Curious about upgrading?
Wondering where to start?
Complex questions that need answers?
Is there a better structure for you?
"They managed to navigate my complex expat income and even got my Google RSU income approved as well."
"I highly recommend Alcove to anyone looking for a mortgage broker who is responsive, trustworthy, and truly cares about their clients. Thanks again to the whole team for making the process such a positive experience!"
"As founders, we're constantly jumping between things so having a partner that handled the details & made the process super clear made the buying process breezy for us. Very happy with the experience!"
“It almost felt like it was his responsibility to make it clear to me, not my responsibility to understand it.”
“I've been pretty much fully leveraged the whole time. So the sounding board on that, in terms of what was achievable, what wasn't — I think trust is just built along that.”
"Alcove has been a great partner. They look after my audience properly, keep things simple, and deliver real value. I’ve got full confidence referring clients knowing they’ll get honest, straightforward advice."
"Property is one of the biggest financial decisions people make. Alcove stood out because they take a strategic approach to lending - helping clients structure property and debt decisions in a way that genuinely supports their broader financial plans."
Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.
Pete Wargent and Chris Bates break down the latest fuel shock, rising inflation risk and shifting rate expectations, and what it means for the Australian property market.
This podcast is proudly brought to you by Perla, the official brokerage platform of Rask. With Perla, you can effortlessly automate your money, whether you're investing in ETFs or shares from Australia or the US stock market, whether you're a grandparent or setting up a kid's account or your own account.
You can do all of that with full automation on Perla.com. If you want to learn more, head to Perla.com slash Rask. And of course, before you invest in anything, be sure to read the legal documents like the PDS and FSG.
This episode is brought to you by Stripe, helping your business be ready for whatever comes next. And the next shift in how people buy is already happening. Agentic Commerce lets customers discover and purchase directly inside an AI conversation. No checkout page, no friction.
The businesses positioning themselves now are the ones who will lead this channel. Whatever comes next for your business, power it with Stripe. Learn more at stripe.com. This is a podcast by The Rask Group. It's for educational purposes only.
So please do not make a financial, legal, investment or taxation decision based on solely what you hear in this show.
Welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. We're on a mission to be Australia's most trusted property podcast. I'm Owen Rask, founder of The Rask Group.
I'm Pete Wadgent, author and buyer's agent. I'm Amy Linardi and I am a buyer's agent.
I'm Chris Bates, ex-financial planner and mortgage broker. Together, we'll take you through every step of your property journey.
From first home buyer to decades of property investing.
I don't believe there's lots of people on the market. I reckon May, it's going to be really dire for new listings. Agents will find it really hard to motivate a seller to sell when there's a lot of uncertainty.
Hello, welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. I'm Pete Wargent from Alan Wargent Property Buyers. I'm here with the mortgages guru, Chris Bates from the Alcove Group. Chris, what a week. What's been keeping you busy this week?
Well, not too much exciting on the personal side, to be fair. Tomorrow I've got my daughter's Easter hat parade at 9 a.m., but tomorrow that's exciting. But other than that, I mean, what a time at the moment. I'm trying to reflect on a longer-term basis and think, you know,
what some points that it was this uncertain. I mean, the GFC when I was working in the UK was absolutely like this. Started COVID, you know, very similar. And yeah, it's really a lot of concern out there.
And how you navigate this depends on your situation, whether you're a first home buyer, you're an investor, you've got lots of properties as an investor, you're thinking about upgrading or renovating. So everyone's, sort of every household is going to make different decisions. And
some people might be absolutely really concerned and others might be feeling quite pretty you know i've got no mortgage i'm you know i've got heaps of cash in the bank i don't really care what's going on too much so i think there's just a lot of uncertainty going around and um yeah i think it's really hard to know what to do but you know when there is uncertain times i regret to inform you that chances are a lot of you will need financial advice since we started the rask advice business
I've noticed quite a few trends, but one of them is the importance of having confidence in what you're actually saving towards or investing towards.
A lot of people in the RAS community are very capable of managing their own money, but when it comes to critical points in their life, like retirement, selling a business, scaling a business, getting married, buying your first home, so on and so forth,
Getting expert advice will actually save you from a bunch of mistakes and give you the confidence to know what it is you're doing and why you're doing it.
If you want to get matched with one of the trusted financial partners that we have, you can just head to rask.au slash financial planning, or you can get in contact with us on any of the Rask websites.
