Posted
11 November 2026
6 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
October 17, 2025
Episode
261
 ·
53
 min
The show

Australian Property Podcast

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with the investment experts at Rask. It’s all about buying, managing and investing in Australian property.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Guest

Will negative gearing crash the Australian property market?

They also cover some of your questions in the Listener Q&A segment at the end of the show, so stick around for that.

Transcript
Owen Rask

This podcast is proudly brought to you by Perla, the official brokerage platform of Rask. With Perla, you can effortlessly automate your money, whether you're investing in ETFs or shares from Australia or the US stock market, whether you're a grandparent or setting up a kid's account or your own account.

You can do all of that with full automation on Perla.com. If you want to learn more, head to Perla.com slash Rask. And of course, before you invest in anything, be sure to read the legal documents like the PDS and FSG.

This episode is brought to you by Stripe, helping your business be ready for whatever comes next. And the next shift in how people buy is already happening. Agentic Commerce lets customers discover and purchase directly inside an AI conversation. No checkout page, no friction.

The businesses positioning themselves now are the ones who will lead this channel. Whatever comes next for your business, power it with Stripe. Learn more at stripe.com.

Chris Bates

Is the 40 year mortgage a route to wealth or a debt trap? It's just the next evolution in trying to allow new buyers to be able to afford current prices. But just because you take out a 40 year mortgage doesn't mean it's going to take you 40 years to pay it off.

The minimum repayment is the minimum. Obviously, if you can afford more than that, you would just put the money either into the loan or into the offset account, and you would try to pay it off on your terms.

They had to get rid of interest-only loans off owner-occupier loans because it was a bit of a risk in our system back in 2015. I think interest-only loans are going to come back in full force.

This is a podcast by The Rask Group. It's for educational purposes only. So please do not make a financial, legal, investment or taxation decision based on solely what you hear in this show.

Owen Rask

Welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. We're on a mission to be Australia's most trusted property podcast. I'm Owen Rask, founder of The Rask Group.

Pete Wargent

I'm Pete Borgent, author and buyer's agent. I'm Amy Linardi and I am a buyer's agent.

Chris Bates

I'm Chris Bates, ex-financial planner and mortgage broker. Together, we'll take you through every step of your property journey.

Pete Wargent

From first home buyer to decades of property investing.

G'day, welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. I'm Pete Wargent from Alan Wargent Property Buyers. I'm here with Chris Bates from the Alcove Group, mortgages specialist. Chris, how's your week been?

Chris Bates

It's been a good week, Pete. If you have been following along at home, which we're all very grateful if you are, but I'm an uncle now. I mean, I have got other sort of nieces and nephews through my dad's remarried and kids and all that sort of stuff, but...

You know, my sister, who I'm very close with, had a little baby girl last Friday night. All healthy. She's okay, my sister. And had a really good first week, I think, you know, as you can expect with a newborn, you know, feeding well and all that sort of stuff.

So, yeah, I'm absolutely, if you can't even see it on my face, you're absolutely chuffed. We saw her in the hospital last Saturday, and we got back to see her again on Saturday this weekend. And, yeah. Yeah. Like super pleased. It was so cute. Tommy and Ellie, Ellie's five and a half.

Tommy's almost four. Um, and you know, I was so proud of my boy just got into the hospital and said, can I hold the baby, you know, straight away, which was just amazing. So, um, yeah, super happy right now.

Pete Wargent

Exciting times. My sister-in-law from the US is actually also due, but not till just after New Year. So the countdown's on there as well. But yeah, it's always an exciting time when you get a new addition to the wider family. So congrats.

From this end, so what else have you been up to on the work front? A lot of the buyer's agents around the traps are telling me how busy it is, not necessarily with the volume of clients, but just trying to actually get properties bought.

I know that certainly our team has missed out on a fair few in recent weeks with multiple offers going in, in some cases up to 20 offers. So pretty hectic, I think, buying conditions with so little stock around. But what are you seeing from a mortgage broking perspective?

Chris Bates

Hmm. It's a hard one to read at the moment, Pete. I think it's, obviously there's first-time buyers in the market, right? And they're pretty strong. Obviously the 5% deposits. It's not a great time to be a first-time buyer.

It is in some sense because you're in the market, but it's also not good because there's a lot of other first-time buyers in the market and it's very low listings. It's already October. And so we've spoken about that a lot. Yes, there's investors.

I think, you know, and I think this is kind of like a little bit of the canary in the coal mine. It's going to be part of our conversation that we need investors in the market.

I'm finding it hard when people are saying investors are the problem when, you know, one of our stories today is talking about just there's no key worker housing in Australia. a lot of our capital cities because there's just no rentals and rental vacancy rates are really tight. Rents are reaccelerating.

And I think there's a real problem here and underbuilding of stuff that's actually more affordable. And so, yeah, the investors are there, but I just don't think they're, you know, they're, they're often, they're not going back replacing where the old investors are. Um, and so, and their budget's a lot smaller.

Upgrade is a sort of very eye on tenterhooks. I mean, we had a client buy a six mil plus last week. We've had, you know, quite a few clients buy, you know, two to three and, you know, et cetera. Um, which we haven't had too many in the last few years.

That's, let's be real. That part of the market's frozen up. Um, But I do think they're on tenterhooks. I think the rate conversation you can see through the AFR this week and just sort of feeling the confidence around it, I think people are going to want to wait and see.

I think people are going to want to see what happens in sort of April, sort of March time next year when we come out of the Christmas bubble and we get in that first quarter of 2026. And, you know, where's the rate expectations?

