Curious about upgrading?
Wondering where to start?
Complex questions that need answers?
Is there a better structure for you?
"They managed to navigate my complex expat income and even got my Google RSU income approved as well."
"I highly recommend Alcove to anyone looking for a mortgage broker who is responsive, trustworthy, and truly cares about their clients. Thanks again to the whole team for making the process such a positive experience!"
"As founders, we're constantly jumping between things so having a partner that handled the details & made the process super clear made the buying process breezy for us. Very happy with the experience!"
“It almost felt like it was his responsibility to make it clear to me, not my responsibility to understand it.”
“I've been pretty much fully leveraged the whole time. So the sounding board on that, in terms of what was achievable, what wasn't — I think trust is just built along that.”
"Alcove has been a great partner. They look after my audience properly, keep things simple, and deliver real value. I’ve got full confidence referring clients knowing they’ll get honest, straightforward advice."
"Property is one of the biggest financial decisions people make. Alcove stood out because they take a strategic approach to lending - helping clients structure property and debt decisions in a way that genuinely supports their broader financial plans."
Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Pete Wargent and Chris Bates unpack how long the Sydney and Melbourne property downturn could last, why build costs may rise again, and what buyers, sellers and investors should do next.
This podcast is proudly brought to you by Perla, the official brokerage platform of Rask. With Perla, you can effortlessly automate your money, whether you're investing in ETFs or shares from Australia or the US stock market, whether you're a grandparent or setting up a kid's account or your own account.
You can do all of that with full automation on Perla.com. If you want to learn more, head to Perla.com slash Rask. And of course, before you invest in anything, be sure to read the legal documents like the PDS and FSG.
This episode is brought to you by Stripe, helping your business be ready for whatever comes next. And the next shift in how people buy is already happening. Agentic Commerce lets customers discover and purchase directly inside an AI conversation. No checkout page, no friction.
The businesses positioning themselves now are the ones who will lead this channel. Whatever comes next for your business, power it with Stripe. Learn more at stripe.com.
War could add maybe another 10% to construction costs. That would add at least $50,000 cost to new builds, according to the AFR.
I think it'd be a major concern for the development industry. The last thing they needed right now was more uncertainty, issues around inflation or getting access to materials. Secondly, it's not really good for people signing up to contracts.
Not only do you need your finance, when you're potentially signing off the plane, you want to go, yeah, I'm confident, but can you really sign an off-the-plane contract with three years to go and knowing that you're going to have to to be working and earning a certain income.
It's just too risky right now.
This is a podcast by The Rask Group. It's for educational purposes only. So please do not make a financial, legal, investment or taxation decision based on solely what you hear in this show.
Welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. We're on a mission to be Australia's most trusted property podcast. I'm Owen Rask, founder of The Rask Group.
I'm Pete Borgent, author and buyer's agent. I'm Amy Linardi and I am a buyer's agent.
I'm Chris Bates, ex-financial planner and mortgage broker. Together, we'll take you through every step of your property journey.
From first home buyer to decades of property investing.
Hello, welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. I'm Pete Wargent from Alan Wargent Property Buyers. I'm here with Chris Bates from the Alcove Group Mortgage Specialists.
G'day Chris, how's your week been? It's been good, Pete. Miss seeing your face. Just obviously we didn't do an episode last week. I was down with the family in Mollymook. I mean, such a good time of the year to go away. Water's still warm, a bit of sun. I don't get too cooked.
The kids don't get burnt. And so, yeah, it was such a nice break. First school holiday really for us. You know, my daughter only started kindy this year. My boy starts school next year. And so, yeah, it's a bit different. But I think you're going somewhere a bit more exciting than me.
You're in Fiji, which is nice.
I'm in Fiji this week. Not quite so exotic last week. I actually had the week in Sydney while you were down the south coast.
And yeah, it's always interesting to get to another city and just see what's happening in terms of the economy, sentiment, what's happening for jobs and particularly for housing construction and housing market sentiment.
I think the one observation that I would make, well, I think firstly, despite the fuel price shock, it's just still very busy around the city. I think you've got these days, you've got trams and bike lanes, and it's more of a busier 24-hour city, certainly around central.
But I think the other thing I noticed, these are all places I went to over the past week. I got out to the Blue Mountains. I went to Penrith, Homebush. I went to Parra, Blacktown. And I went to Mascot when I left at the airport.
And I think the main observation I would make for the housing market is if you went back to... let's say, a decade ago. You couldn't turn around without seeing cranes everywhere and high-rise apartments, particularly in those sorts of places around Sydney.
This time around, though, the cycle, yes, we're building some luxury apartments, but it seems like a lot of the housing construction, and we've got a lot of units now under construction and in the pipeline, they seem to be much more in places like Redcliffe, Gold Coast,
Newcastle, it seems to be much more about owner occupiers buying places to maybe downsize to or move to the regions, but much less appetite for high rise apartments. Is that something you're seeing as well?
Yeah, I think that's going to be one of our big stories today, Pete. And I do have some sort of new intel, I guess, on sort of, you know, some developments are getting approved and it's sort of gone another level, particularly in Sydney.