Not only does Rask itself provide financial advice, but we also have trusted partners if we're not the right fit for you. So we can help guide you in the right direction. And that in turn supports us to create more free financial education content like podcasts, courses, and so much more.
There is actually also opportunity.
And so I think it's just making sure that our clients make sure they make the right moves, whether it's just restructuring their mortgages to protect themselves, whether upgraders take advantage of potentially nervous markets if they're in a strong financial position, or first-time buyers still kick on but be even more diligent around the asset than ever.
So yeah, a lot of extra conversations at the moment with our clients, and that's all our focus is on.
Yes, I saw the consumer sentiment survey that ANZ has run since 1972, so longer than my entire lifetime. It's at the lowest level in its history of the survey.
So I do sometimes wonder, we've got obviously a whole new cohort of people who don't remember what life was like in the 1970s and 80s.
Regardless, yeah, it's an incredibly low reading. It's the first time the index has ever been below 60. I read in the media one in seven servos in New South Wales is out of at least one type of fuel. Starting to see a few of those photos of empty shelves again.
It's like a rerun of COVID. A slightly bemusing anecdote for you. I'm down in Brisbane today for the football, but driving down from the Sunshine Coast popped into the servo. I was astonished to see the price of diesel, the highest I've ever seen, 329.9 cents per liter for Sunshine Coast.
And then in the 15 minutes that it took me to have a long black and a Krispy Kreme, the price had increased twice more. So I think normally in life, you get this creeping suspicion that prices are rising. You see it in the $7 coffee or
or for that matter, the $20 coffee and doughnut, but actually to see the prices rising before your very eyes and in real time, it's pretty disconcerting. And obviously, lots of uncertainty as a result of that.
So you would have seen this week, Chris, the government's announced from 1st of April, cutting 50% of the fuel excise. So that'll drop 26.3 cents per litre.
off the fuel price from 1st of April to 30 June. But I suppose at the time of speaking anyway, the prices have been going up so quickly that could quite quickly be absorbed anyway.
Well, that's right. You take your diesel from $3.30 to $3, let's call it. You know, it's still $3, right? And yeah, but I do think it's a good move. I mean, they've just done the full excise. I mean, that's just a debate for another day.
But the reality is I do think it's probably doing a lot of the heavy lifting that interest rates aren't doing. I think we've spoken about this before is
know it's a law of diminishing value already hurting the people who are hurting the most by increasing interest rates and you're actually giving more cash to the people with money who've got cash right and um is that going to really stop their spending probably not um and so but you know just the mentality around sort of fuel groceries you know is a lot of people going to have to make cutbacks or decisions to delay their holidays absolutely no that's the case um going around and so
But yeah, I do think there's a lot of peak fear going on. And whether it's peak fear now, whether peak fear is in a couple of months' time, that's usually a time when there's a lot of, obviously, uncertainty.
And it just wouldn't, if you lifted your property in sort of February, it would have been maybe pre this. And so... If it didn't sort of sell in March, you know, unless you have to sell, you might be taking it off the market right now.
And so I do think if properties aren't needing to sell, they'd probably be pulled off the market and then maybe relist in sort of springtime potentially. But I do wonder what's going to list after Easter sort of Anzac Day, like what's going to come on in May.
Because if you don't have to sell, why would you list? And so if you are in the market at that point, it could be a good opportunity, particularly obviously the budgets around there as well.
If investors are sort of trying to front run that as well, it could be a good little buying window. And that's not me just being pro and being tone deaf to the way the world is. The reality is sometimes it's hard to buy good assets when there's confidence.
So when there is uncertainty, potentially a chance of getting good assets is higher. There's usually less of them, though. That's the irony.
And so I do think the people who are in a really strong position, while interest rates might be hurting a lot of people, they may say, well, yeah, it doesn't really affect me.
Even if rates stay high the next few years, I'd much rather like the opportunity to buy a better asset with less competition.
It's a complex environment, isn't it? I think, well, to take it from the macro to the micro. So obviously we've had a massive oil supply shock. I was chatting to a friend who's an executive in the industry over the past week. By no means an expert. in the supply of oil.
But he was saying even if the war was to terminate today, it takes a long time for these things to be resolved. A few different reasons. One, damage to the existing infrastructure. But two, just the complexity of modern day supply chains. You can't just switch these things on and off quickly.
So it's going to be dragging on. I saw Lucy Ellis at Westpac this week saying that, well, markets are pricing that the cash rate could peak at 4.6%, possibly 4.85%.
