Posted
2 November 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
October 12, 2024
Episode
354
 ·
53
 min
The show

The Elephant in the Room

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with Veronica Morgan. It's a deep dive into what really goes on in the world of real estate.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Veronica Morgan
Veronica Morgan
Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor

Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

Guest
Cameron Kusher
Cameron Kusher
Executive Director, Economic Research at REA Group

In this episode, we sit down with Cameron Kusher, Executive Director of Economic Research at REA Group, to unpack the trends shaping the Australian property market right now.

Cameron Kusher on Why Australia's Property Markets Split Five Ways

REA Group's Cameron Kusher takes Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates through what the country's biggest property portal sees in its listings and search data. The picture is five capital cities pulling in different directions, and supply explains most of it.

Transcript
Veronica Morgan

In this episode, we're talking with Cameron Kusher from the REA Group, and we're going to explore the insights that Australia's biggest property portal is able to gain from its user activity through the lens of an economist. What are buyers searching for and where? Are listings on the rise? If so, where?

And how does this all translate into transactions and ultimately prices? Essentially, we want to lift the lid and look under the bonnet of the property market in this episode. Welcome to the elephant in the room.

This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about. I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, recently ranked number five in Australia out of over 18,000 brokers in the annual MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Awards. Before we get started, I need to let you know that nothing we say here can be taken as personal advice.

We always recommend you engage the services of an appropriate and experienced professional. Our guest today is Cameron Kusher, the Executive Director of Economic Research at REA Group.

Cameron's 20-year property sector career spans valuations, property development consulting, commercial property research, as well as residential property research. And he's seen as a thought leader on housing market trends, as well as broader economic trends, particularly those that impact the housing market. Now, Cameron, it is really great to see you again.

It's been way too long. We always enjoy our chats with you. So welcome back.

Chris Bates

Thank you for having me. Cameron, obviously it's late September. Someone listening to this is probably it's middle of October. But how's spring shaping up from REA's point of view? And is there any surprises in terms of listings?

Have you seen a change in sort of search data and buyer behaviour in the last few weeks? I mean, what's REA saying? I mean, you've got some of the best data in the country, to be honest.

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, look, we're seeing quite a good increase in the number of listings. We're not quite at the end of September yet, but looking at sort of the daily data through September, we are seeing a ramp up in listings and it's not just in Sydney and Melbourne anymore. We're starting to see more stock

coming to the market, I think there's a few reasons for that. I think a lot of people were anticipating that interest rates would be cut later this year, and that's looking pretty unlikely now.

So maybe some people that are holding out hope that we were going to get those cuts are now saying, well, I can't hold on for another five or six months, and they're looking to move on. But I think one of the big things that's really changing is actually in the rental market.

We know that a lot of people, when they sell a property, need to transition through the rental market.

and that's been a really big challenge over the last couple of years because there's been no availability of rental stock we're finally starting to see a bit of an increase in rental stock availability as well and i think that's giving people confidence that okay i can sell i can continue to rent somewhere close to where we're living at the moment and then i've got a bit of an opportunity to buy so i think that's another thing that's starting to drive more stock onto the market then of course even though we don't have interest rate cuts

coming this year, at least not seemingly, it's looking less likely that we're going to get interest rate hikes. And I think most people are expecting an interest rate cut early next year, followed by several other cuts throughout 2025. So again, perhaps people were starting to position for that.

Veronica Morgan

I love that quick snapshot of some of the drivers of what's happening in the market at the minute. We definitely want to unpick a lot of those things, right? But before we do, I'm curious because spring is selling season, right?

That's the agents put it out there, get your house on the market, the daffodils are out, blah, blah, blah. But as a buyer, I know that spring is buying season, you know, and I like the fact that sellers think it's selling season.

And so there is a typical spring market I would imagine in most the whole country into some degree would follow this pattern. So I'm keen to know, I guess, from your position, what is that pattern and how is this year? Is it tracking it or is it differing in any way? Yeah.

Cameron Kusher

What we usually see in spring is that the number of properties coming to the market ramps up, starts to ramp up late August and then through September, October. And then once you kind of hit Melbourne Cup Day, it starts to ease off there.

Now, auction activity is still pretty strong right up until the week before Christmas, but we don't continue to see the number of properties coming onto the market. I think your point there about it being buying season is really what it's all about.

Yes, there's more listings, but that obviously gives people wanting to buy a property a lot more choice and a lot more opportunities to buy. And even though there's a lot more properties going to auction, we also tend to see auction clearance rates easing.

We tend to see a little bit of an increase in days on market because people don't have that same fear of missing out that they do when there's not much stock on the market. Right.

So if we look at what's happening this year, though, we did see a big increase in new listings in August, much bigger than what we usually see. So again, maybe people are trying to get into the spring selling season earlier this year than they have in the past.

That's certainly something that we've witnessed. Auction clearance rates and auction volumes have been pretty strong so far. Again, we're not even quite yet a month into spring.

We're still seeing a lot of inquiry out there. But again, talking to a lot of real estate agents over the last month, there is a sense that buyers are being a lot more selective. And again, I think that comes back to the more stock being available.

And also some of the feedback I've had is that the volumes of people coming to open homes and the numbers of registered bidders are actually down a little bit as well. Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

So that would be predominantly Sydney and Melbourne where you're looking at that auction data and Brisbane to a degree, but Brisbane's still not what you call an auction capital, is it? No.

And so what are the things that are happening in other cities then or other locations where then you can't sort of read the auction data in quite the same way?

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, so if we look at places like Perth and Adelaide, I mean, those two markets have seen the biggest increases in prices over the past year. So to give your listeners an understanding of how much prices have increased. So in Perth, over the last 12 months, prices are up more than 23%.

In Adelaide, they're up more than 15%. In Brisbane, they're up about 14%. Sydney, you've seen price growth of around 6%, whereas in Melbourne, prices are down about 1.5%.

And I think the main reason why we're seeing this divergence in the performance or the price growth really comes down to supply. If you look in Sydney, for example, the number of properties on the market is 13% higher than it was a year ago. In Melbourne, it's up 15%.

