Curious about upgrading?
Wondering where to start?
Complex questions that need answers?
Is there a better structure for you?
"They managed to navigate my complex expat income and even got my Google RSU income approved as well."
"I highly recommend Alcove to anyone looking for a mortgage broker who is responsive, trustworthy, and truly cares about their clients. Thanks again to the whole team for making the process such a positive experience!"
"As founders, we're constantly jumping between things so having a partner that handled the details & made the process super clear made the buying process breezy for us. Very happy with the experience!"
“It almost felt like it was his responsibility to make it clear to me, not my responsibility to understand it.”
“I've been pretty much fully leveraged the whole time. So the sounding board on that, in terms of what was achievable, what wasn't — I think trust is just built along that.”
"Alcove has been a great partner. They look after my audience properly, keep things simple, and deliver real value. I’ve got full confidence referring clients knowing they’ll get honest, straightforward advice."
"Property is one of the biggest financial decisions people make. Alcove stood out because they take a strategic approach to lending - helping clients structure property and debt decisions in a way that genuinely supports their broader financial plans."
Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.


Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
Behavioural economist Evan Lucas joins Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates to unpick what human behaviour does to property markets, five years on from the lockdowns. The conversation runs from stamp duty bottlenecks to dopamine, super balances and the moment a property becomes a home.
In this episode, we're talking with behavioural economist Evan Lucas and we're going to explore how human behaviour drives property markets. In particular, we want to know how we've adapted in the five years since the pandemic and in what ways have we gone back to normal and what changes have stuck.
And how we view property across the generations and our attitudes towards those in different cohorts. Is this helpful when considering solutions to a housing crisis? And we're also going to discuss the concept of value as we know that Evan's been doing some thinking in this space. Welcome to the elephant in the room.
This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about. I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location Location Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
Hi, I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, currently ranked number three in the MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Awards. Before we get started, everything we talk about today is not personal advice and we recommend you engage the services of a licensed and experienced professional.
Our guest today is Evan Lucas, a leading voice at the intersection of money, economics, and human behavior. Passionate about making the complex simple, he helps individuals, corporates, and nations make better financial decisions. And over the past 18 years, his expertise has taken him across the Netherlands, the UK, and back here to Australia.
Evan is also a familiar face. You might have seen him on the television. You know, that old-fashioned media? Yeah.
Is that black box in your room?
That's it. He's a regular on ABC's News, Brekkie, Sunrise, Today's Show, The Project, Sky News. He's also had several stints on SBS's Insight and as a co-host of Channel 10's The Brighter Side. He also hosts his own podcast, which he's just started, which I have listened to, Exchanges with Evan Lucas.
And today he's here to take us on a journey of fresh insights, bold ideas and a glimpse into the future of property consumers. We are definitely looking forward to this discussion. Evan, thank you for coming along.
Thank you for having me. I'm a little bit worried with that sort of introduction there, Veronica, but this is going to be great. The stakes are high. You and I have been riffing on and off at PIPA events about basically all the stuff he just talked about.
And you're right, it is a bit of my passion. The last five years has been one of the most fundamentally amazing things in behavioral finance that I've ever seen. So we'll get into all that. Chris, good to see you, my friend. It's nice to be on your podcast.
Mate, I feel like I'm on your podcast right now.
You've got a bigger intro than me. Professional. It is going to be a good chat. And that's a nice shirt you're wearing, by the way. Best shirt I've seen on the podcast. But ultimately, let's talk about that obsession there, which you spoke about.
And what do you think about the Australian obsession with property? As someone who sort of studies behavioral economics and just from the outside, if you sort of landed in Australia, what do you think of it?
I think that's the term obsession I think is a really probably a good one Chris in terms of the way that we work I mean this is going to be a really broad very very maybe I'm stretching the band a bit hard with this sort of analogy but we are a nation of DIY we love the DIY we love the fact that we actually have the ability to change things we pride ourselves on being outdoors we pride ourselves in having you know neighborhood communities in terms of how we operate so I think
What I would look at immediately with regards to that answer with the behavior is you look at a player like Bunnings. So Bunnings is a really fascinating roundabout way of saying we will actually now have it in our vernacular.
Going to Bunnings and thinking about doing DIY is actually part of culture in this country. Why? Because you can then go out and get what you need for your property and do it yourself. You take great pride in it. Property is also the only investable asset out there
that you can actually physically change yourself. If you look at something like a business, you can be CEO, but it's more likely than not you're going to have shareholders and a board. They're going to get in the way.
If you look at government bonds, et cetera, that's controlled by the government and it's only basically through issuance, et cetera, et cetera. So that's why all of that together, coupled with the culture that we have, Property is an obsession in this country.
It's been part of an obsession pretty much in the post-Second World War basis. But you would argue even before that, if you look at what was going on during the gold rush, it wasn't just getting the gold, it was about getting the land.
And if you look through the 1850s and through to about the 1890s, land grab, let's call it
probably what it needs to be called land grab was becoming adverted commas at the time an obsession for you know settlers in terms of where it is so it is ingrained in our behavior it's ingrained in our thinking and today even though you might hear gen zedders and those of you listening gen zedders out there you might say you're not going to get into property but you're at an age where that's a hard thing to basically be a fact because time will catch you
It will catch you. It will be there that all of a sudden you will want the ability to control your destiny and therefore control the shelter that you live in.
But there's a funny point you make that to be honest, because I remember back, you know, five years, the share society, right? I'm never going to own, uh, Eric talked about bunnies. I'm not going to own a lawnmower. I'll get it on the local, uh, share lawnmower that I'll share.
I'll never own a house. I'll just use Airbnb. And that sort of, there was that, you know, um, my proliferation of, of share economy. Um, I think that's all flipped in the last few years, right? And a lot of the younger generation, we've gone from, I never want to own.
I'll just be a rent vested to actually, no, no, no. I don't want to rent anymore. This is horrible. I can't even get a rental. My rent's gone up. And I really just want that security and stability. And this is even pre-kids.
They're getting to that couple stage and their desire to own has been there, which has just gone through generation to generation. But on that obsession side, I mean, like all addictions, like there's always a consequence. What do you reckon for the Australian society?
What's the consequence of all the problem that we've got because we've been so obsessed with owning land and buying property?
Wow. Okay. How long is this podcast? I just want to go back to one thing that I agree with completely about what you said with regards to the couple and the moving around from the shared society scenario is what we can't control.
And this is a fundamental sort of comment that always comes from Warren Buffett is that the one thing he can't buy is time, right? You can't buy time. You can't buy it and press pause and stop it. You can...
run with it you can gain it but you can't buy it and so it also gets back to your point there chris is that you forget time will get you with regards to life and life cycles you go from being for a single you go to a couple you then go to a possibly a family and so on and so forth you can fall in and out of those scenarios over time but in general the population moves that way so
That is the catch around when everybody says, I'm never going to buy a property. The other thing is, and this is to partly answer your question because I could go on forever around it and there's no real right or wrong answer.
The reason we're obsessed with it, the clash that we're having and we're seeing that right now with, you know, the amount of supply of housing into the market is governments also know that the obsession is also probably a fundamental right.
And that clash, right, between aspiration of owning your own property and fairness, right, that's government policy in terms of how they look at things and where they sit. It's also then going from I will never get it to the aspiration of I want it and how that also starts to play into it.