Now, if they're saying a flatlining of rates for the rest of the year, I do think you're going to see still a frozen up market. But if there's rates going up, then that's obviously going to be even tighter market for houses. People are going to sit on their hands more.

But if the narrative around rates really shifts and it goes back to kind of what it was, maybe two or three more rate cuts coming. I think that will be the confidence the upgraders need. And so it's a really hard one to read at the moment. Definitely no mortgage wars.

I mean, the papers have been writing, you know, every soon as there's a change to policy, oh, new mortgage wars are back. That's absolute nonsense. Pricing's actually got worse. not better in the last month, which goes against what you read in the media.

It's actually, you're getting less discounts and less competition really on rate than we had a month ago. And so, yeah, it's a really strange market.

I don't know what you're seeing, Pete, right, on the buying side, but I think it's tough to buy and, you know, and everyone's very price sensitive, I would say.

You know, they're not going gangbusters on every property, you know, but, you know, they're just all flocking like a seagull to a chip to the good stuff.

Pete Wargent

Yes, and also the competition is largely at the cheaper end of the market. So, yeah, certainly in residential property, we've got a couple of commercial property searches underway as well. But even that's pretty tight. I think a lot of investors have come back into the market over the past year.

As you said, I think on the interest rate expectations, they've certainly been dialed back. in recent weeks.

We're recording this on Thursday morning, so before the release of the labour force statistics, so that will have an impact obviously on what's expected to happen with interest rates, but we're coming off a very weak month in the preceding month, and there probably would be a rebound you would expect.

This will go out on Sunday, so you'll know by then. So, yeah, I think maybe some people are just a bit wary that interest rates might be kind of stuck around the current levels for quite a long time to come, and therefore repayments are still pretty tough.

There was a couple of other bits of news earlier in the week. So, firstly, the ABS put out the latest arrivals and departures figures, and over the year,

467,000 net permanent and long-term arrivals. So that's been rising now for seven months in a row. You may recall there was a bit of controversy as to whether this sort of equates to what the immigration figures will show because border crossings might not map exactly to immigration.

But I think it's pretty clear that immigration has re-accelerated in 2025. That much is pretty clear. I suppose the other piece of stats is

The other release that was out this week was just on dwelling starts and dwelling completions, and they were particularly low, really. I think if you look at housing starts, well, they fell back another 4% to about 45,000, and dwelling completions fell to about 40,000 most in 11 years.

So what do you think that, in the context of a government target, of effectively 60,000 dwellings a quarter. Well, we're absolutely nowhere near that. We managed about 177,000 over the financial year versus a target of 240,000.

There's quite a lot in the pipeline, Chris, but I think a big part of what's happening in this cycle is it's just taking much longer to build a house and a unit than it used to. It's a year now for a detached house. 2.7 years for an attached dwelling, particularly for a unit.

I think that's partly because in the previous cycle, we were building high-res towers very quickly for overseas investors. This time around, it's a different quality and type of property. They're bigger units, more so for owner-occupiers, and the quality is much higher.

That's a good thing, I would say, for the market overall, but it is taking much longer for these dwellings to get out of the ground. And I saw Tarek Brooker, who's an independent analyst, said, well, let's look at some housing supply scenarios.

There's definitely a case where if the dwelling supply peaks up, by the end of the decade, we could be starting to address the housing shortage. But there's other scenarios where The shortage just keeps on getting worse.

If you just think about those two figures on a standalone basis, net arrivals of 467,000, permanent and long-term arrivals, and 40,000 dwellings in three months. It's a massive mismatch, and the housing shortage is clearly getting worse before it gets better.

Chris Bates

Pete, I was just wondering your thoughts on this. I mean, there's a very aspirational target, right? 1.2 million homes over five years. Very unlikely that, you know, and there's a kind of set this line, Sandra, where you said like, well, you know, divide that by five years, 240 dwellings a year. Yeah.

There's no chance that we're going to hit that where, you know, there's articles all over the media right now, you know, a 70,000 short. And I wonder if it was always when they released that number, they knowing that they're going to under, you know, not hit it, right.

They're going to, um, understeer to it. Then they're going to say, Hey, now we need to do zoning changes. Now we need to really be pro development. So maybe it was just setting this target. That was really just a plucked number from the air, uh,

And then that could be the reason that we're starting to see a lot more of this YIMBY movement. I haven't sent the article to you, but it's Cathal Leslie. He's an economist. He's based in Paris. He did an article, Why Planning Reform Alone Can't Solve the Housing Crisis.

It is actually a really quite smart article, I felt. Basically, what he's highlighting is that we don't have a dwelling problem. We have an allocation of properties problem, right? Lots of spare bedrooms, lots of properties that don't suit people's needs.

And he says that the incentives around the way the property market is structured is that

right disincentivize people to you know get rid of properties that are too big for them or to hold on to property their house into the retirement years because it's not in the pension and it grows tax-free and etc the other thing i would just sort of highlight on this in um

which I think has got a lot of merit, you know, to be honest.

I think the other thing I'd like to highlight is that there's a lot of people jump on this anti-development movement because they're basing it on the previous boom and the quality of properties that we built in the 20s or the noughties and the 2010s.

And, you know, I think it was when private certifiers didn't have to In 1999, there was a shift. I'm not exactly sure of all the technicality behind it. It's not really my area. But basically, you can see there's a line in the sand where the quality of buildings really deteriorated due to certification.