In Brisbane, though, it's down 3.8%. In Adelaide, it's down 14%. And in Perth, it's down 20%. So you've got this kind of tale of in Sydney and Melbourne, you've got more choice. Buyers have got the ability to be a little bit more selective. They can wait.

There's quite a lot of stock coming onto the market every single week and every single month. So I think... People are going, well, I like this property, but if I miss out, not the end of the world because something else is going to come onto the market.

On the flip side, you go to Perth, Adelaide or Brisbane and people start looking for properties. There's not much available. And then there's not much coming to the market on a regular basis either. So it's almost like if you find something that's good,

you've really got to try and get that because if you miss out it could be several months before something else comes onto the market and you know the prices could have moved 5 10 15 20 higher than than what they are now so you've certainly got that higher level of desperation from buyers in places like Brisbane Adelaide and Perth and you know less desperation in Sydney and Melbourne and that really is a story about how much stock is on the market and how much stock is coming to the market

Chris Bates

Are you seeing, I mean, the data that you have that not many other people have, right, is around what's, you know, search data basically, what people are searching, how many times they're looking at properties, are they making inquiries on properties, you know, how many people are just window shoppers, et cetera.

Like, you know, there's some other people who've got that data, but nothing like REA have. Have you seen, is there anything that you can sort of provide over the last,

few months and um you know that's so much pent-up demand in property markets that people don't realize right and um you know a little bit increasing confidence we've absolutely said on a mortgage broking point of view more people come to us over the last couple of months but

Does that correlate with search data? Are you seeing more urgency there?

Cameron Kusher

So we're seeing a lot more search volumes. We're continuing to see more and more users coming to our site. We hit a record high number of users in August, I think, which is our latest data.

In terms of the buyers, the way we kind of look at demand is looking at the number of inquiries per listing. So if we look at inquiries per listing, they're pretty much flat from where they were 12 months ago in the capital cities.

Interestingly, they've actually increased a little bit in the regional markets. Now, again, geographically, that's all very different. So inquiries per listing are lower in Sydney and Melbourne than they were 12 months ago. They're higher in Brisbane, Adelaide and Perth.

And then if you look in regional areas, they're lower in, they're stable in regional New South Wales. They're lower in regional Victoria. They're quite a bit higher in regional Queensland and they're marginally higher in regional WA and regional South Australia. Then you go to the smaller capital cities. Inquiries are up in Darwin.

They're up marginally in Hobart. They're down in Canberra. So it is really a bit of a mixed bag. I think one of the more interesting things I've started looking at is

taking all of our inquiries and taking all of our listings and matching up, you know, where there's a mismatch between the volume of inquiry and listings.

And, you know, when we look at this across the nation in terms of houses, what we're seeing is, you know, a bit of an oversupply of two-bedroom houses on the market and a bit of an oversupply of four-bedroom houses. But on the other hand, a bit of an

under supply, relatively speaking, of three bedroom houses. And I think that that speaks to the price sensitivity of buyers at the moment. You know, they probably want a four bedroom house, but that's outside of their price point. But five bedroom houses, there's also a mismatch as well.

And I think that speaks to a couple of things. Firstly, there's some people that aren't really being impacted by higher interest rates or certainly not to the same magnitude. Probably a sense that we want more space because we're working from home.

I think an increase in consideration for buyers as well is, you know, it's expensive out there. My kids, they might be teenagers now, but they could be living with me for another 10 or 15 years, so I need some space. That's kind of what's happening in houses.

In the unit market, we're definitely seeing a bit of an oversupply in the three-bedroom market. Really? Yeah. And that's both in terms of brand new properties, but also existing properties. And then the one and two bedroom stock, we've been seeing a bit of an undersupply of that.

And again, I think we know that investors are coming back into the market. We know that not a lot of new one and two bedroom stock is actually being delivered. So people are increasingly looking for secondhand one and two bedroom apartments.

Veronica Morgan

I mean, of course, this is across the country because, you know, and there is no one property market, as we all know, because, you know, I'm thinking particularly with the three bedrooms and the one bedrooms in Sydney right at the minute, it's like there's – we think it's the opposite. Yeah.

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, so Sydney is the one that's really the outlier here.

We are seeing three-bedroom stock relatively undersupplied compared to the amount of stock, to the amount of inquiry. Whereas you go to Melbourne, you go to Brisbane and you go to Adelaide and Perth, there is an oversupply, relatively speaking, of that three-bedroom stock.

Veronica Morgan

That's interesting, isn't it? I mean, I can see Melbourne because, like, from my sort of perspective, my take on that is three-bedroom apartments rise in popularity when the houses become expensive, usually in urban areas, right? And Melbourne's obviously there's sport for choice at the minute.

It's an easy place to buy compared to what it has been in the past or what other cities are at the minute. So that sort of answers Melbourne. But in terms of the other cities, you know, I'm sort of a bit head-scratching around some of that.

Cameron Kusher

I think what is happening in some of those other cities, so there's typically probably not been as much three-bedroom supply. So in the established market there's just generally not as much of that three-bedroom stock. And a lot of that three-bedroom stock has kind of been penthouse apartments. So it's not necessarily price-pointed.

Whereas in Sydney, you go out to the Western suburbs, there's a lot of six-packs, 12-packs with three-bedroom apartments that are actually representing pretty good value these days, especially if you compare it to buying a brand new three-bedroom apartment in Sydney at the moment.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah. Do you think there's anything on the horizon? Actually, before I ask you that question, going back to Perth, I think it's really fascinating that you've got a shortage of listings when you've got such rapid price growth.

It's obviously easier to sell properties and they've come out of a period of 10 years of pretty horrible conditions and

And I'm wondering, was there a real surge of people getting their properties sold early on in this sort of cycle because people after that period of time of no growth saw price movement and said, that's it, now is the time to get out?

Or have we not seen that early on and we literally got people that potentially would be selling or would want to sell in Perth but they're perhaps thinking, well, this is you know, this rollercoaster's got a way to go before it's anywhere near the peak. I mean, any thoughts on that?

