Curious about upgrading?
Wondering where to start?
Complex questions that need answers?
Is there a better structure for you?
"They managed to navigate my complex expat income and even got my Google RSU income approved as well."
"I highly recommend Alcove to anyone looking for a mortgage broker who is responsive, trustworthy, and truly cares about their clients. Thanks again to the whole team for making the process such a positive experience!"
"As founders, we're constantly jumping between things so having a partner that handled the details & made the process super clear made the buying process breezy for us. Very happy with the experience!"
“It almost felt like it was his responsibility to make it clear to me, not my responsibility to understand it.”
“I've been pretty much fully leveraged the whole time. So the sounding board on that, in terms of what was achievable, what wasn't — I think trust is just built along that.”
"Alcove has been a great partner. They look after my audience properly, keep things simple, and deliver real value. I’ve got full confidence referring clients knowing they’ll get honest, straightforward advice."
"Property is one of the biggest financial decisions people make. Alcove stood out because they take a strategic approach to lending - helping clients structure property and debt decisions in a way that genuinely supports their broader financial plans."
Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.


Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
Domain Group's chief revenue officer John Fong joins Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates to explain why property portals are moving from search to suggestion. The conversation runs through ranking points as a disclosure lever, his pessimism on supply, and the terms buyers actually type in.
The way we search for a property and gather information before making purchasing and selling decisions has changed profoundly over the past couple of decades.
But the way in which we buy property hasn't really changed that much at all.
I mean, we might be able to finally ditch the checkbook, transfer large sums of money electronically, sign a contract digitally, and then proceed to settlement entirely online, but real estate agents remain the gatekeepers to our property dreams.
And yet, as real estate portals and digital platforms become more sophisticated, as we trade more and more information online, the relationship between the seller, the agent and the buyer has been changing, even if we haven't really noticed it. So what is happening in this space? What does the future look like?
Is the real estate industry ripe for disruption?
Welcome to the elephant in the room. This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about.
I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location Location Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, recently ranked number five in Australia out of over 18,000 brokers in the annual MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Awards. Before we get started, I need to let you know that nothing we say here can be taken as personal advice.
we always recommend you engage the services of an appropriate and experienced professional.
We have a bit of a double-pronged episode for you today. We want to learn about what property data reveals about buyer preferences and whether or not they've been changing over the past few years.
But we also want to find out whether AI and other new technologies could create an upset in the real estate space. And today we're joined by John Fung, who is the Chief Revenue Officer, very important title there, of Domain Group.
John has access to a huge amount of property search data, as well as a background working in the US, Europe, Australia, and Africa for the likes of Google and Uber.
And so we are excited to hear John's unique insights about changing buyer search behavior and how he sees the future for the industry as a whole. Nothing like a big, chunky topic to discuss. Thank you so much for joining us today, John.
Thank you, Veronica.
Thank you, Chris. It's a pleasure to be on.
John, thanks for coming on, mate. I guess you've come from the Silicon Valley world into residential real estate. What made you sort of make that shift? I mean, I guess it domains a real technology play, I guess, but where does the line between residential property and technology really sort of interlink?
You know, the cool thing about Silicon Valley is I think that the fundamental belief is that anything can be technologied. I'm not quite sure what the right verb is. You know, who would have thought taxis, huh? And now we have Uber. Who would have thought go to the library?
And that's a bit what Google is. So for me, real estate, I mean, both in America, particularly Australia, it's a place where everyone's trying to use technology to make it faster and simpler. So for me, it was a very, very natural fit.
And I guess going into sort of domain, what made you sort of, out of all the companies you could have gone and worked for, right, in Australia, what sort of, what excites you about the real estate industry and digitalizing it, I guess?
Yeah. I mean, I love real estate, even though I've never formally worked in real estate except for the last two years. I've bought and sold out 20 or 30 properties in most of the states and territories of Australia. Do a lot of investing in the States now.
My dad was a real estate agent. Ever since my first paycheck was like, we're going to buy an investment property. That's what we do. We're in the market. We stay in the market. And so it's really been my, I guess, my family's business to say with my wife.
And so even though I never thought I'd actually work in the industry, when this came up, it was like, oh my goodness, this is the dream job for me.
It's funny, though, because the real estate industry in Australia, it's so dominant. I mean, in terms of the asset value, it eclipses everything else. And obviously, our big four banks dominate the share market and their big business is the mortgage. It's just everywhere, right?
But fundamentally, real estate agencies is really a cottage industry. And, you know, in many ways. And so I wonder if that has been frustrating for you or do you see it as just pure greenfields opportunity?
You know, I'll make a generalization about Australia versus America. In America, particularly in Silicon Valley, as you'll hear the intro, I spent 15 years working for Google and Uber, most of that time in Silicon Valley. Paranoia runs deep.
Everybody is trying to one-up themselves before they get one-upped by some guy or girl in the garage doing it better, right? That's how Google and Facebook started, things like that. And I think there's something very exciting about that.
A lot of innovation comes from there, but there's something that's a bit exhausting about that. I think one of the whole things about Australia is there's a lot of, I guess, time for the American way about trying to do things better, but it's a little more balanced, a little more sustainable.
I think it's probably the right mix for me.
That's an interesting insight, that one in itself. All right. So you come from outside the industry, technically. I mean, technically, you're not outside a technical industry, but you've come outside the real estate industry. But I guess you've got sort of familiarity with it because you've grown up with it.
Can you give us an idea of how the user experience, as you see, is evolving for property buyers on platforms like Domain?
You know, domain and its competitors, the big shift about 20 years ago went from a fundamentally a newspaper classified-esque environment, you know, to an online. And then I guess over the last 10 years, particularly as apps have become more intelligent, they've gone from, you know, static online.
It was a print listing and now it's online to something that's more app-like experience with search parameters, with movable maps and things like that. I think you're going to see two shifts, and this is certainly true of domain.
It will be true of many of our other, not even competitors, but other technologies, other apps in the space. You will see a lot more from the reactive to the proactive. So what the app will try and do is instead of saying, okay, tell me what you want. Okay, here's some results.
We'll go from based on your search history and what we know about you, here's what we think will be a good fit. Is that good or bad? And then based on your actions to that, that may change how it suggests. So I think that's one shift you'll see.
The other thing is obviously around AI and machine learning. Some of that will be in the suggestion, but some of the experience altogether. What can we do to create content, maybe not even by a human, that would help make your experience quicker? Can videos be quickly automated?
Can certain kind of maps which bring out statistics that you like specifically be made, which would make sense if a human had to do it and make it just for you, but with AI, those things can be done. So
I think we're meeting a pretty exciting new world for not just businesses like real estate that's part of jobs and car sales and things like that, but there's some of the trends that you should expect to see.
When you say that, John, do you mean that, I mean, I guess the, looking at people's search data, you can see they're all, they're very keen on houses in Newtown and they want, they just, they spend lots of times on those listings and whenever someone comes up, they always go on it.
