Curious about upgrading?
Wondering where to start?
Complex questions that need answers?
Is there a better structure for you?
"They managed to navigate my complex expat income and even got my Google RSU income approved as well."
"I highly recommend Alcove to anyone looking for a mortgage broker who is responsive, trustworthy, and truly cares about their clients. Thanks again to the whole team for making the process such a positive experience!"
"As founders, we're constantly jumping between things so having a partner that handled the details & made the process super clear made the buying process breezy for us. Very happy with the experience!"
“It almost felt like it was his responsibility to make it clear to me, not my responsibility to understand it.”
“I've been pretty much fully leveraged the whole time. So the sounding board on that, in terms of what was achievable, what wasn't — I think trust is just built along that.”
"Alcove has been a great partner. They look after my audience properly, keep things simple, and deliver real value. I’ve got full confidence referring clients knowing they’ll get honest, straightforward advice."
"Property is one of the biggest financial decisions people make. Alcove stood out because they take a strategic approach to lending - helping clients structure property and debt decisions in a way that genuinely supports their broader financial plans."
Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

In this episode of Australian Property Podcast, Amy Lunardi and Chris Bates unpack the psychological traps that can quietly cost property buyers money, momentum and confidence.
This podcast is proudly brought to you by Perla, the official brokerage platform of Rask. With Perla, you can effortlessly automate your money, whether you're investing in ETFs or shares from Australia or the US stock market, whether you're a grandparent or setting up a kid's account or your own account.
You can do all of that with full automation on Perla.com. If you want to learn more, head to Perla.com slash Rask. And of course, before you invest in anything, be sure to read the legal documents like the PDS and FSG.
This episode is brought to you by Stripe, helping your business be ready for whatever comes next. And the next shift in how people buy is already happening. Agentic Commerce lets customers discover and purchase directly inside an AI conversation. No checkout page, no friction.
The businesses positioning themselves now are the ones who will lead this channel. Whatever comes next for your business, power it with Stripe. Learn more at stripe.com.
You cannot ever speculate in a negotiation on what someone else is going to say or do. I see this all the time with buyers saying, well, if I do this, the vendor is going to probably do this or the other buyer might do this.
There's about a thousand different ways how you can negotiate and a thousand different strategies in all different markets.
Only focus on what you can control in your own decisions. Try and play out all of the different scenarios so that you have a clearer picture. This is a podcast by The Rask Group. It's for educational purposes only.
So please do not make a financial, legal, investment or taxation decision based on solely what you hear in this show.
Welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. We're on a mission to be Australia's most trusted property podcast. I'm Owen Rask, founder of The Rask Group. I'm Pete Borgent, author and buyer's agent.
I'm Amy Linardi and I am a buyer's agent.
I'm Chris Bates, ex-financial planner and mortgage broker.
Together, we'll take you through every step of your property journey. From first home buyer to decades of property investing.
Welcome to Australian Property Podcast. I'm Chris Bates in the studio today with Amy Linardi. How are you doing?
I'm good, Chris. I'm actually quite excited to talk about this episode today because this forms a big part of my job as a buyer's agent, and that is dealing with the psychological traps which cost buyers or which cause problems for buyers.
Yeah, I mean, you get excited, you get ready, but then it's just the market kind of teaches you a bit of a lesson, right? You're at the mercy of sort of your emotions taking over. And it's so stressful and emotional, the whole buying journey. And we do self-sabotage a bit, don't we? Mm-hmm.
I think it's fair to say that property buying and negotiating and making decisions is unlike any other type of purchase you're ever going to make in your life. First of all, because it's so much money, it's such a big decision. There is a
which influence your own opinion. Lots of pressure to make the right choice. We've got limited data available. So for all of those reasons, it's just very rarely a straightforward, hey, this is what I wanna buy. I know this is the exact price. Okay, I'll go and buy it.
Imagine if you could just, I was thinking the other day, imagine if property was like Depop. Have you ever bought on Depop, Chris? Do you know what that is?
I do, actually. My sister's on parental leave. She's a little one and she started a little Depop business off to the side, going around a lot of the wealthy women in the eastern suburbs selling their clothes for them. Oh, actually, that's a good idea.
Yeah. Because on Depop, you list your price and you could list a price way more than what that thing is worth. And if you get no offers, which is a market signal to you, right?
Or people can then just put offers in, they can ask questions and then you can accept whichever you want and they've got to pay within a certain time. It would be so much more straightforward if property was like that. And it's not, it's so complex and complicated.
And I thought this episode would be really great to do because these tips that we're going to talk about are relevant at any point in time, in a buyer's market, in a seller's market, no matter which state you're in. So this is applicable to everyone.
Listen to the end of this episode because you might be saying at the start, oh, I don't need psychological advice on how to buy a property. I got this. But just hear me out because as you're going through the process, you might get involved in one of these situations and think, oh, actually,
I'm going to be aware of this now and therefore I'm not going to fall into this trap.
Yeah, there's just a lot of people you have to, like stakeholders, like you said, family, you know, often partners, maybe a lot of people making these big property moves I find at the times where they've got a lot going on personally, whether it's pressure to get kids into school or there's a baby in the belly coming and, you know, there's already a bit of anxiety that, you know, they're the one that got away or they wish they made a move.
There's all this other stuff, the baggage that, It's sort of affecting them to have this sort of clear mind. And yeah, and then they get out of the auctions and all the open homes and they start getting new information and new opinions.
And it's really hard, I find, to just get a real clear clarity and stay the course. And even when I've got it personally, it's just you get wrapped up. You're at the mercy of the market, I find. And yeah, it's really challenging, I find.