Cameron Kusher

Look, I think Perth's an interesting one because we never have really seen over the last couple of years much of a surge in the number of properties coming to the market in Perth. It's been very low really since about 2020.

We have seen, just looking at the data now, so new listings are marginally higher than they were a year ago. They're a little bit higher now than the longer term average, but the total amount of stock on the market is extremely low.

So how I look at it is I compare things to last year. So total listings in Perth are down 19.7% from a year ago. If we look at the August average, over the five years from 2018 to 2022, the number of properties on the market in Perth is down 46.1%.

So when I speak to... Underpinning the growth then, isn't it?

Veronica Morgan

Exactly.

Cameron Kusher

So when I speak to our team over there, you know, the feedback they get is... You know, we know we can sell our property but there's nothing else to buy. So where am I going to move to? And it kind of becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

But what I would say is I remember kind of 24 months ago people were saying the same thing in Sydney and Melbourne and then all of a sudden they just seemed to be a bit of a circuit breaker where people –

thought interest rates had peaked and and said okay now it's time to get on with it but we just haven't had that in perth i think the other thing in perth is you're seeing a huge amount of investors buying up in perth as well i think investor lending in wa is up 96 percent in terms of value uh from where it was 12 months ago so you know if you've got a lot of investors in the market they're not having to sell anything they're not necessarily having to sell anything locally

Veronica Morgan

Although also, I mean, if you compare that to, say, the Brisbane unit market, a lot of Brisbane unit owners were investors and they've taken advantage of the surge in prices to get out after, you know, 10-year doldrums.

Whereas if you're an owner-occupier in Perth, like you say, you're not going to suddenly bail and suddenly grab a win for if you've got to trade up and you can't find something. So that does make a lot of sense to me.

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, and you're trading up in a really tricky market to actually secure something else. So I think for a lot of people at the moment, it's just too hard. It's just keep riding the wave. But as you said, you know, prices went nowhere in Perth for 10 or 15 years.

I would definitely have that in the back of my mind. You know, we've got this huge surge now, but what comes after this surge?

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, and who's buying always worries me when it's mostly investors that are driving something.

Chris Bates

Cameron, obviously listings aren't, low listings ain't great for REA, right? That's, you know, you'd love Perth listings to be up 50% rather than it was five years ago. And obviously over the longer term, you know, if you look back 10 years ago, right, that was pretty good for REA, right?

The amount of listings of people were transacting properties much higher, right? How does REA feel around the, The turnover rate of property dropping as a percentage as a country and people living in their homes for longer. And have you guys done much research on that?

Because it's obviously a big discussion point for you must internally when you forecast listing numbers in the future long term. What's REO's thoughts on that long term?

Cameron Kusher

it's it's definitely something we look at obviously our customers are predominantly real estate agents and we're driven by listings um now our two biggest markets are new south wales and victoria and those markets are quite strong at the moment so it's it's obviously positive for our business um and you know we do tend to have high yielding customers in those markets as well um so

The strength in Sydney and Melbourne is certainly really positive for us at the moment. And if you had a weaker Sydney and Melbourne, but a stronger Western Australia, Queensland and South Australia, that probably wouldn't be enough to offset a weaker market in New South Wales and Victoria.

um i guess our market's kind of double-sided because we also advertise new homes now it's a different pricing model and everything like that but whilst we're seeing a big surge in established properties in new south wales and victoria we're seeing a lot fewer new developments come to site um and it's really a mixed bag so in in victoria it's really hard to sell new homes whether it's a new apartment or or a new house and land whereas in queensland and wa

The projects are selling out really quickly. So we might not even end up getting that advertised on our site at all because there's such pent-up demand for that stock that those projects are selling out without ever having to advertise on our site. So I guess...

when you've when you've got the established market going well that can be positive for for that part of our business but when you've got the developer side of the business going well but not too well um and people are advertising a lot that's positive for our business and we've obviously got the geographic mix i mean we would love lots of listings around the country all the time but we also know that that's realistically not going to happen

Chris Bates

Yeah, I just more think about the research behind just the structural. I mean, the green competitor of yours did some research that I did love, right? It showed basically that we're living in our homes. You know, it was seven years, now it's 14 years.

And, you know, REA must be looking at that as a business and going, not the domain research, but the turnover rate of property. And, you know, like obviously we're living in our homes longer and longer. And, you know, have you got any sort of, thoughts on why that is?

And, you know, is it going to keep on going that way?

Cameron Kusher

It's an interesting question because, I mean, there's actually two ways to kind of look at that turnover rate. And what we deem sort of hold period is looking at basically what's sold over the last 12 months and looking at the difference between that sale date and the previous sale date.

And I think we've got the same metric. It's about 12, 13 years. It's a bit low for units, a bit higher for houses.

But the other way to look at it is having a look at how many properties there are in the total market and then having a look at how many sales you're getting every year. And based on that, about 5% of stock turns over in any given year.

So it's a bit of a different result to the hold period. The hold period will give you 12, 13 years. But based on that 5%, obviously that's 20 years for a property typically to sell. And that's been pretty stable for about the last 15 years or so.

So I think what you find when you look at that whole period metric is there's definitely certain stock that sells on a more regular basis. And when you delve down into the suburbs and the areas, particularly in a lot of new housing estates, you see a lot faster turnover there.

Whereas in the established blue chip areas of cities, you tend to find that properties are held onto a lot longer. But I think for us, we kind of know that It's going to take about 20 years for everything to come onto the market.

You're going to get about 5% of stock being advertised for sale in any given year.

Chris Bates

That's interesting because, yeah, that really does. Yeah, I mean, with the first-time buyers, that does make a lot of sense and investors, right, and the apartment market. So while people are living in their homes and their houses for the longer term when they get into that family stage, yeah,

You know, you know, you're going to consistently get a lot of turnover with the first home buyer or the house and land package and decides to upgrade or that the investors coming in and out.