And I think while we are in Sydney as a business, we've got team members, you know, in Brisbane and Melbourne and Geelong and, you know, Griffith. So, and we've also, I've lived in Melbourne as well.
So, you know, we've got a really good understanding of different markets, but I think Sydney is a bit of the canary in the coal mine. It's the city that had the biggest, you
pressure cooker effect with the house prices and a lack of options for, say, younger families in particular and downsizers as well. And I think what they're doing around changing planning zones is just such a big change.
And I've some crazy developments that are trying to get through at the moment as well, which are even out of LMR areas. So It's definitely a big story in 2026. I mean, I'm the same as you, Pete. I'm pretty property crazy, and I'm always thinking about what's happening.
So when I'm thinking about the regions and I'm watching, I'm actually just trying to start up conversations with people in the cafe when I'm getting my coffee or at restaurants or just even at the park with the kids. always just trying to get a litmus test on how people are feeling.
And yeah, it seems like people are still moving down the coast. And even asking locals, I said, think about anyone that's come down, that's gone back. And often they were scratching their head. So often a lot of people are still staying. I had some friends who live in Kiama and
You know, I sort of, um, you know, they're from that area and, you know, had a good chat to them about it as well. And so, yeah, randomly I was having, uh, my boys, there's this Blu-ray spot, um, Bendalong, I think it is.
It's not far from, um, you know, sort of Mollymook there, just a bit further north. And all these Blu-rays will come and eat, um, you know, fish and you can feed them. I'm not sure how, uh. eco it is, but a random basically said, hey, are you Chris Bates?
And I listen to your podcast every Sunday with Pete when I'm mowing the lawns. And that was awesome. And then I randomly saw him again at Taronga Zoo a few days later, which was uncanny. And so shout out to that listener there and enjoyed the chat.
But yeah, I think when you're traveling, I think that's one of the best parts of it is you Just start to understand what's happening on the ground. You know, media articles is one thing, but what people are seeing on the ground is another.
And yeah, the building supply thing is going to be a big topic today.
Yeah, it's a double-edged sword, isn't it, getting recognised around town. It's fine as long as the kids are behaving and not mucking around too much. But obviously our podcast numbers are up, so thanks everyone for tuning in.
I guess when I was down in Sydney, I mean, obviously the fuel prices are just ugly. I saw $3.35 for diesel, even with the discount. Some places, they're completely sold out around the airport and so on. I think in the property market, the auctions this week,
or this weekend just gone, but probably about the worst since 2018 for Sydney and Melbourne wasn't a whole lot better.
I guess I'm always a bit cautious to talk about market pricing because by the time I finished recording, something's changed in the Middle East conflict. But at the moment, anyway, the time of speaking, the cycle peak 4.65% for the cash rate target could go higher. and things can change pretty quickly.
I wanted to tap your brains, Chris. I did a bit of research this week into how long property market downturns normally last in Australia, because I think Sydney and Melbourne are in a sentiment downturn at the moment. So this is what I came up with.
So property downturns in Australia typically last around 9 to 12 months, with price declines averaging 2.8% to 4.3%.
from peak to trough so while boom periods often last over three years downturns are shorter frequently representing dead money or periods of stagnation rather than severe crashes we've definitely seen that before with things like high-rise apartments we just get no growth for ages
So typically downturns, this is from Grok actually, downturns commonly last less than half the time of the preceding upswing. So short term price drops average nine to 10 months and we can often get periods much longer with no growth in real terms. 2008, we saw a 13-month decline.
2022 to 2023, downturn lasted through roughly 13 interest rate rises. So I guess, look, I've seen in Sydney, when the credit squeeze was in full swing, prices in some places like Ride fell about 15% in nominal terms.
Some of the high-rise apartments saw no growth for a decade or more. I just wanted to sort of
sense checker scenario with you could this be something like this be plausible where you see maybe a 10% decline in housing prices in Sydney and Melbourne in nominal terms and after inflation it might be near a 20 maybe with the big price increases around the country maybe the currency drops 10% is that kind of a plausible scenario or I guess this is a crystal ball question but I read all this stuff online and people are talking about 50% crash the world's going to end Great Depression um
Yeah. What do you reckon?
Well, absolutely. Is it possible? I mean, I think it's really impossible, right? We don't know what's coming around the corner. We have no idea, particularly when you think about now is what's going to happen to inflation, what's going to happen with everything that's happening overseas.
And I think that's when you open up your news apps each day or each hour or each minute, it depends how much nervous you are. You have no idea what's going to happen, right?
I do think that, you know, if I look at what our clients are doing right now, I do feel maybe we've moved past that sort of peak fear. It doesn't mean that it can't spike again, but I do feel like that maybe even mid to late April is everyone was extremely concerned.
And, you know, it is a bit of a watch this space, but I think the issue is when you're sort of trying to pick in better markets. So you're in a good market to buy, let's just say, because
But under the 1.5 in Sydney or a million in Melbourne, there was articles this week that basically showed that the bottom end of the market has basically gone up 7%, even a lot more in some pockets. So when you use an aggregate number, it doesn't sound that bad.
Even 7% has gone up at the bottom end of the market over the last six months. If you break that down and look at certain pockets where a lot of first-time buyers, it's going to be more than that. particularly if it's a really hot spot where investors are going.