And we basically built for investors. And, you know, we'd actually probably like that in the market right now, actually, is a lot of investors buying, building new stock. Not that I'd want to be the investor myself, but that's going to, we need a lot more rental accommodation.

And, you know, if we could get some of that getting built, that would be good. Unfortunately, that stuff doesn't stack up.

And if you go on real estate or domain, whatever portal you like, and if then you go into look at new homes on the tab, then you go into the different states and you go look at the apartment buildings. that we're building in New South Wales and Victoria, Queensland, all around the country.

These are very, very high end, architecturally designed, bigger apartments that suit either the family market or the downsizer market. And they're not sort of built cheap and cheerful to go out because that won't sell.

There is a few of those sort of old school sort of high density developments going on that are really big. And I don't know whether they're selling.

um personally but you can see the quality of the next run in in i think um properties getting built in our capital cities is going to be really um match the streetscape it's not going to be you know crazy and just you know horrible really i think we're going to be seeing a much now there are going to be cases where people are going to feel it's on um over the top particularly because in new south wales you can build a bit higher because if you had a bit more affordable housing and i think there is going to be cases where the community should really stand up but

You know, often a lot of these new apartments that are getting built, I feel that, you know, it's what we need to be building. It's the missing middle. And even if it does just get a lot of downsizes, those downsizes have to come from somewhere.

And so what you're going to do is start to create some freeing up some housing stock and turning six houses to 60 apartments is not a bad thing.

Pete Wargent

Well, yes, I think you're right on the housing target. There's certain things in politics that are easy to announce, but difficult. Well, there's certain things that are politically difficult to get through, but they're very easy to implement. So if you want to increase taxes.

It's not going to be popular, but it's actually easy to implement. You just put in place a new tax rate and off you go.

On the other hand, there's certain things that are very easy to announce, like a dwelling target, or we're going to bring in lower energy bills, but actually the implementation is really difficult. If memory serves correctly, originally the housing supply target

was announced in a Labour budget, and it was going to be 1 million dwellings, well-located dwellings over five years. Then it was clear that we were short of that target. And then suddenly there was a new announcement, it's 1.2 million, but nothing really changed on the supply side.

So, yeah, it's proving more difficult than people might have expected to actually see that change. Because in the end, the market's got to deliver those properties. The government isn't really providing much of it. There's a couple of other articles related this week. One, housing shortage threatened by lack of tradies.

something we talked about last week. That was a Fin Review article. But yeah, a lot of young traders are going to work on, for example, Victoria's big build project infrastructure, and they can get paid really good money to do that. So working on the residential side is probably less appealing.

And also our SQM research, rents reaccelerate as vacancy rates remain tight. So the vacancy rate fell to 1.2%.

Sydney's vacancy rate fell to 1.3% and vacancies are under 1% now in Brisbane, Perth, Adelaide, Darwin and Hobart. And asking rents are now on the up again. So that could be a potential problem for the Reserve Bank. And it's another tick in the box, I think, for interest rates on hold.

I think, yeah, it's just starting to annoy the electorate now because people are feeling this in rental affordability. You sent me a Sydney Morning Herald article where teachers just can't seem to find affordable properties to rent close to where they need to be.

So, yeah, I think it's, yes, we've got big immigration numbers. We're not really building enough. But people are starting to feel it on the ground now and it's becoming a political challenge for the government. There was one other sort of piece of news this week. Unrealised gains on...

superannuation, there was a lot of debate about whether Labour could actually tax unrealised gains in super. It looks like they're backtracking on that and instead introducing a $10 million cap. So some implications there for the wealthier people in their superannuation.

But yeah, I think the big sort of question over the next five years is what happens with immigration and what happens to housing supply? Because at the moment, there's that enormous mismatch.

Chris Bates

Yeah, I think the super story is quite a big one. I think we should talk about that one next week, Pete, because I think there's still a few things to iron out. But I think they have backed down.

It was a pretty brave policy, to be honest, and the financial advice industry rightly was probably up in arms because it didn't really make sense the way that they were doing it.

The thoughts about taxing more bigger ballots in super makes sense, I feel, and they weren't against that, but they were just the mechanics on how they were doing it.

particularly unrealized gains and no indexing was just didn't feel fair and so they're back down on those things and um uh but they have increased taxes for three and ten million dollar portfolios much higher and um i think that makes sense but they're not sure how capital gains tax is going to work yet and

Um, so I think it's a, it's an interesting topic, um, that one, because it was going to encourage people to sort of move money out of super.

Now, if you're a bit gung ho, and even though it hadn't gone through parliament, when sold all your assets and got out of money out of super, you're going to be regretting it.

Um, and, uh, so that, and that was often what a lot of people thought was going to happen, but you're careful what, you know, um, I guess taking action before legislation has actually gone through would be my point on this one. What's your thoughts on New Zealand dropping the cash rate again?

I mean, you know, they're down to 2.5%, 3% of cuts down there. Why have they been so much stronger over the ditch than we are here?

Pete Wargent

Well, the higher interest rates have really impacted. I think as well, a lot has happened in the housing market in New Zealand to the extent that the RBNZ is also easing LVR restrictions.

So I think I wouldn't say it's panic stations, but the economy is kind of ground to a halt in New Zealand. The housing market is taking quite a sizable hit.

Actually, a lot of the stats NZ figures show that about 0.6% of the Kiwi population per annum is now going to Australia for better employment prospects and higher wages. So, yeah, they're kind of stemming the bleeding a little bit by cutting interest rates. Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it?

