Posted
16 November 2026
6 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
May 1, 2026
Episode
299
 ·
48
 min
The show

Australian Property Podcast

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with the investment experts at Rask. It’s all about buying, managing and investing in Australian property.

Listen on your favourite platform

Co-founder of Alcove.

Guest
Lucinda Hartley

Why buying your first home feels impossible (and what to do instead) with Lucinda Hartley

This episode was originally featured on The Australian Finance Podcast.

Transcript
Owen Rask

This podcast is proudly brought to you by Perla, the official brokerage platform of Rask. With Perla, you can effortlessly automate your money, whether you're investing in ETFs or shares from Australia or the US stock market, whether you're a grandparent or setting up a kid's account or your own account.

You can do all of that with full automation on Perla.com. If you want to learn more, head to Perla.com slash Rask. And of course, before you invest in anything, be sure to read the legal documents like the PDS and FSG.

This episode is brought to you by Stripe, helping your business be ready for whatever comes next. And the next shift in how people buy is already happening. Agentic Commerce lets customers discover and purchase directly inside an AI conversation. No checkout page, no friction.

The businesses positioning themselves now are the ones who will lead this channel. Whatever comes next for your business, power it with Stripe. Learn more at stripe.com. Are you a first home buyer struggling to get into the market? What if the problem isn't you, it's the rule book that you've been following?

Today's guest is helping us unpack why the way that your parents bought their first home might not be the way that you can approach it. Stay tuned for this episode. This is a podcast by The Rask Group. It's for educational purposes only.

So please do not make a financial, legal, investment or taxation decision based on solely what you hear in this show.

Welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. We're on a mission to be Australia's most trusted property podcast. I'm Owen Rask, founder of The Rask Group. I'm Pete Borgent, author and buyer's agent. I'm Amy Linardi and I am a buyer's agent. I'm Chris Bates, ex-financial planner and mortgage broker.

Together, we'll take you through every step of your property journey. From first home buyer to decades of property investing.

Today I'm joined by Lucinda Hartley and we are going through how to get in the market, get into your first home, what trade-offs and different considerations that you need to be thinking about, how this landscape's changed from when your parents bought their first house all

or other people that you're hearing stories about, they're already in the market. We want to unpack what things that you need to be looking at, what you can consider, and how you can really start finding home. So Lucinda is the author of the book, Finding Home, that is out now.

Lucinda, welcome to the podcast. Thanks so much for having me, Gemma. Very excited to get into this. As we were talking about before we hit record, this is going to hit home, pun intended, for so many of our listeners. This is something that lots of people are struggling with.

Buying your first home or even thinking about getting to the market is such an overwhelming decision. Yeah. And I feel like it's getting further and further away for a lot of people. So the fact that it financially is getting further away makes everything more complex.

So if you look at the past 20 years, house growth has outpaced wage growth by two times. So the longer you wait, the further behind you get. But it's not only a financial equation. If your home costs 10 to 12 times your income when

10 years ago, it costs five to six times your income. The trade-offs that you have to make are so much greater. It's not only that you're spending more money, but you have to factor in so many other considerations as well.

Yes, that trade-off is so important because there's a trade-off in every aspect of our life, right? Anytime we make a decision, whether it's our cash flow, it's our money, it's our health or exercise, whatever, there is a trade-off. And I think that's where I'd love to focus a lot on today.

And I know I've got your book here and you can see, if you're watching on YouTube, you can see all my notes, my sticky notes from just all the great stuff in there that I wanted to talk about today. So got this, absolutely love it.

But yes, you have the trade-off triangle that we'll go through in a little bit, but let's step back and go, let's actually unpack what's changed. Why? Like, so you said the income ratio. So the rule book has changed.

So what did it look like 20, 30 years ago, which most of us might have seen that, like our parents modeled that for us. What did the rule book look like and why has it changed so drastically? So the world a lot of us grew up in looked something like this.

You know, you grow up, you study hard, you get a good job, you work hard, you buy a home and you live happily ever after. You might go on an annual camping trip to the beach or something like that.

It was much simpler and there was the idea that if you worked hard and saved hard, you would be rewarded by being able to have a stable roof over your head.

Now, tragically, that's actually no longer the case for a lot of people in Australia, that you can work hard, you can save harder, you can save longer, and you're still trying to chase a property market that's running further away.

And part of the problem there is the type of house that we're looking for, the type of ladder that we're on, and I guess our imagination of what this great Australian dream looks like. There's the idea that there's a property ladder that you have to get on it any way you can.

This is the idea that we aspire, at least, you know, there's many stories, but for the majority of cultural narrative, let's simplify and say the majority of people aspire to a standalone house. Yes. Now, I grew up living in many different countries and Australia is really an outlier in that aspiration.