You then have people that vote and we're about to come up to elections. We're recording this just before an election is going to be called. You can see the policies, designs of all colors and shapes and sizes of political parties to –
affect that behavior the behavior that goes i want to own my own home i want to control my own destiny and then we get all these different things like first homeowner scrapping of of stamp duties or you know rent to build or all of these new policies that just basically go into your question chris is that the australian culture and psyche is also built very much into what we want and therefore it's built into what politicians will give us and the ability to get access to property
And there's an interesting pool there, isn't there? Because 11 million of us own property, right? And roughly every year you've got about 160,000 that want to buy a property for the first time.
And if you're going to look at how many people vote and whether property prices have to come down far enough to give one cohort of 160,000 buyers
to be able to get in because then, you know, the market will take on again, even off again, even if you brought down prices, so one year's worth of first home buyers to get in easily, or even double the amount, then the market will reset itself and that's the economics of it, right?
The demand will take off. Oh, I deserve that. I'll go off again.
You're literally just quoting U10 economics. I mean, this is the catch with it in terms of, yeah, by all means.
I mean, like, for instance, let's look at, I mean, it's state by state, I get that, but the 600,000, 700,000, wherever you happen to be in the country around the scrapping of the stamp duty for first homeowners, all it's doing is creating a bottleneck. It's just creating a demand attraction
to a certain cohort of property that in the end, let's also be honest, blows out from what it's worth because of the demand. So a property that probably is fair value between half a million and 600,000 becomes a property value between 600,000 on the nose.
You then lose those that can't go above it because they'll have to pay stamp duty and those that are in the 600,000 to 650,000.
So it is, it's not in the behavior, it's just simple economics that you're creating bottlenecks because the supply side, and that's what you're also alluding to there, Veronica, is the biggest problem in terms of where we are. I mean, this, and I've listened to your guys' podcast over and over.
I know you go on about it all the time, but the supply of property and how it's, it's not the supply, it's how it's supplied. Yeah. I think the language is different. And I think that's what we get lost here is how it's supplied is what's not meeting the mark.
I mean, we've got an incredible amount of apartments that are coming onto the parade of the market over the next five years. But that's not what people want. People want the soil underneath the apartment. They want the land.
And that gets back to Chris's question way back before, which is that our obsession with land is what it is. Detached houses, semi-detached houses, not apartments. Yeah.
And that's interesting too, because the pain and gain report, Coologic bring that out every quarter and that came out a week or so ago. And that showed very clearly three key areas where the biggest losses were for the December 24 quarter.
And you had something like 37% of Melbourne inner apartments sold at a loss in that quarter. There was something like 30% in Ryde, I think it was, and I think 22% in Parramatta. They were the top three.
And there were other double digit percentages across the country that are heavily populated with reasonably newly built unit stock. And so the resale, the first time resale of those properties Is that a loss?
And I've got another podcast and an online course to help first home buyers learn the process of buying property. And we actively discourage them for going and buying that stuff for that exact reason, that they're going to... elevate their chances of losing money.
And that's not a good first step on the property ladder. So it's not only do they not want it, but then that feeds into the fact that it's a bad investment and a bad first rung on the property ladder anyway.
And a bad experience.
And a bad experience.
That is key.
Some of them don't even end up owning anything after that.
Correct. So that's the other part of it is the experience, the burnt. I mean, you've seen me talk about this before, Veronica, is there is nothing more visceral than loss in human beings. And particularly with property, because it has gearing attached to it, the loss is more and more acute.
I've always said that when you talk about the beauty of leverage is that it's like using a power tool. That's the property analogy. And the fact that if you use a power tool properly, you can build your house really, really quickly. If you use it wrong, you'll cut your fingers off.
And it's the same concept. When you look at that, because I think the other thing I found fascinating about paying numbers from CoreLogic was that the time that they'd owned it, right? These are properties that are six to seven to eight to nine years old.
Yeah, yeah.
When you start to get that concept that, you know, property basically always gains and away we go. And, you know, by year nine particularly, you would have thought you'd have some or reasonable amount of gains, right? And they're losing money.
And that is, again, this concept of the Australian psyche is that property never loses. Now, I've been on the record saying the Australian property market's fascinating because it doesn't tend to lose. People tend to sit on their properties during downtimes.
But there's no one thing as the Australian property market that I think is the other part of the answer.
Yeah. Evan, you're a money markets guy, right? So you've been around money for a long time. And I think I was on this journey as well. Like, you know, you understand that, you know, you get into financial advice, for example, and it's marketing everywhere, right?
Pick this stock, pick this fund, build this portfolio this way. And you sort of naively sort of think that you can do it, right? You sort of fall for the marketing and this is what consumers do as well, right? They think that the people who are doing that can do it as well.
But at some point, you know, some advisors realize they can't and then they go, hang on a sec, there's all these other things called behaviors that, you know, humans are basically stuffing it up on themselves, right? And they potentially should just go, when did that sort of light bulb, the behavioral economics,
sort of come for you and can you sort of explain it to our listeners and why you believe it matters so much when you're investing is understanding this side of the equation?
Wow. Okay. That's brilliant. I think the first time I saw that was when I was in the Netherlands working on the Dutch Stock Exchange.
And I was working in sell-side research, as they refer to it, which is basically writing all those research reports that if you do work in it, you see it over and over. And
The thing that caught my attention when I was doing that is that even with the guardrails, not controls, guardrails of things like waterfall data and all of them, like the inputs that were going into the systems and into what was referred to as the key.
So the actual projects that actually drove the numbers to sort of evaluate whatever it happened to be. that the bias of the analyst could still manipulate those numbers, right? So you could actually see that they would talk together.
Now, admittedly, a lot of the time they weren't doing it in Dutch, so I would miss a lot of it, but I was getting a very decent gist of it because they then realized I'm listening and they'd immediately click and speak in English.
that they would basically confer about their view of a sector or their view about Dutch housing or German manufacturing or French aerospace material, as an example.
And they'd go, we think because of X, Y, Z, so the behaviors that are going on in the French economy or the behaviors that are going on in the Dutch economy or what we're seeing in Europe as a whole will drive X. Let's put that through our model.
But they'd already made the selection. So what you're asking there, Chris, is that when – that was like, okay, so hang on a minute. Realistically, this is – we're just going to basically make a report that reflects our view rather than actually letting the data reflect the answer.
And that's still today, even with AI and generative AI, that is still going to be the number one thing. I mean, people talk about AI in terms of the fact that AI – And what it is, I mean, AI has been around for 30 plus years.
Generative AI is obviously the thing that everybody's getting excited about, but it's still not necessarily full human intelligence. It's not actually forming thought. It's actually collating everything rapidly and giving you a collated, amazing, very clean answer. But it's not necessarily right. The difference is it's learning off us.
So it's already taking our bias and just giving you the answer that you already wanted. So that's what it's amazing about at the moment. And so that was my light bulb moment, which would have been, what, 2009, 10. And it's sort of been there since. Okay.
And then that'd be sort of, that's probably from an analyst point of view. But then if you think about it from a individual investor's point of view, where do they, you know, they have all the great intentions, right? I want to do something for my future. I want to invest.
And then all of a sudden they try to outsmart the market. And really they're self-sabotaging in the background because their human behaviors are destroying all their decisions, right? And they don't even know it.