So you can say that someone's an active buyer, et cetera. And then you could say, look, we've got a new listing in Newtown. It's very similar to what you've been looking at. And maybe there's some type of push notification, et cetera.
Almost like what, I guess the notifications you can get now, but much more targeted to them. But the search sort of,
you know, the buyer sort of who's in the market looking about what to buy, do you see yourself becoming a little bit more like a core logic or, you know, a land checker or, you know, overlaying things like flood maps or getting the data from the state revenue, the, you know, land registry of all past sales, not just ones on the platform and getting all their numbers on it.
Do you see yourself almost becoming the tool that people use to help them buy rather than just a, I guess, a platform that shows what's on the market?
That's exactly right, Chris. We have a new chief product officer, a guy called Nathan Brumby, similar to myself, an Aussie who spent the last 20 years at the States. That's exactly his vision. You know, if you imagine what Google Maps has done, it went from being like, it's a map.
It tells you where to go. That's cool. To now, it is suggesting layers and advertising to anticipate what you might be, what is your intent in coming to this map? That's exactly what we aspire to do.
So that layers, whether it's stuff that we know, we own a company, we own a product called Price Finder, which has data on 90% of Australian properties.
We want to overlay that data and then we will try to make it in ways, and I referred to graphs earlier, where I think if we do it well, everyone who's using the app becomes a local market expert.
You know, they're going in and you're giving them the right insights at the right time, maybe even snippets from podcasts or press or things like that that's going to be interesting to them. How do you compress that in like experience they can have while waiting at the bus stop? That's our challenge.
Yeah, it's huge. And so effectively, you know, like it's like if, you know, you're on Facebook and you get your feed. So basically, you know, we don't need to then be asking for or trying to dive in and looking for particular things.
You're suggesting that it should all just get pushed to us based on what we've responded to in a way. So that's a total turnaround from search because that's going to be receive rather than search, isn't it? So how then does that change the measurement of what people are doing?
Because then in an echo chamber, you're only going to be responding to what sort of comes under your nose as opposed to you actively going at it. I mean, I just look at this because I think about back in the olden days where we used to look through a newspaper at listings.
And you knew you'd seen everything because literally you could just run your finger down the columns and you've seen every single property that's on the market there. And we've all got used to the idea of not necessarily seeing everything.
We're seeing a filter of it and based on whatever parameters we put in, but also at the back end what the agents put in. And now we're actually moving to the next phase, which is like we're not worried about seeing everything anymore. We're literally just wanting our curated space.
version of events, which is sort of interesting because I think to myself, I know when there's not much stock on the market, I would go back and look again and again and again to think, did I miss something? Did I miss something? So, yeah.
Oh, man, I've got so many comments. There's like so many jaws in there. The first comment I'd make is actually a question. How do you think TikTok measures success? Engagement? Exactly, right? And how do you search on TikTok? We don't. We don't, right?
But it's an annoying platform. I mean, for someone like me who actually wants to have a bit more discernment over what I see, it's not the platform for me.
So, you know, are you suggesting that everybody's going to end up being the TikTok generation and we're going to buy a property like that or we're all going to be converted?
I hope not because I think there is a world. I'm like you, right? If I'm looking at the area, once I'm at parameters, I just want to know everything. I want to know every single one of that population.
In fact, I want to know the things that aren't popular because I might have a better deal there as an investor. So I'm with you, Veronica. I don't think that's going to go away.
And I actually think from an architectural engineering point of view, that's actually a bit easier because that's just the database. It's just the phone book of everything there.
I think what TikTok has done, obviously a different analogy, is by using behaviors and what you've engaged with, to use Chris's term, like what you spend more on, what you flicked over, it actually has allowed two things. It's maybe increased the overall experience of video watching.
People spend much longer on video than they did before. But secondly, just to challenge your notion, and people like myself, we have our search parameters, but actually our search parameters are the mechanical interpretation of what is our desire.
But what if there are other things outside of those parameters that we haven't thought of that actually better that needs? And that's the genius of TikTok, you know, things like that. And I think a great app could possibly do that. Hey, you weren't looking here, but maybe you should.
I wasn't looking for cat videos, but now I am. I'm an avid fan. It is interesting, though, but the thing is, and that's something that we like to do in our business, you know, on a very, very manual, granular, analogue sense, you know, with literally consulting with people.
And so, obviously, but also the very nature of our business as a buyer's agency is that you can only deal with a handful of people at any one time. We've got a capacity constraint. So you're suggesting that, obviously, technology is
can expand that and the ability for people to have exposure to other options that they may not have otherwise looked at. The thing is, I also know human behaviour and I know human behaviour in Sydney, right, in terms of buyer behaviour.
And we're so parochial, you know, we are bordered by bridges and then within those bridges, we're bordered by main roads. We will not buy on the other side of that road. We will not buy on the other side of that bridge, right?
So it's sort of interesting because, and I have no doubts that AI can deal with all this stuff, right? But it's like people aren't that open to other suggestions when it comes to property location. I can tell you that.
You know, and I think that's the genius of technology is not what it can do. It's discerning what should be sold by technology and what shouldn't. And for me, I mean, I love buyer's agents. I wish that there were more buyer's agencies here. We used one to purchase the home we purchased recently.
And in America, it's a standard. You know, there's always a seller's agent and a buyer's agent. And it's interesting when I look at some of the data from America, because you might expect America to digitize agents, right? That agents actually go away. Like travel agents, you know, have gone down over time.
But actually, use of agents in America is at an all-time high. Like it's over 90%. It was always in the 80s and now it's up to 90%. And that's on both the selling and the buyer side. Like it's crazy. People don't have to use it.
Well, hang on, but there is a key difference over there. And in terms of the buyer would use an agent over there because they're not paying for the agent. And so the vendor pays a higher amount of commission and that is split between the vendor's agent and the buyer's agent.
Whereas over here, buyer's agency is very much user pays and so therefore there's only a small proportion of people that are going to engage one. But when you say 80 or 90% of people use an agent in the US, are you saying as an alternative to selling their own property?
Exactly. That's right. Or private, yeah, private treaty, effectively.
That's so much higher than I would have expected. I would have expected the percentage of people trying to sell their own property being less than 10% or less than 5% even.
I would have thought that were tiny. That's the crazy thing. You'd expect it to look like travel agents over time.
But the point I was trying to make is very much that there is a human element to buying or selling one of the most important purchases of your whole life that I don't think will ever go away. You can't automate that. You can't TikTok that.
Now, you can automate the stuff that maybe leads up to it, how people get educated and excited, discovery. And that's why I think agents will always be here and I think will only grow in value. But the way they add value will change as things such as discovery get commoditized. Absolutely.