Lucy Ellis said they're predicting now two extra rate hikes to 4.8% based on their new profile. And before things reverse and come back down the other side in 2027, I don't think you can really forecast the supply shock and the outcomes. We saw that during the pandemic, but
And in fact, it wasn't so long ago that Westpac were talking about the next move in interest rates being down. Bond yields were down a bit this week. I guess probably I would guess is because investors are turning their attention from inflation, just as you were saying, towards the risk of recession.
So, yeah, I mean, there's a bit of a narrative thing going on there. But as it relates to the housing market, well, it's complicated. I saw... Nerida Connersby at Ray White saying, well, yes, normally rising interest rates are a dampening factor on the housing market. We're definitely seeing that in auction clearance rates.
But then at the same time, we're getting less housing supply. Construction costs are going through the roof. Supply chains are under massive pressure. So it's all sort of adding to the housing shortage concerns. And as you said, this is even before the budget reforms that are proposed for May. So
Yes, I think there's still a bit of pressure on the bottom end of the market. We're just not building enough housing, but the consumer confidence is extremely low.
Yeah, I think the real challenge right now is people with mortgages that are really probably too big for them and they're really struggling just to keep holding on to properties and they might have been struggling the last few years.
So there might be some type of people who have leveraged up quite hard over the last 21, 22. They've
know works maybe not as done as well as they thought it would and they've just been really struggling to keep on top of it but they've seen this light at the end of the tunnel and then that light shut down on them a bit and um so yeah it's going to be interesting to see if there is some type of bank intervention here as well i i can sort of see that happening again with a sort of payment holiday maybe not a broad everyone can get it but a case-by-case basis um maybe the banks have the ability to do that uh you know given this latest shock i wonder if that's going to happen
And last week, we didn't think a fuel excise reduction was going to come in, and then that's hit. So yeah, I do think that when you've got consumer confidence at the lowest, you've got rate expectations at the lowest, this does factor into sentiment. Sentiment drives markets.
And so the opposite is when you want to buy. You don't want to buy when everyone thinks the world's going to continue to take off really late in a cycle. It's actually the opposite. The buying conditions are best when there's a lot of uncertainty.
So I think you can look at it two ways. If you're wanting to make moves into the market, it could be a good time. If you're in the market, you've got to really try to figure out how do you knuckle down.
And the ways to do that, usually just trying to focus on making sure your lending structure is the best way and then taking opportunities to sort of de-risk yourself and build buffers. It might be selling assets, it might be you know, just building buffers, et cetera, or cutting your spending back.
Yeah, well, we've got two segments we're going to cover today. One is how the fuel shock crisis has evolved and what that's doing to Australia in particular, because we're particularly vulnerable to oil supply shocks in Australia and New Zealand, as we'll see shortly.
And then secondly, we're going to look at whether there's some panic selling out there, certainly a big surge of auctions over the past week or two as people are rushing to get things listed.
And yeah, I think it's starting to translate into some weaker auction clearance rates and weaker auction results and a bit more price negotiation, especially in Sydney and Melbourne. And then stick around because we've got time for some listener Q&A at the end of the show. Always keen to answer your questions.
So let's first look at what's been happening with the fuel shock crisis, which we've already touched on a little bit anyway. So just a sort of bullet point recap. Obviously, we've seen fuel supplies are running low. So I've been chatting to the
the guy at our local survey when I fill up and he said, yeah, for the time being anyway, the deliveries are arriving every day, but they're selling out of fuel every single day.
So even though there's not maybe some panic buying going on, people are certainly taking the opportunity to fill up as much as they can when they can. I've seen the same thing in Coles and Woolies, some people taking some enormous shopping baskets out or trolleys full.
So at the moment, we don't have fuel rationing in Australia. I suppose one of the criticisms of the fuel excise cut is if you've already got a potential shortage to reduce the price, well, you may be encouraging people just to buy more.
But I guess if you look across the wider economy, we've got the Easter week coming up. I've heard of people canceling trips, road trips, as much as anything, because they're worried about sort of going out to the regions and finding out they can't get home due to a lack of fuel.
or maybe it's just a price thing. But I do get the sense that around the country, businesses are cutting back, productivity is being hit, probably agriculture, production, tourism, that kind of thing. So I suppose there's a potential actually in the second half of this year that we have a recession or technical recession.
And if you look at unemployment rate forecast, probably now near a 5% as the year goes on. So are you starting to see any of that sort of around the traps, people cutting back, taking less risk, that kind of thing?