So that gives you a lot of confidence that, yes, people are living in their homes longer, but we've still got a lot of people turning over property. But that does show that suburbs are still getting more and more tightly held, though, right?

So, you know, when it's getting harder and harder to get into these suburbs because people are still selling less.

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, exactly right. And I think, you know, there's obviously at the moment a really big push for more density in inner city areas. And, you know, we know that in a lot of areas, people don't necessarily want that. So that might encourage them to be less inclined to sell.

But also it makes houses in these areas more sought after and they'll be even more tightly held because over time if we do get more density in these inner city areas, a detached house is going to be increasingly rare and more sought after. Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

And this is where my little spotty senses are going off when you're talking about that, that you've got certain areas where properties are transacting more often.

Have you ever done any work to sort of look at the, forget the transaction cost for a minute, in terms of just the capital growth of those types of areas or stock types or whatever?

Is there a different, have you done any research on that to sort of look at, well, what's a better asset?

Cameron Kusher

Oh, look, I haven't recently. I mean, as I said, we do look at it and you can see that generally the areas with the shortest toll period are new housing estates and areas like growth areas on the outskirts of the city.

In terms of the capital growth, I mean, what happens in a lot of those areas, you go in and you buy a house early on in the new development and

And especially if it's a big master plan community or it's a big area where there's lots of development, every developer is bumping up their price a little bit every time there's a new stage or every time there's a new project.

So you are getting some capital growth, but you're probably not getting the same sort of capital growth in, you know, Box Hill in Sydney, as opposed to owning a house in Volcluse or Bellevue Hill in Sydney.

Veronica Morgan

No, but just because the developer jacks up the price of the next release doesn't actually mean that if you sell yours, you're going to get the same money as the brand new one in the next release.

So even what you just talked about there, in terms of data, it says that their values are going up, but the actual reality is if they tried to sell or when they go to sell it, it might be a different story.

So I'm always interested to see if there's some, you know, any research being done on that. Yeah.

Cameron Kusher

Or maybe it's something we can have a look at.

Veronica Morgan

You're probably not even interested in that. Not in the way I am, I can understand. I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions and you can find out all about what I'm working on at veronicamorgan.com.au.

There you will find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program, information about my newest project, Preferrental.

proactive property management in sydney or if you're looking to buy your dream home or investment property in sydney's inner west eastern suburbs or lower north shore you can connect with my team at good deeds property buyers and if you'd like a 30 discount plus free postage my book auction ready how to buy property at auction even though you're scared shitless and yes i'm a potty mouth use the code elephant at the checkout

Chris Bates

If you're looking to buy your first home, thinking of upgrading to a new home or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Please reach out to myself and the team at flintgroup.au.

Veronica Morgan

But from your position, though, from all the work that you've done, what are the key factors that contribute to the established dwelling price movements, whether they be up or down? What are the things over and above just supply and obviously interest rates because that's not the key driver?

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, look, supply and interest rates are probably the two main ones. Obviously, in some of the more desirable areas, scarcity as well is obviously a really key driver. In terms of interest rates, you've also got borrowing capacity. So we know at the moment there's still the 3% serviceability buffer.

That's knocking quite a lot of people that do want to buy out of the market. You've also got just when you go to a lender and you try and borrow now, the questions that you get asked are a lot more intrusive.

And we know banks are looking at things like, are you planning to have a family? Are your kids going to private schools? So all of these factors also play into that. But in terms of what drives price,

you know, where we are in the cycle, economic conditions. I mean, I think everyone is a little bit surprised even now how strong price growth still is, given that interest rates are the highest they've been in 12 years. You know, all the common knowledge, all the common belief is

as interest rates go up borrowing capacities fall and prices shouldn't rise or they should fall moderately but that's certainly not the case at the moment and i think it's it it generally comes down to the willingness to people to sell but also

Yes, interest rates have gone up, but people have got so much equity in their properties now. And we know particularly that that downsizer market has been really active. And if you're moving from a $3 million house in Sydney to a $2 million unit, you may have totally cleared your debt.

You may not need any finance at all. I think also that the population is becoming a lot more mobile. We know that during the pandemic, a lot of people left places like Melbourne and Sydney and moved to coastal areas.

so i live in brisbane if you uh you know i'd love to have a house on the gold coast or the sunshine coast but it's really expensive but again if you've sold out of sydney and you're in a blue chip area of sydney you might have got three or four million dollars for your house and you're buying at one and a half to two million again probably completely cleared all your debt um and

you're buying in a way that locals can't really compete with that. They don't have that same capacity to pay those prices that people moving from interstate do.

And I think that's, especially in terms of people moving regionally, this has been a really tricky part of it because the people that are moving have got a lot of wealth and they just outbid all of those locals that want to try and buy in that market as well.

Veronica Morgan

Is that still happening? Are you seeing it in the activity on realestate.com.au? Are you seeing that inquiry? Because you can geo, what's it called? Geo something. Geotag, yes. That's it. You can geotag people. So you know where they are now and where they're looking.

Has that changed, that interest in relocating?

Cameron Kusher

It's eased off a little bit, but it's certainly not back to sort of where it was pre-pandemic. So we are still seeing a large volume of people looking to make that move. 2021, 2022, that movement was huge.

It has pulled back, but it's settled at a level much higher than it was pre-pandemic. So we're still seeing a lot of interest.

Veronica Morgan

Even that's interesting because the pandemic sort of migration out of the cities was very much triggered, I think, by a latent desire, if you like, and then all of a sudden it's like here's the circumstances, now's the time. So the fact that you've still got more people actually actively participating

playing with the idea online, that sort of, you know, for the next pandemic we get, then I think we should brace ourselves, right?

Cameron Kusher

Yeah. I think it's also we've kind of settled into a sort of for people working, we now have some certainty about what that's going to look like. Now, we know some businesses are telling people they've got to be back in the office five days a week. Then there's other businesses that are hybrid.

So if you're hybrid, you know, two days in the office, You know, in Queensland, you can live on the Gold Coast or Sunshine Coast. If you're in Sydney, you can live in Wollongong. You can live in the Central Coast.