John, I think there's a lot of plays in the PropTech space that help agents better communicate with their customers, right? Do you see yourself as a domain playing that role where they're almost the tool that agents are negotiating on? The bids, you know, people are making offers on like a domain.
real estate portal i guess that you get access to once you've got your contract check do you see yourself becoming part of it the overall transaction from you know once they display some interest in the property to actually almost being the platform that they use to or do you want to leave that to other tools and you really focus on that the sort of the the search and the listing part of the the portal
So we actually have some technology that does that. So domains, I guess where domain is at is we started off as a newspaper and now we're a portal. That is the majority of our business. And we have a bunch of products that help properties get discovered.
So, you know, you might advertise a domain and then buy like a social boost package, you know, which then it's your ads in one more place. Those marketing talks, that's the mainstay of domain. But we've got a lot of other, I guess, software as a service.
So I referred to Price Finder before, which is all that agents use to do research, similar to CoreLogic RP data. But we have something called, for example, Real-Time Agent, which is like a DocuSign. That's the process and digitize it. And we have something called Bid Tracker, which is similar to what you're discussing.
It allows us to capture auction bids live and report instantly if people want to do particular remote auctions that are live. And so where we see ourselves adding value is we want to be a great portal. We want to be a great website where people come to.
But for the agents, we want to offer them tools that make their life easier and give them more time to do stuff. So I think we are in a lot of those markets and we'll probably try and add more over time.
So John, I guess it's this information that agents may not want to put on there, but is domain's attitude though, is that if we make it an amazing consumer experience, then that'll get more engagement. So ultimately the agents win anyway, because we get more people on the platform, more people using it.
But yeah, some agents might not be happy. Some listings might be showing data that's not positive, but if we don't do it, maybe REA will do it or maybe some other platform. And then all the buyers would go there, which is ultimately the key thing that you need is buyers, right?
Yeah, exactly. I think your phrase is very well, Chris, that trade-off. I don't know if many of you have read the Amazon story, but we all use Amazon. There's a very famous episode where Jeff Bezos says, we want there to be ratings for every product.
And one of the board members says, hey, Jeff, you know we only make money when people buy the product. So if you have a bad rated product, people aren't going to buy it. It just says, no, you're thinking about it all wrong. Transparency builds trust and transparency builds speed.
And in the end, I think that's our core belief is ultimately a best customer engagement is to give them as much relevant information as possible to make good decision. And in the end, that is the best thing for every ecosystem, including the agents. However, it doesn't mean in the short term there's friction.
There may be friction from that. And so what we believe is that agents are central to the transaction. We need to consult them as we start to deal with some of these changes and manage in a way that protects their business, but it's the right thing for the consumer.
So it's getting that trade-off right, and that's a lot of my job.
This is actually really interesting because if this conversation progresses in the way that I would love it to progress, i.e. that you guys are doing what I think will be amazing, providing information that is over and above what is legislated, right?
So this is something that I talk about in my business all the time and also with the Buyer's Agent Mentoring Program that I've created. is that in every state and territory in this country, there's a different type of vendor disclosure that's been legislated.
So some areas such as New South Wales and Victoria, it's relatively high. When I say relatively high, it is by no means exhaustive. The vendor does not have to disclose enough for you to make decisions on, but most people don't realise that. In Queensland, it's the worst.
The vendor discloses the least amount of information, and ergo the agent.
If Domain as a national platform started providing this sort of information for argument's sake that I believe is realistically or reasonably, the buyers really need, I guess, to make good decisions, and then who determines that?
In an ideal world, you go over and above legislated. You get over and above and you actually provide information that really does help people make good decisions.
You do a lot of shit buyers agents out of a job, which would be great because there's people out there buying property for clients, charging them and not even knowing what they don't know.
So it would be amazing to have one source of truth or two or a number of them, depending on how many portals decide to do this.
Is that what you're talking about? Is that you're sort of talking about potentially providing more than is even legislated, more than is the bare minimum?
Because then I can understand why agents are digging their heels in, or might dig their heels in, I don't know if they are, because they're not used to having to provide more than is absolutely necessary.
I've been present when I've heard debates over what constitutes material fact, for example, you know, that they're scared in many cases, but
Having said that, though, I've seen situations where people have sold a house that has had triple murder in it or double murder in it, and they've had to disclose that in New South Wales anyway because of material fact legislation, and it's actually buyers didn't give a shit.
So it's like the agents were always fearful of transparency, but transparency actually helped, right? People do respond to, as you say, it does build trust. So anyway, long-winded sort of diatribe on my end, but is that potentially what you're talking about here?
Yeah, let me talk about what we're actually doing and let me talk about the realm of uncommitted possibility, but I'll point you to that. You know, so I think we generally, that more better data and more transparency is a good thing.
So recently, you know, now it's a bit of a trivial example, but it makes a lot of difference to people. We now report on in the end availability, right? Which actually makes, it's meaningful.
And we're trying to now like sustainability scores and things like that, which again, like the absence or the presence of that might be a factor for people. So we would love to bring more information there.
We see that as something that's a differentiator for us, you know, where we're really going to educate folks. I think portals have a big responsibility in terms of what they can do above and beyond legislation. I'll give you a comparison. I spent about 13 years at Google beforehand.
I worked on the search engine and in Google Cloud. And there came a point in time in the early-ish, you know, 2000, 2010, when mobile was happening. And we came to a conclusion that actually... In the future, more people will be searching on mobile rather than web pages, than on a laptop.
But the problem is the way you architect a page for mobile, it doesn't have my default. It does now, but it didn't then. You had to make it smart, mobile, bigger text, icons, all that kind of stuff. And what Google is asking itself is, okay, what can we do to encourage this?
There's no legislation for this, right? But what can we do? Because fundamentally, it's a catch-22. If we keep making the best websites only really just work on the laptop, then you're not going to get people investing in mobile. But if you encourage people to work for mobile, then you'll get that market going.
And in the future, we'll have mobile apps that move much faster. And what we basically decided and disclosed to the webmaster community is, we are going to penalize your webpage if it's not mobile-friendly. And we're also going to penalize your webpage if it's got too much data and takes too long to load.
That'll actually cost you making quite transparent about that stuff. And so we saw it as our way to kind of shape the market, right, in terms of that. And again, it's not just Google who made the difference there. It may have happened eventually, but we saw ourselves pretty crucial as hasting that.
But Google is a dominant marketer. player. You know what I mean? If you own that degree of market share, you can do that stuff, right?
You can. Now, Domain and its other large, very, very impressive competitor, Marine One, again, amazing company. They're doing great things. There's a lot of value that those two companies create. If either one of us were to say, hey, here are things that we care about. We want this to be disclosed.
We want there to be an inspector report that's downloadable. We want them to be a video. If you do that, we're going to give you ranking points. I mean, that ranking, particularly if we move to a more suggestion or active versus a pure classified to reactive, that's very powerful.