Because if you look at Canada, they've experienced similar challenges. Housing markets on the way down. Immigration's dried up, really. New Zealand, very similar. And yet Australia, we just kind of kept on going. I suppose the government has come under a lot of criticism for... high rates of spending.

But in a sense, that's what's kept our unemployment rates so low and kept the economy fizzing along. So I guess there's always two sides to that story. So yeah, New Zealand, a few challenges there, but maybe those lower interest rates will start to bite.

Right, we better get through our top three news stories of the week as time's getting on. So first story, which was covered in Macro Business and also the Australian Financial Review, is the 40-year mortgage, a route to wealth or a debt trap. So we are starting to see a few

40-year mortgages in Australia. So I think with a longer loan term, it might potentially mean smaller repayments each month, but then obviously you're going to pay back over time more interest over the life of the loan. I suppose so there's going to be pros and cons. Chris, you're a mortgages expert.

If you go down this route and take out a 40-year mortgage, does that have some impacts on your serviceability in the same way that an interest-only loan might do? And do you ever sort of get clients wanting a 40-year loan?

I guess as somebody who in the sort of not too distant future will be heading towards about 50s, I'm starting to think, well, a 40-year loan is actually too long. So I guess there's a few different things to think about if you were thinking of taking that longer loan term.

Chris Bates

Um, look, it's, it's, I guess they're saying hate the system, you know, don't hate the player, hate the system. Right. And I think this is a, a symptom of a, basically of the system. I'm trying to get my words out here, Pete.

So basically it's just the next evolution in trying to basically allow new buyers to be able to afford current prices. And one of the ways to do that is to allow them to pay the loan off over the longer term.

And I think this is when I've spoken about this for at least a year, I reckon. I was saying, look, 40 year loans are going to come. You can just see that it's just the next evolution. I think interest only loans are going to come back in full force.

They had to get rid of interest-only loans of owner-occupier loans because it was a bit of a risk in our system back in 2015. You can just type in AFG index home loans and you can basically go back and see the proportion of interest-only lending back in 2015.

And some of the banks, i.e. Westpac, had a huge exposure to interest-only loans back then because they were offering 15-year interest-only terms on homes. And so basically, what they had to do is come in really hard.

They penalized homeowners with higher interest-only rates, basically to bring a bit more stability into our banking system and protect the banks a bit. Now, when you look at it, $2.4, $2.5 trillion of home loans on a almost $12 trillion property market. I don't think they're as concerned as they were.

And the proportion of interest-only lending has been very little all the way back since 2016, 2017 or something like that. So yeah, I reckon interest-only loans are going to start coming back. Well, we're talking 40-year mortgages here. What's the consequence of a 40-year mortgage?

Obviously, if you take 40 years to pay it off, you're going to pay a lot, lot more interest than if it was over 30 years or 20 years. But just because you take out a 40 year mortgage doesn't mean it's going to take you 40 years to pay it off.

The minimum repayment is the minimum, you know, and obviously if you can afford more than that, you would just put the money either into the loan or into the offset account and you would try to pay it off on your terms.

Owen Rask

I want to tell you a story about how the new Rask platform came to be. In 2025, everyone was still waking up to this idea that AI was going to have an impact on the world. And it wasn't until mid to late 2025 that it really hit me like a ton of bricks.

At that time, I thought, what can I do with this new tool, this innovative technology? That set in motion what has now become a totally new Rask platform, which you can find at rask.au. It is 100% free to create an account and start using tools. But what did it actually do?

And what does it do for you? At Rask, we've produced thousands of podcasts. probably 20,000 articles were written on investing and all these different types of things like personal finance, superannuation, you name it. So we really needed a place where we could bring all of that together for the entire community.

That can be found at rask.au. Whether you're a retiree, a business builder, or a student of finance, you should go and check it out. But once we built the platform, we realized that that wasn't enough. So in 2026, we've decided to launch a new community known as the Rask Ultra community.

This is the deepest, most advanced part of what we do as a business and as a community of investors and builders. We want to build a network of people that can come together and share ideas in a new ecosystem that we've built just for you.

You can find out more, like I said, by Googling Rask Ultra or by creating a free account at rask.au and see if Ultra is right for you.

Chris Bates

You know, a lot of people would argue, though, if you have a minimum repayment, people just lifestyle creep, you know, the hedonic treadmill, you'll just spend more if you've got more in your pocket and the banks will win. But I think that I think a lot of the next generations, unfortunately.

will be buying properties and holding debt all the way through to retirement. And then we'll be forced to downsize at retirement because they've still got home debt on their home versus a house paid off. I just think this is the problems with buying a property later in life.

You know, you're not a 25 year old buying your first home. You're getting there at 40. And then also the challenges of the cost to purchase plus the

You're not getting on top of your mortgage because you've got to get your kids through school and then you get to the 50s and you can't really get on top of your mortgage.

I think what you'll find is in 20, 30-year times, a lot more people are going to retirement with debt and they're getting rid of that debt either with using their super or just selling the property. And so... Yeah.

And, and you know what, to be honest, most people are getting 40 year loans now anyway, that's often a miss, um, not spoken about enough.

If a client comes to us and they bought their first home say five years ago and they would have taken out a 30 year loan, that property's gone up. Now they've got a smaller loan. They've got, we would then refinance that loan and we would put it back on a 30 year mortgage.

The reason is it's less commitment to them and they just keep paying off on their terms. So most people are getting 40-year mortgages anyway because every time they refinance, they go reset it back to a 30-year mortgage. And that's just the reality of the way it works today.