Yeah, I'm gonna give you a really great case study to show how strong the power of psychology is. This has actually happened to me twice. One recently where we put an offer in for a property pre-auction and it was a property that my clients absolutely loved. It was the maximum of their limit.
And I thought, oh, it's probably gonna go a bit over, but we've got nothing to lose in trying. Put an offer in and unfortunately someone else beat us. So they put an offer in like 20, 30 grand above us. And we're like, okay, that's fine. No problem. They were disappointed.
They went to sleep. The next morning, the agent called me and said, that other buyer, they're not proceeding. Do you still want the property? And I called my clients and said, look, great news. This almost never happens, but you can have it for the price that you previously offered.
And they said to me, oh, we talked ourself out of it now. Because once they were like, oh, okay, we didn't get it. It mustn't have been meant to be. You know, here are all the problems with it.
Like they basically talked themselves out of it because they thought they'd missed out on it. I said, look, I understand this. This is a very interesting situation.
I think we need to go back to the fundamentals, all the reasons why you liked it before, go back and compare it to all the other properties that have sold and just take a moment, take a breath. let's chat at the end of the day.
And as I expected, they were like, Amy, you're absolutely right. We really want this house. They bought it. They love it. And I've had another situation. Same thing happened. We're bidding at auction. We were the underbidder. The person who won the auction went inside and asked the agent for a six month settlement.
when they'd previously only asked for 60 days. Agent said, nope, that was never agreed. We can't allow it. So then the agent called me and say, hey, you can have it if you want. You're the underwriter. My clients had already talked themselves out of it again.
Even though we always put in hours and hours of research and prep and talking about the property and price, this power of psychology around property is so strong. They ended up buying it because again, I talked them through it and gave them the time and they love it.
but there are so much that influences a decision. So let's have a chat about it.
That goes both ways, right, as well, because I can think of many types of clients where – you know, they've been looking for a while. It's usually that, it's usually buyer fatigue and agents love them.
They call them sort of wounded bulls and, you know, they know that they're likely to, you know, every time they get closer to missing out on one, they're one closer to buying sort of thing.
And they're willing to make more and more compromises and, you know, can reflect on some conversations and, you know, they know that it's not the right property for them. They know that it's not going to give them a long runway.
They know that it's just not really the right fit, but they almost convince themselves that it's what they want, whether it's a, you know, a smaller townhouse and, you know, they just keep missing out on the dream property.
And so I feel like also the brain, you know, wants to end the pain sometimes and it just sort of forces them to just sort of get something. And they, you know, they know that it's not the right decision, but internally they convince themselves.
I've seen it definitely happen the other way as well.
Absolutely. And today's episode is particularly relevant, I think, right now in Melbourne and in Sydney, perhaps other parts of the country, we are in a buyer's market. And Pete and I recorded an episode, I think it was last month, talking about the differences in hot markets and
And the things that people struggle with are actually way more in a buyer's market because in a buyer's market, Buyers have the power. And that sounds like a good thing, right, Chris?
Why would you buy in a seller's market if you could buy in a buyer's market where you've got more negotiating power, you've got lower prices overall? But with all of that, there is always a reason why it's become a buyer's market.
There's like a big policy change or macroeconomic shock and it affects everyone and it affects buyer sentiment. That's why prices have come down, right? So anything that is therefore impacting sentiment for buyers makes them nervous and makes them worried.
And the reason why they're concerned is a couple of reasons. So first of all, it's because they worry if they buy now.
the value of that property might drop. Number two, they worry that, well, maybe I wait a little bit longer on this property and I stretch out the negotiations and I've got more bargaining power and I can get it for a bit cheaper.
And then they struggle to make that decision or they miss out because someone else comes along. Or they worry that If they buy something now, they could have waited. And if prices continue to come down further, they could have bought something better. All of those reasons are really, really, really relevant, right?
But also the catch 22 there is in a buyer's market. Sometimes you have less stock available, less quality stock, more goes off market. So you have to work harder to find them. And the main issue is that you can just then never time the bottom of the market.
So you can end up in a position where you wait too long, things pick up, or you say no to a really, really great property because you're like, oh, what if? And then it's the one that got away. So there's never a perfect time, is there?
Well, I think we're herd animals, right? And I think that's the problem. When you are buying in a market where there is very low sentiment, very low confidence, you sort of have to step away from the herd and go, I get all that. I know that potentially prices could go lower.
I know that there might be cheaper. I could get better options in the future, but I'm going to make this decision and we're going to put my stake in the ground and
That's quite brave because you've got to be going against your family, going against your friends, going against like – and so I think that's the danger of it.
In a hot market, everyone's like wrapped up in it and prices are rising and it's much easier and you can just sort of get – but I think in a buyer's market, you sort of got to like have the confidence to know that it's going to be a good decision and you got to just be able to I guess back yourself and I find that's really hard because –
Often, you know, just naturally we're herd animals and we don't want to be proven wrong or feel like we've made a mistake. And sometimes it's better to do nothing in that situation.
Yeah, exactly. So let's work through the specific psychological traps, what they are and how to manage them. And the first one is basically exactly what you've been talking about, Chris, which is the human need for social proof.
And this is applicable in like a lot of areas of our life, but especially with property, there are so many situations where buyers are needing their decision validated by another buyer coming along and saying, hey, I'm prepared to pay this price.
Because otherwise, if they feel like they're the only person interested, then that makes them question, hey, is this the right property? Why does no one else want it? Am I paying the right price? Versus then someone else coming along, hey, I'll pay that price.
And then all of a sudden they're like, oh, it is worth that. I'm prepared to pay a little bit more. That's why auctions are sometimes, and auctions only work in competitive environments, right? But auctions are the perfect environment for that social proof situation. But then when a property passes in at an auction,
Then that need for social proof, especially if there were no other bidders, a buyer who was prepared to pay, say, a million dollars, and all of a sudden that property passes in at 950, they start to question, oh, should I even pay 950?