They might just look at the first three results. Once people know that, then you've got agents who are then going, well, if you want to be at the top of the rankings, you need to have this.
And then it's going to force sellers to get their act together like, oh, I better make sure this house is in good condition. Because if I can't get it to rank, I can't get it to sell. So that's how you create the market over time.
Can I come on as a consultant? Because I think you need access to what we need.
I'll walk you in time as a consultant, Veronica. I'd love to say more about you. Of all people, know what buys what. And need.
And need.
It's a big topic within us. I'd love to make that happen.
Yeah, because there's so many other things, right? It could be the DAs in the area, all the sales from the land registry that haven't been sold on Domain. Domain should really just be reporting on that. That didn't sell on our platform. Why isn't that listing just showing?
I think there's so many things, even just checking the strata report or checking the building report. I guess is there plans to almost becoming like, You know, AI could be checking those to a certain extent and saying, actually, it's a really good strata report, you know, or this one's issues.
Like, are you going to step into the legal space at all? Or is it really just going to be search overlays on, you know, things that are easy to get access to?
I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions. And you can find out all about what I'm working on at veronicamorgan.com.au.
And there you'll find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program, access to suburb help for investors, or if you're looking to buy your dream home or an investment property in Sydney's inner west, eastern suburbs, or lower North Shore, you can connect with my team at Good Deeds Property Buyers.
If you're thinking about buying your first home, upgrading to a new one or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Please reach out via our website, wealthful.com.au.
Don't forget that you can download our free full or forecaster report. Which experts can you trust to get it right? Theelephantintheroom.com.au I can't comment specifically on the legal thing.
I don't think we haven't got up to that part of the conversation yet. I think the way you've talked about it is, yeah, I guess overlays might be the right way to think about it.
Probably what I see the teams try to do is, how do we create an app where it's possible to map any kind of geospecific information into that app? Just like what Google Maps has done.
How do you do it so that we can both have our own feeds from things such as Price Finder, from government feeds, just the value in general, and from third-party feeds like Google Maps, like whoever? How do we get that fit in?
And then how do you create a system where, over time, we can experiment with the right level of exposure and correlate what are the factors that most heavily correlate with engagement? You know, hey, when a customer saw that, they spent more time on the page. Or actually, it got confusing.
They just kind of bounced. You know, what will that system over time? And that's what the team, uh, we were very talented, uh, product leader called Thomas, uh, Thomas, he's the guy who's basically basically building this next generation of the app to do the kind of things you're talking about.
I mean, Google maps is a prime one, right? Because you could be putting on this road is, you know, running this many cars per hour, um, in this section. And it's really busy between these hours.
Um, this road's actually like a rat run when, you know, when this road's busy, this road gets busy. Um,
you know, that type of Google map data is like really interesting for people because it's really hard to know, especially if you're searching out an area, you know, yes, you can read a map and that's the main road, but you don't know about that rat run.
You actually don't even know how busy it is, you know, and you know, going on street view doesn't show you traffic, right? So, um, Yeah, I mean, that would be a really interesting overlay. Together with like the turnover rate, how many times do people sell in certain streets, right?
Like you could be, and you'll see alignment. It's good for buyers to say, well, actually only 1% of these properties turn over per year. This is a very scarce property, right?
And, you know, that sort of information could, you know, really help buyers really understand, you know, the complexity of the market's much faster, right? Whereas this street turns over at 7%, you know, a year, whatever it is. So, yeah.
The tightly held index.
No, I think I would love to be transparent. You know, we talk about walkability scores and things like that, or safety and things.
I think the challenge that, again, generalized beyond real estate, the challenge that you have in a API environment like ours, where in theory, if you build the app the right way, you can plug anything in, is that you have like a thousand data points you could use, and the customer probably only absorbed three or four.
How do you prioritize that so it doesn't overwhelm, but it creates speed? And so that's why you have things such as heat maps or things like that. I think that will be our challenge. First, can we architecture and bring in the right feeds?
Now that we have them, how do we create it so it's easy for the customer and not overwhelming? I think that's the challenge.
Because you've got sort of two aspects here. You've got what the customer wants and then what they need. And often what they need is very unsexy. That's the boring stuff that's likely going to overwhelm them. What they want is stuff like, oh, I want their off-market.
I actually had a bit of a giggle when I saw the ads for Domain's off-market portal because I'm like, if it's on Domain, it's not off-market. Like, what the hell is that? And what are you – How's that going? I mean, and what is it meant to be?
So you're talking about a product we have called Early Access, right? And what it effectively does is depending on, you know, what the vendor's relationship with the agent is, they can effectively get their house notified to buyers who have been looking at that area before it actually comes on domain.
In some cases, it can actually sell without even coming onto domain. So they don't even take the transaction, right? People sell it. I think what we're trying to do with that product is, to your point, give buyers as much information as possible, as early as possible. That's what we're trying to do.
In some cases, it will actually cost domain money because domain won't get the listing. But we want to create an attitude of like, hey, if you're using domain, you're going to get as much as possible, as fast as possible delivered to you. So that's our intent behind it.
But just to your point, Christopher, I think this relates to your point, Veronica, as well. I don't think domain is the be-all and end-all.
So in the sense that you talk about what people want and what people need, in some ways, the way I see domain is I do want to give them what people need. But actually, if we're getting engagement because of what they want, they're not going to get all the information from us.
Hopefully what we do is we link them to the right buyer's agent, you know, and we create that curiosity. We get them, you know, we're not the end-to-end journey, right, in terms of that.
And so I think what people want and what they engage with is quite a useful metric, even if it's incomplete, because we can point them to where they get the right information.
So, John, in a different sort of change of direction for the conversation, I know you're working in Ireland. What was sort of, and all through the GFC, I think you were working there, it's a huge property crash.
Sort of, what was your experience sort of watching that over there and what sort of your learnings?
Thanks, Chris. It was an amazing time. I moved to Ireland in 2007. I just finished my MBA degree, and I ended up staying there until 2013. I loved Ireland. I'm actually an Irish citizen. I have a lot of friends there, a godson there.
I came right when it was the end of the Celtic Tiger, it's called, 15 years of straight growth, some of the most apartments built in the whole world. In 2008, it all came out. It was crazy. It was a crazy experience for a few reasons. There was so much excess property.
You actually had this because you were squatting. And what people are doing is renting out these giant houses just to anyone who would pay anything for them. And so I was in my 20s at the time. You know, I had some of my good friends.
I remember there were six of them living in this giant mansion, paying about $50 a month, right? And we would have the most epic dinner parties, hang out there. Like, it's just one of those strange relics of time.
It's like, oh my goodness, like, this is not going to happen in a normal environment. It only happens when there's real supply-demand mismatch. I think the other thing was it was a really difficult time of poverty. I mean, my housemate was a South African. He was an architect, a great guy.