So when did that sort of light bulb come that, yeah, we're actually bad investors because we've got all these biases that basically inhibit us.
Yeah, you can also actually help you. So it needs to be both sides in terms of how I answer that question. It can actually help you to sort of, if you come from a pessimistic view, you can therefore very quickly, you know, alter out certain things.
If you come from an over, you know, this is what we call self-attribution bias, right? Where basically if you make the right decision, it was all on me. If you make the wrong decision, it was on the environment, right? So it was on the, that's self-attribution.
So that question and when it happened and how I looked at it, Yes, it was in investing in terms of that space and probably was what was sort of going on in what I saw in Amsterdam when I was there with working on sell side because they weren't just the analysts.
They were also the traders. They were also the investors working on funds. You then came back and I was working in broking. It was the first time I also had touched to housing because I want to bring it back to that. Like the first time I actually saw...
housing investing done poorly was people were investing on the concept of where I live is the best place to invest. Home bias. Home bias is the one to highlight straight away. The stat is fascinating. Domain had a really good report on it, I think, in 2019.
There's been a few before. But I remember seeing it in about 2012 to 2014 where people
a lot of people that I was living around that were investing in property were buying where they either grew up, where they lived, or where they had a home bias, as Roy just pointed out. And that, you know, led them to basically go, I live here. I know what it's like.
I'm going to invest in that townhouse or that apartment or that new sort of, and away they go. And they are now, you know, it's spread out further.
Veronica's just highlighted those that bought apartments in, you know, the adverted commas up and coming, adverted commas prime real estate areas are the ones that are actually in real trouble because it wasn't done on pure analysis. It was done on feeling. That's probably the term.
The thing is, though, we're not a particularly financially illiterate country, which makes us susceptible to being bullshitted, you know, by... Quite easily. You know, by people in the industry who are very good at packaging up these lovely little solutions for you. And developers have been fantastic at this for many, many years.
There's a lot in the buyers agent space now that are... delivering lovely packaged up solutions. And in fact, it's funny because you talk about home bias, the opposite of that can be equally challenging and there can be other biases that play into that.
So let me give you a scenario and perhaps you can unpick it and share with us all the biases that are coming into play. So recently I've just been doing a bit of research into the way borderless bias agents operate and the bigger operations, right?
Yeah.
And, and I've been reading, you know, the, the success stories, if you want to call it that, as they claimed, um, a lot of them in social media on people's websites and the rest of it, you know, I've had these great successes with these clients and some of them are people that, you know, so I go and see one of these, these buyers agents and maybe I've got borrowing capacity, maybe one and a half million dollars.
And they say, you don't need to pay that. You don't need to pay that. We can get you a great asset in an up and coming booming city. Um, for $600,000, $700,000, and maybe they buy in Toowoomba or Perth or somewhere like that.
So they're actually buying in Australia. They're not buying overseas for you.
Yeah, see, in Australia. A few years back, they were trying to buy in America. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, and so we'll get you in one of these growth areas. You want to get in on this growth.
It's got heaps to go, blah, blah, blah, and I'm going to get you an off-market asset, and I'm going to get you something that hasn't hit the market. And then, bang, you're offered something that you're told, look, I've got a line of clients.
I've got a waiting list and I'm offering this to you. You've got a small, short period of time to take advantage of it. Otherwise, I'm going to give it to the next person in the queue. Would you like it or don't you want it? They buy it.
Then six months, maybe 12 months later, in a rising market, they get a valuation. And instant equity uplift. They feel fantastic. This investing game, it's a hoot. It's so easy. I don't understand why more people don't do it.
And the buyer's agent comes back to them and says, I know you think I'm great. I've done a great job for you. And look how much equity you've got. And we left some fuel in the tank so you can go again if you want.
So the buyer then says, yeah, yippee, get me on the gravy train. They go and buy again, buy another similar type of property in a similar type, you know, circumstances. And this cycle continues basically until their borrowing capacity is chewed up.
And they're bought a lot, a number, look, I've heard of people with multiple millions buying, you know, many, many properties in, say, a two, three-year period. Now, the merry-go-round's got to stop at some point.
I can hear exactly what they are. They are... So ethically challenged they are going to be. Probably that the buyer's agent might have actually been attached to the construction agency as well. It's, yeah.
There's lots going on. But in terms of the consumer, I'm sort of picking up and I'm not a behavioural economist, but I read a lot of this stuff and I'm fascinated by this stuff. So for you in that space, what sort of behavioural biases are you sort of hearing now?
that are in play and actually undermining the individual who is buying these properties, their ability to make good decisions.
So you said through there that, you know, the buyer's agent comes back to you that says, you know, I've got all these people online. I've got all this sort of material behind it. I've got, so it creates a sense of urgency. So urgency is certainly part of it.
It also suggests in there that everyone's doing it, right? So you said, you know, I think you said something along the lines that basically, you know, everybody's trying to get into this property. You should get into it now, blah, blah, blah. This is what we refer to as the colloquial term is hurting.
I'm going to use the Warren Buffett quote again, getting back to Chris's point about my background in working in markets. But one of his most poignant quotes ever is one of the most corrosive, disastrous five words in investing is, everyone's doing it, so should I. Yeah.
And so property is not immune from that comment in terms of, and I probably slightly misquoted him, but you get what I mean in terms of where it is. It's exactly the same. And so there's another part of it is that urgency creates reaction.
So it is very natural for a human being to see urgency as opportunity rather than risk and to jump on it.
Right.
And that, you know, you are being presented with these very glossy numbers, this very, very good return, this opportunity to make, you know, high amounts of money. And then you also have things like confirmation bias, you know, conformity bias, all of these other sort of human traits that come with it.
I mean, this is just a property idea of things like GameStop, which for those of you out there who can remember 2021, when this fairly run-of-the-mill American company that is basically equivalent of our EB Games,
was being bid through the roof of absolutely no fundamental reason, but because of a Reddit group that was trying to outdo a hedge fund. And that all got lost in the media hype and all the confirmation, all of the attention that was being put onto it. This is exactly the same. It is...
Also, it's marketing 101, right? Create urgency. Marketing is absolutely key to this, is that if you create urgency, you create a thirst, a want, a need immediately. You create, it is also basically a sort of a buy before you do.
So again, one of the more fundamental things that also is quite fascinating with this is that this also goes not just behavior, it goes physiologically. So if you look at shoppers, let's use shoppers as a great example here. You get a dopamine hit from buying, right?
So shoppers get a, and you definitely get a dopamine hit from buying a property, right? The surge, the rush, the excitement that comes with signing that piece of paper, knowing you've got this asset, but also the money that comes with it, et cetera, et cetera.
The dopamine hit doesn't actually come from the purchase, like the day you sign, it's the anticipation. It's the same in shopping, right? So buyer's remorse, the reason it's referred to that, it's actually your fall in dopamine and that come down that happens with the drop in dopamine. Wow, yeah.
Property is the same, right? So if you create urgency, I'm missing out. It immediately triggers dopamine into your body and you get that surge and you get that buzz. that comes with urgency from dopamine.
And then when you do it, you get that, oh, moment that sort of, because your dopamine falls through the floor. So it's exactly the same concept in what this happens and they are tapping it into it perfectly.
So what you're saying basically is that we're basically physiologically and psychologically predisposed to get sold to. Yeah.