Because all of a sudden, no one else is prepared to pay 950 or a million dollars. Why should I? And, but then they could wait a few days and I've seen this happen before plenty of times, Chris, where then they walk away. They say, Oh, we'll just, we've got the power here.
Let's wait till next week. Maybe I can get it from less than nine 50. And then someone comes in on the Monday and they buy it and sometimes push the price even higher over a million dollars. So that absolutely happens.
Yeah, I think there's, you know, it's that in the auction environment particularly, right, it's as many people as you can get there, even if it's, you know, agents just want any type of bid, right?
Like they just want people to feel like, you know, they're not the only ones who are really keen on this property.
I've absolutely seen, like you said, that go down like a lead balloon and the whole thing flips and everyone starts doubting their decisions and you've got to keep going back to the fundamentals in that situation. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, the whole auction game is a whole world, right?
All the biases that play out in that and anchoring and loss aversion and scarcity and urgency and all these sort of things that an auction creates. It really is a whirlwind for a lot of people in that environment.
Absolutely, so in these instances, I always say to my clients and anyone I'm speaking to, don't wait for the social proof because the social proof just then means you've got more competition and maybe you have to pay more.
So the way to overcome this, and this is really, really hard because this is such a strong human desire, is to really just focus again on the fundamentals. So you've done all of your due diligence, you've done your comparable sales analysis and you've decided what that property is worth to you
Therefore, what anyone else does or thinks should in theory be relevant, irrelevant, sorry, easier said than done. But that's the way to overcome that.
And just know that in property, if you wait for social proof, that is fine if you need that to validate your decision, but just know that that could cost you more.
I do think there is a bit of the brain is trying to protect you, though, as well, right?
So, like, if there is a property and it hasn't got much interest and you are the only person there and, you know, there is a bit – you don't sort of ignore that, though, I guess, as well.
Like, you've got to sort of – particularly if you go to another open home up the road and – You've got to be thinking, well, maybe why is no one loving this property? Is it something I'm missing?
Obviously, you can keep going deeper and deeper, but you might realize, well, actually, you know what? There's a privacy problem here, or it's a road, or there's something that it's just too small. People just really want something a bit bigger. So there might be something that's actually really quite compromised with it.
that the brain is sort of warning you.
So don't ignore that, I guess, because even in sort of cold markets and buy markets, good property should probably, like a seagull to a chip, should be buyers will probably gravitate to that property because they've got choice, they've got time, they're going to be more selective in what they buy.
In hot markets, though, And unfortunately, you know, everything's going like hotcakes. And so it's, you know, it's easy to get that social proof because everything's selling. But I mean, I love that saying.
On that, I will definitely say though in cooler markets because buyers are spread so much more thin. I have seen plenty of great property, great quality properties, no issues, great, great like family homes or first home by properties. They have...
sold for less than what they should have because just a bit of bad luck. Because just say you've got an X amount of numbers of buyers in a market, it's relying on a little bit of luck for that vendor to have the right people at the right time.
And then you might have, and I've seen this happen so much recently, you might have three people have said they're interested. And then the week before the auction, one person buys something else, the other person gets gold feet and the other person...
can't get their finance, whatever it is, but that vendor's left with no buyers and they have to sell. Therefore, they're going to accept almost any price at the auction or just after. So, that's the need for social proof. The next one is never assume what someone else will do
I see this all the time with buyers saying, well, if I do this, the vendor is going to probably do this or the other buyer might do this. You cannot ever speculate in a negotiation on what someone else is going to say or do. It's just so, so, so common.
And I suppose it's easy for me to say because I've seen every single negotiation go every single kind of way. But some people just assume other people will behave the way that They will. That absolutely isn't the case. People are irrational in most cases when it comes to property. So I've seen.
Yeah. I think back early days when I was an advisor, one of my boss at the time basically said, why did you say that? I assumed. He said, never assume basically. It was a real eye opener and ask the question and go deeper. And I sort of always remember that.
And I sort of always, because every time you ask more questions and you start to find out more information. And I think even with when I first started learning about property, you know, oh, this is how you negotiate.
And then I sort of realized pretty quickly that there's about a thousand different ways how you can negotiate and a thousand different strategies in all different markets. And you know, all different agents. And so I think you're right.
It's like, there's always a level one thinking of if I do this, they're going to do this, but you know, there's thousands of different options that, you know, and it's very hard to just sort of assume you can have a guess and you can have a strategy. Absolutely.
But it doesn't mean that that's going to come out that way. Right.
Yeah. So the solution here is to only focus on what you can control in your own decisions. Never assume what someone else is going to do.
And also try and play out all of the different scenarios so that you have a clearer picture rather than just being like, I think they're going to do this. Okay. If the agent says this, this could happen. If the
so that I can explain to my clients the risks of each decision we might try and make. Because there are a lot of variables here. The next one, this is so common, Chris.
Never try, and this is really hard, never try to let a bad agent or vendor impact your negotiations or your decision-making. Have you heard this happen before? No.
Oh, absolutely. But I mean, it's hard, right? Because sometimes the agents do take you on a bit of a ride and it's all of a sudden, there's a bit of a frustration with the agent and you're saying, well, what are you... It's the property. They're a stakeholder in this, I get it.
But sometimes you just got to get through them to get the property done. And Yeah, I think that sometimes clients actually get burnt out just dealing with the agents and particularly if they feel like they're being blindsided, right?
They've been really open and transparent and then all of a sudden they thought they had a property and they lost it. All of a sudden their trust with all agents goes and they sort of sometimes blame the agents for the reason they can't buy, but it's usually the experience they've gone through.