He'd come to Ireland like so many foreigners because it was such a big building boom. And then it all fell out. He ended up working in Saudi Arabia and things like that. And it was a very, very rough time, particularly people in the building industry.
But even in technology, that was the first time Google had done any cost cutting at scale. So with technology companies, it really gave people a wake up call. And I think it was very tough on the Irish psyche. So yeah. Yeah, it was the best of the worst of times, I feel.
And how did that sort of... I was in London at the same time. I was there in 2007 to 11. And, you know, I think I got there. I started working as a financial advisor just as the peak of the markets, right?
It was like the first week on the job was when Northern Rock went under. So, you know, but what was interesting is the years after it, right? So... How do you think that, I guess, the Irish market evolved?
Because there was this massive oversupply, this massive fall in prices, this massive collapse of the banks. Certain parts of the market probably still haven't recovered, right? Dublin, for example, maybe have. But how did it shift over the years? How people's mentality changed towards property?
I think it was both positive and negative. The great thing, there was this phrase at Google we used to have that was, scarcity brings clarity, which is only when things are tough and you don't have much you want that you really are forced to prioritize. And the reality is we always need clarity.
It just seems to be harder to get clarity when times are good, and we're forced to have it when times are bad. And I think in some ways that was very positive for the Irish property market because there was just any development was happening everywhere all the time, all the place.
And that was not healthy. That was a waste of resources. It would result in a lot of this effectively pyramid schemes and people investigating things. You know, people weren't asking the right questions. And obviously that led us to question those things. And now people are making better decisions.
I think on a negative, you know, The Irish culture is an amazing one. It's welcoming. It's friendly. There is a deep, I guess, cynicism, a deep distrust. I think it's been cause of a thousand years of hardship with the English, frankly.
But there is that paranoia of the good times will always run out. And I think the difficult thing was this validated everyone's worst fears. Actually, no, no, no. It wasn't good. It was actually just a time, and now it's back to being like it always was.
And so I hope there's a balance there. We should not be over-optimistic, but there's a lot of reasons for optimism, particularly in property. Property, particularly as it's so hard to go to great places like Australia. Property prices are always going to increase faster than wages. It's just how it's going to be.
So if you're in the market, a lot of great things are going to happen. And I think whether it's in property or with life, there's a lot to be optimistic about. And it was sad to see some of that optimism come away.
And I mean, I guess then you went to the US, right? That was, was it before and after that as well? I think just had a quick squeeze on your LinkedIn. Out of the US and then came back afterwards. And sort of what is your experience of the market over there?
Because, you know, I think what happens is people do try to relate the markets to Australia, right? Well, if it's happened in Ireland or it's happened in the US, it can happen to Australia. A lot of, we've got a lot of Irish clients. I love working with Irish clients. And it's amazing people.
And I think you're right. A lot of them is coaching them on the experience that they've gone through and, you know, and how to protect themselves. Because there is that, you know, that paranoia that that could happen here. And how do I protect myself?
Well, maybe I don't want to enter the market because, you know, I don't want to happen what happened to me when it happened when I was in Ireland. So what's your sort of experiences in the US related to the property market?
Yeah, just so my history, I lived in the US 2005, 2007. There was an island for six years and London, and then came back in 2013 and was there until about two years ago.
I had the chance to, we purchased quite a number of properties and some commercial in the US, so quite familiar with that market. And we had our first homes there after me and my wife got married. So the US is kind of an interesting market because it's very twofold.
The top cities are very similar to Australia's top cities. So you think a place like San Francisco, where I live, the city itself is in some disarray now, but certainly the suburbs. Very similar dynamics. Very, very hard to build, not in my backyard.
A lot of migration, both within America, overseas, like a lot of the Asian capitals and things like that. People come from all over the world to study and they stay. And you have very, very similar dynamics there, which is the demand for particularly single family residents, actually house and land,
always outstripped supply and even apartments are quite hard to build. At least they had built to rent there, which I think has allowed for a bit more elasticity of supply. And so particularly the higher end actually available is pretty good.
But at the lower end, particularly things such as rent controls, that's really kind of screwed everything up there. So you have these, you know, a real lack of supply and people don't come in the market. So I think very similar dynamics, and they've seen very similar price movements.
The rest of America is very similar. It's very different, sorry. The average Silicon Valley house might be $3 or $4 million. Average house in America is like $300,000. It's that kind of disparity there. And in America, mostly, apart particularly away from the cities, you have huge expanse of land.
giant, giant lots, these giant shopping centers. I remember going into Texas and feeling like, well, it's some kind of theme park where everything is twice the size. It really is huge.
And there you have a different kind of proposition where housing prices tend to match cost more than demand, where it's quite easy to afford more. And that follows similar to, I would say, some of our regions. So our regions have been undersupplied up until late as well.
So similar, but a bit different and a lot more supply outside of the big cities.
Yeah, I think it's going to be interesting to see what happens here. I mean, obviously, we have this chronic shortage of housing. I think I was listening to, actually, it was the Guardian podcast. It was our housing minister whose name has cased me right this minute.
But she was saying that Australia per capita has the lowest number of housing in the developed world. which I was unaware of. And, of course, with COVID increasing the demand for space, so each household has gone up a bed, requires an extra bedroom or something, we're now a million properties undersupplied.
And to gear up to build and develop enough properties to provide plug that gap. Well, it's like turning the Queen Mary, isn't it? It takes a long time to turn this thing around. And we're in a state of declining approvals at the moment as well.
So despite the fact that the federal government is...
you know, coming out with these initiatives to try to sort of get this thing happening, it's going to take a long time before we're anywhere near the point of, I guess, solving the problem. But also, we could overshoot the mark, couldn't we?
We could be in a situation where suddenly, you know, we're ramped up and all of a sudden we're in oversupply. Certainly in the unit space, we've seen situations in recent, in the last decade at least, where we've had units oversupply in Brisbane and Melbourne. So,
And it's sort of weird to think we've got this shortage of dwellings in this country, and yet within recent history, we've had oversupply and the inherent problems that that brings for those individual owners as well.
So I'm not sure you can, I don't know if you can add to this conversation, but I'm watching with interest just to see how this will unfold. We're not going to really know for a decade or so, I would think.
I mean, I think, honestly, Veronica, I'm a little more sure than you are. I'm actually a bit pessimistic about where this goes. If you go back a generation, you could buy a property with like four times your yearly wages. Everyone was doing it.
And then half a generation ago, you need a double income. And now you need double income and a house of mom and dad. And where this goes, if you look at a place like San Francisco, New York, Singapore, a place like that is, you just get more and more people locked out, right?
The home ownership percentages will go down. Rentals will go up. People will be new in interesting ways. And that is because we are not unlocking properties fast enough either through build or expansion or other things such as stamp duty reform, which will increase supply.
We're not doing that at the rate that people want to come into this country and live.
Well, I think that's really because we want to protect our existing markets and then create new markets which are not protected, right? So it's, you know, you're talking about the difference between Texas and San Francisco, for instance.