You know, yes, I wouldn't want to do that commute every day, but if it's two days a week, it's all right. And then in Melbourne, you know, Geelong, Bendigo, Ballarat, they're all commutable if you're only doing it a couple of days a week. But I also think the other type of commuting...

is I live on the Gold Coast, I have that Sydney job or I have that Melbourne job, I jump on a plane Monday morning, I go and work in Sydney or Melbourne for two or three days and then I fly back.

And I think there's probably a lot more of that going on these days as well. It's not just that I... I have a Melbourne job, so if I want to move to the beach, I've got to be down the surf coast. I can be on the Gold Coast.

I can be on the Sunshine Coast. Some of the other regional markets may be a little bit more difficult because you don't have the airport infrastructure to do that, but certainly here in southeast Queensland, there seems to be quite a bit of that going on.

Veronica Morgan

So that's why plane tickets are still expensive.

Chris Bates

I mean, we've seen that, to be honest. A lot of people coming back to the cities, I think our clients are absolutely trying to hug the capital city more, but they're absolutely getting pushed out because of budget.

And so they go looking around what they can do, you know, get for their budget in around the capital city, let's say Sydney, and...

They're like, oh, actually, I don't really want to move up the coast, but because work is more than I expected in the office and it feels a bit risky, but it's actually my only option.

And I think particularly because budgets are just so tight and prices have gone up, even though borrowing capacity has fallen so much. But are you seeing that with... It's all about your search data.

I'd just love to be if I could get a, you know, a password or something, if you don't mind, just to get me access to the data pool.

But are you seeing that naturally where, you know, the search used to be like a, you know, your bell curve was, you know, 20 or 30% higher than it was, you know, say two or three years ago? Because it would make sense, right, that...

yes, borrowing capacities have come down, but it doesn't mean the buyers have disappeared, right? They've just had to readjust their budgets.

And so when they readjust their budgets, they're, hey, I'm not buying at two, I'm looking at one seven, or I was looking at one five, now it's one two, or 1.2 to 900.

So really the bell curve should have shifted, not as much as borrowing capacity, because people are then getting a bit of generational wealth to offset that. So Is that what you see internally where the search is there, they're just changing the metrics and the maximums to suit their new budgets?

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, and they're changing their parameters. I think they're not being as specific on their searches. Yes, they are. they want to sit on live in suburb X, but the reality is they're not going to get there and they might not get to the one next to it.

They'll keep an eye on that suburb, but they will branch out a little bit further. We also do a lot of consumer research at REA and we know that people are now looking. So we ask questions around things like, you know, compared to where you live now, how far would you consider moving?

And over the last couple of years, we've seen that people are considering moving further away. Oh, absolutely. And again, I think that's being driven not out of want or desire, but more out of necessity. We're also interestingly really seeing this in the rental market at the moment.

When we look at our rental data, when we look at rental growth, when we look at rental inquiries, You would probably think in Sydney, for example, your strongest rental growth and your strongest inquiry is in the inner west or it's in the northern beaches or the eastern suburbs.

Where we're actually seeing the strongest rental inquiry and rental price growth at the moment is in the southwest. It's in the Blue Mountains. It's in the outer southwest as well. In Victoria, so again, you would think it's the inner suburbs of Melbourne.

It's actually the southeast of Melbourne where we're seeing, and the outer east of Melbourne, where we're seeing the strongest rental growth and inquiry. And in Brisbane, it's places like Ipswich and Logan Bow Desert.

I would say that's probably not aspirationally where you want to live as a renter, but I think out of the high cost of renting, it's pushing people further away from the city centre into those markets just because that's all they can afford.

Veronica Morgan

Well, that makes perfect sense. And it's the tide, isn't it? You know, it's the ripple effect, right? So this is just the next best thing. They keep going further and further afield until they can find something that they can afford. And then they'll come back in once things shift.

Who knows when that will be. That is interesting, though, because there has been some data that's come out recently that rental price growth has slowed considerably. It seems to be across the board. Have you seen demand online fall?

Cameron Kusher

We have started to see demand fall as well. Now, what's driving that? I know the federal government's talking a lot about student caps, but if you look at the temporary student visa arrivals, they've been falling for about 12 months anyway.

So there has been a big pullback in those temporary student numbers coming into the country.

Veronica Morgan

But I also ask how many, you know, rental properties do students really take off the market?

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, look, obviously there's student accommodation at universities. I think the property council said it's 4%. I think the Department of Education said it's about 7%.

One thing we also know is, though, that people are starting to go more and more back into share houses. So one of the businesses that we own is a website called flatmates.com.au. And for the last 18 months, we've seen a massive surge in people signing up to that website. Now...

unless you're a uni student you're probably not really wanting to go back into a share house but i think for a lot of people out of necessity they're either going back into a share house or if they've got a spare bedroom looking at a way that they can rent that out and i i think this really speaks to the fact that the cost of everything's gone up interest rates have gone up but rents are growing at a faster pace than the cost of everything else so you know something's got to give at some point and

How do you respond to that? You move to a smaller property, you take on a roommate or you move further away than where you'd really like to be renting.

Veronica Morgan

Well, if you bring more renters into the house, then that just props up rental prices, really.

Cameron Kusher

It does. And that's, I mean, if you look in Sydney, for example, I think the median house rent in the eastern suburbs now is like $1,500 a week. And, you know, people just can't afford that. That's just...

Veronica Morgan

astounded actually i mean um i've mentioned the podcast before but you know i've got a new business called prefer rental and so we've actually just um gone into property management and i'm actually really astounded at even though i help investors buy properties now that i'm actually you know and i'm not dealing i'm not on the operational side of things but now that we're sort of dealing more with tenants it's dawning on me that wow

These people have to have a high disposable income to be able to afford really quite basic, you know, when I mean basic, they're nice apartments, for example, but they're not big. Yeah. And you think that's a lot of money. Yeah. Yeah, it does astound me that that's sustainable.