Pete Wargent

The interest-only loans point is an interesting one because back at the peak of the interest-only frenzy about a decade ago, it was almost 40% of mortgages by value were on interest-only terms, including a lot of homebuyers or homeowners. And then APRA absolutely smashed that. Now it's about 12%.

But I did see just in recent times, there's been a bit of chat about, well, If investor lending takes off, we could reintroduce macro prudential measures to punish investor loans and interest only loans again, even though now it's only about 12% of the mortgage book by value is on interest only.

It's an enormous decline. I'm pretty sure banks would be keen to lend a bit more on interest only, though, if they're allowed to. So let's look at the second story of the week. The real estate carry trade is a death star.

So this is Martin North, Digital Finance Analytics with John Wright, his guest this week. They must use AI to create these titles. That's brilliant, a death star. So I think, I mean, I suppose in short,

Well, the thesis here is property holding costs are greater than income for investors and there's a lot of household leverage or debt in the system and therefore the housing market must inevitably collapse. I suppose my question is here, is it a bubble or a cycle?

Because in 2006, I remember a very similar debate going on. Because at the time, an investor on a unit, for example, might get a rental yield of, let's say, 5%. But at one stage, mortgage rates were near a 9%, and there was a huge negative carry for investors.

But we did have a massive housing shortage. Well, it seems to me that we're back in a very similar situation now. Rental yield might be, let's say, 3% or 4% for an investor, but you might have a mortgage rate of 6%. So same dynamic applies. Across the system, you've really got...

what they would call a negative carry or a negative cash flow.

And I suppose that the theory here is that if it's like Minsky economics, you're creating a Minsky moment where the rents don't cover the mortgage payments and the other holding costs and therefore everybody rushes to the exit and it creates a crash. And yeah, that's not really what seems to be happening.

We seem to have more investors coming into the market in anticipation of the housing shortage. I suppose if you look back at what happened in 2006, obviously there was a recession internationally, which Australia by and large dodged.

But what happened was interest rates went very quickly down towards 3% from previously a much higher level. above seven. And I think as well, if we did get a sort of a deep recession, we'd probably see a rebalancing through the currency as well. The Aussie dollar would drop.

So I'm not saying that there won't be a downturn. There will at some point, but whether or not it's kind of a death star is a different debate. Yeah. What do you think, Chris?

You know, it's obviously a key issue in the market that a lot of investors can't get income to cover the holding costs and therefore they're negatively geared in the early years and sometimes maybe for a decade or more. So what do you reckon?

Does that create a Minsky moment or wins more of a cycle?

Chris Bates

Look, Martin North and I are actually friends. I've been going on his show pretty much every two, three months, I think, for seven, eight years. I remember going down to his house in Thoreau back when he was getting a lot of heat around a 40% market crash.

So I was going into the bear den, I think you would call it, and he's got a very passionate YouTube community. And Martin himself, we've interviewed him lots of times on The Elephant,

um sort of admits that he sort of got it wrong which he sort of got it right you know he knows that he's been really thinking a crash is coming and you know what i but i sort of put him on the spot with it basically what he admits is he just didn't realize the amount of conflicts in the system and how the government would do everything it can to keep the

the system going, um, because every time he thinks that, oh, something bad's gonna happen, someone steps in to protect the housing market. It's like the sacred lamb that you cannot, um, ever. stuff around with.

And so, yeah, I mean, John Wright's obviously going to be great for his community and talking up there to collapse. But it's a funny one, right? You could say that around lots of things right now. You could say that around Bitcoin. You could say that around, look at the price of that.

You could say, look at the shares. I think Simon Mahoney, I can't say his name, but he basically runs Alan Gray. I really rate Alan Gray as investors, by the way. They're sort of counter cyclical sort of, Oh, what's the, what's the word?

Pete Wargent

Contrarian.

Chris Bates

Contrarian. Sorry. Yeah. I was thinking, and I actually walked past him when we were doing the hike in the blue mountains. And I was like, at the tip of my tongue, I went to stop him. I was like, Oh God, he won't know who I am. And,

But I know who he is and it would have been a bit weird. But, yeah, because I want to chat to him because he's always got such an interesting mind.

He's been in the AFR all this week basically saying that, you know, the momentum in the Australian shares and international shares, it just put them up to, you know, valuations on forward price earnings of just, you know,

high very high levels um and so you could say the stock market's a pretty dangerous place to go in right now you know based on just long-term valuations you could say gold right now we've all seen the rush of you know their images all over social media where people running for rushing for gold and lining up to get their hands on gold and gold's at all-time highs so

Yeah, it's a funny one. It's not property, but yes, there's a lot of equity in there and a lot of high valuations. But if there is a downturn, people don't just rush to the equities. It's one of those asset classes that you still have to live somewhere.

Do you really want to sell your home and go into the rental market right now? I don't think so. And so I think, yes, you might see some investors bail. And I think there is a bit of a...

um an issue for the investors who have bought in the last few years who have bought the momentum i think in the more affordable parts of our you know regional locations um i think they're in for a bit of a dangerous time if there is a bit of a correction i think you'll see a lot of investors bail and and you could see a repricing of properties based on what locals could afford but um until that sort of reckoning happens you might find that they just you know still hold their value um what's your take on it pete

Pete Wargent

Well, I think if you look at what's happening in Canada and New Zealand, there comes a point where the market cycle peaks. And sometimes the way that this stuff comes out is through declines in real terms.

If you actually account for inflation and nominal price drops, and then suddenly you get to these situations where in real terms, prices are 20% off the highs. So I think that's often how these things play out. It's not always...