And so the government 5% deposit scheme has absolutely put a lot of steam in the lower end part of the market. And I don't think that, I think that'll continue. And so, yeah, I do think the upgraders are slowly coming back.
If we talk about some of the clients are getting pre-approvals at that moment, there's a lot of people that are worried about their jobs and there's a lot of people that aren't.
We've got some doctor clients, got people in oil and gas, we've got people who are running businesses that are not affected, that are potentially making even more profit than they were the last few years. And so, there's even people in tech industry, yeah, you'd be very concerned, right?
Your share prices have crashed, your job security's maybe not there, but A lot of other industries are doing quite well. And so I do think in these markets, there's a sort of flight to quality.
And so I do feel if you wait too long and you go, oh, I'm going to wait till I get certainty, then you basically will miss the opportunity to buy the good stuff. And I think that's the... the May time is the opportunity. Not trying to catch the knife right at the bottom.
And, you know, trying to, because when that happens, less people sell the best properties. But if you could potentially just before sort of the winter shutdown, you might find that you've got motivated vendors and, you know, you've got the chance of buying really top quality properties.
And so that would be sort of my advice right now and what we're seeing. But, you know, I think when there is a bit of a downturn, I think what you've got to be, you know, there is just such a big incentive with driving prices higher. And what would happen in that downturn?
Do you see interest rates get cut? Do you see borrowing capacity get relaxed? Do you see a building, you know, not happening because, you know, developers can't make it work. And so you, and people still need to live somewhere. There's still households, right?
And so what you'll find is a real reduction in listings and, I think that's more likely when you see really lots of listings on the market.
But when you look at, you know, Quartality released its monthly chart right now, it's pretty dire when you look at total listings and particularly when you dig deeper into the housing marketing in different cities.
I think it's mainly a Sydney and Melbourne thing. In fact, cotalities showed prices actually rising over the past month in most of the cities around the country. It's really Sydney and Melbourne where the downturn has happened.
We're recording this on Wednesday and I'm just looking at the stock markets in the US and I mean, it's more or less erased all of the downturn, not just from the tariffs, but now also from the Iran war and they say markets are forward looking and
I guess you take that at face value. Markets are saying, well, the war is effectively over, in inverted commas, as far as markets are concerned, which is quite amazing when you look at the price of fuel around the place.
Also this week, SQM Research put out some stats on rental vacancies, which basically crashed, particularly in Sydney. down to 1.1%. Rents are up 7.4% for asking rents in Sydney and actually rising in lots of parts of the country.
If you look at some of the vacancy rates around the place, Brisbane 0.8%, but they also fell in March in Adelaide, Perth, Darwin, Hobart. And just look at some of the rental vacancy rates. They're just unbelievably low. Hobart 0.4%, Darwin the same, Perth 0.5, Adelaide 0.7.
I suppose when you're looking for big downturns in nominal prices, the things you would probably expect to see would be high interest rates, big oversupply of properties or too much housing, rising unemployment, which we haven't really seen yet. They've got an unemployment rate of 4.3%. And yeah, those would be the factors.
And yeah, we've got I guess if you look at the housing shortage, it appears to be getting worse. I think we did see an increase in dwelling starts in the December quarter, but the delivery of housing is just so slow.
So, yeah, I suppose if I was to throw in two curveballs, one is... default.
So Chris Joy had an article in the Fin Review last week saying we're in for the mother of all default cycles, but also I guess the May budget, I suppose capital gains tax and maybe negative gearing reform on the table that could shake things up a bit. But yeah, what do you think?
Yeah. So the negative gearing sort of capital gains tax is going to be a big, I mean, it's four weeks, I mean, three weeks, pretty much, if you're listening to this now, until it's sort of going to be announced, it's highly likely a CGT change.
But I'm very interested to see if they go for negative gearing. Do they go to one to two properties or are they really brave and just go to new properties now? And that's a big change. It means that basically buying
you know, assets that are negatively geared in capital cities as investments, you know, established property is going to be really hard to sort of for investors to maintain cash flows. And so, you know, they probably will grandfather it. And so existing investors will probably still keep hold of it.
And that'll probably reduce supply because they'll be like, well, if I sell it, I won't be able to rebuy it. I won't be able to claim the deduction. And so you will probably find some investors of good assets will just hold, but
And new investors will find it really hard to enter these markets. And so what you'll find is that – and new supply just doesn't happen overnight. And the feasibility for developers isn't there.
So what you're going to really do is smash the investor market and then you will still find people that are bailing out of – you know, investment properties just naturally because it makes sense. You know, a lot of people have got, you know, a lot of growth there.
Yeah, they're happy to pay CGT because they want to put it into shares. They want to put it into super or they want to upgrade their home or they want to... And I think a lot of investors will probably bail out a market that... are exposed to the investor market.
So if you think about any suburb, you've got, say, 100 properties, just doing round numbers. If 50, 60 of those properties are owned by investors, then it's highly driven by the investor market.
Whereas if that was 80, 90% of those properties were owner occupiers, what's happening in the world is obviously a concern, but they still are living somewhere. So they can't just rush and sell. But investors can really sell at any point, even if they've got a tenant. And so...