Oh, absolutely. And I deal with so many different types of agents, Chris. Most of them are pretty good. Some of them are so difficult to deal with. They talk in riddles.
Some of the more difficult ones to deal with, and this is not by their own fault, are the really inexperienced ones. They haven't done many transactions. They haven't dealt with many buyers or they're just very young. They haven't been trained properly.
I have to really manage those people when it comes into negotiation so I can get a really clear process and strategy from them. But the ones that are genuinely difficult and also the vendors, sometimes a vendor will really be quite hard to in that like they might just not give us counter offers.
They might not be willing to negotiate. They might not be flexible on any kind of terms or changes or anything. You just might get into a situation where you feel really frustrated. You're angry at the agent, angry.
And I've seen this happen before where I've had a few buyers I'm helping negotiate where they have gotten to a point where they're like, I don't ever wanna negotiate with this anymore. I am just over this. And again, this is my job.
I'm in the middle to talk them off the ledge and say, no, let's not lose sight of the bigger picture here. just because you've come up a little bit in price does not mean that they have to come down. That is not how a negotiation works. Every negotiation is different.
And also you've come in way lower than what you're prepared to pay. And I don't think they're asking prices unreasonable. Like let's focus on that for a moment. But ego and frustration can absolutely cloud a judgment.
So the way that you need to deal with this is before you go into any negotiation, figure out where you want to end up and try to not lose sight of that goal because that is the ultimate, like that is the best way to then come back to that original point, like data point.
I want to tell you a story about how the new Rask platform came to be. In 2025, everyone was still waking up to this idea that AI was going to have an impact on the world. And it wasn't until mid to late 2025 that it really hit me like a ton of bricks.
that time, I thought, what can I do with this new tool, this innovative technology? That set in motion what has now become a totally new Rask platform, which you can find at rask.au. It is 100% free to create an account and start using tools. But what did it actually do?
And what does it do for you? At Rask, we've produced thousands of podcasts. Probably 20,000 articles were written on investing and all of these different types of things like personal finance, superannuation, you name it. So we really needed a place where we could bring all of that together for the entire community.
That can be found at rask.au. Whether you're a retiree, a business builder, or a student of finance, you should go and check it out. But once we built the platform, we realized that that wasn't enough. So in 2026, we've decided to launch a new community known as the Rask Ultra community.
This is the deepest, most advanced part of what we do as a business and as a community of investors and builders. We want to build a network of people that can come together and share ideas in a new ecosystem that we've built just for you.
You can find out more, like I said, by Googling Rask Ultra or by creating a free account at rask.au and see if Ultra is right for you.
Yeah. I mean, it's sometimes the final, the vendor always wants to feel like they're winning, right? And they're the one who's got the property who's, I find that they are the ones who can ultimately make the decision to sell it, right? And
you know, sometimes they'll get, you know, they just want to feel like they've won. They want to feel like they've got to pay the agents. They're going to, particularly, you know, if they're selling a property with less than what they want.
And sometimes I find that, you know, negotiations have fallen over over 10 grand, right? Where, you know, they sort of, each party gets a bit stubborn and, you know, the deal doesn't go through because they're sort of both not willing to sort of move. Is that sort of what you're referring to here?
Where the final thing is you're forgetting the The priority here is actually just getting this deal done. Sometimes you might feel like you're losing, but ultimately, you don't want to feel like you're losing when you bought the wrong property. I think that's the key thing.
If you maybe paid a little bit more than you wanted to, but you secured it and it got you out of the market and you know you got a good asset, that's way more important than saying, I got a really good deal, but I'm just maybe not happy with the property I bought.
It goes both ways too, because I've seen plenty of situations. I'm not going to say plenty, but definitely a few situations where a vendor slash agent has decided they don't want to deal with that particular buyer anymore.
The vendor's like, I do not want that person to have my house based on their behavior at the opens, their behavior with the agents, their attitude with the agents. And the agent is the conduit between you and the vendor. They're the ones controlling the narrative and passing all that information along.
And they can spin that a little bit. If you've really annoyed that agent, then that agent is not going to frame you in the best light with the vendor and the negotiations.
And they will, I know this is not necessarily the right thing to do, but they'll sometimes steer the vendor away from you. So, I have seen properties sell for less than to another buyer.
I'm not talking like 50 grand less, like maybe 10, 20 grand less because that agent slash vendor does not want to sell it to that person or they don't even call them back. Don't let that happen to you.
Yeah, I think, you know, sometimes the low ball offers, right, that could really upset them and, you know, the agent feels like I've got to get you up from a long starting point here and, you know.
Well, that's a great, yeah, low ball. Let's talk about that really quickly, Chris, because in a buyer's market there's a lot of talk about low balls. There's a difference. I think the definition personally of a low ball offer is like a –
It's just, it's below what that property is worth and an opportunistic type of offer. And I'm not saying never do it. Like sometimes you can actually get a good result, but it's the way that you frame that offer with the agent.
It's not, you need to try and do it in a way that's then not becoming offensive or like you need to be able to justify it in a way that to say that like, I appreciate this is not where the vendor is going to be. This is why I'm putting it forward.
I'd love to, you know, I'd love to get a response to see if this is even an option. I can be more sharp on terms than price. Like you do it that way rather than like, hey, vendor's asking way too much. It's not worth it. You know, just being really aggressive about it.
They're the same offer. It's just the way that you frame it.
I think on the other way, I've also seen clients win with letters, you know, and being super nice. Yeah, I've had a few letters with success. Yeah, and I think it's, yeah, I don't know.