Most of the world live in apartments and high density cities. And I don't look around and think people in Paris or New York City are having a terrible life.

But when we think about how the rule book has changed, if you can't just save your way to a house, then you have to rethink what home looks like in a couple of ways, what finance looks like, but also what the shape and your aspiration for what a home looks like as well.

Yeah, that was one of the things that really resonated with me in your book is just the thought that in Australia, we seem to put so much pressure on what success looks like. And then we define that success as generally owning a freestanding home with a bit of land.

You know, even I know there's

like for myself, not being a first home buyer, but being divorced and having to drastically change the type of home that I now live in, it's still so much of our worth and our self-worth and our success is tied up in that type of home.

But it really, as you say, it needs to shift. And we seem to be the only country that puts so much importance on that dream. Absolutely.

I think there's an idea that this story is that successful adulting, like the sign that you've made it as an adult successfully, is that you own a house, a freestanding house. Now, there's many reasons why we've adopted that narrative, but what we're really seeking is secure shelter.

Now, I think there's a lot of challenges with renting because it's insecure, but it should be culturally okay to rent because you know, it should be as an older person. Lots of countries, right? Yeah. Most countries in Europe, you know, you will have long-term renters and they're not suffering.

Here, I would say you might have challenges, but that's because of the regulation around renting rather than renting is bad. But you know, for argument's sake. And there's also, like you say, you know, you might be living in a different house. I've had that story too.

You know, I was living in a freestanding house following the story. And then after a separation, found myself back in the market where the property price had doubled, my income had halved. I was never going to be able to buy a house again.

And it's been many years of living in apartments and now in a townhouse. And I actually love it. I I actually love the low maintenance living, but it's somehow seen as less than.

It's somehow seen that if you live in an apartment, particularly, heaven forbid, you live in an apartment with a family, that that is somehow second best and that we should all aspire to the lawn. And for some people, that is a great aspiration.

I'm not suggesting that it shouldn't be, but it's more that that's the dominant narrative that I think we really need to question. Yeah. Yes.

So I think we absolutely need to question it and question it in ourselves as well, not just, well, what will other people think and what are society expectations, but how will I feel and will I be happy with it and really challenge why we think we need it one way, just because we've always known, like the example of what we've seen with our parents.

Yeah, it can be really hard to shift that mindset. Yeah. Yeah, I think about it for myself that when I did have a house and look, I appreciate this, you know, and perhaps of the age where I was able to buy with a property market wasn't so astronomical.

But when we had a house, it was a fixer-upper. It was just chores. And some people love it. So if you're someone who loves maintenance, who loves gardening. Just always pottering. Yeah, then it's perfect. It's part of your project and your pride and you're working on this place that you own.

But if you're busy and stressed and you don't like painting and you don't like mowing lawns, then the idea of spending all of your free time doing that is stressful.

So my experience is that I didn't like spending, you know, after a huge week coming home and needing to fix up the backyard as now I come home and there's literally nothing that needs to be done to my house. And I find that quite a relief actually. Yeah.

Yeah, well, I'm in Melbourne for a week right now, seven days, and I just get to leave my house and just lock it up and it's good. So I think, you know, that's an important thing that people need to be hearing as well if they're considering their first home.

And this is one of the things in the trade-off triangle that you talk about is maybe they actually – They want to be thinking more about their lifestyle than what a successful property is.

So can you talk to us about what used to make a good first home and what now might be considered things that we need to be thinking of? So I would say if we look 10, 20 years ago, the first home pathway, you know, we've always had to make some level of trade-offs.

The first home pathway might be that you bought an older house that needed some work but still in a fairly good suburb. And so then over 20 years you would gradually renovate it and then it's probably worth a lot and you've done quite well. Now that's a great story for that time.

And if you can afford it today, it might still be a good story for you. But for many people, even buying a fixer-upper in the right kind of suburbs is still going to be really out of reach.

And so rather than thinking that you're buying your forever home, I like to see life as a series of chapters. that will continue. We have this idea that you need to trade up, trade up, trade up.

But because it takes so long to buy a place and then wait for it to increase in value and then buy another, by the time you've traded up to the family home, your kids are probably 17, 18. They're probably ready to leave again.

And then you're left in the four-bedroom house and they're gone. Yes. And I just wonder, like, rather than having this ladder that we're looking towards trading up and trading up, maybe if we think, well, what does my lifestyle look like now? Because your house is so much more than just your financial investment.

It impacts so many of other areas of your life, your time, your relationships, your work opportunities. So if you're choosing a house that's right for this season, really,

where you're working, whether you're travelling, whether you have kids, what kind of work you're doing, choosing a house for that season might look really different than the next season, but that's okay because you can move. Yes.

And you can look at housing as that series of chapters rather than a ladder where you always have to be bigger and better than the last one.