I would say the big issue with this is if you own assets in areas that are highly driven by investors or have been driven up by investors in recent years. So the owner-occupier rate doesn't look that bad.
But if you look at the last six to 12 months, if 80%, 90% of the properties have been selling to investors, that's a real concern because they might just say, look, I want to get out of this. I want to cash in.
And this is my big concern for all those rent-vestor sort of BA, borderless buyers agents.
you know, if you find that, you know, a lot of investors want to bail because they want to sort of prioritize, you know, a home or they just want to take their money and they're worried about falls, then that market could easily flip and markets go from undersupplied to oversupplied very fast.
Yeah, so it'd be interesting. We've already got record low rental vacancy rates, where the reform to taxing housing makes that worse than it already is because it looks like rents are re-accelerating again. So let's go through our two big news stories of the week.
Firstly, we're going to look at what's happening to building and construction. Then secondly, we're going to talk about, well, what should buyers do or prospective buyers do in this market if you're a first-time buyer, maybe an upgrader or even an investor?
And then we've got time for a couple of your listener questions at the end. So stick around for that. So firstly, what's happening with builders? Well, there's a whole slew of articles this week, macro business, fin review, elsewhere, basically sort of showing how war could add maybe another 10% to construction costs.
I think even that might be on the low side, talking to a few people in the industry over the past week or two. That would add at least $50,000 cost in new builds, according to the AFR, and some industry participants saying that the impact has been much worse than this.
ABS had some stats out last week. Dwelling starts rose to 53,000 in the December quarter, which was the best since 2018. So quite a big uplift, I think, in parts of regional Queensland, southeast Queensland. It's a big sort of uptick. Also, some other regions around the country, as already mentioned. But
Yeah, I think, I suppose on the other side, though, the actual completions are still incredibly slow. I think we're on track for, at the current pace, about 875,000 dwellings over five years, which sounds like a lot, but versus a target of 1.2 million, we're about...
well, we're about a quarter short of the government's target. So yeah, I've got two questions for you, Chris. We've got 236,000 dwellings under construction. Apparently, I've driven around the East Coast last couple of weeks. I can't see where they all are, but that's what the ABS says.
So I guess there's got two questions. One is, are we just waiting for this supply of dwellings to suddenly magically appear? Or do things just stay really slow for the next few years?
And I suppose the other thing is, if we get another burst of price increases, because a lot of developers are building on fixed price contracts, are we going to see another round of insolvencies? Or is that kind of all washed through the sector now, do you think?
I want to tell you a story about how the new Rask platform came to be. In 2025, everyone was still waking up to this idea that AI was going to have an impact on the world. And it wasn't until mid to late 2025 that it really hit me like a ton of bricks.
that time, I thought, what can I do with this new tool, this innovative technology? That set in motion what has now become a totally new Rask platform, which you can find at rask.au. It is 100% free to create an account and start using tools. But what did it actually do?
And what does it do for you? At Rask, we've produced thousands of podcasts. probably 20,000 articles were written on investing and all these different types of things like personal finance, superannuation, you name it. So we really needed a place where we could bring all of that together for the entire community.
That can be found at rask.au. Whether you're a retiree, a business builder, or a student of finance, you should go and check it out. But once we built the platform, we realized that that wasn't enough. So in 2026, we've decided to launch a new community known as the Rask Ultra community.
This is the deepest, most advanced part of what we do as a business and as a community of investors and builders. We want to build a network of people that can come together and share ideas in a new ecosystem that we've built just for you.
You can find out more, like I said, by Googling Rask Ultra or by creating a free account at rask.au and see if Ultra is right for you.
Oh, I think it'd be a major concern for the development industry. The last thing they needed right now was more uncertainty, issues around inflation or getting access to materials or, you know, supply challenges, um, you know, labor challenges. Um, I don't know, I, I'd be.
really concerned um and you know do they really they're already running on tight margins like you know they a lot of people they were running so tight in that pre-covid boom they were sort of if you didn't take on the work your competition would take it on and everyone was fighting for the work and you know a lot of developers and builders sort of got burnt over the last five years for so many different reasons not just covid whether the list goes on and so
Yeah, I don't think it's great for the construction, any more uncertainty.
Secondly, it's not really good for people signing up to contracts because not only do you need your finance when you're potentially signing off the plane, you want to go, yeah, I'm confident, but can you really sign an off-the-plane contract with three years to go and knowing that you're going to have to be working and earning a certain income?
Yeah. it's just too risky right now. You know, you just don't know. And so why would you want to sign a, you know, a pre-sale on and off the plan and give 10% for deposit with the chance of risking it?
Um, and so, you know, the state government's got limited, you know, ability to do that with, um, you know, pre-sales guarantees. Like that's just tiny. Um, we are seeing some stamp duty changes in places like, uh, South Australia to sort of encourage downsizes to buy new, um,
And so, yeah, I do think they're going to have to do as much as they can to support the construction industry to get sales. And so that's why I think they're going to go for negative gearing on new property. Secondly, I think they should bring back depreciation benefits.
And thirdly, they potentially should make it a much more attractive CGT for, you know, if you do invest in. So, A, you can negative gear, and B, you get potentially no CGT on new property versus the current discount. I think... You've got to really flip it in pro new supply.