I've definitely seen that work, you know, and I think obviously there's some vendors who, you know, don't really care. They just need a certain price and, you know, if someone offered a dollar more, they'd probably take it. The letter didn't make any difference. Yeah.
You know, you can definitely see where, you know, the negotiations happened and they've got a deal done. Particularly, I've seen it, you know, over the years, a lot of first home buyers in the family market and they just sort of play into that, particularly if they're buying it off.
I mean, even when we were renting a property out, like... There was four different offers and someone for our property renting wrote a letter and said, like, we just really need to rent something. I was like, okay, I'll take these guys because they could just see the emotional there.
And the rent was the same, right? But it did make a difference in my belief of the four different options there. I wanted to support that family. So I can definitely say that that's worked as well.
And just to summarize this little section on agents and vendors being frustrating, I have come across a lot of situations where someone comes to me and says, I don't want to deal with that agent anymore. He was playing games. And in a lot of...
I would say to them, okay, talk me through that scenario. What happened? What did you say? What did they say? And in most cases, it wasn't the agent playing games. I mean, agents, some of them are more difficult to deal with, but ultimately they just want to sell a property, right?
They will try their best to just sell that property. And most of the time it's because the buyers didn't ask the right questions. So before they put their offer in, they didn't ask that agent, how are you going to handle my offer? When am I going to get a response?
What will the process be? Are you going to disclose my offers? What will happen from there? Instead, they gave an offer and then all of a sudden the agents called them back a few days later. Hey, is that your best offer? Yeah.
And, you know, the person putting the offer in might say, yeah, I already gave it to you. And then the agent just doesn't call them back and they see a sold sign. The buyer's like, well, why didn't they call me back if they had another offer?
They asked if it was your best offer. So the buyer might think, well, why didn't I do a Zoom auction? I did that the last time I bought a property with another agent.
So they then like, you know, that's agents off their Christmas card list that year, but it wasn't actually the agent's fault. The agent should have explained it to them. But a lot of agents often forget what buyers don't know as well. There's the problem. It's information asymmetry in the real estate market.
Yeah, I mean, I'd be awful at being an agent. I feel like it's also kind of like a recruiter, though, unfortunately, though. It's like you can sort of hate the game, but it's not really their fault. They're having to play. It's really hard for an agent, right?
They're keeping information, making sure you've got enough buyers. They've got to also do a job for their vendor, and I feel like it's sometimes a bit hypocritical. When you're on the buyer side, it just doesn't feel nice.
But then when you're selling a property, you want the agent to be doing all the tactics they can possibly get to, you know, create a best price for you. It's the same sort of thing about underquoting, right? I find that, you know, people get frustrated with the price guides alone.
Then when they sell their property, they do the exact same tactic that happened to them. And so, yeah, sometimes you just got to sort of go, okay, look, they're doing their job. They're actually looking after the vendor. They're not there for you. So you've just got to, yeah.
Yeah. It's also a case of They kind of can't win in any situation. This is not like a poor real estate agent approach, but it's no buyers are going to be happy with like all processes.
So either an agent's not disclosing offers, which some buyers prefer because they're like, I don't want anyone else to know my offer, or they're being fully transparent, which other people don't prefer. Like it's just- They can't win. And I talk to agents all the time.
They're like, this is our process and everyone gets angry about it, but we have a blanket office process and that's what we do. So look, ultimately you just got to realize there is actually no perfect way of selling real estate. Private sales have their flaws. Auctions have their problems as well.
I know that Victoria is introducing, what do you think about this, Chris? The requirement to disclose reserve prices.
Yeah, and New South Wales Fair Trading are doing some stuff as well. I mean, it's – I don't know. Like I feel like it's – the whole agent game, I do feel like people do need to still – there's an art and a sort of to actually still get things sold.
And so I do hope that it doesn't, you know, sort of –
Yeah, make it even harder for agents just to do their job to actually get the price they need to for the property. This is my sort of, you know, because I don't think it should be like, it is quite subjective, right? And there's, like you said, all these emotions.
You've got to sort of motivate people to sometimes take action. And sometimes that scarcity there and the desire and the fear actually helps people make decisions and gets properties sold. And so more transparency sometimes doesn't mean people will take action. That's probably my concern.
Yeah, I'm thinking, and I know we're going a bit of a tangent here, but it's topical news here at the moment in Melbourne, but I understand it in that there are so many agents who under quote to the point where the reserve prices is over the quote range.
And that is a problem because that's a controllable element. If competition takes it well over the quote range, And there's comparable sales that support the quote range. That's a different story. That's outside control.
But if a reserve is genuinely over and they're not supposed to do that, like if they know what a vendor's reserve price is that they have to quote accordingly, but they just, you know, there's a compliance involved there and all of this stuff that just isn't then followed. Right.
But the problem is the way that I look at it, a vendor's reserve can change so frequently depending on what else is selling at the time, depending on how motivated they become, depending on the buy interest. And the reserve can even change during the auction. Yeah.
So I just don't quite yet understand the logistics of – What is the agent checking every day? Hey, is your reserve price range? Hey, is it changed? But also more importantly, whose responsibility is it?
So for example, if that vendor says my reserves $700,000 and then on the auction day or during the auction, they're like, nah, I was never gonna sell for that because you can't force them to sell for that price. Nah, I wouldn't sell for less than 800. Who is then liable?
Is the agent then liable for whatever repercussions are gonna be involved here? I don't think the government would ever penalise a vendor or pursue a vendor. I really don't understand how they're going to enforce this.
Yeah, yeah. Well, I know New South Wales are definitely going to do a lot of checking around sort of price guides and selling within a range and sort of getting some really good data on it. So I think, yeah, I mean the whole sort of I agree with the reserve.
Who's to say you can't change your reserve literally on the day, the morning you wake up?