Yeah, I do see a lot of people waiting on the sidelines for that perfect strategy like we'll buy the fixer-upper and then we'll renovate it and whatever.

But like anything, when I see people have really clear strategies that they want because they've seen them modelled, they tend to sit on the sidelines waiting for that to come up a lot.

Actually, when you were talking, one saying was like repeating in my head, do you know the advice, buy the worst house on the best street? Yeah. Does that still ring true? Like do any of these, like there was all this advice for first homeowners like get the fixer-upper.

Do any of this still apply or is it kind of all out the window and we need to strip back and focus on those trade-offs and priorities first?

I would say that we need a totally different framework, which is why in the book I say that rather than focusing on affordable housing, we need to focus on affordable living. Yes. And I would say the fuel crisis that we're in right now is a great example of that.

So you might have made a choice in order to get the sized home that you want, the freestanding house, you've decided to move an hour away, an hour's commute away. Mm-hmm.

But perhaps what you hadn't factored is that you need a second car that costs an average of $12,000 to $18,000 a year to have an extra car in and running costs, according to RACQ. You've got extra fuel costs, which might have been manageable, but now you're vulnerable to a fuel price increase.

And so now, even though your house was cheaper with the sticker price, you've added all this other costs. let alone your time, into the equation. What I do still think is true around that idea of buying the worst house in the best street is that neighbourhood really, really matters.

It matters on lots of levels. It matters on the level of convenience but also things like your health, your wellbeing, your community. And I would say it's less about buying the worst house on the best street but still being intentional about the neighbourhood. That might mean living in an apartment. Yeah.

And it requires being really reflective and actually understanding your lifestyle, like looking at what your typical day looks like. What does your time look like? What do your relationships look like? Do you have kids and you're wanting grandparents involved?

Are you prepared to move 45 minutes away or is it actually better to be 20 minutes away and live in a smaller house? Yeah. None of these trade-offs are easy.

They're really difficult, but neighbourhood matters on a level that I think people don't often understand because it's not only about, oh, this neighbourhood is better than another. It can actually affect your health.

Like if you've got access to transport, to shops, to amenities close by, you're statistically likely to be happier and healthier than if you don't have those things to the point that it can even affect your life expectancy on some levels. So...

Thinking about these trade-offs, it's not only about comparing one house to another or an apartment to a freestanding house. It's about considering all of the aspects of your life and the neighbourhood is one of them. Yeah, that is so, so true.

And I think we're putting so much emphasis on, is this going to be the stepping stone that builds me wealth or is it the perfect home? But we often do forget to think of those trade-offs.

I think we think about them as a throwaway, oh, you know, it'll be further to commute to or it'll be a bit more annoying to go visit mum and dad. But I I don't think we probably dive into that as much.

So what kind of practical exercises can people be doing to make those trade-off decisions? So for me, go-to is always a spreadsheet, but most people aren't like that. So if somebody's listening and they're going, you know, I was thinking of I just needed to get into my first home as quickly as possible.

What kind of activities, exercises practically can they do to start weighing up those things and see the actual impact, not just the throwaway thought? Absolutely. And I think the thing to caveat here is that it's a very individual choice.

So the trade-offs that I make or that you make will be different to what listeners might make in your own personal view of this.

I mean, I talk about 10 different areas of your life in the book, but if I was to boil those down to kind of the core areas that you need to really think about is start with understanding your values and where does your idea of home come from?

So if you're diehard wanting to buy a house with a picket fence and you're wanting that vision, it might be the right house for you. But I would question whether that's a cultural narrative that you've inherited. Yeah. or whether it's something that you really want. I'd ask that question.

The most important exercise you can do is look at a day in your life. You know, look at your calendar. Where do you go? What do you spend time on? You know, I often say, like, if you show me how you spend your time, I'll show you what your priorities are.

If you're spending lots of time working, maybe you're in a stage of life where you're building a company, you know, where convenience is really, really important. Can you afford to add a commute into that? Maybe you're the opposite. Maybe you're actually really flexible.

You can work from home right now and you can afford the commute and it really would be the right choice. So there isn't a right or wrong, but I would say understand your values, take a deep look at what your life looks like and you can map it.

draw yourself in the middle, draw all the places that you need to regularly go. How long does it take you to get from each of those places and add that up? Like, have you got time in your week to do it? Yeah. And then I would think about, you know,

your home, your home and your neighborhood as being an extension of one another.

And by that, I mean, you know, if we look at how, I guess we've lived in Australia, particularly over the past 40 or 50 years, houses have got bigger and bigger as we've started to include more and more of the activities within the house. So we need more bedrooms.

We need one per child. It's not okay to share anymore. Many of us grew up sharing rooms. I I'm not suggesting you should have your kids share rooms, but, you know, culturally sometimes it's worth questioning why do we think that's okay or not okay.