You know, if there's lots of land, lots of supply and the price of properties around the cost, tied to the cost rather than, you know, demand and supply inequality, right? then that's going to have two-speed markets.
And we've had two-speed markets in this country before, as I mentioned with the Melbourne unit market as a classic example. During a boom, some people were losing money in their properties because there was an oversupply of stock. So I guess...
what you're suggesting there is that the lockout of certain markets like a key Sydney and Melbourne for argument's sake will continue but there'll be new markets opened up where not necessarily they're not going to owners of properties in those areas are not necessarily going to benefit in the same way the owners of properties in Sydney and Melbourne have been able to benefit over the last few years I think what I'm saying is if I just take the capitals particularly the eastern seaboard capitals right like
I think over time, the oversupply, the undersupply will only grow. I think you will have some of these micro situations where a particular segment like two bedroom, you know, premium apartments is temporarily oversupplied. I think over time, market will correct.
If I fast forward a generation, I think the supply problem, unless we do something very differently, will be a lot worse. We're a lot worse. We're very hard to get in the market.
It'll be like more like a New York where like very few people own, you know, and then people are, if they really want the land, we'll have to go to Texas or have to go to really outer suburbs. So I think that is my prediction.
I'm quite negative, I guess, about it, unless we can make significant reform and make it where it's easier for developers to overcome problems like inflation and DA approvals, whether it's stamp duty reform that encourages people to not hang on to their property, even though it's too big for them right now.
There's a lot of things that we can do in the market to increase supply, but if we don't, it's just getting harder and harder to get it, and the price will be more and more expensive, particularly the big capital cities.
In that vein, John, is there sort of a domain play into working with, you know, people like Archie Star, right, who sort of do feasibility for developments? You know, you could also work with the councils and say, look, we've got the search data. We know what buyers want, right?
Ultimately, they want more properties in these suburbs, not just because of the lifestyle benefits, but maybe because of the which is part of life because of the commutes it might be, they really love more properties in these areas and we need to change zoning.
So you almost work as a market maker, you almost start to help create more supply by saying this is what people want, this is what we're undersupplied. Is domain sort of playing at that level or do governments come to you at all?
The data you guys have got access to is probably the best search. Obviously, what buyers, the public, Australian public want from property, right? But you can see where the gaps are.
Yeah, we have a really great relationship with governments. They use a lot of our data. We have a company under us called IDS, for example, that helps make land valuation and house valuation more accurate. And that's very, very important to governments. It helps to make decisions about zoning and things of that nature.
So that is something that we have invested a lot in. And so we have a relationship with the government in that sense. I do think the answers to these questions apply are fundamentally political.
If you think about why haven't some of these, let's say, common sense solutions about making it easier to get approvals, make it easier to build, make it less costly to have a transaction, why does it happen? It all comes down to political wealth. A few things.
Are we willing to give up the revenue, the stamp duty hit, and change it for something that's more annual? Number two, are we willing to have people develop in our backyard?
Number three, do we have the right infrastructure solutions so that if we build on the outskirts, those aren't like commuter towns, but they're actually part of the city itself? It all comes down to the politics of it in my mind, which is I think ultimately these are political solutions.
And domain has some political advocacy. We have government communications. We have a PR group. We see it as our role of one of the leaders of the industry to influence things this way.
But I think that's also going to be the answer when there's enough political world saying, we're going to make these changes that's going to dramatically make it easier to build and have more supply. Just like if you think of migration, migration is ultimately a reflection of political wealth.
In the beginning, there was real-world migration with the white Australian policy, but then that shifted. And now we actually have a good amount of migration post-COVID, but not too much because people are afraid of big Australia.
It will track how big the sentiment is, and I think it's all similar on the supply side. And that's why I think if as leaders of the industry, we have to be politically savvy. That's something I'd love to see demand do more.
Although from a housing perspective, I think we're probably importing too many people at the moment because we've already got a shortage and then we're increasing our immigration, which just puts more pressure on the system. That's only one-dimensional. I'm not saying immigration is bad.
I'm just saying that it's like what you're saying, being political is –
I don't disagree, but it's scary because it probably means that, you know, we're still not going to see any real major change because our politicians find it difficult to make those longer term changes, which might potentially get them voted out. But anyway.
Let's go back to sort of search behaviour and the ways in which individuals are online looking for property. And it's just a bit of a personal interest of mine because I've got a few theories about how we have changed post lockdowns.
And I'm careful to say not post COVID because we live in the COVID world now. But...
I think some of the ways in which we live has changed. I mentioned before about needing an extra bedroom because we're doing this work from home, hybrid, most of us. Some things have gone back to normal. They've gone back to as they were before.
Some ways in which I thought we might change as a society, we haven't. There's just some personal observations. In terms of search data, have there been some fundamental changes in what's important or what's reflecting as what's important amongst property buyers?
And look, I could ask about renters as well, because obviously you have that access. Yeah, but what observations, I guess, can you share with us?
Yeah. I was looking at the data recently myself. It's just really interesting whether we're in the market or not. We have seen a lot of more requests, like if I say New South Wales, the thing we search for the most is the pool.
That's the number one word that people put in that search term box. Number two is pool, swimming pool.
Wow. Yeah. Okay. It's interesting. Number one term, pool.
By far. It's like three times. Wow. There you go. Number two is study.
That's number three in Victoria, number two in New South Wales. And then guess what number five and number six are? It's granny and granny flat. So people are looking for ways for that home office augmentation, and that's a pretty new phenomenon, that kind of rise.
So I think that's one thing we've seen a lot of. We've seen a lot more, I guess call it interstate and intercountry searches. So, you know, New Zealand, I mean, 23% of all overseas searches were New Zealand, particularly now it's spiked since the new citizen rules for New Zealand residents.
So people want to come here. You know, it's same within the States, right? Like you look at something like a New South Wales, New South Wales people are searching all over the place.
All over the place, not just in New South Wales, still the majority of New South Wales, but whether it's Canberra, Victoria or Gold Coast. So we're seeing that more and more. And then as post-lockdowns, like our China increases have increased dramatically. They're the number two searching country now, just behind New Zealand.
That really spiked in January when they went through their COVID catastrophe and now post-COVID lockdown for them. So that's some of the data we're seeing. It's a much more home office and a much more transitory world.
That's interesting. And the home office thing, I remember we interviewed Alice Stoltz, you know, a couple of years ago now, and she did say that that term, that search term had gone up something 800% or something, you know, in the immediate wake of lockdowns.
So are you saying the New South Wales or New South Welsh people are the most actively looking to the state? Is that what you're saying? Or is it just one example?
No, I think, and I don't have all the data at hand, but if you look at, we have this matrix that has, I guess, all the statistics of what states, what state is the person looking from and what state is the person looking to, right?