I definitely think that the consumers will be taking less appetite to spend money. Upgraders are absolutely going to sit on their hands.
If we rewind back to as soon as we had the three rate cuts in the middle of last year, we saw a huge sort of resurgence of people saying, right, okay, I know I'm in a home too small. I know I need something a bit bigger. I know rate cuts are coming.
I just want to get on the front foot. and they sat on their hands sort of October, November, December. Don't believe any of this sort of listings nonsense that's been happening through the media over the last month.
I think people have just been sort of using very weak data to say that there's higher listings than this time of the year, but they're not factoring in when Easter is. They're not factoring that all the agents sort of front run all their listings.
And there's no listings gonna be really all the way through April. You just wouldn't list your property even from late March onwards, basically. And if you look at total listings around the country and even in lots of pockets, they're way down. So I don't believe there's lots of people on the market.
And I think even though people are thinking a lot of people are going to rush to sell, I reckon May, it's going to be really dire for new listings. I think agents will... find it really hard to motivate a seller to sell when there's a lot of uncertainty.
They just, a seller will say, look, I'll just wait a few more months. And unless they really need to sell. And I think, so yeah, I think listings will stay really tight. And, you know, that's while demand's dropped. I don't think demand's going to drop too much from sort of first home buyers.
I think upgraders will be all sitting on their hands. So it's like a one plus, you know, one selling, one buying. It's sort of, you know, that sort of cancels each other out. But I do think also investors will keep pushing on.
I think they've just been so strong, the proliferation of these borderless buyers agents. I've been adding up how many properties I think they're purchasing. It's in the thousands a month. to be fair, all going into similar regions. And I do feel like that's going to be a story of 2026 slash seven.
I think a lot of investors are going to bail out of these regions.
A lot of recent investors who have bought in the last two, three years on the promise of big growth, those markets are going to cap out, A, because of borrowing capacity, B, because investors aren't going there, and three, because investors are actually going to bail out of these markets.
And I think you're going to see that those investors start to retreat on top of other investors just bailing out of the cities just because they need to build buffers or stage of life. So yeah, I think that's going to be the big story the second half of this year.
I think so. One of the big debates that's going on is if you look at what's happened in New Zealand, as housing demand has cooled, prices in real terms, in a lot of cases, might be down 20%, 25%, not everywhere across the country, but some of the markets that saw the biggest increases.
Canada has seen its population growth go from a million to zero, pretty much, and suddenly the housing shortage is not quite so apparent anymore, and the rental market's cooled right off. In a similar vein, prices in real terms are well off the highs. Australia, not so much.
In March, housing prices were up 0.7% in nominal terms nationally. Sydney and Melbourne have cooled, but Brisbane and Perth and Adelaide still pushing on. So I suppose there's two sides to this debate.
I was looking at the RBA's financial aggregates this week, the stats for February, and it looked to me like, at least in net terms, investor credit growth sort of peaked back in December and it's cooled off a little bit since then.
And those are net figures, so that could well be some more people selling. I suppose the Yeah, there are two sides to this debate. One is, yes, interest rates go up. Let's say the cash rate target goes to 4.85% and some mortgages will be mid-sixes, getting close to 7%.
That's going to really hurt some of the more leveraged people in the market. And that's going to cripple sentiment as there may be some forced selling or some people keen to offload. On the other side, I've got a cousin who's a builder.
And yeah, the cost of materials and availability of trades is blowing out enormously. And in that context, it's hard to see the price of certainly entry-level housing going too much lower because you just can't build. I've seen projects being canceled. I think even some infrastructure projects are not going to go ahead now.
Some high-rise projects I saw this week being canceled in Melbourne. I dread to think what the cost of the Olympics is going to be now at these new sort of newly quoted prices. So I suppose, yes, there's potentially a big sentiment hit coming over the rest of 2026 as interest rates go up.
But the other side of the coin is the cost of actually building stuff is going up at the same time. So, yeah, what do you reckon?
Do you think we'll see a significant correction like New Zealand has seen or Canada, or are we just going to sort of plateau as the year goes on?
I think it's interesting. Just be careful reading too much into sort of median prices. I think you've got to look at a suburb level, and I think what we will see is demand will decrease, listings will decrease, particularly of the good quality properties because people will say, I'm just sitting on these.