And you decide that it's the right property for you and it's worth more money to you.
And then it's up to the vendor to then actually communicate that to the agent. The agent can update it. That's easy enough. But it relies on the vendor communicating it and also then adhering to it as well. That's the hard part. Anyway, so moving on. The next psychological trap is...
The length of time a property is on the market does not always indicate that there is something wrong with it. So sometimes buyers will see a property that has either been around for ages and say, no, something's wrong with it. Not going to even consider it.
Or they might've seen that that property has sold a couple of times over the last five years. I think no, something's wrong with it. Whereas, you know, the people who have lived there, they might've gotten divorced. They might've just got another job and moved into state.
But the length of time on the market, it could be so many different reasons. It could have been really overpriced at the start and it just lagged there and sat there for a while.
Maybe they got offers and the vendor at the time weren't prepared to take them or the terms were not right. Or maybe there was genuinely a problem, you know, building inspection issue. And you will only find that out once you do your own due diligence.
But it's definitely a case of like, just because a property's been online for a while, doesn't mean it's a dud. Sometimes. But I think that sometimes buyers then just let that weigh on them too much. And that comes back to social proof again, Chris. No, no one else has won it so far.
I don't want it. And then all of a sudden someone puts an offer and the agent calls you, hey, it's sold. Oh, damn, I would have bought it at that price.
Yeah, I think that's usually classic. Sometimes it's just not a property, right? People don't really want it, right? And sometimes you're right. To get the listing, the agents probably had to flatter the owner a little bit. Everyone believes their properties are worth more than they are. That's just the behavioral bias. And then
You know, they've had to list it at a higher price guide and then they've had to sort of condition the vendor down. And so it's a good property. It's just that there was just a very high expectation. And also sometimes it's time of year, right?
Like maybe they've listed it a little bit too late in the spring campaign and they didn't take it off over Christmas. So it's been sitting on the market, but really it was only –
You know, the buyer sort of pull was only really the late November and, you know, it's still quite high price. So it looks like it's been on the market for a long, but it's more when they listed it as well. But, yeah, I think – but sometimes it's a good sign, right?
If it hasn't been selling and everything else has been selling in the market and this one's just sitting there, like that's absolutely a sign to do a bit more DD and obviously check, right?
Yeah, absolutely. Another psychological trap is – is benchmarking against one sold property. So what I mean by this is you... I'll have people come to me and say, hey, I can definitely afford what I want in this market. Look at that one that sold.
That would have been perfect and that sold within my budget. And I might say to them, okay, that was one example or maybe I know the story behind it and it sold cheap for a certain reason.
Yeah, you need to know the story, don't you? Yeah.
Exactly. But I'm like, okay, that's fine. That's great. One great benchmark. But try and find some more... So that we've got at least confidence that that wasn't an anomaly.
Or it's also relevant if someone is then trying to appraise a property and decide how much they're prepared to pay, but they're only looking at one other sale that's similar, not a broader data set.
So when I'm doing a comparable sales analysis, I'm trying my best to get between six and 10 properties that are sold to compare to. So that one property sale is not my benchmark because again,
It can just be luck of the draw, either a lucky buyer who got a massive price for it on the day or sold for way less because they were extremely motivated. So we need to have a broad set.
If you anchor yourself too much to one sale, it can really cloud your judgment and rational decision-making in my experience.
Yeah, and I think every property is different, right? I mean, if you've got a cookie cutter sort of, you know, street after street, you can easily sort of get a good idea of what value is and particularly if you've been in the market for a while.
But, yeah, I think some markets are much harder, right? And, you know, what's the discount for a busy road? What's the discount because the block is a bit steep or, you know, it's an older house versus a renovated house. If you actually haven't been through the house as well, like –
You know, it might need a lot of work. The photos might not have shown it. You know, there's just, you know, and I think, you know, you've got to go to the sort of the open homes. You've got to go to the auctions.
You've got to sort of, and even the stories the agents say or the other agents say can sometimes not be the truth as well. And so, yeah, I find that as well is, well, if that sold for that price, this must be worth this.
Well, yeah, but that didn't sell under competition or did sell under a lot of competition.
Exactly.
And so you've got to be really careful. I've seen that happen as well.
That was one of my most difficult things to wrap my head around when I first started working in real estate trying to appraise properties because I came from an economics background and I'm a very rational person. I was like, okay, how much of a discount is a main road? Is it 4%?
Is it 8%? How much extra value does an en suite have? And is it 20 grand? Is it 50 grand? There's actually no answer to that. And that's, it's take, I've done, I don't know, 5,000 appraisals now. Some are much more straightforward and others, I have to be a bit more creative.
I have to go back further in time. I have to extrapolate a little bit more. And depending on the amount of comparable sales you have, you might have high confidence around value or lower confidence around value.
And that can be really, really then challenging to be able to determine your own value of that property. So yeah, there's definitely a risk in just only using one other one that's sold.
And then also that extra risk I just mentioned of looking at a property and say, okay, well, that was on a main road. Therefore, this is worth 5% more because it's on a quiet street. Unfortunately, it just doesn't work that way.
Yeah, and it's completely in different markets, right? In some markets, the gap's not much at all. And that's frustrating because you're like, oh, but, you know, a lot of buyers just haven't got that extra cash. And, you know, if you had that bit more, you probably could have got it.
But, you know, in some markets, yeah, the gap's huge between, you know, you need to discount it a lot because, you know, it's some severe, you know, compromises or, you know, you're getting a really good deal because you're not paying extra for all those extra benefits. So, yeah.
Yeah, exactly. So the next one is around the psychological trap of what a property is worth on paper versus what a property is worth to you. So when I'm helping clients, I'm doing a comparable sales analysis for a property.