You know, we used to go to the playground, now we need to have play equipment in the backyard. We used to go out to the cafe, now we need a barista grade coffee machine inside.

Now, again, none of these are wrong choices, but if you need to own all of those things, it's quite expensive and then you're going to need a home that is either further away or costs more. you could share all of those things in the neighbourhood.

So you might live in an apartment, but if it was in the right location, you could go to the cafe every day, you could walk to a co-working space, you could be opposite a park and, you know, outsource your lawn mowing and your outdoor activities to the local park. So location matters. But

Yeah. So when we're thinking about lifestyle, it's not just thinking about, you know, you as an individual, but what's in the neighborhood that you could share and borrow. And that might mean you need to own less and your house could, you could choose a different type of home.

Yeah, that makes a lot of sense in regards to the expenses and things as well. So the trade-off is a cheaper home and you can afford to outsource more of those things.

And like your example, making coffee at home versus going to the cafe, maybe if you've downscaled on the type of house, you have more time, money, freedom to go and spend on those things that add value of getting a coffee and being out and being social and getting all those other benefits as well.

I want to tell you a story about how the new Rask platform came to be. In 2025, everyone was still waking up to this idea that AI was going to have an impact on the world. And it wasn't until mid to late 2025 that it really hit me like a ton of bricks.

that time, I thought, what can I do with this new tool, this innovative technology? That set in motion what has now become a totally new Rask platform, which you can find at rask.au. It is 100% free to create an account and start using tools. But what did it actually do?

And what does it do for you? At Rask, we've produced thousands of podcasts. probably 20,000 articles were written on investing and all these different types of things like personal finance, superannuation, you name it. So we really needed a place where we could bring all of that together for the entire community.

That can be found at rask.au. Whether you're a retiree, a business builder, or a student of finance, you should go and check it out. But once we built the platform, we realized that that wasn't enough. So in 2026, we've decided to launch a new community known as the Rask Ultra community.

This is the deepest, most advanced part of what we do as a business and as a community of investors and builders. We want to build a network of people that can come together and share ideas in a new ecosystem that we've built just for you.

You can find out more, like I said, by Googling Rask Ultra or by creating a free account at rask.au and see if Ultra is right for you. Yeah, I remember when my first son was born, we lived in an apartment that fit into about two car parking spaces.

It was tiny by all stretches of the imagination and no one could imagine that we could possibly have a child in such a place. But one of the things I loved about it is it was directly next door to a cafe.

This apartment was behind a shop and it was actually faster to go and order a coffee next door than it was to make one. I timed it. Yeah.

And sure, going to the cafe once or twice a day is expensive and I never would have done that if I had a really like huge mortgage. But we made a decision to live in this tiny compact house. But if you live in a house that's that tiny, you have to get out.

Yes. And so we got out by making best friends with all the cafe staff and that felt like, and it was an extension of our house and I could go there twice a day that have my order just as I walked in and it felt sense of community.

So there's, there's things that we can actually start to think about the neighborhood as being part of your home and it can be a creative way to problem solve like space issues. Yeah, yes, I love that.

As you were talking, I was thinking, like I said, I've got a smaller home than I'm used to. We used to have a big Queenslander that we renovated and made for entertaining purposes. Just loved always having people over.

And I sometimes look around my house and I just go, oh, this is not what I'm used to. Like I want that big entertaining space. But when I think about it, I travel so much for work. With the kids, I have them every second week.

Like my lifestyle, I probably would be entertaining maybe once a month. Hmm. And then the rest of the time, so you talked about the ordinary day. If I think about the ordinary day, my house is perfect for that. It's small, low maintenance.

There's no yard because for the everyday it suits, but for that one-off and I like that one-off where I want to entertain, I could go and do that somewhere else. It could be a picnic at the park. It could be at somebody else's house where I don't have to like clean and stuff.

You know, I can get that feeling so many other ways without having to sacrifice every single day by paying for it. Absolutely. Yeah. So we've talked about the types of things that have changed, the rule book, how that's changed. We talked about how the income to value ratio has significantly moved.

Have you seen a direct, so you work in mortgage broking as well. You are an expert in this space. Have you seen a direct impact with the government

incentives and grants and things and how that's changed behavior around first home and not just, not so much the property prices, but in, I guess, the strategies that people implement to get into their first homes. Like, do you see a correlation between behavior and when those things change?

Yeah, there's certainly a big correlation with government incentives and first-time buyer behaviour. And unfortunately, you know, if you've followed the story of grants and incentives, they tend to elevate property prices rather than having the desired impact of making it more affordable. The biggest impact...

last year with the expansion of the first home guarantee scheme, making a 5% deposit available to any first home buyer meant that the more affordable homes across Australia jumped 10 to 12%. Yeah. So the competition in that space now grows. Yeah. So I guess it,

was intended to make housing more accessible, but making that much capital available in the market all at the same time to everybody, uh, meant that it had the impact of houses that we know being a hundred, $150,000 more than they were three months prior. And suddenly they're out of reach.