Gear to it. Absolutely gear to it. And again, that's why, you know, you... you look at bodies that are now designed to regulate human behavior, right?
I mean, if you look at what the ACCC is designed to do, or if you look at what ASIC is designed to do, or APRA, they are designed to basically rein in two sides. The fact that, A, we're geared to be sold to, as you just alluded to, Veronica, perfectly.
Unfortunately, the other side of it is also where you were sort of leading with that sort of story question was that human beings are technically in competition with each other. And therefore, when you have...
a, you know, an offering that is technically counter to the client, but you get commission from it, or you get sales from it, or your business is designed to actually sell something to somebody, then you also have that drive as well.
That's a, you know, a biological and fundamental human need is that you need cash. The
can create greed and greed can then also perpetuate bad behavior as well. And that's what you're alluding to in that story question is that it's so many different things crashing into each other.
And it's why you have bottleneck economics and $600,000 townhouses that you were talking about before, because where are most of those properties aimed at? The player that is trying to get in fast, quick turnover property options with ready-made turnkey options. Let's do it.
That's it.
supply and on the other it's funny because some of these players they learn the language of those that really know what they're talking about and they'll say things like oh we don't buy off the plan so you get many that do spruik developer stock there's no doubt about that and it's very highly lucrative for them
Um, and you've got others, oh, we only buy established, but then they go to, they go to these regional sales, um, agencies and, and they'll start picking through their, their crappy property management book, you know, then the agents will be like, oh, this is great.
These owners would have loved to have said sold for the last five years, but we haven't been able to find a buyer, but hey, you got a, you got a whole book full. So excellent. Yeah.
Moving along a little bit though, there seems to be a growing generational divide, not just in terms of perceiving who has and who has not got property, but in attitudes towards property ownership.
And Chris talked about it earlier in terms of as we get older ourselves and have kids and then our own pressures will change the way we do view property and property ownership. But
These sort of differences, you know, I saw you on the Insight program and there's a lot of finger pointing at boomers, for example, and there's the avocado toast accusation at millennials. And there's all this sort of stuff that one generation may accuse the other of.
What do you see as the big differences in beliefs and behavior around property across the generations? Yeah.
Yeah, and I think also that actually the belief is probably also similar in terms of their times and where they were.
So today's millennial is tomorrow's boomer. Is that basically what you're saying?
Yeah, that's what I'm saying. So if you look at what boomers were saying about the bots referred to as the builder or silent generation, so the ones that went to war, there was fairly similar accusations being made in the 70s and 80s.
Right, yeah.
And I think what's also forgotten in like the early 2000s, there was this genuine belief that the booms would be a massive, massive drag on the economy because you'd have all these people that didn't have enough superannuation, didn't have enough savings that would have to get the pension.
You know, housing wouldn't do enough job of actually generating wealth and away you went. We're talking 25 years ago in terms of what boomers were expected to be.
Now, it's the completely flip side as you're alluding to there, Veronica, where, you know, millennials and Gen Zs are accusing them of hoarding property and, you know, they're never going to get in and what have you and away you go. They've had the time.
I think this also gets back to my question before with Chris, is that they've had time. Boomers, the youngest group of them are actually 65, right?
Actually, they're not.
Yeah.
The youngest boomer is now 60.
Is it that, or it depends when you, okay, so the cutoff is 60. Okay, so you're looking at 955 to thereabouts, right? So 65 to thereabouts. 65, yeah. Yeah, yeah. So- The youngest version of them is five years away from retirement. Most of them are in retirement in terms of where you sit.
Generation X is the one that gets away with everything because they're sort of this sort of stuck one in the middle and I hope I didn't offend anybody on or listening to this.
I'm Gen X. Yeah.
Because... They're fascinating because they've actually also had a scenario of time, right? So they're the ones to really look at here, that they are in time. They've had probably 20, good 20 plus years in the workforce.
They are more likely not to be a generation that's had full exposure to superannuation when they started because the youngest Gen Xer would have been 94, maybe early 90s, like even 90 for when superannuation came in. So pretty much their entire generation major earning part of their life.
They've been getting super and they still had property prices in the 90s that were pretty low. So they've been the ones to accumulate. The other thing about boomers that's fascinating is that boomers They are just the same as Chris's question before. They have their own cultural biases. They have their own homing biases.
And as I said when I did the SBS Insights, the thing about boomers is that they probably do want to downsize except for there are several things. One, stamp duty. We know stamp duty is a massive drag for them. Why are they having to pay the state for the luxury of moving?
They don't like that. But the bigger one is where? They want to stay in the area that they've grown their kids, their family, their life, their culture, their lifestyle, their friends in. And that property doesn't exist.
So you can't all of a sudden turn around if they are the ones that get fingered in Toorak, for example, or in Double Bay in Sydney and all these ones with lots and lots of money. But they want to stay there because that's what they know.
They've been there for such a long period of time. What are they buying? And so because they can't find what they want, they're going to get charged to move anyway. They don't. So instead of having 10 properties that should come on because boomers have nested nesters and downsizing, only one will come on.
And then you get the other side that we've talked about before with Chris's point around the size of families expanding. That home that should be grabbing a full, you know, there should be 10 four-bedroom homes for the family. There's only one. But the amount of families doesn't slow down.
In fact, if anything, it's getting bigger by immigration and just by sheer time. So that's all part of that point.
I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions. You know, most people don't realize that they can cost themselves hundreds of thousands of dollars over the medium to long term when they make property decisions without all of the information that they need. I'll see you next time. Bye-bye.
And there you will find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program. You can connect with my Sydney-based property management and buyer's agency teams, Australia-wide vendor advocacy, or ask me for introduction to the small group of buyer's agents that I would personally recommend across the country. That's veronicamorgan.com.au.
If you're looking to buy your first home, thinking of upgrading to a new one or purchasing investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Reach out via my website, alcove.com.au.
Yeah, it's interesting what the downsides of stock, I guess you'd call it. I mean, they are trying to build it as fast as they can right now, but it's extremely expensive, right, to build.
And they can make the fundamental stack up, but everywhere where they want to live, like you said, along the beaches or eastern suburbs or whatever it might be, they just can't build enough, right? Absolutely.
And then they get the boomers back, sorry, the millennials and the gens, they're just back at them going, oh, how stuck up are you and blah, blah, blah. But it's the same point.
I mean, I would say to, and I'm a millennial, I'd say to my generation, if you were told that you were not able to live where you had grown up as a child,
And then your parents weren't allowed to live there either because the only places they could find was way out in outer suburbs or in a completely different city or on the other side of the bay in Sydney or the other side of the river here in Melbourne or wherever it happens to be you're listening to this.
That should flip the story. If you couldn't get access to your parents, how would you take that?
Well, I think that's the big point right now is once the kids can't buy, let's say the grandkids, you know, the millennials and then having kids and then the grandkids and they're getting inheritance from their parents. They say, well, if they're moving away, they're then tapping their parents and say, hey, can you...
I know you're living in this house. Can you give it to the grandkids, right? Because then I can't see my grandkids. You know what I mean? There's a pressure coming down because they haven't got enough money. They've got a mortgage.
The question that's interesting about that, why is that a problem? So this is, I think, also gets back to the cultural thing, right? Is that, again, living intergenerationally in the 50s was fairly common. Why is that now a problem?