What do you think is, because I guess the affordability of a rental property, like you talked about, how do you make it more affordable? You move further away, you get something smaller or you get more people in.

It's always kept or it's constrained, isn't it, by incomes in a way that property prices in terms of sale prices aren't.

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, I think people are getting tapped out. And I think that there probably is now, you know, I've seen examples of it in certain sort of more desirable areas that some properties are proving quite difficult to rent.

And obviously, from a landlord's perspective, we know that, you know, interest charges on investment properties have gone up massively since the start of the pandemic. So it's not as if people are recouping all of that increasing cost. But, you

People just don't have the capacity to keep paying 10%, 15% more in rent every single year. And pretty much everywhere we have seen that the annual rate of rental growth now this year is lower than it was last year. And I think we'll continue to see that.

And I think especially as interest rates fall, I think more first-home buyers, more people that are sort of at that higher income level,

will be going, well, you know what, I want to get out of renting and yes, it's going to cost me more, but interest rates are on their way down and I'm going to try and get my own property.

Now, you're probably not going to be living in the same suburb that you're renting in, but I think people will be prepared to pay that premium to get that security of tenancy they just don't have in the rental market.

Chris Bates

Just on that, Cameron, I mean, you would be able to see just with some data matching, right, going, this property was listed on our portal for rent, 12 months ago or in the last three or four years. Now it's on a listing for sale.

And then you've got to correlate that and go, it's highly likely this is an investment property. Yes. And are you able to see that there's been a massive increase

in that type of listing over the last couple of years because that's really the the suction out of the market of our rental our investors right and that's our rental supply and you know rates staying even if rates cuts do happen like you said rents aren't going to condition consistently keep going up because it's um an affordability problem it's also good news to be honest because that means our inflation figures aren't going to be as strong right and that means they're going to get rate cuts so

Luckily, that's happening because if it wasn't happening, it's going to delay rate cuts. But investors can't hold on because they're still going to be paying 5% or 4.5% mortgages on their homes and the investment properties are still neutrally or negatively geared.

So I do think you're going to see a lot of investors consistently bail over the next couple of years. Have you seen a massive increase there? No, that's…

Cameron Kusher

So the share of new listings coming to the market that we kind of identify as former rental properties has been elevated right throughout the pandemic. It's been at about 35% of new listings.

now in a lot of areas it started to pull back a little bit it hasn't really pulled back in sydney or in melbourne now we know in melbourne obviously the state government there's ramped up taxes on on investors and that's probably encouraging people to bail um but it's still quite high in sydney as well and again i wonder if that's just people are tapped out you know because you're paying a lot more for an investment property in sydney in the first place and you just got those very high interest rates um

I think the other thing with the rental market that's probably not spoken about so much is what's happening in new housing. So when we look at what's being built at the moment, I'm mainly talking about apartments.

Most of the new apartments are large two bedrooms, large three bedrooms targeted at that owner occupier segment of the market. So when you go back to 2017, 2018, when we were building a huge number of apartments, a lot of it was one bedroom, two bedroom stock. It was sold to an investor.

And once that building was completed, say it was 400 apartments, you'd probably get another 250, 300 apartments coming into the rental pool. Now, the apartment building's 120 apartments, and you may be getting five or six coming into the rental market.

So that rental pool of stock is just not growing at a very fast pace at the moment.

Veronica Morgan

That's really interesting because pre-COVID, rents were under quite a lot of pressure in inner Sydney. And I was talking to a number of property managers, particularly over in the east, and this really surprised me. They were saying that rents were considerably down.

I know my own investment properties, I took rental cuts basically in that period of time. And I was told that because there was a lot of new development over in Mascot.

Cameron Kusher

Yep.

Veronica Morgan

a lot of brand new apartments, you know, some of them city views, quite, you know, and they hit the market all at one time and they sucked demand out of places as far as Bondi, which amazed me. I thought, no, why would someone who was looking previously in Bondi go to Mascot?

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, it's a bit of a different vibe.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, totally different vibe. But, yeah, and this is something I heard from a lot of different property managers in the west across to the eastern suburbs actually that said a similar thing, that that's where a lot of the tenant demand was going.

And, look, you know, I'm not sure if you remember that period of time. I'm not sure if you were paying attention to that inquiry. But is that the sort of thing that can happen, that it can really take, you know, tenant demand away from more established areas? Right.

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, it definitely can. And I think it's, you know, renters obviously aspirationally want to live somewhere. And I think a lot of people in Sydney would love to live in Bondi. But if there's no choices there, you've got to go somewhere else.

And again, if it gets too expensive, you've got to go somewhere else as well. And I guess mascot... Yes, there's a critical mass of people there. You are pretty close to the city. There's good public transport there. So I can understand why that would happen.

But, you know, look, now there's very little investor stock being built. There's very little new homes being bought by investors. And, you know, when we talk to property developers, they basically say that one- and two-bedroom stock just doesn't stack up for us at the moment. Interesting.

The only thing that is actually profitable for us is that downsize a market. So when we talk about needing new housing supply, I mean, from a developer's perspective, it's still got to stack up. There's still got to be sufficient profit margin there.

And the higher interest rates are certainly playing a part here because a lot of the projects that are now being built

The developers bought those sites at the top of the market, and they paid a very pretty penny for it, and it just doesn't stack up at anything other than high-end downsize of stock.

Veronica Morgan

So, and this leads into some other conversations we've been having around rezoning of sites to allow for, you know, high density.

And then if the developer is thinking, well, it actually stacks up to create more for the downsizing market, it's not really going to bring on lots and lots of new housing stock that their governments or that our councils may have been anticipating, certainly if they're putting more three-bedders in there rather than ones and twos.

Which we would argue that one of the reasons why that's probably profitable for them at the moment is there's been such a lack of development, particularly in Sydney anyway, of good quality three bedrooms for a long time. Yes.

Because the ones and twos being sold off to investors were stacking up more for them. So it's quite an interesting turn and I hadn't realised that.