I'm saying, okay, based on these sales and based on current market conditions, this is what I think the property is worth. It's usually a little bit of a range because it's It's almost impossible to say this property is worth $1.275 million. Exactly.
But then over that, on top of that, we have to overlay how many boxes does this stick for you? Is this ticking all the non-negotiables plus all of your bonuses? Do you need to get into this certain school zone by the end of the year? How long have you been looking for?
And also, if we're benchmarking against all of the properties that you've previously seen and were in your homework when you were doing your research around your briefs, Where does this sit? Is this in like the top one, the top three, or is it somewhere in the middle?
That then allows us to determine what I call personal value. It's extremely subjective. What a property is worth to me, Chris, is different to what it might be worth to you based on your own personal circumstances. You've got to figure out the on paper value and your personal value.
And then also just because sometimes a lot of people say, oh my gosh, I can't believe they paid that much for a property. Well, maybe that was their dream home. And then vice versa. So that's a really important thing to help to try and figure out.
And then to not let other people's opinions on value. Oh my gosh, I say this so much, Chris, but someone's parents will just come along and say, well, I don't think it's worth that. I think it's worth that. And I say to them, okay, based on what? Oh, I just think so.
That can really cloud someone's, you know, their kid's judgment. They're like, oh, well, my parents, you know, they've bought property before. They know what they're talking about or they're helping me buy this property. I need to listen to them. But it's actually based on maybe no actual data, no research, right?
but also then just an opinion and it doesn't overlay that person's personal value. Personal value, by the way, is not always more than the on paper value. Sometimes it's less. For example, if you need to do some work to that property to meet your needs, it might be less.
Yeah, I mean, yeah, the opinions in there, they're already stressed about making this decision. And, yeah, I mean, everyone wants their parents and their family to like what they bought and be proud of it, et cetera. But I have seen that as well, the parents that have come in and sort of,
You know, if anything, they're sabotaging the purchase here and bringing the doubt into the situation. I think you've got to be careful paying for what you really value though as well.
Like you've got to be absolutely, you make sure the property suits you, your life and pay a premium because you could pay a very similar price for a similar property that doesn't give you any near as much happiness because it's a bit further away from where your friends are or the school or whatever really you would value.
But also, you know, making sure that if you are paying more, it's something what a lot of other people would value as well, right? And you haven't just overpaid because you really wanted a view, but it was a really steep block. I'm thinking about myself here.
And, you know, other people don't want that. They want a flat block, right? And so you've got to be careful that the market also wants what you want. You're not just, you know, because, you know, when you do sell it one day, that's kind of what's going to price it, right?
It's not what you loved. It's what the market wanted.
Well, it just means that you're also then more reliant on finding someone else who values what you value, which is a lower chance than having more broad market appeal. But I like to think about it in a different way in that not everybody...
buys a property for the sake of trying to maximize resale value.
If you plan on being there for 10 years, the most important thing, and obviously we need to make sure that it's got no major problems with it, but the most important thing is to give you as much satisfaction as possible with living there. So we need to balance it all up.
Yeah, absolutely.
All right. So only a few more left, Chris, on our list. Now, we talked about auctions a little bit before. and pass in situations.
I just want to circle back to it and reiterate it on because the amount of times where we've been bidding at an auction and it's passed into us below what we were prepared to pay.
And then my client has had a bit of a existential crisis because like, why is no one else bidding? Why does no one else want this and have to talk them off the ledge and say, no, we need to see this as an opportunity. This is amazing.
We can now get this potentially lower than what you were prepared to pay. If you don't feel comfortable, that is totally fine. We can wait till Monday. We are then taking a risk because right now we have the exclusive right to negotiate. Let's go back to the fundamentals. But this happens so often.
So I always have to prep my clients before we go into an auction. Hey. If it passes in, this is what will happen. This is going to be our negotiation angle. And I frame it in a way that that's actually not a bad thing.
So please bear in mind whenever you go to an auction, a lot of people don't expect it to pass in, especially in a hotter market, maybe not so much right now. But plan ahead. Put yourself in that scenario.
Think about the way you're not going to negotiate as well, Chris, because passing situations can be high pressure. I've heard some agents that say, all right, if we don't do a deal in 10 minutes, I'm leaving.
And other agents who will, you know, stay and try and facilitate and hold hands a little bit more.
Mm-hmm. Yeah, I think the whole sort of, I do think that this is where great buyers agents add so much more value than, because, you know, it's hard, right?
If you haven't gone through this process, you know, once every X amount of years, you've never done it before, you know, what do you do in these situations?
It's kind of right for people to freeze and get worried and get concerned and want to sort of, and, you know, and time also helps you make better decisions. And so, you know, I can sort of, you know, in that situation, I would naturally also want to just say, right, okay, cool.
I need to go home and sleep on it. I need to go and think about something else. But you're right. That maybe misses the opportunity to, you know, get a deal done now, knowing that the agent's going to go back, make some calls, probably call other buyers.
And, you know, who knows at 7.30 that night, another buyer could come out of nowhere and sniper you off. And you think, oh, I thought I had time, but you didn't.
My best advice in any kind of negotiation where you feel like you're either being put under pressure, you're worried you're going to say the wrong thing, or you just don't know what to say, always just say to the agent, give me a minute, I've got to make a phone call.
You might say, I've got to call my partner. I've got to call my broker. I've got to call my parents. You don't have to make a phone call. You go and pretend you're making a phone call.
That's your opportunity to go and have a moment and go and have a think about what you're going to say next rather than just being, you know, blundering out something that you didn't mean to say or just making a decision under stress and duress because sometimes you just need that time.