And that, I think, also needs to be challenged back to the today status quo. Why is living with your parents and your grandparents a problem?
It's funny, actually. I mean, at the outset, you were talking about sort of our colonial history, effectively, and how that sort of leads to us having this desire for a piece of dirt.
And I'm not overly familiar with the American market, but I feel like that there's some similarities to, you know, being a relatively new country. But As opposed to, where was I reading it?
Maybe it was something you were saying that Bunnings, was it Bunnings that tried to set up in the UK or something?
That was me.
Yeah, yeah. And there's no market for it because it's such a much older country. I guess people have a different attitude towards DIY or different attitudes towards ownership. And a lot more people bring up kids in apartments too, right? And because the cities are bigger and more dense. Yeah.
Yeah, and all of the above. So they have a culture of not what we do, which is DIY. They have a culture of do it for me. And the Bunnings concept, admittedly, the way they got into the UK was probably not the greatest.
But overall, they were expecting that we are a colonial European colony, have fairly high ties. It is still the largest nation of migrants that we get from, although that's quickly changing towards India. But overall... It seems complete sense.
But as you perfectly alluded to, the way the housing market in the UK is set up to Australia is completely different. The majority are renters. They're not owners. Or they are long-term tenants. There's co-ops.
There's all other forms of overlay in terms of if you own a place in London, it's more likely or not that it will be part of a co-op or some form of strata. And so you can't just go down to Bunnings and go, I'm going to knock a hole in my wall.
You have to tell. The agents, what the hell are you doing in your place? So it becomes a headache. So why would you do it? Get somebody to do it properly. And that, again, is the difference in terms of, yeah, the American one's the great example.
It's not the same for every state, but they are buying the white picket fence. That whole analogy comes from the US, not from Australia. The white picket fence is where it is.
I can hardly believe we're there because, you know, the Bunnings boomed. They boomed in COVID too, didn't they? That whole DIY thing really went on steroids in Australia.
You did get out, right?
Well, yeah. We've just passed the five-year anniversary of COVID lockdowns. You know, now looking back, how have we changed?
Yeah.
The interesting thing that we have changed about is our ability to adapt. So if you had asked somebody about their adaptability pre-COVID, they probably wouldn't have agreed with what we've done. So we have done this.
I mean, the ability to actually work from home quite rapidly has been a fascinating change that is structurally here, despite the fact that possibly the opposition and incoming government wants to force public workers back to there and some employers do. This is a fundamental thing that's there. Productivity proves that it actually works.
in terms of having hybrid living. The way we consume is also different. The unbelievable bound to online was incredible. So one of the fascinating stats that happened during COVID was it took, the internet had been around for about 35 years when COVID hit properly.
And only about 20% of purchases were online of all products. In that one year alone, it jumped 8%, 28%. And it's now up to 32%. Wow, so it hasn't gone backwards. It hasn't gone backwards and it's not slowing. I mean, you look...
In terms of the high street, and this is the interesting thing I spoke before about prime real estate. Back in the day, the high street was seen as prime real estate. You get constant rent. You've got a rent that's generating income from a business that they own.
You've got foot traffic that's always there. There's always interest. The high street's the one that suffered the most from COVID. It's not returning to what it was.
So even more than office space.
Yeah, but it's different. I mean, if you're a cafe, you've got a different, you know, there's other external factors, like there's inflation, there's cost of business, there's regulation overlays, red tape, insurances. That's another one that's really gone through the roof in the post-COVID world.
So it's not just as simple as saying the behavior, but the high street is under real pressure because of the fundamental changes that have happened. And that's both the behavior, but also the economics and then the regs that have come with it. So that's one.
The one thing that hasn't changed is the desire and the thirst for property. In fact, if anything, it's got higher. So the one thing that was fascinating from COVID is that we don't like living with each other anymore.
So we now have a scenario where we've got the lowest level of people per houses pretty much since records began. So it's 2.62. It's actually 2.4 across the whole nation, but I want to use a 2.62 because that's the 20 major capital cities that are highlighted. Because COVID, obviously, we had isolation.
Empty nesters has rapidly ramped up. But also like renting properties. So back in the day, renters, particularly students, would have been four to five. It's now two to three. And that isn't returning. It also puts pressure on the rental system. And why we have that is that...
Not as many people are renting together as they once upon a time did. It's why I asked that question before about, is it a problem being intergenerational living? Yeah. That shouldn't be a problem, but psychologically and behaviorally, it clearly is.
Because that change in average household size, I mean, didn't that add something like a million dollars to our required homes?
It's like a million new homes that we need to actually keep up with that. So that will change because just by pure force, because people aren't finding homes, right? Yeah, it's going back the other way, right?
Yeah, it's going to go back the other way because of pure force of the fact that there isn't enough property for us to keep living with such a low level density in our housing.
Evan, you obviously got your finger on a pulse on lots of different things, but leaving the cities was a huge thing in COVID, right? Let's just run away to the regions, get that tree change, sea change. I've always wanted to do it. Properties are cheap. I'm going to go.
I'll be able to get remote work for the rest of my life. Things have changed, right? Five years on, you know, there's a pressure to return back to the office.
How do you sort of, from a behavioral point of view, how are you sort of thinking about this and how it's going to play out over the next few years? Because there's so many conflicting competing interests, right?
When the market's good and the corporate, you know, leasing and, you know, company productivity and, you know, what workers want and workers want talent. So how are you sort of digesting this trend? Because it... It's sort of going back faster than probably people expected, I would say, right now.
What's being seen with that position, Chris, that's fascinating around the drive to the regions? Like, look right now with what has just been announced by the opposition around the changes to the fuel excise tax, right? So the move to the regions during COVID made absolutely no
100% sense, like just complete sense in terms of where it is. You had more freedoms, you had bigger areas you could consume and that movement. The catch now is that businesses do want you back in the office and not do they just want you back in the office. You have to commute.
And so you asked before about what's going on with that movement is that what we did also see is that those that were in the tier one, two, and three, so those lower, mid, and sort of middle brackets were the ones going to the regents because they could get the property they couldn't get in the capitals.
Yeah. Now they're facing this scenario where they have to keep up with the mortgage repayments that would have been done quite cheaply. But the commute and the time cost and the time value that comes with that commute is going against. So Victoria is a great example.
Victoria is one that's bucking the trend where the move back to Melbourne is on, whereas New South Wales and Queensland, it's the other way around. Now that comes down to affordability. And that's a completely different story.
But it is fascinating that the behavior to the sea change, let's call it that, was absolutely there. People still want to do it. But their work is now becoming a problem.
And I've spoken about this before with regards to one thing that's fascinating about Australia and to some extent New Zealand versus the rest of the world is that we are one of the only players that want to live where we work rather than live and work where we have to.
So you look at, we talked about the UK. The UK is happy the more money they make to go and live outside Australia. of the city. If you've got money, you don't live in the city.
You go and live in Richmond or you go and live in Essex, Sussex, what have you, Middlesex, et cetera.
If you look into New York, you don't live in Manhattan. You live in Westchester or you go and live in Long Island. It's the same pretty much around the world. We're the opposite.
The reason we talk about the 8K ring in Melbourne or the 15K ring in Sydney or the 7K ring in Brisbane, the same thing on the inner east and west of Adelaide, et cetera, because it's very, very close to where we're more likely not to work, which is the CBDs.