And the poorer quality properties, well, buyers will be way more conservative, right, and a little bit less competitive.
willing to because they'll have less fomo right they'll be like okay if i don't buy now that's okay rates are going to be high and so if you've got a compromised property let's say it's a busy road it's dark privacy issues you know it's a bit of a run rat run or not a great block or it's a really run down house like
buyers are just going to be like, well, there's no urgency here. I'll just wait. And so I think in these markets, the poor assets absolutely get hit harder. And often they're the ones who have stretched into the market that have bought these properties because they just try to get in.
And unfortunately, if they have to sell because finances are good, then they're selling into a really bad market. And so And what happens is those new sales reset the median. So median looks like it drops a lot more because the number of properties selling at a lower price point increases.
And so you get this sort of structural sort of imbalance. Yeah, the whole suburb hasn't fallen. It's just that the properties that are selling on the market right now are a much lower price point. And so just be really careful on that.
And I think when you are looking at the market, you've got to look at what you own or what you want to buy and how is that going to be impacted because it could be massively different to other parts of the market.
But yeah, I think it's going to be an interesting time, but the natural, all the bears are going to come out right now. You can see them. They're all licking their lips saying, yep, all right, I've got it right. The crash has finally happened. I think they've been saying that for so long.
So they've got no shame to just keep on peddling that drum. And they're just hoping they're finally going to be right. But just be careful. There's going to be a government response here in some way. Like we've seen it with the fuel excise.
I reckon there's going to be some other things because the reality is when there is times of real distress, the government will do things often just to sort of protect households. And I reckon there's going to be something through the banking system for sure.
Yeah, when I think of my personal situation, I'm in my 40s, just I should say, so it might be, but I think if I was 10 years older, I'd probably be looking at the current market and thinking, yeah, if I've got some non-core assets, government's potentially going to come steaming in for a capital gains tax.
hike and maybe I'll just be looking to de-risk and offload. I figured when I tried to look at it objectively, I'm still young enough, I've got a couple of cycles ahead of me before the traditional retirement day, but I could certainly see some investors selling ahead of the
the federal budget, which comes around in May. I think just one more point on this before we move on to the second story. ABC News did a piece on whether we're on track to hit 1.2 million homes over five years, which was the government's target. Well, no, is the short answer.
We'll probably get somewhere between eight hundred thousand and nine hundred thousand, I guess, at the current pace. But interesting to note, Western Australia, Victoria and the ACT have been among the stronger performers. I mean, Perth has got an absolutely chronic shortage, so that's good to see. But New South Wales
is well behind its longer term trajectory measured against the sheer scale of the underlying housing demand, particularly in Greater Sydney. Tasmania and the Northern Territory, very slow as well.
So, yeah, I think that's the other thing is that one of the ways the interest rate mechanism works, if you increase interest rates, it slows down the pace of building and construction. And in an environment where we're already missing the targets, that's only going to worsen.
Yeah, absolutely. The feasibility start getting and developer risk will just reduce dramatically. Getting finance is harder. There's so many elements to it and even just borrowing capacity. I think that's something that
every time there is a rate increase, it reduces borrowing capacity and credit growth and ability to borrow and how much you can borrow. Absolutely is one of the key drivers of prices, right? It doesn't mean it's 100% linked.
You know, you've seen borrowing capacities fall 30, 40% probably now over the last four or five years, minusing off what wage growth has probably happened. So that sort of, you know, maybe it's only a 15% drop or something like that, but absolutely borrowing capacity and appetite to borrow
is heavily linked and every time there's a rate increase and if there's two or three more, well, that's quite a substantial drop to borrowing capacities, which when people are borrowing every dollar, it will take a bunch of heat out of the market.
But it doesn't mean that you're gonna see that price fall in the market. It just means that the buyers who are in that market might move to another suburb and the buyers that are in a suburb, a little bit more expensive might be moving down. And so it's gonna compress the buyers
down the cycle, you know, and down the price points. And you might actually find even if you're not borrowing every dollar, you might actually find there's more competition because people are coming into your sort of area that weren't there before. So just be, yeah, I guess careful with that as well.
Sounds good. Okay. For our second segment, we're just going to take a 10-minute look at what's happening in the auction markets. So yeah, lots of auctions right now.
As we went through the month of March, I guess we're coming towards the end of the warmer weather and sort of going into a quieter period. But we've seen volumes have been as high as we've ever seen, really. Some vendors, I'm sure, are trying to get out before a possible correction.
Also, the budget coming up in May. with talk of changes in capital gains taxes. So I think in Sydney and Melbourne, we've seen the auction clearance rates drop right off, lowest in a couple of years in some cases. Sydney eastern suburbs, lots of properties being passed in and then going on to negotiation.