So competition is really fierce. Uh, With my work at Zuru Home Loans, so we have a 0% deposit mortgage product. Where it probably doesn't have the same impact as the 5% scheme is that it only affects hundreds of people a year, not every first home buyer.

But saving for a deposit is the biggest barrier for first home buyers. And there's a lot of people who are in the situation where they're earning good money, they're working really hard, but you can't save faster than the property market is growing. Yeah.

And where one of the cultural myths I think that we need to dispel around risk now is that, you know, one of the reasons why you needed to have a deposit is to show that, you know, you're a safe financial or is to show that you're reliable financially. You're a good bet for

the banks. Yeah. That you know how to save, that you know how to manage money. But we work with people every day who are doing everything right.

But when you're paying $1,200 a week in rent, when your food bill and your grocery bill and your fuel prices have doubled, how are you meant to save? Mm-hmm. it actually in many ways, being able to pay rent consistently, being able to manage your expenses to me is good evidence of fiscal responsibility.

And if you can pay your rent like that, you're likely to be able to pay a mortgage as well, which means I don't feel lending, you know, 100% of the property value is risky anymore. So that's a big shift. I think that

The deposit, I know that banks need the deposit for many reasons around their own risk protection. But if you're looking at simply from a fiscal responsibility lens, I don't think that's the case anymore. I think that's really shifted. I do see, sorry, go ahead.

I see a lot of frustration with people when they go, the bank won't give me this money, but my rent is more than that currently. And you're just like, yeah, I just don't really feel for them. Yeah, it's really, really challenging.

And I think when you're looking to, you know, the amount of money that you need to buy in the market, it's a lot, you know, repayments are high. I see more and more first home buyers, particularly younger people, being much more accepting of apartments, townhouses, units, other... types.

I do see that most people, and this might be you, I don't know, still see them as a stepping stone rather than the end game. When I guess I question why that needs to be the case as an asset class. So sure, as your family gets bigger, you need more space.

Does that necessarily mean that you need a house or do you just need a bigger apartment? That's something that people often don't think through. But I do see, I guess, a shift in that there are more people with an openness to living in particularly townhouses and smaller things for affordability.

It could be, I guess, a bit like a boomerang asset. If you think about like, if you started out with an investment and then you, the goal is to step up a lot of the time in retirement, we see people going back to apartments. Yeah.

So if you think about it like that, did you ever need the minimum, the middle step? would be a great question to kind of ask. Or maybe, you know, I haven't done this personally, but maybe you rent that. Maybe you own the apartment.

You rent a house for the decade where you've got teenagers and they need more space. And then you go back to the apartment when they leave.

Because I think there's a lot of cases, you know, we look at the empty nesters, you know, people sitting on four or five bedroom homes and there's two of them there. They've got all the children have grown up.

More dusting, more cleaning, more maintenance and more money tied up in an asset that's not able to produce them income. Yeah. So there's lots of benefits to that. I am a big fan of rent vesting.

So for people that aren't sure on what that is, it's when you rent where you want to live, for example, or a family home that suits your needs for that period, for that chapter. I was a rent vester for a long time. Long time. Three years. Yeah. We call that a long time.

It felt like a long time. And now I've just gone back into a family home, but that made sense for me to be renting in the area that I wanted, but investing elsewhere. So I also think that's something that we need to shift our mindset and go, is that success for me?

Is that a path that makes sense? And it could be, you know, that you do have a property that suits you for a portion and you come back at different times. I love your coining of that, of it being a season and how it can work for you.

Yeah, and it's a different mindset when we've grown up with this idea that the forever home is what we aspire to. But, you know, your life is not the same. My life is totally different than it was 10 years ago and even more different than it was 20 years ago.

So why should my housing be the same? You know, we can evolve with the different seasons and chapters that we live in. I also think there's a myth that only...

you know, something on land, like house and land is the only asset class that goes up in value or that goes up the most. I actually think that's been very much disproven, particularly in the last five years.

I think house price growth on the whole still does increase more in value than units and apartments. But in the right suburb and the right asset type, we're actually seeing movement in a whole lot of different ways. So there are pockets of Sydney and Brisbane where units are outpacing house growth.

And so if you do your research and you understand the suburb, it might be a really great investment too. Yeah, that's a really good point. Because I know that I always thought that as well, that apartments wouldn't do as well. And the data is showing us very differently.