There are issues here. This is not what we would encourage our investors to do once they change that policy. But because there's no secondhand market. So if you buy something new, you want to sell it two years later. And the new investor would say, well, it's established now. Why would I buy it?
I will just buy another new one. And so you basically create a two-tier system.
And so that will force investors to have to hold it, which is a good thing, but it also takes a big risk for investors because there's likely to be no growth if you can't resell it in a few years' time.
Yeah, well, yeah, it was like the similar reform that was taken to the 2019 election by Labour. And it was all this talk about, well, if you've got different tax rules or legislation for new builds versus established properties, then you end up with a two-tier market.
And that's always the way with these incentives. It's the same with the first homebuyer schemes. You've got different rules for different properties. participants in the market. It always makes things difficult and distorts everything.
So that actually segues quite nicely into our second segment, which is what should a prospective buyer in the market do right now? So we've all seen the forecast for rising interest rates. We've got potential tax reform in the budget that we've talked about.
Consumer sentiment, depending on which gauge you look at, is at the lowest ever, probably in the past 50 years, maybe just about equal record lows on Westpac's index. Auction markets in Sydney and Melbourne are sort of in the bin at the moment.
So, you know, we've all read the doom and gloom, but what should somebody who's a prospective buyer in the market do right now? I guess for first-time buyers, Chris has already talked about being wary about off-the-plan purchases. There's a lot of uncertainty there.
You've got to be pretty careful, I would say, in that segment. Obviously, you probably need to keep a buffer. in the event of rising interest rates and repayments.
I think if I was a first home buyer now, you really need to focus, try not to read too many headlines and focus on the process, getting the process right more so than the outcome and making sure you can manage those repayments.
I think for the investor segment, I guess, as Chris already said, a lot of people seem to be keeping a tight grip focus on their budget and looking at some of those lower price points because it seems to be the sector of the market with a lot of competition from first-time buyers.
It's more supported by rising construction costs. Chris, I know you do a lot of work with upgraders and financing deals for them. What sort of thing are you seeing in that space? Is the uncertainty sort of knocking the upgrader market for six or is things still transacting?
Yes. If you break it down, anyone with a mortgage, you need to be absolutely on top of it, right? A, making sure you're repaying it, but B, if you can, extend your loan terms, release equity, extend interest-only terms.
You've got to really need a mortgage strategy to refine because lending can always get worse. And every time there's a rate increase, you get lower borrowing capacity. And so you've got to be really careful. And banks can also make more conservative changes to policy. That's not the case now. You can still...
So if you've got a mortgage, get a mortgage strategy. The second thing, if you're a first-home buyer, we've been saying this all along, but one of the reasons why they're doing the 5% deposit scheme is they're getting first-home buyers basically to go and buy all the ex-investor stock
And which is all the new apartments. Hence why a lot of these older, like newer, which are now older apartments are basically selling the first time buyer. So if you're that, don't buy into these apartment blocks would be my advice is that they're already heavily still driven by investors.
And if there's changes to CGT, negative gearing, they're the markets that are going to get hit.
So if you're a first-time buyer and owner-occupied driven markets, not just in the past but also today, if you're an investor, it's really hard because do you really want to take a gamble that not between now and say three or four weeks' time, they're not going to make major changes to negative gearing?
And there's sort of been these retrospective tax changes as well that have happened over recent years. You know, the expat policy has been some others and, you know, even super. And I'd just be concerned that they do something a bit wild around tax policy for investors.
And so, you know, you can gamble now and go, I might be able to get something now, still get negative gearing, still get a lower CGT. Um, But if something changes in four weeks and that pulls a lot of investors out, maybe, you know, that would make less competition.
Maybe you're not even going to buy. Maybe you're trying to upgrade your home. Upgraders though, I do think if you're in a really strong position, the last thing you want and you need to upgrade and you can get a quality asset, like that's perfect buying conditions. like the reality is.
And if you can find, you know, your chance of getting a, you know, a triple eight asset, something that you're going to live in long-term, you know, that window won't stay open forever. At some point, confidence and uncertainty comes a bit more less concerned. The rate story will flip.
And then all of a sudden you're going, Oh, it would have been better to buy in 26 when, you know, we could, we could really, and I think you're gonna have motivated vendors coming into sort of, um, you know, Easter, sort of winter, I mean.
So yeah, that'd be my sort of advice going around the ground.
And obviously different states have got different sort of, you know, but in particularly Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane, well, yeah, I mean, even though prices have run so hard up there, I do think you've got to be even more careful what you buy up there just because rising tides lift all ships.
And I would say that would be my take on the sort of Brisbane, Adelaide, Perth market. You just got to be careful you don't end up getting the frothiness after a really big bull run and you end up paying a lot of money for an asset that's not one of the better properties.
I don't know, Steve, if you think the same thing up in Brisbane, Pete?
Completely, yeah. Yeah, I think we've had a really strong run over the past probably five years now and Yeah, I think it's hard. It's just been really hard to find good stock because something good, you know, good property gets listed, good location, nice quiet street. There's just people pouring all over it.