And I'll try and pull it up as we go. But effectively, you see New South Wales as quite active. Lots of people are looking to come to New South Wales, but when you're in New South Wales, you're often searching for other states as well. And we've seen a lot of that, right?
It's the perennial Gold Coast shift that we've seen over the last few years.
I mean, it makes a lot of sense, right? First-time buyers are pushed out of prices, right? And they look for family solutions for their family. So they're exploring, do I go, you know, regionally in New South Wales? Do I make this lifestyle shift to, you know, Queensland or Melbourne?
Or do I go to Adelaide or et cetera? But also for investors, you know, it's an expensive place to invest, right? And budgets don't usually allow to buy in a lot of places in New South Wales.
They're like, well, I need to go look for an investment property in Brisbane or in Melbourne or Adelaide or Perth, et cetera. So it sort of makes a lot of sense there. I mean, have you got a property dumbo for us, John? Obviously, you've listened to a few of our episodes.
20 years of buying property. I'm sure you've got a few good stories for us.
Yeah, I'll give one. I'll give two. I think one which I thought about was, I mentioned I invest in most states and territories. I bought a property in Northern Territory about 20 years ago. It was a bit speculative. Me and my dad were looking at stuff together. We thought, hey, look, it's
It's placed near Darwin. It's near an army base. Let's give it a shot. It was at 200 grand. We made some profits on some properties in Cairns. I was like, let's give it a shot, right? And I thought it was a bit risky. Actually, in retrospect, it was not risky at all, right?
There's a very, very steady base there. And actually, over the next year or so, it went from 200 to 260,000.
And I think we were like, great, this is awesome. Let's sell. We took the money and ran. Of course, it's like dumb, right? Because if we held on that property, a few years later, it would have doubled. And right now, it must be close to a million bucks.
I hold on to those things. And I think we'll reflect on all those times where we sold and we didn't have to sell. Generally, because prices generally go up over time, 7% year on year if you average out over 10 years.
Generally, you've got to make your money if you spend the time in market. And so for me, that was one of those times like, oh my goodness, we didn't have to sell. What do we do with the money, right? Like we want to spend as much time in market as possible.
And because transactions are important, are expensive, we don't want to transact too much. We buy and we hold. And that was that Dumbo story.
Although weirdly enough, Darwin has done abominably. So you may well have been better to get out. But maybe you could have held on a little bit longer than you did before getting out. But did you have another example?
Yeah, I mean, one where, you know, I wish I'd gotten out was actually invested in, there's some towns in South Australia that were near the old General Motors Holden factory, $100,000, the SPAC about 20 years ago as well. We thought, hey, look, you know, we've got a steady employer there.
Politically, surely it'd be too hard, you know, for the government to exit it, which of course, surely they did, right? Because those were losing money and those property prices, you know, they didn't plummet, but they decreased. And I think...
For me, the story I took away was like, hey, you've got to play out the worst case scenarios in these things. You've got to play out what that is. You've got to probability weight that.
And if I could do it again, it wasn't a terrible investment because it's a world where hindsight is 20-20. But in terms of backing yourself to a place where there's more downside than upside, and there's only one thing that needs to go wrong, and then your investment's totally screwed.
That's one thing which I almost do again.
Yeah, I remember looking at the property prices in Elizabeth and those areas when Holden, yeah, left. And I guess that's one of the classic mistakes of buying in a one-horse town in a way. It's like that's the main employer.
It's like the mining towns and the devastating impact that that's, you know, some of those, the changes in demands in mining towns have had on individual investors because they're bought in one place with one employer. And that's a bit of a classic example of that.
And people do, they just, it's amazing the amount of people that were like, oh, it's like an airport's going in. So one big piece of infrastructure, what about everything else in an area? You know, one big employer is relocating. What about everything else? What about the other employers, you know? It is important.
It's easy to get sort of waylaid by the marketing spin too, because there's quite often, you know, real estate agents and developers will actually, they're really hammered up on certain types of infrastructure and certain types of employment.
No, I like, you know, very good in terms of your work. Like you're helping people see the fundamentals, playing the positive case and the negative case. And that's where good decisions come from.
And it still might be wrong or still something might happen, but you make the best possible decision with the information you have at the time. And, you know, to bring it full circle, I think that's very much what the division domain is. How do we bring the right information at the right time?
So we make good choices because it's so important. The worst thing in the world, you spend, you know, your life savings in a house if you made a mistake. And the good thing in Australia is if you hold it long enough, it probably won't be a mistake because over time we'll go up.
We don't want people to feel that way. We want them to feel confident and good and get on with living their life in the house they bought. So I think our missions are well aligned.
Yeah, I think your first one there, it's definitely, we find clients are a bit pigeonholed. So their attitude is, I've got to sell. And they're completely oblivious to the potential of maybe keeping something.
Even if they're just keeping it for another one, two, three, four, five years, you know, is that the cash flow on that negative or positive and the additional cost on, you know, having less debt, having more debt, is that worth holding it, you know, rather than just selling it right now?
Maybe you could hold it for two years, right?
and you know just maybe sell it at a better time um or they potentially uh have the idea to have to keep it um i just there's emotional attachment i'm just going to keep it i never sell um and often we're re-educating whether it's the debt level whether it's the quality of the asset whether it's it actually makes sense to sell and and recycle it and buy another property and um
Even if you do have to pay transaction costs, I think you've got to always be a little bit on the fence, not get too, you know, in your thinking because sometimes it's better to keep, sometimes it's better to sell. And I think that's a good case study.
Well, I think what I found valuable, Chris Wells, you know, working a lot with your kind of colleagues was to take two assumptions. Generally, if you've got a house in a good area, over time it's going to be 7% year-on-year capital gains. You've got an apartment, assume it's 5%. That's part one.
Secondly, I'm going to say, please don't anybody listen to that and act on it because this, but it doesn't play out that way. I mean, it does for some people and some assets. And if you aggregate data, it looks like it plays out that way.
But the problem is that people don't buy a share in a market. They buy an individual asset and not all of them do that. So that's why you've got to be careful by applying that sort of that overarching macro numbers to, to individual decisions, that's where you can get unstuck.
I actually created a masterclass for clients at the beginning of last year, 2022, when a lot of people were saying, should I be selling my investment property now because basically the market has peaked, right?
And so I put together a masterclass that takes people through a framework of working out whether it's the right time to sell an investment property. There's a number of different factors to take into account and everyone has to work through that process to work out, firstly, on asset caliber.
So is it a good enough asset, right? And then there's individual decisions around your own circumstances, where you are in your life cycle and that sort of stuff. So I'll actually put the link in the show notes because I've made it available for people for 39 bucks.
So if you're thinking, I want to sell a property, I have to sell it, or I have to keep it, or I really don't know what I should be doing, That's a really easy framework to work through.
It's a 32-minute video, literally, that I put together, so I put it in the show notes.