Do you think that this last five years, like, I wish we had a crystal ball, right? But do you think this is a trend we'll keep seeing? Because we have to make a shift, don't we? So is this a trend that should keep going? Or is this a knock-on effect of COVID? Like,

Is this something we can rely on? Well, if we look at population is continuing to increase, a couple of hundred thousand people a year at a minimum, they need to go somewhere. So you're either going up or you're going out.

And cities are already going out, Australian cities are already going out a heck of a long way. Like you're talking 40, 50 kilometres to get an affordable place on the fringe. How much further can they go out?

Probably not much further because it's not just about the housing, it's about the infrastructure that goes with it. And so, you know, there is the opportunity to go up and that's happening in a lot of places, particularly Melbourne, Brisbane, Sydney, but other centres as well.

So I do think that we'll see both happening as their small population growth that it's the... As we're seeing more population growth, we're seeing growth in both apartments in some areas and houses in some areas.

So I think it really all, you know, I hate to say it depends, but it always comes down to the area. We say that all the time.

Yeah, there's going to be pockets where house and land doesn't really grow in the way that you expect it to or might even go down or sideways. And there's going to be areas where apartments go up in value and the reverse is going to be true too in different suburbs.

So it really pays to understand those dynamics. Yeah. Yeah, and as we're talking, I'm also thinking my brain is just trained to think of property as wealth, right? Yes. But maybe it doesn't need to. If it's your lifestyle, it's your safety and your security, and it did go backwards, maybe that's okay.

Maybe you're not buying it. Like if you do your trade-off decisions and work out why this is the property for you, maybe it doesn't matter if it goes backwards. backwards or it doesn't grow at the rate that some others will.

Because if it's ticking all these other boxes, you could be investing and building wealth outside. And that is literally your safety, your security, your community. I'm just thinking that maybe that's also a hurdle that we need to get over, that not everything needs to be a very sound financial wealth building strategy.

It has all of these other benefits and our wealth is tied to our safety and security. So if that How does it grow but it provides you that?

Yeah, when you look at the origins of the Great Australian Dream, which I talk about in the book and going back to, you know, where does this kind of ideology come from, it wasn't really about being a first-time buyer or getting on the ladder or accumulating wealth.

The promise of it was financial stability, the idea that if you owned a house, that you would have more security and could therefore work harder and build wealth in other areas of your life. And I actually think that that's kind of the primary goal.

I think if you can build financial growth through property, then absolutely you should make the most of that. But the comparison that I give when you're thinking about the home that you live in, it's a really different equation if you're looking at investment property. Yes.

But when you're looking at the home that you live in, imagine if you chose a life partner just based on their credit score. Or just based on their savings capacity. And you... Or how, you know, if you only looked at your life partner through that lens, I think you would miss a lot.

Yeah.

So when you're thinking about the home that you want to live in, sure, you do want to think about finance, but as one of the pillars alongside your time, your relationships, your community, your health, your work opportunities, and when you get them all right or you get them right for you, then you're actually able to make trade-offs that are much more balanced and potentially open up more opportunities for housing that you hadn't thought of before.

I agree. So we touched on lending before and now you've also mentioned credit scores. So I want to talk about two, I want you to go through two things for me. The importance of credit scores, because I think that's a misconception. I feel like it didn't really matter years ago.

It was a very American thing. So I'd love to dive into that. And also we used to have this figure thrown around that a mortgage stress was if you spent more than 30% of your income. Can we talk about those two things? Yeah. So credit score, I believe, is really important right now.

So in the work that we do at Zeru Home Loans, we've got a minimum credit score in the 600s, 650s, or we look at for an individual, which is fairly high. It's in the kind of good range if you've done your credit score before.

The reason for that is that we're lending 100% of the property purchase price. And so we need to be sure that there is like a good fiscal history behind the people that we're working with.

You can really improve your credit score or take a nosedive by all of the other debts that you have in your life that you accumulate without even thinking about. Your afterpay account, you might have three credit cards. Do you use them?

That couch that you bought from Harvey Norman two years ago on finance, having a car loan. When you add up all of these little pieces of debt that might seem insignificant in and of themselves- They can impact your borrowing capacity by $100,000, $200,000.

And so if you are able to close some of the credit cards, particularly if you're not using them, pay off your car loan, you can potentially borrow a lot more for your mortgage. And I think while that's not directly your credit score, having lots of smaller debts does decrease your credit score.

And you're going to have more options, be able to get better interest rates, be able to get better loans if you're able to manage some of those other smaller debts. Yeah.

I remember a while ago I would hear the advice from older generations saying as soon as you can get a credit card or a personal loan so that you can build your credit score and show that you're good at repayments and things.

Is that a strategy or does that do more damage than good? Do we need to go into debt to build a credit score or how does it get built if we don't have debts? I actually must say that I –

am not the expert on all of the factors that contribute to how credit scores are assessed. What I know is that the more debt that you have, the likelihood is that your credit score, even if you're on time with everything, will not be as high. Yeah.

because it shows perhaps that you've not necessarily that you've got bad spending habits, but just that you've got less borrowing capacity and you've got less ability to pay that.