So we've already talked about the potential for slower housing supply. But do you think some of the people in the market at the moment are selling in a bit of a panic, taking price cuts? I mean, just some context here, Sydney and Melbourne prices were in nominal terms, minus 0.1% in March.
So we're not talking about big numbers just yet. But do you think there's potentially some haircuts being taken at the moment?
Oh, I do think that, you know, people would have listed thinking they're going to get one price in February and they're taking a different price in March, particularly if they've already bought and they're having to sell. That would be not a great situation or it's a sort of death or divorce or whatever.
you know, an estate type of issue. Yeah, I mean, there's definitely people who have been forced to sell. And, you know, you'd like to think if it wasn't a great asset right now, it's most likely going to be one of those ones that has passed in.
And, you know, and if there is a buyer on it, then, you know, it depends on how good they have played the negotiation. And so, Yeah, I think Melbourne less so. I think Melbourne, you know, hasn't had the sort of, you know, the run that other cities have.
It just might not be getting that sort of momentum benefit that it should be getting coming into 2026. And buyers are like, oh, look, it just doesn't feel like there's a rush. Hasn't really built that sort of real FOMO in the market yet. So maybe less so in Melbourne.
But you got to be careful reading auction clearance rates because you know, it does, there's a bit of a barometer for the desperation in the market. And you can see, well, that desperation's, you know, been removed over the last month.
But, you know, what you want to see is the better qualities within there. You know, they've still been selling strong. And, you know, and having a look at those because, you'll still see that buyers are still willing to go and trade on those properties.
And often they'll still sell, they're the 50 or 60% that do sell is usually the better properties and the poorer ones or the buyers are just moving on to other stuff.
So just be too, yeah, over the longer term, it's a good reading of desperation, but it doesn't mean that the properties you want to buy are the ones that are going to be the, you know, the ones that are feeling it right now. Maybe that's going to be later on.
Yeah, good point. Just a couple of sort of anecdotes really. Our part of the country, Sunshine Coast, you do get some auctions, but by far most properties sell private treaty.
And we've seen a couple of cases whereby somebody's had a valuation, but by the time they've come to actually list and sell the property, the market's moved and it might only be sort of 5% off the highs.
which in the context of what's gone before is not too damaging really. But certainly the appetite for properties with a few challenges has come off.
I think if you've got a property that's perfectly presented, it's affordable to a wide cohort, then yeah, there's still lots of appetite there around Malula Bar and so on. But yeah, Yeah, I think there's some of the sort of properties that aren't perfectly presented. Yeah, definitely.
There's been a bit of a change in sentiment and more scope for negotiation for people on the buy side. So I think we've got time for a couple of listener questions. So let's go through those. So the first one's from Mr. No Idea. Hi, Chris and Pete. I'm 49, my wife is 39.
We earn about 800K combined and we've got a $12 million property portfolio with $6 million in equity. The rent's about 300 a year and it's costing us about $60,000 a year to hold. We've also got a million in super and our employers are contributing about 50K.
So I'm just using some round numbers here. Our goal is to reach 15 to 20 million net worth by retirement at the age of 65. So a question on capital allocation, and we'll have to put our disclaimer in here.
We've got two properties in Cairns, we've got properties in Launceston and Tassie, both sitting around 20% loan to value ratio. Would you sell these and potentially recycle the capital, pay down debt, pump up the super, or just hold and let them compound given the strong equity position?
Yeah, I think, yeah, obviously, disclaimer, we don't know the full situation here. And yeah, if you need a specific financial advice, go and see a licensed advisor on that. I mean, I guess the questions you've cited there got very low debt against them specifically.
But I think this really comes down to a personal choice thing and it's sort of a risk tolerance matter. I think there's a lot to be said for Australia's superannuation system, at least at the time of speaking anyway. There could be some tax changes in the future.
But yeah, I think it depends whether you're trying to build an intergenerational wealth for your kids, in which case you'd keep pushing on. But I guess you could easily de-risk the portfolio and put some money into super.
So I think it depends on your risk tolerance and also whether you're trying to sort of build a legacy for the kids or whether you're happy just to sort of start winding down towards semi-retirement. But what would you say, Chris?
Look,
probably a decent problem to have.
And so, you know, I guess the key is now, is it better to put, you know, that's a, I'm not exactly sure how the total equity here, but it might be a million bucks after costs, you know, is it better to put that, I assume there's no mortgage on the home, you know, that's my,
And we haven't seen that in the question, but if that's the case, then a million bucks better off the home loan, particularly if rates are gonna be six plus, that's not a bad bet. The issue is that, you know, even though the income's really strong, right?