We have hubs of work, and that's where we want to be. So the pullback into the city is getting stronger because these people didn't necessarily get jobs in the region they moved to. They were doing it because they could, and now they've got the dilemma that...
I have to commute an hour a day. Now, again, overseas, that's completely normal, but our infrastructure is not great, and transferring on a train for an hour is, okay, maybe only realistically New South Wales has probably got the infrastructure to do that, but most other states don't.
Queensland, if you're in the Brisbane, or let's call it the southeast coast of Queensland, you're probably okay with the Gold Coast, the Sunshine Coast, but overall, the infrastructure isn't there to sustain regional populations commuting to the city and then coming out again.
If you had to make a bet five days back in the office or, you know, three days working from home, you know, who do you think is going to win that fight? Because this is really what, yeah. You reckon that the employees are going to win?
Yeah, I do. Because the other thing that's been changing and changing and changing, and we talked about the generational differences before, is
Millennials and Gen Zers are the ones with the highest level of surveys that show that life and lifestyle and their alignment with purpose, let's call it that, Chris, is more important to them than salary.
And so if they are forced back in for five days, you watch how fast they jump over a six-month period. They will be unhappy and they will quickly move. The laws are moved. I mean, even we've seen this week the changes to non-compete clauses, right, for those earning under $175,000.
That will feed into that ability to move even more because they no longer have- Working mobility. Yeah, exactly. I mean, from an economics perspective, that is one of the biggest things I saw on Tuesday that is actually a good thing for productivity because it forces businesses to be much more fundamental.
It forces the ability to be streamlined and to actually have- pretty slick systems in place rather than being slovenly and go, well, that client list that you built, we get to keep it. P.S. You have to sit on your hands for six to eight to 10 to 12 weeks. That's gone.
So no longer can business, I mean, business is going to hate it. I'm not going to deny that. But from a productivity perspective and from an overall perspective, it's a good thing.
Well, that's right. You get the biggest wage increase when you quit your job and go to the competitor, right? And none of my staff don't think about that.
You guys are already on a good salary, so that's okay. And you guys love working here, so that's fine. You know, let's just go on a different, there's a lot of tangents here.
I know there's everyone.
Diary of the CEO. I don't know if you saw it. There was a huge podcast around with Stephen Bartlett and Gary Stevenson and Dan Presley, which is hard to listen to. Yeah, it was hard to listen to.
But just putting inequality on the table, what's your thoughts on what Australia's becoming and the way the system that we've built, what's your take on all that? Yeah, okay.
I think we need to put into perspective against global peers right before I answer that question because people will have very, very strong opinions of this and the best opinions
way I can sort of put my two cents into you is to say, we are still absolutely not just a lucky country, but a country that is significantly further ahead than even some of our big developed nation peers. And that needs to be front and center.
There is a reason why we have the highest level of immigration in the world to our peers, you know, 2%. of growth compared to pretty much everywhere else, which is about 0.5 to 0.9. People want to live here because of our living standards and the way that our country is run.
I said this earlier before, and the catch that governments have is they have to balance aspiration and fairness. Now, both sides of politics at the moment are pretty much just tinkering at the margins, so they're purple. So what their view on fairness and aspiration is, is there's probably some
Thank you. you know, semantics debate around it, but overall what they're doing is pretty much the same in terms of that space. Is it perfect? Absolutely not. I mean, let's look straight away at something like super.
The concept of super is a really good one, but it has created, if we want to argue about generational wealth difference with boomers and extras and blah, blah, blah, that's a key point. I mean, it is basically a tax haven for the rich and a tax burden for the poor.
Because if you look at how it's done, how it's structured, it benefits the highest earners by throwing as much money into superannuation as you can at a 15% tax rate rather than the standard tax, you know, even salary sacrificing and all those materials inside it as well. It creates an imbalance.
And therefore, we have an imbalance in super because there are those with millions and those with nothing. I mean, if you look at some of the big industry super funds, the average balance in a, like, I'm not going to highlight which one, but it is one in the top five, is $46,000. Wow.
$46,000. Now, if you listen to Asper and what they're saying, you need on a single person to live modestly, and it is absolutely modestly. You need $40,000 a year. That means you've got one year of savings.
So, okay, this has been going for a long time and it's now up to 11%, 11.5%. I should know because I am an employer. I do pay, I do, the statutory amount, I will tell you that. But, you know, there's been a long time for some of us to accumulate super.
Certainly, I've been, you know, contributing for many, many years. In COVID, one of the things that was able to happen was that people were able to access some of their super if they needed to.
And without any real guardrails around that, you know, what they spent it on was a bit alarming in some cases and some possibly did use it to keep afloat. I'm sure there were those people that did use it in the way it was designed to be given access.
And now you're talking about first home buyers being given the opportunity to access their super.
What are your thoughts on that? Because that's, you know, if the average balance is $40,000 and that's clearly inadequate, we've got a whole social security system based on the concept that everyone's going to be able to support themselves.
And also if we've got home ownership declining and getting into retirement without owning a home, that does contribute to higher… Yeah, it's becoming more and more probable.
I mean, back in the day… The other thing about that $40,000 that I said before, that assumes that you've paid your house off at retirement.
Right. Yeah.
Okay. So that needs to also be factored into that point is that more and more people now are not paid off their homes by retirement, are having to work longer because they're not clear of their mortgage. So you and I had this debate at the PIPA conference in Sydney around what it is.
What scares me about it is that once it's out of super, it never gets back.
It also comes back to Chris's point about time and expanding from being a single to a couple.
So time and the magic of compounding.
Yeah. So we'll come back to that because you missed that in super. But it's also that 50 grand that you might use as a deposit for a house. When that house is up for sale, you're not putting the 50 grand back in super.
You're going to be using the deposit for the next property from the profits or the capital you've gained out of that and so on and so forth. Now, some would argue that's going to be better for you and what have you because you can start building your wealth through housing.
The catch with housing, it's not a liquid asset.
It's a static asset that has capital appreciation, but it's not crystallized and it's not giving you a personal home, is not giving you an income. It's not an investment property. It's your own personal home. And then it also gets back to what we've been discussing all the way through this.
It's creating another bottleneck. It's giving people the ability to borrow and ability to therefore go to that tier two and tier three band that otherwise wouldn't have been there. So there's more demand. Less supply and all that material.
Then it gets back to, as you said before, the compound problem as well is that that 50 grand over the life that it would have been in super can return as much as $480,000 in just that 50 grand alone, let alone all the other contributions that would have been happening to it.
So I was talking to one of our Homebuyer Academy students. So he's a first homebuyer and he and his partner have saved up their deposit. They've been trying to get into the Melbourne market and it's been quite tough for them. It's quite competitive in first homebuyer space at the minute. It is.
And I asked him how he felt about it and he said it scares the pants off him because they've worked hard to save that deposit and they are in a position to buy. He said it will pretty much force us to have to dip into our super. To keep competitive.
And I don't want it. Yeah, exactly. To be competitive. And I don't want to dip into my super to be competitive. I've got myself into this situation now.
It's actually putting pressure on me to really, really, really want to buy before the election because I don't want to be in that situation where I'm forced to be competitive. And I hadn't thought of it like that before. And I was like, well, that is an interesting angle. Yeah.