So it is something that I'm not a financial advisor by any stretch of the imagination, but I think that I ask people to consider because I think they're often not aware that by buying everything on credit and paying it later, even if you pay it off every month, it's going to impact your borrowing capacity.

Yes. Yes. So the three things, the three things that impact your borrowing capacity, dependence, any debt, regardless if you use it or not. So your, um, the limits on your credit cards and things, and then your credit score, like your past behavior. So they've got, I've

Of course, your income and all of that, but they're the ones that can just really just knock your credit ability to borrow, your borrowing potential really quickly, right? Really fast.

And, you know, we work with people all the time every day and they might have the same income and you've got two people earning $100,000 a year. One of them might be able to borrow $50,000, $70,000, $100,000 more than the other one.

They're earning the same because one's got a car loan and a couple of credit cards. Now, dependents also affect your borrowing capacity. And, you know, I guess it's an assumption. I think it's reasonable that, you know, you have more expenses when you've got kids. I certainly know that's the case for me.

That's the case for me.

So I understand that, but it can make it challenging as well. Yeah. So before we move on to some insights on the trade-offs, and I'd love to pick your brain on what makes sense and what people kind of regret, the 30% rule.

So we've debunked a few of the other rules, the best house on the worst street and things. Is paying more for your mortgage than 30% of your income mortgage stress? Is that a thing anymore? Are we just all in stress all the time regardless? Yeah.

Well, it is still considered mortgage stress, but I think the reality is that almost all of us are in mortgage stress. So yeah, the traditional rule is don't spend more than 30% of your income on rent or mortgage.

If you look at the statistics, renters are spending about 32%, I think it is, just over 30% on average. It's not everybody on rent. Mortgage holders, closer to 50%.

sometimes even closer to 60% in Sydney. So that would score on that scale as extreme mortgage stress. Now, I do think people are struggling. I do think it's really difficult to spend 50% or 60% of your income on your mortgage.

I don't think that that's something that we should just accept as normal and carry on. But I do think that it is a reality and that we should acknowledge.

So when it comes to other cost of living pressures, people are already really under a lot of pressure with so much of their income going on mortgage or rent. The other trade-off I guess you're making is that you're buying stability, you're buying potentially you're investing in an asset that is going to grow.

So there's other trade-offs that might long-term be beneficial around that. That make them more comfortable with making that decision. Yeah, that's right. But the 30% rule I think is dead. Yeah. Yeah. Unfortunately, unfortunately. Okay. So more money for coffees and avocado and toast and enjoying the community.

Yeah. So in the book, we talk a lot, you talk a lot about trade-offs and we have in this episode, you've got the trade-off triangle, the decision-making around that, um, What do you think when people apply the lens, so you've got the 10?

There's 10 pillars of, I guess, if you think of affordable living being all of the costs that surround your housing, your time, your community, your health, your relationships, et cetera. So there's 10 aspects that make up affordable living, including your money and your finances.

Do you think you can put them in priority order or does that really come down to the individual? Like is there the top three that you say these are where you need to start? Yeah.

When I was writing this book, I really just hoped that I would be able to have a completely objective view on if we all did this, then this outcome would happen, cause and effect. Yeah.

What I learned, the more I read, the more people I interviewed, the more I looked into this space, it's immensely complex. Yeah. And so while I don't think there is one right answer, I think accepting that there isn't a right answer is actually quite liberating because you can –

if you think that somehow you need to buy your forever home or work steps towards it, that in and of itself is kind of a cage. If you're able to, and it might be the right one for you.

I'm not saying, you know, this is all about free choice, but if you want to make a different decision, the book gives you some guardrails on knowing how to identify what you want.

So these 10 pillars, rather than giving you, I guess, the answer, they're kind of 10 questions that you need to ask yourself and understand what it means for you before you make your own trade-offs. And they're really in three categories. They're about you, like understanding yourself and your lifestyle and your ordinary day.

They're about your home. Mm-hmm. So what is it about your space that you need? And it can be a small one or a large one, but we have different preferences. And then there's a bunch about your community. So your home and your community and your relationships and what that matters.

So you can put them on a matrix and you can force rank them if you want to. But what I find is that most people will find that there are certain aspects of each one that resonate with them. And it's about choosing what's right for you. Yeah.

I feel like a lot of the time, like I say, like we say it on the podcast all the time, is if you're thinking about buying your first home, the first step is to talk to a mortgage broker, look at your borrowing capacity. But I think you're making such a valid point here.

We probably need to actually step back and define what home is to us.

