the water and sewage and so on um it's also the case that um if you're an investor or a landlord then you'll pay capital gains tax on that increase in sales um which is

Okay, so you still get most of the benefit of the uplift, but the government does capture a large share of it. There's...

I think most economists think that capital gains tax should also apply to owner-occupiers. Yeah. And whether or not they do, I believe that. And that would capture a substantial amount also. We talked about the capital gains discount.

As I said before, I think that's questionable that there are good arguments for getting rid of that discount.

So even within the current tax system, there are some relatively simple tweaks that would capture it. a very large share of the uplift.

In the ACT, they have a betterment tax where increases in land value accompanied by re-upzoning. I think three quarters of that goes to the ACT government.

And I don't think it's especially well-signed or well-implemented, but in principle, I think that gets a...

a more fundamental policy that a lot of people are attracted to. It's

Whenever you talk about taxation of housing, it gets very, very controversial. It's very difficult. My personal agenda is based on the idea that increasing supply is controversial enough, and I don't want to bite off another big issue at the same time.

So far, I'm just...

He's sympathetic to the idea that government should capture more of this uplift. I think that that just makes the issue a whole lot more controversial and difficult to serve. So as a priority, I don't think it makes sense to push that.

Chris Bates

No, exactly. I mean, people have to start factoring that into their sales. It's like they want more money and then it just slows down the whole process. But, yeah, you have to admit it's a bit of a free kick for them.

And, you know, those costs you spoke about, they get passed on to the buyer, right? So they get factored into the sale price and the developer has to pay higher for the land. So, you know, if you, yeah.

Peter Tulip

Okay, that depends on which specific tax we're talking about. In terms of taxes and charges, yes. So I think infrastructure charges. Most obviously going to be passed on to the buyer, as they should be. The idea is you don't want people building houses on the top of a mountain.

Veronica Morgan

Without a road.

Peter Tulip

that it's incredibly costly to connect the utilities to. Though, if they're prepared to pay the hundreds of thousands of dollars required to service that property, then fine, it should go ahead. But

um user cost charging i think gives you is how you decide where to build and where you should um other taxes in particular value uplift charges probably would not be passed on to the buyer that i mean there it's the price is what the market will bear and it's a question of whether that windfall goes to the government or to the landowner

Veronica Morgan

I guess if it's an investment property, then government gets a bit, but if it's not, they won't.

Your thoughts on capital gains tax on the family home is interesting because all I can think of is, well, that will really constrain upgrading and that in turn will constrain price growth. So I guess that's one way to slow things down.

Chris Bates

Very unpopular, I would imagine. You've got to finish this off here, Peter, with a property dumbo. Did you have one up your sleeve? I know I stole one from you already with the Willara example, but have you got another one for me?

Peter Tulip

No, I'm interested in the basic idea of heritage.

In a lot of cases, heritage protections make sense, that it's good to preserve buildings that are unusually old or unusually attractive. But some of what is being used with heritage is just dumb.

And we mentioned earlier Haberfield, one of the local where there is talk about redeveloping some vacant land there that used to be owned by the army. The army decided they don't use it anymore. And so the council is talking about putting suburban houses, new suburban houses there.

I mean, that's controversial, but what I laughed at was when one of the councillors said that they wanted heritage protections on the new houses.

Veronica Morgan

Oh, God. Totally don't understand what it even means to even say that. Boy.

Peter Tulip

No, that's a good one. I like it. Heritage is just being used as a device to stop housing. And the other amazing example that's similar to this was down in Melbourne. There's an old concrete car park, you know, four or five storeys of raw concrete, which...

Okay, this is my own personal value judgment, but I think concrete car parks are about the ugliest sculpture that we see in cities.

Chris Bates

A brutalist architect fan would love it, though. They would be like, this is the most gorgeous car park I've ever seen.

Peter Tulip

And what's happened is the decision was left up to three brutalist architects. Yeah, who said exactly what you're saying, is that they just love raw concrete. Yeah, yeah. And so this car park is being preserved under a Heritage Protection Act.

Veronica Morgan

Oh, it's gold. You didn't actually mention about Wallara, because Chris said, oh, you said that's Madumbo, and we didn't finish the story, so tell us.

Peter Tulip

No, no, no, I was talking about heritage in particular.

Veronica Morgan

What has Hilara Council been doing?

Peter Tulip

So when I said you're stealing my number, I was talking about bad heritage convictions. I can't remember the heritage proof.

Chris Bates

I think they're basically throwing on some pretty average apartment blocks on Edgecliff Road and just say, oh, you know, this is heritage. And, you know, it's not like it's an amazing Art Deco building that's just completely unique.