At a hundred grand a year as a couple, you know, times that by five and you're looking at about $4 million of debt, they probably got close to $6 million of debt.
So even if you do sell, you're not gonna be buying any more assets, whether it's, you're basically just gonna have this cash. And what do you do with that cash? Well, you could put it in offset accounts just to build yourself buffers, but you might have other cash as buffer.
I don't know if you've got any cash. That would be the first thing. And do you need that buffer? Do you have to sell them all? Maybe you could sell one and hedge your bets, but I mean, ultimately, are you really confident that these properties are gonna grow really strongly long-term?
It comes down absolutely to the asset quality here.
And if you're not that confident and you can sell it in not a dire market, as in there's still pretty strong demand, you're going to get a pretty good price for your properties, as in it's not really a really seller's market or a buyer's market, I mean.
And yeah, I mean, putting in the super, I mean, it depends, right? Like you've got maybe 10, 20 years to sort of retirement, depending on whose name you put it in, et cetera.
you know, you're probably already capping out on your concessional contributions. So whenever you're putting more money in via non-concessional contributions, you've got to be really confident.
And, you know, I have no idea how much you got in your supers, but if you're on those salaries, even if you just decide to compound what you've already got in there, plus putting your concessional contributions in, are you going to start getting close to the caps on tax-free amounts in super?
Because, you know, there's been some changes recently with super around sort of division 293, I think it is, whatever it is. And the max you can have in tax free and super. And so just be careful. Like you'd be throwing into a low tax environment. That's great.
But you know, you might have to then really pull it out anyway to keep it at a... I'd be really making sure you've got a really good home as well. Never always forget the opportunity of upgrading your home into a better tax-free asset, whether it's something you're going to live in long-term.
So yeah, there's lots of options. And this is where a good advisor would consider those options. Is it better to have money in the bank? If there is a bit of correction in stock markets, you know, that might create an opportunity for you to enter there.
You know, even commercial property might be a better move if you're sort of getting closer to sort of retirement and you've got cash, maybe you could borrow, you know, under a separate entity to go into the commercial market if you took this cash and you might be capped out on a resi.
So what's going on here? And yeah, it comes down to really the quality of those properties you've got and whether you really want to keep a lot of equity in there or there's benefits of just restructuring. The whole thing I'll never sell is just nonsense.
At points of time, you're better off just to crystallize games, restructure, and then rebuy into other assets. Yes, there's transaction costs to do it, but there's often a lot of benefits as well.
Yeah, good advice. Thanks, Chris. Okay, we've got time for just one more from Deer in the Headlights. So my wife and I are in our early 50s. We've started a self-managed super fund with a plan to buy property in it. We're also in the process of purchasing an investment property outside of super.
We've engaged a professional SMSF management company as well as a professional property investment firm. We're planning to seek professional, personal financial advice.
And my question is this, should I utilize the financial advisors available within our self-managed super fund management company or property investment firm, or would it be wise to seek financial advice from an unrelated third party to ensure an unbiased degree of separation? It sounds like you've almost answered your own question there.
I think a couple of things. I mean, it's a long time since I did my financial advisory exams, I think 2011 or so.
I think if you went to see an unrelated financial advisor, they would probably question whether you're going all in on property and ignoring other parts of your portfolio, which is a valid question, but I guess in the end, it's your own choice.
I think just that this is not related specifically to your circumstance, but one of the things I worry about is when you engage a property investment firm and they only recommend new build properties because they're linked to the developer and they're taking a commission from the developer of somewhere between 6% and 8%, and then you buy an expensive new build property, they tend to try and sell you on the depreciation tax benefits.
But there's a concern there that in five or 10 years time, the property is no longer new. Even though it might be easy to rent out in the first instance, the capital growth might be underwhelming or sometimes non-existent.
So that's just a concern I have with the self-managed super fund space is that there's been a lot of people active there. Of course, over the years, they're often trying to sell off the planned apartments and that kind of stock. And it can come with a lot of risk.
But what do you think, Chris?
Oh, look, I'm really not a fan of property within self-managed super fund unless it's commercial. And, you know, I'm really concerned around the lending in self-managed super funds.