Again, this is all the thinking. Because somebody asked me also, has the interest rate cut in February stoked the market? I said, no. The market was already stoked by the probability that we were going to get interest rate cuts in 2025.
Already priced in.
Yeah, it's already happened. It happened back in September, October last year. You saw the jump when all of a sudden the language changed and the media and everybody else was confirming the bias that rates were going to happen this year. And we've seen one and there's probably going to be some more.
The thing is, when? Great question. I mean, some will argue it's next Tuesday. Some will argue that it will be as late as September. So it doesn't, but again, it's going to come. So this is all part of that perception. So you've also highlighted something I've said many times, that urgency, right?
So they are now making a decision urgently on a possibility of a change of government. Yes.
Well, I mean, think a few years back of the change of government in New South Wales and you had the end of Perite's government. We had first home buyers were able to buy and not pay stamp duty. They could opt out of stamp duty and pay a rent, land tax.
And, you know, there was a definite, you know, there was definite impetus in the market. It definitely helped kick us back into gear after a really, you know, crappy 18 months or so.
And there was urgency there for good reason, you know, because Mins came out and said, well, if we get in, we're going to axe it. So they knew there was a deadline. And there's a small cohort of people that are paying ongoing land tax and didn't have to pay stamp duty. We...
I want to get to value. We're sort of running out of time and, you know, we've been talking about all these other things. Tell us, you know, you said to me, I want to talk about value. This is an interesting thing.
So share with us a little bit of your thinking at the moment in terms of this, you know, concept of value, real and perceived in the context of property.
Yeah. So real and perceived is an interesting way of putting it because this is where linguistics is a fascinating thing in psychology, not in economics, but in psychology, it's very, very strange because the word value has a different persona depending on what you put it towards.
The value of the property has a capital value, but it also, if you ask, why are you buying this property? Why are you buying this property will change when you say, why are you buying this home? So that word change from property to home changes the value.
Because the value then isn't just capital. It's emotion. It's time. It's experience. It's life. It's belief. Bingo. Keeping up with the Joneses. Value all of a sudden flicks from being just pure capital to something else. And it also therefore means that it's why people overextend.
Because the capital value and the possible loss and the overextension gets overdone by the value of status, by home, by family, by belief, and all those things in between.
This is why, for me, property is fascinating because it is not just about value. Pure, utter capital, which all other asset classes I would argue is. It is about pure capital.
The value that you get from owning a business, buying a share on the stock exchange is not the same value as you're going to get out of having a property. Or, sorry, let me use the word again, a home.
And that's the difference, is that that's where everything else can get in the way. Now, I do want to say this very clearly, that actually can sometimes be the right answer. The way I'm saying it, it sounds like it's wrong. It's not, right? It is not wrong.
If you're okay to give up capital gains, but you know for the next 20 years, the experience and the lifestyle that you can afford to pay off, I want to put that in there very clearly, that you can afford to deal with,
Maybe not get the capital return that you could have got if you went to an up-and-coming suburb or an up-and-coming area can offset that because you don't get time back. You only live once, all that kind of viola rubbish.
The value can actually be offset. So it isn't just trade-offs. It isn't just this whole idea that be very, very careful of value around ethics or value around experience or value around family or keeping up with the Joneses. They can be good things. You've just got to be aware of them.
I think with that, though, there's a nuance to that because value, if lots of other people have the same emotional response around that particular type of property, for example, that value does get baked into the price and actually contributes to capital growth.
So there are certain times when, and that's what we look for, we look for properties that you know, that buyers respond to in more, you know, more than others, you know, and because it does tap into, and that's why you've got the best street thing, right?
The people will pay a premium to live in that best street because of that emotion. Why do you think the block works? Sorry?
Yeah, of course. Why does the block work? Because all of a sudden this is aspirational, beautifully built.
No, I want to be in television showing how much money I've got.
All of the above, right?
So it's all part of it.
Look at the renovated house, the F at the time and all that material that we put into it is because there's emotion to it. There's a belief to it.
I'm renovating my house, not because I'm going to sell it, but because I want to live in that renovated time and effort and money capital that I've put into it because the value to me long-term is there. It's why those programs are so attractive.
I mean, that's why your program with location, location, location, Veronica, was so visceral to people because they could see and feel the value of not just the capital side, but the experience and the lifestyle they could have got from being in a location like that.
Yeah. And in that home, in many cases too, it's quite fascinating, that perception of value. We certainly take clients through that. We talk about the subjective aspects to setting your price limit and the objective one. So the objective is relatively easy. The subjective are a lot harder.
And what I see, talk about behavioral economics, you see people at auction that haven't really properly thought that through. And so then they're under the pressure of the fear of loss. And you can absolutely see all of that just
crowding in and taking over their judgment when they're under pressure because all of those things do count. And there's a lot of this talk around properly, you've got to take the emotion out.
I think you've got to embrace the emotion, understand the emotion, and then put a value on that, on how important that is to you. And that helps harness that and not make foolish decisions in the heat of moment. Yeah.
It also puts time into consideration, right? So it basically says, because you forget, if you're buying a property, 10 years is a minimum, an absolute minimum, right? In terms of how you're thinking of what you're earning it for.
If you can get the value instantly from the lifestyle or from that sort of emotion that you're alluding to, Veronica, it will offset the first three years in particular of the capital impact that it will have on your life.
Yeah, absolutely. And, you know, we do see, I've met plenty of people over the years who actually have bought and they've overridden that emotional response because they've thought, no, I have to make a sensible decision. And sometimes I've met many people over the years that have bought something they've never liked.
They've never liked living in it. It made sense. It was cheap. Yeah, it made sense. And it's got under their skin and they don't keep it for 10 years. They don't enjoy living in it. They do trade out of it, and they incur all those additional costs. So it does...
It does happen when people try to override their emotions and they end up with a suboptimal experience and a suboptimal property for them. Hey, Evan, do you have a property dumbo for us?
Yep. I'm going to say myself. Good.
Yes, I love it when someone brings their own.
So my property, Dumbo, what we did was that we lost sight of what we were doing. So we originally went into a property that we bought. because what we originally were doing it for was an investment.
Then we got the realization that actually we've been talking about generational wealth transfer and all that kind of material, that actually we could get the girls this property and we can pay it off and slowly but surely over time we'll be able to give it to them.
And then that emotion took over the actual analytics that we'd been doing.
you know so the properties that we were looking at for an investment in the areas that we knew were going to grow got sort of pushed to one side and this emotion of the girls could be here right the girls could live here um yeah and
And that overrode our decision making. And, you know, as you've heard, I mean, I've been working in markets for 18 years. I've been working in this space for that same period of time. I, you know, have made mistakes, but small mistakes with regards to it.
But, you know, we lost perspective of what we were doing. So the Dumbo was me.
And the reason I want to highlight that is that everyone is perceptible too. Everyone. Yeah. So can you give us an example of, thanks for using yourself as well, because it's always better, you know, self-analyzing yourself. And you're right, everyone does it. Myself, Veronica, absolutely included, and everybody.
You actually think you're a good buyer until you actually start trying to buy, and then you realize, shit, I actually don't know what I'm doing. And everyone, yeah, buys, they hate me as a client because I'm worse. I'm horrible at it. But what was the result? Like, what was the...