Like, it just is an old brick building that's, you know, they're just trying to reduce that going from six levels to nine levels, I think, from my understanding. Yeah. They've been slapping these heritage overlays on in the last five years because in anticipation that there's going to be a pressure for density. Right.

And that's what I think they've been doing. So they're getting a bit of stick at the moment for being a bit over...

Veronica Morgan

A cynical application of heritage.

Peter Tulip

And it's happening about one block away from Edgecliff Station. Yeah, exactly. That's right. And even then, it's within walking distance of the CBD or the harbour. I mean, this is some of the most valuable real estate in the country. And they're saying no.

And you would think it'd be nice if thousands of people could enjoy it. Yeah. Could benefit from the amenities of this site. But they're saying no, they want it lower density and they're using heritage as a roundabout way of achieving that.

Veronica Morgan

So I hope I say it's funny, Peter, you say you're a libertarian, but you sound a little bit like a socialist at times. So...

Peter Tulip

I know you're winding up.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, go, go.

Peter Tulip

One of the reasons housing is interesting is that a lot of free marketers, it tends to have problems in terms of equality. I mean, it tends to hurt the poor and benefit the rich.

And housing is a big exception to that, where a libertarian policy in housing Benefits renters, benefits young homebuyers and the people it hurts are the wealthy property owners. So it's something that egalitarians and libertarians will agree on.

Chris Bates

Thank you, Peter. Thank you. We'd love to come back around in six months' time. Once we know more about these means, we'll start to see if this development starts to, you know, pipe up, I guess.

And if it's a, you know, the plan of actually increasing application doesn't actually happen or really does happen. And like you say, there's been some really good sales and development applications start increasing and, you know, we start to see some light. But unfortunately, these things are three, four years down the line, right?

Yeah. So it's not going to be an immediate effect, but it's good long-term planning. So thanks so much for coming on, Pete.

Peter Tulip

My pleasure. I enjoyed your chat.

Chris Bates

Thank you. Thank you. All right.

Veronica Morgan

If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website, theelephantintheroom.com.au, or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au. If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit.

And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great. I know that sounds a bit cringy but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.

Click any timestamp to jump.

Key takeaways

  • The 1.2 million home target means building at close to peak construction levels for five straight years, which Tulip calls very ambitious rather than impossible.
  • New South Wales needs about 75,000 dwellings a year to hit its share of roughly 370,000, against current output of about 40,000.
  • The announcements cover 39 station precincts and low density infill, but nothing yet on greenfield western Sydney or regional New South Wales, and Tulip does not think what is announced is enough.
  • He separates the planning code, which sets quantity, from the building code, which sets quality, and points at private certification rather than the code itself as the reason for defects.
  • Heritage covers about half the City of Sydney and 30 to 40 per cent of the inner west council area, which he argues is being used as a device to stop housing.
  • Research he cites puts negative gearing changes at 1 to 4 per cent off prices against 40 to 50 per cent for zoning reform, and immigration growth over the past decade or two at about 9 per cent on housing costs.

Can Australia Build 1.2 Million Homes?

Peter Tulip starts with the target National Cabinet agreed to: 1.2 million homes over five years. Everyone agrees it is very ambitious, because it means building at close to our peak level for five straight years. Updated: that pace implies roughly 240,000 completions a year. Australia completed 43,816 dwellings in the March 2026 quarter, seasonally adjusted, an annual rate near 175,000 (ABS Building Activity, Australia, March 2026, released 8 July 2026).

The New South Wales share, he says, is about 370,000 over five years, or roughly 75,000 dwellings a year, against output of around 40,000. He does not think the announcements close that gap, with nothing yet on greenfield western Sydney or regional towns. Updated: the state completed 10,227 dwellings in that same quarter, an annual rate near 41,000, so the shortfall has barely moved.

He calls the approach heavy handed and accepts you would ordinarily want it more consultative. His argument is that asking councils to set their own targets failed, and affordability kept getting worse. Councils remain free to write their own plans if the uplift is similar.

Feature Matrix: What The New South Wales Announcements Cover
ElementWhat It AllowsStatus
Transport oriented developmentUp to about six storeys within 400 metres of 39 named stationsAnnounced
Previously low density suburbsGreater access to granny flats, dual occupancy and townhousesAnnounced
Council alternativesCouncils may put up their own plans at a similar level of upliftAnnounced
Greenfield western SydneyNot addressed in what has been announced so farStill unknown
Regional New South WalesScope for a lot more housing in rural townsNo announcements yet

As described from 3:02 to 7:03. Figures as stated on air.