People often talk about big drops in nominal prices, like happened in parts of the US in the global financial crisis, but often the way it seems to play out is that prices come off the highs a little bit, but then after inflation, they suddenly down 20% from the highs.

Yeah, I don't know is the answer. I do think, yes, if there's a risk, I think at the moment, the capital cities have just got such enormous shortages of housing. But a lot of regional markets, people have really piled in. I've seen some massive increases in prices, 50% to 100% since COVID. And

Yeah, some of that demand is driven by interstate buyers agents and speculative demand. So there's definitely some people flying naked out there. So yeah, I'm not disputing there are risks in the system.

But I suppose the thesis here of John Wright is that there is no solution and there has to be a massive crash. I tend towards the view that where possible, the Reserve Bank, APRA, the government, they tend to put in place measures when housing markets are in downturns to cushion the blow.

And often when the downturn comes, it often comes out through inflation and declines in real terms rather than nominal. So we'll see how it plays out when the cycle does peak. But it feels like at the moment, we're sort of in an upswing.

So it's going to be some way off, I guess, before we find out. So let's wrap it up with the third story of the week and then we'll do your listener Q&A at the end. Three ways to future proof your mortgage repayments. That's an article.

that was in domain so firstly get the right loan in the first place think about getting a flexible offset account the ability to redraw and the option to make early repayments if desired secondly consider home loan protection and thirdly keep a rainy day buffer Chris what sort of other tips or advice would you give to a borrower today do you

For example, if people have the option to make early repayments on a home loan, should they do that or build up a buffer in an offset account? What sort of strategies do you recommend to clients these days?

Chris Bates

This is a funny one, right? There's brokers I know, and there's nothing against them, but there's a lot of content going around around offset accounts versus putting money into a break draw. And some are putting their hands in this, you know, their stake in the sense, like offset, offset, offset.

And some are saying,

redraw redraw redraw and what i think it's missing is that you know some people are going to be better off you know forcing themselves to save and some people are going to have yeah not sticky fingers not be on the hedonic treadmill be able to keep money in an offset account and not spend it and um i think it's just looking at you as an individual being real with yourself and saying hey am i going to get on top of my mortgage or am i just if i have money in my bank account am i going to spend it um

And, you know, if you are a type of person that's very good at, you know, living more frugally, you know, doesn't really get, you know, shiny object syndrome and spending money and, you know, then you might say, well, let's just, I'm really quite, I've already got my system in place.

I'm not going to spend more money. I'm just going to put that money in the office. He had a big bill buffers. The irony is they're the ones who are going to least need the buffer. because they're probably the one who's least going to get themselves into trouble.

The other one that is probably spending everything they've got, they're probably the one who have to force themselves, right? And so then they are probably better to put money into a redraw and pay their mortgage off as fast as possible to actually force them to save.

It's one of the benefits of a mortgage that doesn't get spoken about enough. Like superannuation automatically forces you to put money away from your time and so does a mortgage. It sort of makes you save for your future at the same time as well. Yeah.

I mean, to sort of get ahead of it, I guess it's like really trying to get really good at your cashflow and managing your mortgage.

And yes, you might pay off your mortgage through paying it off, but you might want to just have emergency fund set up maybe at an offset account that you can't see on your internet banking. That's really hard to transfer in and out of, but it's still offsetting your mortgage and

Um, yeah, it's there if you absolutely need it, but getting access to it's quite hard because you have to go to the bank or something like that. So there's ways to sort of just, it's all about behavioral science and behavioral finance, I would say. Um, but yeah, I mean, it's.

I think you do also really understand how much paying a little bit more pays off your mortgage faster. A lot of people don't understand that as well. So that also gives people the desire.

If they see the benefit, well, I'll pay my mortgage off in 10 years earlier if I pay an extra $100 a week. Yeah, sometimes these are the conversations people need just to get on top of their mortgage.

Pete Wargent

Well, we had that when mortgage rates were 2%. People were saying, well, why bother paying it back? I'm like, well, yeah, but you've got to think about the life of the mortgage and the weighted average expected mortgage rate over the whole life of the mortgage.

It's not going to be 2% forever, not in Australia, because we don't have long 30-year fixed rate mortgages. So actually, if you can make accelerated repayments on a home loan, that's a good thing. And I think you're right. It's a case of know thyself.

And I say that as somebody who's just gone through uh, two or three significant refinances. I know there's a massive risk of me spending that money. It's just, um, I like travel, you know, and there's a, there's a risk that if money's there and it's available that it gets spent.

So I'm trying to filter it into a renovation rather than spend it all on trips abroad. So let's do a couple of listening questions.

Chris Bates

The final point, which I forgot to say, Pete, around insurance. Um, it's obviously I've come from a financial advice background. We don't do financial advice now. Um, I'm not a fan of any short-term income protection policies and any type of insurance that will protect your income for a short period.

The reason is it's usually very expensive for them and the benefit they offer is usually short-term, hence why it's short.

The real risk when you have time off work isn't if you're off for three months because you break your ankle or that you've got an illness that you back at work in four or five months.

That's not great, yes, but you've got sick leave, maybe you've got more sick leave at work and maybe you've got a bit of a buffer and you can use your annual leave and, you know, that's okay. The real issue is if you get a real medium to long-term illness.

Now, I'm not up to date with the... I used to say it all the time, but I think it's if you're off work for more than a year and... This could be completely wrong because I can't remember exactly what I used to say when I used to sell insurance.

But I think it's if you're off work for more than a year, I think the average is eight years off work. So the risk is if you're not back in work after a year, that you're going to be off work for a long time.