So if any time an agent asks you a question, you just don't feel comfortable answering, you don't know how to answer, hey, so sorry, I just need a moment. It's fine. So that's my biggest tip there.
All right. Well, let's wrap things up with just a last comment about real estate agents as well. I think that there is an extremely strong buyer sentiment around the agent is always out to kind of get you. The agent is trying to get one over you.
And I get that because first of all, agents have a bad rat. Secondly, there are a lot of really crappy agents out there and They are ultimately working for the vendor. They're not working for you. But you just also then need to remember that their goal is to facilitate a transaction.
And to do that, they have to, in most cases, help a buyer to do that. Because most buyers don't have a buyer's agent working for them.
So the agent has to help that buyer to get them across the line because a lot of buyers are so inexperienced, so naive, don't know what they're doing. The agent is kind of helping both. But then often a buyer is like, why is this agent helping me?
Or do I really trust what they're saying because they're not actually working for me? So you just always have to go into it with what I call a healthy level of skepticism to know that you are not their client. Unless you have a buyer's agent, you have to figure out this yourself and
But don't always assume that everything they do and say is to get one over you or to play games or they're always bluffing about other offers. Just one tip here.
Once, because people ask me about bluffing all the time, you can, first of all, never know an agent is bluffing until you call their bluff and either you're right or wrong. It's a risk that you take. But secondly, the risk of bluffing is much lower once a property has received an acceptable offer.
What I mean by that is the, there's two phases of a property negotiation. First of all, it has to get to a level the vendor's prepared to sell it. And then they go to every other buyer. We call that first point an acceptable offer. Vendor says, yes, I've accepted those price and terms.
Let's go out to everyone else. If no better offers, that property will be sold. So an agent calls you and says, we have an acceptable offer. or even if they don't use that language, you can ask them, hey, is it acceptable? If they say yes, okay, when's the property going to be sold?
Within 24 hours. There is a very low risk they are bluffing because once they have an acceptable offer, they're paid. They've sold that property.
They have not a lot of incentive to then bluff to just try and get a little bit more versus if you say to them, and this is especially relevant for a pre-auction offer, by the way, Versus if you say to them, well, is that an acceptable offer?
And they say, oh, no, not yet. Well, then you don't necessarily have to do anything there. You'd say, okay, why is it acceptable? Is it based on price? Is it based on terms? You fish for more information there. But just so you know, more chance of bluffing if it's not acceptable.
Because otherwise nothing else will happen from there.
Yeah, I think that's the problem, right? Sometimes the, you know, you feel like they're bluffing, you feel like you've got time and you just don't want that one to get away, right? The other option is sometimes you go in too hot, right?
And you sort of, you know, just need to get it secured and you just don't take that sort of gamble, right? And you just offer as much as you can. So I feel like, yeah, sometimes you got to play the game, right?
And it sounds like that's a really good tip there, unacceptable offers.
Yeah, so I hope this episode has been helpful because you might've listened to this and think, yep, I've been in that situation before and you resonate with one of these things, or maybe you're getting involved in negotiations now, just keep all of it in the back of your mind.
And just the biggest tip I've got is to ultimately just do all of your research, your due diligence, your comparable sales, your price setting and everything before you enter negotiations or before you make decisions. And just come back to that, even if you have to write it down.
And if you've got a partner involved or a dad or a mom or whoever, And they've got lots of opinions or like their personality is very different to yours and they're a bit more reactive and emotional. That's also a hard thing to manage as well.
But all the more reason you've got to come back to your own fundamentals.
Yeah, the only thing I would say from a finance point of view is just get it sorted early, understand your repayments, understand how you're going to structure, how much buffer you're going to have, sort of put that to the side and go, okay, cool, I understand all that, and then focus all your energy on is this the right property for me and then is it, you know, and then –
If you know that, then it's a case of, okay, well, how are we going to actually secure this? And sometimes knowing that the thing that matters is those first two. The last one, the price, it's always a bit subjective. It's always a bit.
That's probably the one that you might in time go, oh, I wish I paid 1.2 instead of 1.25, but you're not going to worry about that too much. If you've structured it the right way and you've got a good asset, that's the last thing you probably need to be as concerned by.
But, yeah, that would be my advice as well.
Yeah. Always a pleasure, Chris.
Thank you, Amy. We'll talk again soon. I really appreciate the episode.
See you. Bye.
Thanks for tuning into the Australian Property Podcast.
If you love the show, why not subscribe or leave us a review on Apple or Spotify? And if you want to work with me, Amy, Pete or Chris, you'll find links in your podcast player to get in contact with us.
Thank you.
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Australian Property Podcast. We're huge advocates of getting the right advice at the right time from the right people. That's why it's important to understand that this podcast episode contained general financial information only.
It is not designed to be specific or personalized to your financial, tax or legal situation. With property, the check sizes are pretty big. So it's important you get advice from a licensed and trusted professional before acting on the information you hear in RAS podcasts. Thanks again for listening.
I regret to inform you that chances are a lot of you will need financial advice. Since we started the Rask Advice business, I've noticed quite a few trends, but one of them is the importance of having confidence in what you're actually saving towards or investing towards.
A lot of people in the RAS community are very capable of managing their own money, but when it comes to critical points in their life like retirement, selling a business, scaling a business, getting married, buying your first home, so on and so forth, getting expert advice will actually save you from a bunch of mistakes
and give you the confidence to know what it is you're doing and why you're doing it.
If you want to get matched with one of the trusted financial partners that we have, you can just head to rask.au slash financial planning, or you can get in contact with us on any of the Rask websites.
Not only does Rask itself provide financial advice, but we also have trusted partners if we're not the right fit for you. So we can help guide you in the right direction. And that in turn supports us to create more free financial education content like podcasts, courses, and so much more.