And yeah, you want to be pretty careful buying into those kind of conditions, particularly given what's happening to interest rates. I think maybe Sydney and Melbourne sentiment's much lower now. and some other parts of the country as well. So maybe more people switching attention.
I'm just going to quote to you from an article from realestate.com.au this week. Rich Harvey from Property Buyer said, "'2026 is ripe for property investment despite the uncertainty. It shouldn't stop investors getting into the market and riding out the cycle of high interest rates, which is expected over the rest of the year.
You've got to get proactive.' and look past the noise, he told realestate.com.au, when there's peak uncertainty, there's peak opportunity. And we've kind of lived through this before. He said, it's the window of opportunity and a great time to make a buy.
Just final part of the quote, we've got population growth, employment is still strong, and there's a lot of positives for investment in property and a lot of various markets across Australia. So I suppose, yeah, short question. Do you agree with that?
Yes, because he's right in terms of when there is peak uncertainty, it does make buying conditions way better. And that's one of the biggest opportunities to be able to get good assets, assets that if you hold for 10, 20, 30 years, you can sell them in any market. They are protected.
You're not having got issues with developments around you, et cetera. And so you've just got to be really careful. I mean, the last thing you want to do is buy a property that's not that great at times like this and not get a massive discount on it.
You can take that other option and get sort of a CD type of property. And if you can find a real... bargain, something that's just really hard to sell right now, but you know fundamentally it'll be easy to fix up and sell it in a peak market.
A lot of people have made money that way, but there is risk to that strategy. Trying to buy the ugly duckling in a suburb and then fixing it up and then selling it in a boom market. You potentially make more money there, but there is risk to get that more money.
But I think the thing that's interesting, for example, in Sydney, I didn't mention it around the builders, is
There's just so many crazy schemes that are trying to, you know, bypass councils and get, you know, state government approval, even out of low, medium rise, sort of, you know, 400 metres from sort of pockets. There's ones in Bronte. There's ones... you know, in the northern suburbs, all over Sydney.
You know, there's one that got announced this week in Lane Cove and it's just like, wow, that's just, you know, crazy. There's ones that are... And so, you know, single dwelling houses or three houses. There's also policies that... you know, 60 apartments are getting knocked down to build 30 apartments.
You know, there's a reduction in supply and they're still getting approved and killing our affordable housing and our rental accommodation at the same time. And so, yeah, I think you've got to be really careful where you buy right now because the sanctuary or the thing that protected your value the most is shifting.
And so you've just got to really factor that into your decision. And so I agree with Rich. I do think you need to be a little bit careful around the investors though, because I do think
You know, we just, we're three, four weeks away from a budget. Like, you know, do you really want to gamble on something that's highly likely to change? You know, 2019, there was, had to win the election and they're going to make the changes. And they were never, it was already guaranteed to happen.
And then all of a sudden they lost the election. And so you just got to be careful if you gamble and then they make some crazy tax change that they actually end up getting through. Yeah.
Yeah, good advice. So we've got time for a couple of your listener questions. So do send in your questions. We're always keen to have a read and cover whatever we can. So the first question is from Dee.
Hi, we've got a house and land package we purchased in the northern outer fringe of Melbourne from an investment company I won't name. It's been rented out since September for $450 a week, which is less than half of the weekly interest-only mortgage repayment.
And we owe about 40 to 50K more than it's worth. We know we're in a bad situation. And if we knew then what we know now after listening to yours and other podcasts, we'd never have done this. The only positive thing is that Melbourne needs to catch up to where it's historically been.
But this may take many years. Do you think we're better off to sell and cut our losses or ride it out and hope it increases in value? We're in our early 50s. This is our first investment. So... Yeah, I think it was a few different things here.
Firstly, yes, Melbourne is probably the one city that does have to sort of have some catching up to do after some softer years. I think if you look at some of the market forecasts, they've generally been better than some of the other cities. If you're looking over five, 10 years, I think though,
And you probably answered your own question a bit here. Sometimes these outer fringe house and land packages can sort of lag the market, especially if the infrastructure rollout is slow.
And if you've got new developments all around you and it can take, you know, two, three, four, five years for those markets to sort of recover as all the new supply comes on. So I guess, yeah, you've got two choices. One is you can sell and cut your losses.
or you can ride it out. I think the riding it out thing, look, you can do that, but you have to be comfortable. If you're losing half of the cashflow before you've even covered things like property management costs and rates and repairs and vacancies,
it's going to be a pretty nasty negative cash flow pre-tax, I think. So you've got to be okay with that. You've got to be okay with the illiquidity and the market risk. I think, obviously, there's an extreme cash flow gap here. And if it's your first investment, you've still got some time.
If the market is supportive, you could lean towards selling and cutting your losses and then getting a better investment. I think Yeah, it depends. You've got a pretty long time horizon if you're in your early 50s. And yes, it's always painful to sell something potentially for less than what you paid for it.
And it's an expensive lesson. But yeah, if you can get a reasonable price and get out and get a better investment in place, personally, that's what I'd lean towards, even though it's extremely painful. But yeah, it depends on the price you can get for the property.
Chris, what do you think? Oh, I hate these stories. And hats off for the person for sharing their story. And I think that's one of the benefits of these questions. If you have got stories like this, please do share them.