Something serious is wrong, and that's the risk you need to prepare for. And so income protection, that has a term all the way to retirement. I think it's mostly 65. I think they might even be off and up to 70 now. I haven't stayed up to date with all the latest insurance changes.

That's what you want with income protection. And you really just got to figure out, how do I get that potentially a little bit cheaper? Consider things like maybe a 90-day waiting period, yeah, versus a 30 days. That drops the cost a lot. Maybe you don't have agreed sort of premiums.

Maybe you have to verify your income. Maybe you don't go indexation. Let's just really get some good insurance advice. If you want to protect your income, Don't go through a big, you know, retail. Don't go and get personal insurance. Go get yourself fully assessed through a lender, through an insurer.

You can obviously, but unless you've got some health issues, you've got to be careful here and check with your super fund as well.

So yeah, insurance is a big topic, but I don't like any type of short income replacement type insurance. I think it's very expensive. If you're going to insure yourself, insure yourself for the real risk if you don't go back to work long term.

Pete Wargent

Good advice. Thanks, Grace. All right, let's do a couple of your listener questions, then we'll finish up for the week. So firstly, from Coastal Karen, we own a house in a beachside suburb on the sunny coast that's just been proposed to be rezoned from low density to medium density.

It's currently an investment, but I plan to live in it in the future. We were about to start a fairly major reno, about 500 to 600K next year.

We're now not sure if it's smart to spend that money given the proposed rezoning changes, especially with potential changes to the area's character like more traffic, privacy and security concerns. What does a change like this usually mean for homeowners? Is it generally viewed as a positive or a negative?

Do you think it's wiser to hold off or go ahead and renovate as planned?

Well, I think if your property gets rezoned, your specific property gets rezoned from low density to medium or potentially even higher density in some of the suburbs on the Sunshine Coast, then you can potentially see a value uplift on your land because there's more you can do with the property.

But if it's the locality that's being rezoned, well...

Yeah, well, I spoke to Peter Tulip about this because we've talked about planning changes and he said the stats seem to show that there's no detrimental impact from rezoning on houses in the locality.

I suppose, though, you could argue over the longer term, there could be less scarcity in your property type and there might be less livability if there's more traffic. I mean, of course, a lot of people move to the sunny coast because they like the low density, easygoing nature of the the area.

So there is that to factor in. I think just on the renovation, I say this as somebody who's doing a renovation right now, is that almost every line item on my budget so far is going about double what I've budgeted.

So you could certainly say I wasn't conservative enough on my numbers, but the reality is getting hold of trade is tough. materials are difficult to source at the moment. And the cost of almost everything seems to be much higher than I would have expected when I wrote the budget a year ago.

So that's another thing to factor in. If your budget is five to six hundred, it could easily end up being a lot more. That's just a word of caution. But Chris, going back to the question, should they do the Renault anyway or should they wait and see?

Chris Bates

um look i think every suburb even though there's rezoning developers are going to get attracted to certain parts of a suburb first where they're going to be able to sell the development much easier and you know a lot of people in the development want that um lock up and leave but also the easy access to amenity and the beach and the shops and that's part of the pitch right like you get to live in a brand new build in a great location with a lock up and leave but

And so how close are you to where they're likely to build? If you're sort of far enough away, yeah, it's been rezoned, but you know, you're quite protected. It's kind of going to be a nice, quite a pocket. Well, you're probably going to find more houses are going to get knocked down.

And then more of those buyers who want that live close to the shops are will want to live kind of where you are. And they'll probably find that the amenity in the area is better, right? Like a lot of these apartments will get built.

There'll be, you know, new commercial downstairs, which might be new cafes and restaurants. And, you know, you've got to argue, is that also going to make it, yeah, it's a bit more traffic, but doesn't make it even more desirable to live there.

You can see, you know, for example, in Sydney right now, in Bellevue Hill, right? So Double Bay's going through an ascent and there's lots of, Apartments and even the Intercontinental, I think, is coming down. New apartments are going up there.

But together with that, you've got a lot more restaurants, a lot more lively in Double Bay. That's actually made Rose Bay and Bilby Hill more desirable to live in because people can then just go down to Double Bay for their restaurants. So I don't know.

I think in this situation, it's sort of similar. If you're sort of far enough away from it, you don't have to deal with the day-to-day traffic. But if you're in the middle of it,

I'd be really hesitant because you could easily find that, yeah, you've gone and got this beautiful renovated place that people are like, yeah, I just want to be up the road in one of those other houses.

And so this is one of the costs of zoning changes is there's people who usually benefit a lot and get a lot of capital uplift, particularly the ones who amalgamate the best sites early when developers are still trying to lock in work.

But I would say that it's always people who get hit in that world

who are sort of the ones that don't get spoken about enough when the zoning changes has really affected them because they're the ones, they're the properties that developers don't want and they're nowhere near as livable as they were prior to the density was getting built.

But I think, yeah, that could be your situation or may not be.

Pete Wargent

Yeah, good thoughts. You just reminded me of Sunday afternoons in the Golden Sheaf, Chris. The Great Barrier Reef. Those days are long gone for me. But yeah, I think you're right.

There can be more dynamism in a location through the rezoning, but you do get a lot of noise and disruption in the short term. Let's wrap up with one more question, then we'll finish for the week.

From Shacket Potato, I've been investing in ETFs and individual stocks for a number of years with a portfolio value of 200K. In 12 months' time, I'll need to sell approximately 150 of the portfolio to help fund a new house build.