I think it's, you know, they shut down trust lending last year, basically, because it was getting abused by, you know, buyers, agents and these property investment companies, to be fair. And then I think self-managed super funds, the next one, I think it's going to be absolutely a big crackdown on that because
marketing, particularly property investment companies, marketing, buying in self-managed super funds. It's really giving quasi financial advice, tax advice. And I think, you know, the accounting industry don't like that. The financial advice industry won't like that. ASIC won't like that. So I think it's just this, it'll come back on the thing.
And then at some point, there's going to probably be a heavy handed nurse, I think, with self-managed super funds and residential property. So that's the first thing. Secondly, like any company that's really pushing this strategy, it's just because they know that all their customers are capped out buying property in their personal name.
And they're like, hey, you got super, you don't like super, even though it's compounded at a great rate, if you look over the last decade. And, you know, you could make more money if you put it into resi property and you love property, we love property, let's just go and do it.
And I think it's absolutely a dangerous strategy. And I don't think you, particularly after you, when you're entering now, budgets are really hard because, you know, it's not like you got unlimited borrowing capacity in super, there is a cap.
And then you look at how much prices have risen at the bottom end over the last few years. You're coming very late into the cycle. It's not like you're coming early.
And so, A, you're punting all your money late in a cycle into the cheaper properties and you're basically punting yourself on your super fund. So, you know, I think you've already taken enough risk potentially personally. You said here you're going to go and buy a personal investment property as well.
You know, do you really need to also double gear on a, you know, in your super fund as well? Personally, I would run, but absolutely get independent advice and not from the company and not from your self-managed super fund advisor as well, because they're conflicted.
All those, and just get someone who's completely gonna give you some fresh eyes. But also it's hard in the advice space. Not many, they wanna go near property. And so if you go in there with this type of problem is they might not be allowed to advise on it.
They might not really know. and they might not be confident to give you the hard truth that you need to hear around the dangers of this type of asset.
So if they are recommending a certain location and area, go and get a local buyer's agent's view on that that's been in that market for a long time and hopefully they can enlighten you on why that wouldn't be a property they'd ever consider.
Yeah, get some unbiased advice if you can. So thanks, Chris. Thanks for joining today, everyone. So just to recap, obviously, we've got an oil price shock ongoing. And I think if you look at market pricing, you can expect interest rates to move higher as 2026 goes on.
So if you're somebody who's in the market or thinking of entering the market, you need to have a plan for how to ride out the rest of 2026 before hopefully things get a bit easier in 2027 and just be really clear on what your strategy is.
And yeah, Chris, any final thoughts from you?
Look, I do think it's one of those moments where you've just got to get through it for a lot of families. You've got to come up with a way to restructure your loans, release equity, find a way. you know, potentially take any advantage of any ways to rebuild buffers.
But, you know, on the, Lucy Ellis said this, you know, like, yes, there's potentially higher rates and, you know, that's likely, right? And that's gonna cause some pain. But on the other side of this shock is probably a recession and there's gonna be significant cuts and et cetera.
And so that's a much better market to sell in if you have to sell. So if you can try to ride it out as much as you can, that would be, probably a better option than sort of rushing and you're out of the market and you're back in the rental market.
And so don't be making any rush decisions. And I know there's a lot of people who are struggling right now. And I think you just got to get some good advice around your structures and just see if there's any ways to sort of get through it.
Because I do feel on the other side of this, we'll look back on it and say, oh, do you remember what happened in 26 with the oil shock and inflation went up and rates went up and God, it feels much better now that that's all over and rates are coming back down.
So I feel like it's, you can't ever see that far over the hill right now because it just feels like it's so uncertain, but at some point it'll start to become cleaner and clearer.
And I think you've just got to try to get to that point, even though it's as heavy as it is at the moment.
Yeah, cool. I'll be south of the border this week, just heading down the coast for Easter over that week. It'll be interesting to see if people are still traveling around. I guess mostly they will be, but maybe a few cancellations as well. What have you got planned, Chris?
Off to Molly Milk on Friday, so I won't be doing an episode next week, but the week after, absolutely, we'll be back. And I'm sure a lot's going to happen in two weeks.
Yeah, it'll be interesting to see where things are at when you're back on deck. So thanks for joining, everyone. Send any questions. Always keen to cover those. I look forward to seeing you next week. See you next week. Cheers.
Thanks for tuning into the Australian Property Podcast. If you love the show, why not subscribe or leave us a review on Apple or Spotify.
And if you want to work with me, Amy, Pete or Chris, you'll find links in your podcast player to get in contact with us.
from a licensed and trusted professional before acting on the information you hear in RAS podcasts. Thanks again for listening.