You might not want to do it in a social setting, but there's nothing to be ashamed of here. This is why we've seen this for so many years, the issues around spruiking new developments and poor assets. And it's
Um, you know, while there's house and land has been off the plan, I do think it's just gone down to regional. It's gone down to, you know, a lot of apartments, a lot of, you know, poorer properties, even when they're so, you know, the investor market's gone nuts in recent years.
And I think it's going to see a lot of people that have been burnt. And while you've, you know, you think, oh, we'll never buy new. There's also going to be people who have done really badly buying established or bought some of the new stuff that was old.
And so there's a lot of people that lose money on property that, that
you know, and that's why we're so, uh, pro advice and pro education and, and trying to sort of be that beacon of light with this stuff, because we see these stories, like this is a prime example of a client that would come to us and explain that story.
And we would find out where you bought, who you bought it from. Um, and one of the issues you mentioned here is the investment company you won't name. That's because there's issues of defamation and you don't want to name them. And I get all that, but they're not just one, the only one.
Um, And they would have had some amazing research and a pitch of growth corridor to Melbourne. And, but you know, now, you know, like when you go on the satellite and you look in the Northern parts of Melbourne, one of the benefits of Melbourne is it's flat and they can build a lot.
And there's a lot of farmland to the North and the West and the Southeast and, um, you know, uh, and they're pretty pro development down there. And so yes, prices may go up. I'd be really concerned if a lot of investors have gone into that pocket.
Because what happens is there's always an anchoring bias. And so you've also, or everyone is affected by this. It's just behavioral economics. So you would have paid X price and now it's worth less. And you're like, well, I don't want to sell it until I make a profit.
But a lot of people would have entered at that price with new developments. And so a lot of investors want to bail at that same price. And so as soon as the prices get to a point where...
People can sell because they can make a paper profit and they don't have to feel like there's this loss aversion. It's really painful for people. A lot of people have happened in Brisbane apartments or happened in Melbourne apartments. People just want a paper profit.
And so be really careful because if you can get close to that, it might take a long time to get a lot more than that because even when it does rise to that number, we haven't lost money. you've lost time and you potentially may not even get there for a long time.
And three, when it does get there, you might find there's a lot of flooding on the market and you don't even get much more anyway. And so, yeah, we hate these stories. But personally, a poor property will always stay a poor property.
In recent years, poor properties have been sort of pushed up in price because the building prices have gone up so much and that's really sucked out a lot of new supply. And maybe that'll continue for a few more years, but...
You know, poor assets usually have something fundamentally flawed, and this is because most of your money went into a house and the quality of the land is easily to be replicated, which you already know these things now.
So yeah, it's not a good situation, but I think this is a real key challenge when you think about, you know, people with portfolios is that that mistakes, Really burnt the one opportunity. That was a good decision versus a bad decision. You're early 50s. You bought a good asset.
That's done well for the next 15, 20 years to retirement. Completely different retirement for you. But this company is just taking advantage of you. Sold you a dud. They've made a huge com on it. You know, often 10 plus percent of the purchase price. And you're left carrying the can.
So, yeah, not good.
Thanks for that advice, Chris. And obviously, if you're not sure, speak to a financial advisor to step through the process. Okay, we've got time for one more question from Greedy. So we're looking at investing in an apartment in Melbourne CBD. The price difference between Sydney and Melbourne apartments is huge. Why is this?
Oversupply? Do you think Melbourne will be sought after again or has everyone moved to the beach? Well, you're right. The price gap between Sydney and Melbourne is apartments, especially if you're in the inner city, is often very large, 20% to 40%.
I think if you look at a decent two-bedroom unit close to the centre of Sydney, you might be looking at $1.2 million, but Melbourne, you'd be looking a lot less, potentially, who knows, around $800,000. The median unit price in Melbourne is about $640,000.
And for a one-bedder in Sydney, it's about 30% higher typically. So of course, yes, relatively speaking, much cheaper. I think Melbourne has built way more apartments. Sydney has more of a scarcity premium, tighter zoning that Chris talks about often.
But just the geographical limits in Sydney, you've got the harbour, you've got national parks all around. And yes, maybe something more of a premium because Sydney has seemed to be the sort of finance hub or that global city.
I think in some of the factors for Melbourne, we've had land taxes have now impacted apartments as well as houses. Also, stamp duty surcharges and I guess just a general anti-landlord vibe from the government.
I would just say, look, if I was going to buy Melbourne, I would say yes, but with a caveat. You've got to look for some point of scarcity value if you're going to buy a unit So if you're in the CBD, of course, there's no real high restriction on the building.
So that's a potential challenge. Maybe you want to look close to the CBD, one of those sort of places like, I don't know, St. Kilda or Prahran. But if you're going to go CBD, you potentially are buying below replacement value in some markets.
But I would say you just got to try and find more boutique developments, points of scarcity. I don't know, a three bedroom unit or a place with a view or something like that. But you've got to be a bit careful because Melbourne has been consistently more successful in delivering supply than Sydney has.
Chris, what do you think?
Yeah, I mean, there's definitely a lot of reasons why the Sydney prices of apartments haven't gone up, have gone up compared to Melbourne. Cost to build, you know, restrictions on development, scarcity, land, you know, difficulty to build, topography, you know, the development boom, et cetera.