Yes, you can do all of the actual number crunching, but along that journey at some point, and probably at the start is the healthier time to do it, is to really dive into what home is and what these trade-offs are that you that you're going to, um, yeah, make and decide. Yeah, absolutely.

When I, you know, I was looking into this space and there's so much advice out there. Um, it can be a little bit overwhelming, but I did find that almost all of the advice about buying a home focused on my financial situation, how to save, how to get a

Now, if you haven't done that process, you absolutely need to do it because it's your ceiling. It's your hard constraint. There's no point imagining a future if you absolutely will never be able to afford it. So yes, you need to do it.

But with my analogy before about, you know, imagine choosing a life partner by only knowing their credit score.

If you've only looked at the financial trade-offs and you haven't looked at all of the emotional decisions, all of the relational decisions, all of the work decisions that go into your home, you've only really answered half the equation.

So what I would suggest is that you absolutely do need to answer the financial questions. Yes, speak to a broker, understand, get your finances in order. Everyone should do that. There's three chapters in the book on how to think about that. But don't stop there.

Look at that as your kind of ceiling or your hard constraint. And then within that, think, well, if I'm going to spend $600,000, whatever it is, that could take a shape in a lot of different ways.

And you need to really deeply reflect on your own ideas of home and values to answer that. Love that. Okay. There has been so many insights into this.

And I honestly, I think this is things that I should have been doing before I bought my first home and even before I bought the recent one. It's been really, really insightful, but I wanted to ask, so we've talked about trade-offs, we've talked about all those decisions.

Is there one thing that you see first homeowners as It's like a regret, the one thing that they tend to get wrong when they're either going through that process or the fact that they haven't gone through it. Is there a common denominator that's a regret with first-time owners? Yeah.

Yeah, certainly the biggest one that I see is location. So you can improve your house but you can't change the location after you've bought it.

And I think in order to chase a particular type of house, people might make more sacrifices about the location than they're aware that they're making and then you're a bit stuck because, you know,

You might have chosen a house that had the right benchtops, that had the right trimmings, but actually the way that impacts your life from a neighbourhood perspective isn't what you expected. So I would just ask first home buyers to consider the neighbourhood as being as important as the type of house that

Now, everyone would want their ideal house in an ideal suburb. Of course, everyone wants that. If you assume you can't have that, you're going to have to trade off the size or the quality of your house based on the location.

And, you know, location doesn't mean that you have to live in an apartment in a downtown area. You could absolutely choose a regional town. You might choose to live in an outer suburb. That might all be the right thing for you.

But just know that the location is much harder to change than anything within your house. Yes. You can paint the walls and you can put up the white picket fence. You can't move the house in most cases. Oh, Lucinda, this has been amazing.

So if people want to connect with you, they want to buy the book, where can they find you? The book, it'll be, I assume in all good bookstores, it'll be online. Yeah. The books. The audio book.

Yeah, there will be an audio book coming if you're not sick of my voice after today's podcast. Yes, it's on Amazon. It's in all good bookstores. You can find additional resources around some of the themes and topics on my website, just lucindahartley.com forward slash finding home.

You can follow me online in various places, YouTube, Instagram, TikTok. It's Housing with Lucinda. Okay. Thank you so much. Now, I know you said there'll never be a second book, but I said that as well and I'm eating my words. So we'll have you back when the next book is out. Yeah, hopefully.

Thanks so much, Gemma.

Thanks for tuning into the Australian Property Podcast. If you love the show, why not subscribe or leave us a review on Apple or Spotify. And if you want to work with me, Amy, Pete or Chris, you'll find links in your podcast player to get in contact with us.

Thank you for listening to this episode of the Australian Property Podcast. We're huge advocates of getting the right advice at the right time from the right people. That's why it's important to understand that this podcast episode contained general financial information only.

It is not designed to be specific or personalized to your financial, tax or legal situation. With property, the check sizes are pretty big. So it's important you get advice from a licensed and trusted professional before acting on the information you hear in RAS podcasts. Thanks again for listening.

I regret to inform you that chances are a lot of you will need financial advice. Since we started the Rask Advice business, I've noticed quite a few trends, but one of them is the importance of having confidence in what you're actually saving towards or investing towards.

A lot of people in the RAS community are very capable of managing their own money.

But when it comes to critical points in their life, like retirement, selling a business, scaling a business, getting married, buying your first home, so on and so forth, getting expert advice will actually save you from a bunch of mistakes

and give you the confidence to know what it is you're doing and why you're doing it. If you wanna get matched with one of the trusted financial partners that we have, you can just head to rask.au slash financial planning, or you can get in contact with us on any of the Rask websites.

Not only does Rask itself provide financial advice, but we also have trusted partners if we're not the right fit for you. So we can help guide you in the right direction. And that in turn supports us to create more free financial education content like podcasts, courses, and so much more.

Click any timestamp to jump.