Cameron Kusher

Yeah, I mean, it's all cyclical, right? And I think once we start to get interest rates coming down, these projects will become more viable again, especially if APRA removes some of these serviceability buffers and allows more people to come into the market, then it does become more viable.

Veronica Morgan

If they take negative gearing away from established properties perhaps, that'll certainly push investors that way.

Cameron Kusher

But again, I think it's really variable city to city. So for example, in Melbourne, even once interest rates come down, because prices in the established market are falling, you've got this massive gap between new and existing homes. So it's a really difficult sell.

Whereas you go to Perth or Brisbane and established prices have risen quite a lot, that gap is not as large. So again, once interest rates come down, prices have continued to rise, it doesn't look like that much of a jump to go to a new property.

Whereas Melbourne and maybe even to some extent Sydney, where you've seen softer price growth, It is quite a premium and I think it's hard to get people to justify paying that premium for the new property, especially when there's a lot of established properties on the market.

Chris Bates

Cameron, at REA, is there any exciting things you can share that you're working towards with consumer-friendly sort of buyer products or market search tools? Is there anything that's coming down the line that you can share that REA are working on?

Cameron Kusher

We've actually just this week started, there's a big project internally to reimagine our listings experience on our website and on our app. So if you do go into our app, you'll see that the listing has been reimagined. more advertising, I guess, for the real estate customers.

But if you click on the photos, it comes out on a whole reel. So the way it's always worked is you have to keep swiping to see. Now you can actually see a whole collection of the photos and go and look individually at those.

It's also going to have, I don't think it's gone live yet, but there's going to be some tagging in there to tell you what is in that photo and what sort of appliances are in there. And at the moment, there's a big project internally to completely reimagine our listing experience.

So this is the first rollout of... quite a few that are going to come over the next few years. So it's pretty exciting because, you know, nothing's really changed much in listings ever since the site was launched. Except the price. Except the price.

Veronica Morgan

The cost.

Cameron Kusher

Yes, I think that's probably the most exciting things in terms of the research side of things. I think, you know, there's some things I probably can't talk about too much yet, but there's some things we're looking at doing. Again, just measuring buyer demand in a bit better way, kind of,

getting a better feel for a really good indicator. Now, our real estate customers are really focused on inquiry, but we have found that inquiry is not necessarily the best indicator of someone's intention. Like in a lot of instances, people can just be inquiring to say, hey, what's the price?

Or hey, when's the open for inspection? You haven't put that on the listing. So we're trying to get better ways to measure those buyers that do have very high intent.

And a lot of that actually has to do with how long people spend on site, how many times they view photos and how many times they keep coming back to the listing.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, it's a good point because, you know, the agents that don't put any information on there, well, they force you to inquire. But that doesn't necessarily mean that that's a better listing. So it is a very good point, the weakness in using that as a measurement.

Yeah, I'm sort of interested, I guess, because then that encourages you to gamify, I guess, the whole experience of looking at listings, doesn't it? Because that's going to get someone in there longer. Yeah.

Cameron Kusher

yeah and and i think that's i mean i wouldn't say that's what we're trying to do but we want we want people deeper engaging um with our site i mean i think that's that's any listing portal would try to do that um but also you know we we have people that are registered users and you know we we suggest properties to them so we want to understand what they like and what they dislike so we can better recommend properties

And, you know, I talked about before that people are looking in wider search areas. So it's not a case of just saying, oh, this property in this suburb that you're looking at is the one you want, because people might be considering another suburb five, 10 kilometres away.

They may not have even thought about another suburb on the other side of the river or the other side of the harbour, but the property might be just right for them. So it's about being able to do that as well. Have you got a property Dumbo for us, Cameron?

No, my sister's just bought a house, but she's been looking for about a year and a half, but I think she bought pretty well. So she bought in Melbourne. And I guess for your listeners, I think Melbourne is very cheap at the moment.

I think, I mean, if the government wasn't trying to drive away investors, I think a lot of people would be buying in Melbourne at the moment because we know that compared to the other capital cities, it's starting to look really affordable.

Veronica Morgan

Well, actually, on that, I was going to ask you a question earlier because, of course, the PIPA, Annual Property Investors Sentiment Survey, the results came out a few weeks back, or by the time we go to live with this, a few weeks back, and they show that the top two cities that investors considered to be good places to invest were Perth and Melbourne, which are like at two ends of the continuum.

Have you seen that same sort of sentiment increase reflected in your interest, your user activity online, or is that literally just existing investors being a bit, maybe some of them being a bit contrarian?

Cameron Kusher

I think it's probably a bit contrarian. We're certainly not seeing a lot of investor activity in Melbourne or Victoria. We're seeing heaps in WA, but I think a lot of people are thinking about Melbourne.

The thing scaring them off is what's my land tax bill going to be if I buy a property in Melbourne?

And, you know, people are saying, well, the government will change. Maybe that policy will change. But obviously the Victorian government is in a lot of debt and they need to find a way to repay that debt. And, you know, governments of all stripes like to slug taxes on property owners and

Veronica Morgan

Very true, very true. Cameron, it's been great chatting with you, and thank you so much for coming back on to The Elephant in the Room. I think that we don't want to leave it so long next time. No, definitely not.

Cameron Kusher

Thank you, Cameron. Thanks for having me. If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website, theelephantintheroom.com.au, or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au.

If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit. And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great.

I know that sounds a bit cringy but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.

Click any timestamp to jump.

Key takeaways

  • Over the 12 months to the recording, prices were up more than 23% in Perth and more than 15% in Adelaide, while Melbourne was down about 1.5%.
  • Kusher put the divergence down to supply: stock on market was 13% higher in Sydney and 15% higher in Melbourne than a year earlier, but 20% lower in Perth.
  • Perth total listings were down 19.7% year on year and 46.1% below the August average for 2018 to 2022, with investor lending in WA up 96% by value.
  • About 5% of housing stock is advertised for sale in any given year, which implies roughly 20 years for everything to turn over, and that share has been stable for about 15 years.
  • Matching listings against inquiry showed a relative oversupply of two and four bedroom houses and three bedroom units, and an undersupply of three bedroom houses and one and two bedroom units.
  • Former rental properties have made up about 35% of new listings through the pandemic, while new apartment projects deliver far fewer rentals than the 2017 and 2018 building cycle did.