So there's lots of reasons. The reason why they haven't gone up as well is because The Melbourne market just hasn't had a time yet where people are like, I cannot afford a house. I must afford an apartment. You know, I have to buy an apartment. Sydney's gone through that.
Brisbane slowly maybe transitioning through that a little bit over the last few years is that... house prices have run too far and a lot of home buyers have to buy apartments. Melbourne just hasn't done that. So apartments will go up when house prices get too expensive.
But if we go back to our last question where there's a lot of houses available, that's not as big issue in Melbourne as it is in, say, Sydney, where they can just keep on building these house on land packages, etc.
And I also think that there's a lot of villa units, which is sort of six, eight villa units in great suburbs. So if you're going to buy not in the housing market in Melbourne, the things that will go up first are the things that give you a lifestyle similar to a house.
So it might be an older style townhouse development in a leafy suburb where, you know, the house price is two mil, but you can buy a really good apartment for $600,000.
So look in areas where there's a cap on and buy apartments that are really suited to sort of downsizes and couples and one or two child families, ideally. And yeah, I think you can do really well because I do think the house prices will run.
And then you'll find that a lot of the house buyers demand that says, oh, I don't really want to move to a new estate. I don't really want to move 45, 50 Ks from the city.
I do want to stay close to the city for work and lifestyle and, you know, where I grew up and I'll just buy, you know, a little villa unit or a two bed apartment. And I get the lifestyle benefit of where I'm living, but yeah, it's not a big enough space.
And so if you think about Sydney, they're the apartments that have gone up the most. It's the apartments that give you the same lifestyle benefits, almost like a house, but it's just smaller. And there's restrictions on supply.
And the other benefit is when new supply comes in those markets, it's not competing with the current apartment stock. They often try to target the downsizer, which is the housing market, and they build really expensive apartments.
So you don't have this sort of new supply coming as well, where that'll mean that your growth is limited. And so you can definitely buy in Melbourne. But personally, if you've got the budget,
I'd be going to the housing market down there, particularly the established and take advantage because that I think will boom first, much stronger than say the apartment market will.
It depends on the budget. Yeah, good advice. Thanks, Chris. So just to wrap up for this week, obviously, we're in a period of heightened uncertainty, but it's a time for cool heads. It was always a time for cool heads rather than panicking in the housing market.
I think arguably that the 10-year fundamentals for housing haven't changed that much. But if you look at bond yields, certainly interest rates and mortgage rates for the rest of this decade certainly look set to remain higher than they were over the past decade. You've got to factor that in.
So, um, Chris, what have you got planned for this week?
Uh, it's really head down, bum up for the next few months. Um, you know, a couple of kids' birthday parties, nothing too exciting. Um, and, uh, yeah, pretty pumped just to get through the next few months.
And I think it's going to be a lot of conversations as, you know, it was pretty exhausting the first few months just because there's so much uncertainty. It's really hard in those times to just sort of get a real good read on things. And, um,
Yeah, I think it's a lot of work taking care of our existing clients over the next few months and helping people just be really careful if they are entering the market. So, yeah, it's recharged and ready to go.
Fantastic. I'm off to Los Angeles next week. So property nerd like you, Chris, I'll be looking for some mid-century modern homes up in Beverly Hills. It makes me sound much like I've got a much more interesting life than I actually do.
But yeah, having to go to Europe the long way around because the Middle East is out of action. So trying to make the most of it. So thanks for joining this week, everyone. And thanks, Chris, for your great advice. As always, do send any questions for our listener Q&A.
We'll cover those each week. And look forward to seeing you next time around. Cheers, Chris.
Chat soon. Thanks, Pete.
Thanks for tuning into the Australian Property Podcast. If you love the show, why not subscribe or leave us a review on Apple or Spotify.
And if you want to work with me, Amy, Pete or Chris, you'll find links in your podcast player to get in contact with us.
Bye.
Thank you for listening to this episode of the Australian Property Podcast. We're huge advocates of getting the right advice at the right time from the right people. That's why it's important to understand that this podcast episode contained general financial information only.
It is not designed to be specific or personalized to your financial, tax or legal situation. With property, the check sizes are pretty big, so it's important you get advice from a licensed and trusted professional before acting on the information you hear in RAS podcasts. Thanks again for listening.
I regret to inform you that chances are a lot of you will need financial advice. Since we started the Rask Advice business, I've noticed quite a few trends, but one of them is the importance of having confidence in what you're actually saving towards or investing towards.
A lot of people in the RAS community are very capable of managing their own money.
But when it comes to critical points in their life, like retirement, selling a business, scaling a business, getting married, buying your first home, so on and so forth, getting expert advice will actually save you from a bunch of mistakes
and give you the confidence to know what it is you're doing and why you're doing it. If you wanna get matched with one of the trusted financial partners that we have, you can just head to rask.au slash financial planning, or you can get in contact with us on any of the Rask websites.
Not only does Rask itself provide financial advice, but we also have trusted partners if we're not the right fit for you. So we can help guide you in the right direction. And that in turn supports us to create more free financial education content like podcasts, courses, and so much more.