If you were in this position, would you sell now to avoid the risk of a potential downturn and reduction of funds available or sell at the last minute to allow compounding to continue? Capital gains are not an issue due to historic capital loss. Well, there's no right or wrong here.

If it was me, personally, I would... take the money I need for the house build and stick it on term deposit. Maybe when I was younger, I would have taken a different view and I'd have been mucking around with margin loans and so on.

But the reality is that nobody can predict what happens to a stock market in a 12-month period. time horizon. I think historically, yes, the market goes up more than it goes down and you'll get some dividend income. But in the short term, there's no way to predict it.

And valuations are pretty high, as Chris said earlier on, and things could come down. And you can get 4% on a term deposit now. So if it was me, I would just do that. I would maybe leave the rest of your portfolio invested. But what would you do, Chris?

I guess I'm showing my age now, thinking in a conservative manner. But what about you?

Chris Bates

I mean, why do you need to sell the shares? I mean, have you got equity in your home? Can you not get access to finance? You know, you've got a house. I mean, it sounds like you found a new house built, so maybe you just got some land. Could you...

It makes sense to use cash for that rather than debt because if it's a house you're going to live in, then you'd want to have that with a low non-deductible debt. And so then you might want to then re-borrow in time to buy the shares.

Whether you should sell the shares now or sell the 12s in 12 months, it's like a Who knows? Like it's actually, you know, financially, what's going to be a better option depends on where the stock market is in 12 months time. Like, yeah. And at the moment you're very high.

So like, you know, no one knows that. Right. So it's a question you, no one's going to give you the answer to it. Um, and whoever thinks they know, don't know. Right. So just, I think that's the. That's the wrong question. And that's not me being, trying to be me.

It's just, I just don't think you're going to get any answer. No one can ever tell you the answer to that, right? The reality is that you are taking risks when you're holding properties.

And if you do want to sell and you're forced to sell at any time in the next, say, three to five years, you've just got to know that markets can move very fast. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to go back and look over stock markets and see how corrections happen in weeks.

And they can happen 20 to 30%, you know, in weeks that you just don't want to have a major market correction due to whatever it is at a time when you have to sell. And so you're just like one of those games. You've got to watch the prices, right?

And that, and he's climbing up the mountain and you've got to sort of press the button before he jumps off, falls off the edge of the mountain. Um, and you just don't want to be doing that.

You don't want to just press that button too late and he's already over that and the market's corrected. So yeah, it's gambling. It's gambling when you've got a time that you need to sell by.

And, um, at some point you just got to sort of jump off that, uh, mountain and put the money in the bank and put in a term deposit or a cash deposit.

Even a high-interest short-term cash account, Pete, there's a lot of those going around that are probably offering pretty good rates, even comparable to term deposits. So, yeah, hopefully that was an okay answer. Shuck it, potato.

Pete Wargent

Good stuff. Thanks, Chris. Well, thanks, everyone, for tuning in. Come and join us on the RASC community forum. That's community.rasc.com.au. If you've got any questions on mortgages, give Chris a shout. The link's in the notes. And likewise, if you've got any property questions, always feel free to drop us a line.

And do send in your questions as well, because we always try and cover two or three of those at the end of each Two Cents episode. So it's golf for me this weekend. Chris, what about yourself?

Chris Bates

I see my little niece and that's all I'm looking forward to. I haven't had a night out with my wife actually on Friday night, date night, leaving the kids at grandma. So that should be fun. I'm not sure what we're going to do yet.

I'll probably decide that at three o'clock on Friday afternoon. Party time. Look out. Maybe we'll go stay in Bondi for a night or something, somewhere a bit different. What are you up to, Pete? Just saying a bit of golf.

Pete Wargent

Yeah, just getting up to Noosa Springs. So pretty quiet one for me. And yeah, still searching for commercial properties. So it's not easy pickings at the moment. A lot of competition and not much stock. So yeah, we'll update you as we go along over the coming weeks.

Thanks for tuning in and we'll see you next time. Cheers. Thanks, Pete.

Chris Bates

Thanks for tuning into the Australian Property Podcast. If you love the show, why not subscribe or leave us a review on Apple or Spotify.

Pete Wargent

And if you want to work with me, Amy, Pete or Chris, you'll find links in your podcast player to get in contact with us.

Owen Rask

Thank you for listening to this episode of the Australian Property Podcast. We're huge advocates of getting the right advice at the right time from the right people. That's why it's important to understand that this podcast episode contained general financial information only.

It is not designed to be specific or personalized to your financial, tax or legal situation. With property, the check sizes are pretty big. So it's important you get advice from a licensed and trusted professional before acting on the information you hear in RAS podcasts. Thanks again for listening.

I regret to inform you that chances are a lot of you will need financial advice. Since we started the Rask Advice business, I've noticed quite a few trends, but one of them is the importance of having confidence in what you're actually saving towards or investing towards.

A lot of people in the Rask community are very capable of managing their own money.

But when it comes to critical points in their life, like retirement, selling a business, scaling a business, getting married, buying your first home, so on and so forth, getting expert advice will actually save you from a bunch of mistakes and give you the confidence to know what it is you're doing and why you're doing it.

If you want to get matched with one of the trusted financial partners that we have, you can just head to rass.au slash financial planning, or you can get in contact with us on any of the RASC websites.

Not only does Rask itself provide financial advice, but we also have trusted partners if we're not the right fit for you. So we can help guide you in the right direction. And that in turn supports us to create more free financial education content like podcasts, courses, and so much more.

Click any timestamp to jump.