Why Did More Sellers List in Spring?

Recording in late September 2024, Cameron Kusher said REA Group was seeing a solid increase in listings, no longer just in Sydney and Melbourne. A rate cut in 2024 was looking unlikely, so vendors holding out for one decided they could not wait another five or six months. He also pointed to the rental market: sellers often need to rent between homes, and improving rental stock gave them more confidence to sell, rent nearby and then buy.

Updated: the cash rate is back at 4.35% as at 12 August 2026, the level it also sat at when this was recorded, after cuts to 3.60% through 2025 and three rises in early 2026 (RBA cash rate target).

Listings usually ramp up from late August through October, then ease after Melbourne Cup Day, though auctions stay strong until the week before Christmas. New listings jumped in August by much more than usual, and while clearance rates held up, agents told him buyers were more selective.

What Made Perth Rise and Melbourne Fall?

The clearest thing in the data was how far apart the capital cities had moved, and price growth lined up closely with stock levels.

Comparison Table: Capital City Price Growth Against Stock on Market
CityPrice growth, past 12 monthsStock on market vs a year agoInquiries per listing vs a year ago
PerthUp more than 23%Down 20%Higher
AdelaideUp more than 15%Down 14%Higher
BrisbaneUp about 14%Down 3.8%Higher
SydneyUp around 6%Up 13%Lower
MelbourneDown about 1.5%Up 15%Lower

As stated on air at 6:25 to 7:13 and 9:40. Figures are quoted as stated on air.

Where there is stock, buyers can afford to wait. Where there is not, the behaviour flips. Melbourne sat at the soft end.

If you find something that's good, you've really got to try and get that, because if you miss out it could be several months before something else comes onto the market.

Cameron Kusher, 7:43

Perth was the extreme case: total listings were down 19.7% on a year earlier and 46.1% below the August average across 2018 to 2022, with investor lending in the state up 96% by value. Veronica Morgan noted that an investor driven market always gives her pause, and Kusher agreed the run needs context, since Perth prices went nowhere for 10 or 15 years.

Updated: Western Australia's mean dwelling price was $1,123,700 in the June quarter of 2026, third highest of the states, while Victoria's total dwelling value fell over the quarter (ABS Total Value of Dwellings, released 8 September 2026). Nationally, investor loan commitments were $37.1 billion that quarter, up 8.1% on a year earlier (ABS Lending Indicators, 14 August 2026).

We know we can sell our property, but there's nothing else to buy. So where am I going to move to? And it kind of becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Cameron Kusher, 15:44

How Often Do Australian Homes Change Hands?

Asked about the drop in turnover, Kusher said there are two ways to measure it. The hold period, the gap between the last two sale dates, is about 12 or 13 years, lower for units and higher for houses. The other compares total dwellings to annual sales, giving about 5% of stock turning over each year.

It's going to take about 20 years for everything to come onto the market. You're going to get about 5% of stock being advertised for sale in any given year.

Cameron Kusher, 21:45

That 5% has been stable for about 15 years, though the averages hide a split: new estates and fringe growth areas turn over much faster, while established blue chip areas are held far longer. Morgan cautioned against reading capital growth off estate data: a developer lifting the next release price is not what an owner achieves on resale.

Which Property Types Are in Short Supply?

Inquiries per listing, how REA gauges demand, were roughly flat across the capitals and slightly up in regional markets. More interesting to Kusher was matching inquiry against listings by property type.

Scenario Matrix: Where Listings and Inquiry Do Not Match Nationally
Stock typeBedroomsBalance of listings against inquiry
Houses2Relative oversupply
Houses3Relative undersupply
Houses4Relative oversupply
Units1 and 2Relative undersupply
Units3Relative oversupply, new and existing

As described at 10:32 to 11:53. National figures; Sydney is the outlier, with three bedroom stock relatively undersupplied.

Kusher read the three bedroom house shortage as price sensitivity: buyers probably want four bedrooms but cannot reach it, while working from home and adult children staying put prop up demand for space. On the unit side, investors returning while little new one and two bedroom stock is delivered has pushed people to secondhand apartments. Buyers under budget pressure are not disappearing, he said, they are loosening their search parameters and looking further out. New South Wales first home buyers feel the same pinch upfront, and can weigh an annual land tax against a lump sum stamp duty bill.

Where Are Rents Rising Fastest?

The same pattern shows up in rentals: the strongest rental inquiry and price growth was in Sydney's south west and Blue Mountains rather than the inner west or east, in Melbourne's south east and outer east, and in Ipswich and Logan. Kusher put the median house rent in Sydney's eastern suburbs at about $1,500 a week, and said sign ups to flatmates.com.au, owned by REA, had surged over 18 months.

Rental growth was slowing everywhere, and Kusher expected that to continue as tenants run out of capacity to absorb 10% or 15% rises. Former rentals have accounted for about 35% of new listings right through the pandemic, and that had not eased in Sydney or Melbourne. The pipeline has changed shape too: a 400 apartment building in the 2017 and 2018 cycle might have added 250 to 300 rentals, whereas a 120 apartment project today might add five or six.

Kusher also flagged better ways to read high intent buyers: inquiry is not the best indicator, since people often write in just to ask a price, while time on site, photo views and repeat visits tell REA more.

Buying Where the Stock Is Thin?

This episode shows how differently a low stock market behaves from a high stock one, and how much that changes what a buyer can afford to wait for. If you are weighing a purchase across two or three of these capitals, the structure of an investment property loan is worth settling before you start bidding.

Investment Property Mortgage Broker

Sources referenced: The Elephant in the Room, episode 354, "Cameron Kusher Lifts the Lid on Australia's Property Market Trends", released 2024-10-13. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Cameron Kusher, Executive Director of Economic Research at REA Group. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 10 September 2026.