Yeah.
So this is the other thing that we're talking about before with loss is that one of the things that I am very strong on is keeping your lemons is actually one of the worst things you can do.
So crystallizing a loss is actually more beneficial in the long term than trying to get back to zero.
Ripping off the band-aid.
Yeah. So we crystallized the loss and we walked away and we've now, you know, we've had many years to not even many years. It's the recuperation, the opportunity cost, the time cost, the value cost, et cetera, infinite with it not now actually in our portfolio.
So the answer to your point, Chris, we bought it. It was wrong. We worked out very quickly it was wrong and we ripped the bandaid off and sold the lemon. Well done. Okay. Well done. And so the Dumbo was the buy. The correct decision was to get rid of it.
And it was definitely a lemon. It hasn't bounced back and gone, oh, God. Look, maybe it might be, you know, sort of possibly five figures bounce. But we're not talking six figures. And we're talking low five-figure bounce. Maybe. Maybe. Yeah. If you're lucky.
Don't even look at it.
Correct. So, I mean, here's another Dumbo for you is that –
Everybody loves to compare themselves to it, right, to each other. And so we do that all the time. And there was some properties that we've sold in the past that we were getting frustrated by four-figure differences for properties that were like, it doesn't matter, but you will dwell on it.
You will absolutely dwell on it. Four figures, right, in properties is cents, right? Yes. But everybody has that same feeling.
Absolutely love it.
What a good chat, Evan. I think we could definitely get you back, mate. I really appreciate all your time. Thank you for having me, guys. It's been fantastic. Great chatting.
If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website, theelephantintheroom.com.au, or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au. If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit.
And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great. I know that sounds a bit cringy but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.
Behavioural economist Evan Lucas starts with culture rather than numbers. Australia is a nation of DIY, he says, to the point where going to Bunnings sits inside the vernacular. Property is also the only investable asset an owner can physically change themselves.
He traces the attachment back past the post-war decades. During the gold rush, he argues, it was not only the gold but the land, and from the 1850s to the 1890s the land grab was already an obsession.
To younger listeners who say ownership is not for them, his answer is time. You cannot buy it or press pause on it, and life moves people from single to couple to family. Chris Bates notes the share economy talk of five years ago has given way to renters wanting stability.
On first home buyer concessions, Lucas is blunt about the mechanics. Scrapping stamp duty up to a $600,000 or $700,000 threshold, depending on the state, pulls demand into one band. A property worth between $500,000 and $600,000 becomes one worth $600,000 on the nose, and buyers just above the line lose out.
His framing on supply is a language problem: it is not the supply, it is how it is supplied. Apartments are due over the next five years, but what people want is the soil underneath. Veronica Morgan adds CoreLogic's Pain and Gain figures for the December 2024 quarter.
Around 37 per cent of inner Melbourne apartments resold at a loss that quarter, roughly 30 per cent in Ryde and 22 per cent in Parramatta. Updated: Cotality's Pain and Gain report for the March 2026 quarter, published 25 June 2026, puts Melbourne units at 81 per cent profitable resales, still the weakest unit market in the country, while 96 per cent of all resales nationally made a nominal gain. Lucas found the holding periods more telling: six to nine years, long enough that owners expected a gain, and because property carries gearing the loss lands harder.
There is nothing more visceral than loss in human beings, and particularly with property, because it has gearing attached to it, the loss is more and more acute.
Evan Lucas, 12:13
Lucas dates his own light bulb to around 2009, working in sell-side research on the Dutch stock exchange. Analysts would settle on a view about a sector, then run it through the model, so the report reflected the view rather than the data. Generative AI, he argues, learns off us and returns the answer we wanted.
The first time he saw housing done poorly it was home bias: people investing where they grew up or where they lived, on the reasoning that they knew the area. He points to Domain research from about 2019 and his own observation between 2012 and 2014, calls made on feeling. Kent Lardner tested that instinct by ranking every street in a suburb on the price estimates and checking the result against local knowledge.
Morgan puts a scenario to him. A borderless buyer's agent, a cheaper asset in a supposedly booming city, an off-market opportunity, a waiting list of other clients and a short window to say yes. Lucas names urgency first, then herding, then confirmation bias, reaching for Warren Buffett's line about everyone doing it.
It is very natural for a human being to see urgency as opportunity rather than risk and to jump on it.
Evan Lucas, 24:06
| Situation | What It Feels Like | What Lucas Says Is At Work |
|---|---|---|
| An agent says a waiting list is ready and the window is short | A rare chance that has to be taken now | Manufactured urgency, read as opportunity rather than risk |
| Everyone appears to be buying in the same market | Reassurance that the decision is sound | Herding, and the Buffett line about everyone doing it |
| A valuation a year later shows equity uplift | Proof the approach works, so go again | Self-attribution, where the gain is credited to the buyer |
| The property sits in the suburb you grew up in | You know the area better than anyone | Home bias, a call made on feeling rather than analysis |
| The days before signing | The strongest part of the buzz | Dopamine peaks on anticipation, so the fall reads as remorse |
As discussed between 17:45 and 26:15. Descriptions as stated on air.
Lucas calls superannuation a good concept with an uneven structure, in his words a tax haven for the rich and a tax burden for the poor, because the highest earners can push money in at 15 per cent. He puts the average balance in one of the top five industry funds at $46,000, against a modest single retirement he costs at $40,000 a year.
That $40,000 already assumes the home is paid off, and more people now reach retirement still carrying a mortgage. On using super for a deposit, his objection is that once the money is out it never goes back: the deposit rolls into the next purchase, and the family home is static rather than liquid and paying income.
Morgan describes a Homebuyer Academy student in Melbourne who has saved a deposit and expects to be forced into his super to stay competitive. He feels pressure to buy before the election, which Lucas reads as urgency again.
| Figure | As Stated In the Episode |
|---|---|
| Average balance in one of the top five industry funds | $46,000 |
| Modest annual spend for a single retiree | $40,000 a year, assuming the home is paid off |
| Tax rate on money pushed into super | 15 per cent |
| $50,000 left in super instead of used as a deposit | As much as $480,000 over its life |
Figures as stated between 50:07 and 54:14, quoted as aired.
The part Lucas wanted to reach was value, and he treats it as a question of language. Ask why someone is buying this property and you get one answer. Ask why they are buying this home and the answer changes, because value stops being purely capital. That, he says, is why people overextend.
Why are you buying this property will change when you say, why are you buying this home? So that word change from property to home changes the value.
Evan Lucas, 57:38
He is careful not to file emotion under error. Morgan adds that when enough buyers share the same emotional response it is baked into the price, which is why a premium attaches to the best street. His own property dumbo lands the point on himself: a purchase that began as an investment became a plan to hold for his daughters, and emotion overrode the analytics.
This episode sits on the gap between what a property is worth and what a home is worth to the buyer standing in it. Where a purchase turns on bonuses, equity or business income, the Alcove team structures complex income lending around the decision rather than the other way around.
Premium Mortgage ServiceSources referenced: The Elephant in the Room Property Podcast, episode 383, "Why Behavioural Economics Matters in Real Estate with Evan Lucas", released 2025-05-04. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Evan Lucas, behavioural economist. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 10 September 2026, against Cotality's Pain and Gain report for the March 2026 quarter, published 25 June 2026.