No, Veronica, it's a good point. I mean, I think I do hold to that 7% on the assumption that you're buying a good property, a good area, you've done your research. Obviously, some would do better, some would do worse, but you're right.
It is dangerous to take that blindly, and it's a fair point. The second part of what I was going to say to Chris though, I do look at the 7% and then people have to think about the leverage as well.
If you can get a good property and you happen to hold it for a while and you leverage it and you can manage the cash flow, then there's significant gains there.
And I feel people do tend to underrate that, but that's something in terms of my own philosophy over the last 20 years, maximize the time in market, having good, not too much, not too little leverage and buying good properties over time, you do pretty well. So I appreciate your remarks, Veronica.
I might check out a masterclass myself. Wish I could learn it.
That's the magic formula you just said there, John.
Thank you so much. Thanks so much, John, for coming on. I really appreciate the chat. And yeah, I look forward to seeing domain sort of evolve, right? I'm excited by that future. I've been able to overlay lots of different things in search and I can spend even more time on the platform.
Thanks for coming on.
Thanks, guys. Pleasure to be here. And as I said to you guys offline, this is one of my favorite podcasts in the world. I think you guys do amazing work educating people. You're challenging guests like myself. Oh, my goodness. But just really grateful for the work you're doing.
Looking forward to learning more in the future episodes.
Brilliant. Thanks. If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website theelephantintheroom.com.au or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au.
If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit. And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great.
I know that sounds a bit cringy, but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.
John Fong joined Domain Group as chief revenue officer after about 15 years at Google and Uber, most of it in Silicon Valley. The Silicon Valley belief, he told Chris Bates, is that anything can be run through technology, and property in America and Australia is something people are trying to make faster.
His account of where portals go next had two parts. The first is the move from a search box that waits for instructions to a feed that anticipates. Rather than returning what a buyer asks for, the app would use search history to put forward what it thinks fits, then adjust on the response.
You will see a lot more from the reactive to the proactive.
John Fong, 5:38
The second part is content no human was asked to make: automated video, and maps built to surface the statistics one person cares about. Domain owns Price Finder, with data on 90 per cent of Australian properties, and the plan is to overlay it so any app user becomes a local market expert.
Veronica Morgan was not sold. Her comparison was the newspaper classifieds, where a finger down the column showed you everything on the market. Buyers have already accepted a filtered view, and when stock is thin she goes back a fourth time in case something was missed.
Fong agreed more than he disagreed. He said he wants to see every property in an area once his parameters are set, including the unpopular ones, because as an investor that is where the better deal might sit.
Morgan's other objection was behavioural. Sydney buyers, she said, are bordered by bridges and then by main roads, and will not buy on the other side of either. Fong's answer was that the skill is discerning what technology should handle and what it should not. He noted that use of agents in the United States, on both sides of a deal, is at an all-time high above 90 per cent, where he had expected agents to follow travel agents down. Morgan named the structural difference: American buyer's agents are paid out of a higher vendor commission, while Australian buyer's agency is user pays.
There is a human element to buying or selling one of the most important purchases of your whole life that I don't think will ever go away. You can't automate that. You can't TikTok that.
John Fong, 14:13
Morgan pressed on vendor disclosure, legislated differently in every state and territory. New South Wales and Victoria sit relatively high in her assessment, though nowhere near exhaustive, and Queensland is the worst. Enforcement is a separate question, and the New South Wales regulator has set out how it is chasing underquoting and licensing loopholes. Her question was whether a national platform would publish more than the legal minimum.
Fong's position was that portals carry a responsibility above and beyond legislation. He retold Jeff Bezos insisting on ratings for every Amazon product, over a board member's objection that bad ratings would cost sales, on the grounds that transparency builds trust and speed. His Google example was more concrete: with no legislation involved, Google told webmasters it would penalise pages that were slow or not mobile friendly, and that shaped the market. Morgan said only a dominant player can pull that off. Fong put the same lever in a property setting: if the big portals awarded ranking points for a downloadable inspection report or a video, agents would want the points and sellers would follow.
Fong moved to Ireland in 2007 at the end of the Celtic Tiger and stayed until 2013. Six friends of his lived in a giant house for about $50 a month, a relic of a supply and demand mismatch. His takeaway was a Google phrase: scarcity brings clarity.
On Australia he was blunt. A generation ago a property cost about four times yearly wages, then it took two incomes, and now two incomes and help from parents. Unless supply is unlocked through building, expansion or stamp duty reform, he predicts a drift towards New York, where few people own. He called himself a bit pessimistic, and said the fixes are political: stamp duty revenue, development in your own backyard, and infrastructure that stops new outskirts becoming commuter towns.
The search data was the concrete part. In New South Wales the most searched term is pool, by roughly three times, with study, granny and granny flat behind it, which Fong read as home office augmentation. New Zealand accounted for 23 per cent of all overseas searches, spiking with the new citizenship rules, and China now ranks second.
Fong closed with two of his own mistakes. He and his father bought near Darwin for $200,000 about 20 years ago and sold at $260,000, where he estimates it would now be close to a million. The second was a South Australian town near the Holden factory at $100,000, bought assuming closing the plant was politically too hard. His assumptions of 7 per cent annual growth on houses and 5 per cent on apartments drew an immediate correction from Morgan.
People don't buy a share in a market. They buy an individual asset and not all of them do that.
Veronica Morgan, 53:25
| Search Term | Rank as Stated on Air |
|---|---|
| Pool | Number one in New South Wales, about three times the next term |
| Swimming pool | Named as the next most searched term in New South Wales |
| Study | Number two in New South Wales, number three in Victoria |
| Granny | Number five |
| Granny flat | Number six |
As described at 44:47 to 45:31. Rankings as stated on air, for Domain search terms.
| Product | What Fong Said It Does |
|---|---|
| Price Finder | Research data agents use, on 90% of Australian properties, described as similar to CoreLogic RP Data |
| Real-Time Agent | Digitises the paperwork side of the process, compared to DocuSign |
| Bid Tracker | Captures auction bids live and reports instantly, including remote live auctions |
| Early Access | Notifies buyers who have been searching an area before the home reaches Domain, and can result in a sale that never lists |
| IDS | Improves land and house valuation accuracy, used by governments including for zoning decisions |
As described at 15:26 to 15:56, 28:11 and 41:29.
If portals move from search to suggestion, what you can actually borrow matters more than what surfaces on the home screen. Our team handles complex income lending, where bonus, equity and business income have to be read properly before a listing is even shortlisted.
Premium Mortgage ServiceSources referenced: The Elephant in the Room, episode 287, "From Gatekeepers to Guides: Real Estate Agents in the Digital Age", released 2 July 2023. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Co-host: Veronica Morgan. Guest: John Fong, Chief Revenue Officer of Domain Group. Figures are quoted as stated on air and have not been re-checked against current data.