Do We Have Enough Builders?

Veronica Morgan puts the practical objection: rezoning is one thing, but you still need builders, and the ramp up loads the work onto the back end. Tulip agrees construction numbers are not turning up yet.

On workforce, his answer is that the only way we find out is by trying. The plumbers, carpenters and bricklayers have not gone away, and he says the workforce has grown since the last peak, with many now on renovations and fences because the high volume work is not there. More cranes would pull them onto higher value projects, though wages and immigration may have to shift.

Asked about the defects left by the last peak, he separates the two codes. The planning code sets quantity, the building code sets quality, and he does not think the code itself needs much change. The problem is enforcement, particularly private certification, where certifiers lacked the incentive to check work met code. Buyers now distrust new apartments.

You can change the planning code, which determines the quantity of housing, to allow for a greater quantity, while at the same time tightening up the building code to improve the quality.

Peter Tulip, 11:35

Why Does Heritage Listing Block Housing?

Tulip argues heritage has been greatly overused. Nobody disagrees with preserving buildings that are unusually old or attractive, but what has happened is blanket classification of almost entire suburbs: he puts it at about half the City of Sydney and 30 to 40 per cent of the inner west council area. Owners cannot renovate freely and sometimes cannot choose their paint colour.

His property dumbo sits in the same territory. At Haberfield, on former army land considered for new housing, a councillor asked for heritage protections on the new houses.

How Does Rezoning Affect Homeowners?

In Roseville, where Tulip lives about a kilometre from the station, residents inside the 400 metre circle have been inundated with lucrative offers. Owners are joining together to sell, because a big apartment building is most profitable on a consolidated site.

He expects the change to suit his own street, bringing the butcher, grocer and pub Roseville lacks. The other effect is downsizing: with a median age around 50, the suburb has empty nesters in five bedroom houses who no longer want the rooms, the garden or the stairs, and nowhere local to move to.

Does Cutting Immigration Lower House Prices?

On immigration, he says rents are rising quickly because vacancies are extremely low, and the immediate reason is that immigration numbers rocketed up, much of it making up the shortfall from the closed border years. Saul Eslake set out how an economist read the recovery while the border was shut, days after the November 2020 cash rate cut. His own paper put the effect of the past decade or two of higher immigration at about 9 per cent on housing costs, so his disagreement with cutting it is about desirability, not effectiveness. Updated: net overseas migration has since fallen to 306,000 in 2024-25 from 429,000 a year earlier (ABS Overseas Migration, released 19 December 2025).

If you're going to reduce the housing shortage, you are much better off doing it on the supply side than the demand side. They'll both work, but lower immigration tends to reduce living standards, whereas increased supply improves living standards.

Peter Tulip, 38:16

He is equally blunt on tax. Researchers looking at negative gearing and the capital gains discount have all estimated tiny price effects, while zoning reform is measured in tens of per cent. He still sees equity arguments for reforming the discount, but not affordability ones. On capturing the uplift from upzoning he points to infrastructure charges of about $12,000 an apartment and the ACT betterment tax, and calls himself sympathetic but not committed.

Scenario Matrix: Estimated Effects Of Each Lever, As Stated On Air
LeverEffect On Housing CostsWhere The Estimate Came From
Zoning reform allowing more building40% to 50%Tulip's comparison at 45:49
Negative gearing and capital gains changes on the 2019 model1%, 2% or 4% off house pricesRange of research estimates cited at 45:29
Immigration growth over the past decade or twoAbout 9% higherHis own paper, described at 37:18
Auckland upzoning from 2016About 20% lower than the counterfactualResearch on the Auckland plan at 48:26

As described from 37:18 to 48:45. Figures as stated on air and not re-checked.

Auckland is his worked example. A 2016 plan allowed medium density across about three quarters of the city, construction doubled and the housing stock rose about 4 per cent. Rents fell relative to inflation while other New Zealand cities rose, and the cost of floor space fell substantially.

Housing is a big exception, where a libertarian policy in housing benefits renters, benefits young homebuyers, and the people it hurts are the wealthy property owners.

Peter Tulip, 59:44

Working Out Your Next Move?

The rezoning and downsizing shifts Tulip describes change what your street may look like and what your next home costs. If the timing means buying before you sell, a bridging loan is one of the structures worth understanding early.

Mortgage Broker for Upgraders

Sources referenced: The Elephant in the Room, episode 331, "Is Australia's 1.2M Housing Target Attainable in the Next 5 Years?", released 5 May 2024. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Co-host: Veronica Morgan. Guest: Peter Tulip, Chief Economist, Centre for Independent Studies. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 10 September 2026.