Posted
14 November 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
March 6, 2026
Episode
291
 ·
46
 min
The show

Australian Property Podcast

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with the investment experts at Rask. It’s all about buying, managing and investing in Australian property.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Guest

Are buyers finding opportunities in this two speed market?

The market is splitting in two. Buyers who stay selective will do better.

Transcript
Owen Rask

This podcast is proudly brought to you by Perla, the official brokerage platform of Rask. With Perla, you can effortlessly automate your money, whether you're investing in ETFs or shares from Australia or the US stock market, whether you're a grandparent or setting up a kid's account or your own account.

You can do all of that with full automation on Perla.com. If you want to learn more, head to Perla.com slash Rask. And of course, before you invest in anything, be sure to read the legal documents like the PDS and FSG.

This episode is brought to you by Stripe, helping your business be ready for whatever comes next. And the next shift in how people buy is already happening. Agentic Commerce lets customers discover and purchase directly inside an AI conversation. No checkout page, no friction.

The businesses positioning themselves now are the ones who will lead this channel. Whatever comes next for your business, power it with Stripe. Learn more at stripe.com. This is a podcast by The Rask Group. It's for educational purposes only.

So please do not make a financial, legal, investment or taxation decision based on solely what you hear in this show.

Welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. We're on a mission to be Australia's most trusted property podcast. I'm Owen Rask, founder of The Rask Group.

Pete Wargent

I'm Pete Wadgent, author and buyer's agent. I'm Amy Linardi and I am a buyer's agent.

Chris Bates

I'm Chris Bates, ex-financial planner and mortgage broker. Together, we'll take you through every step of your property journey.

Pete Wargent

From first home buyer to decades of property investing.

Chris Bates

If you consistently target the investors and make it anti-investor, you get the scenario we're in in 2026, where we've got vacancy rates at 2% and rents have jumped 40%. This isn't a good world because it hits the most vulnerable.

Pete Wargent

G'day, welcome to the Australian Property Podcast. I'm Pete Morgent from Alan Morgent Property Buyers. I'm here with Chris Bates from the Alco Group Mortgage Specialist. G'day Chris, how's your week been?

Chris Bates

I've been well, Pete. I'm actually a bit concussed. I was wrestling pretty full-on, wrestling with my two kids this morning, and I got a full-on headbutt from my boy. Yeah, it was a big knock. My daughter turned six this weekend, and yeah, things have been good here, Pete, besides the headbutt.

What have you been up to?

Pete Wargent

Yeah, I've been pretty busy. My daughter did a little promo piece for Cricket Australia yesterday, so yeah, I had half a day away from work doing that, but obviously the kids...

Chris Bates

Very excited to do some extracurricular activities. I've been busy.

Pete Wargent

We've done a couple of commercial purchases this week. They can take a bit longer than residential with all the due diligence that goes with it. I think what we've kind of observed is it's really tough at the lower price points. There's loads of competition, not much new supply being built.

But if you go further up the price points, you can actually negotiate better deals sometimes and get better yields even. Yeah, I think it's an interesting space, but it's hard if you don't have much of a budget.

That certainly seems to be the way we found it, unless you're going to try and solve a problem of some type, like a long-term vacancy or an issue that really needs fixing, in which case then maybe you can manufacture some yield.

I think just more generally, I've been around Brisbane a little bit, Sunshine Coast, It just generally seems quieter. I mean, obviously the kids are back at school, there's less tourism.

I think a lot of people tend to spend up big over December and January, but a few people I've spoken to around the traps in services, business and healthcare, so it's just got really quiet. Now, obviously when the ABS tries to measure all this stuff,

It generally tries to capture that seasonality, but it just feels a lot quieter, certainly in southeast Queensland. I think, obviously, in international news, there's been a massive Middle East flare-up, and we don't know whether that will be over quickly or not.

Obviously, in the short term, oil prices are going to jump and gas prices.

Chris Bates

We've already seen the fuel prices go from the $150s to very quickly over $2.

Pete Wargent

A bit of price gouging going on, maybe. So obviously, in terms of what that means for real estate, there's some inflation risks there.

I think if you listen to the rhetoric from the RBA, they've got a general preference to wait for quarterly data, in which case the May meeting is basically a locked-in rate hike. But who knows? International issues may force their hand sooner. I think March's price is about a 30% chance now.

And even potentially another hike later in the year, in which case, We're getting back to where the peak of the interest rate cycle where we were previously, 4.35% cash rate target. So I think there's other stuff going on, you know, travel disruption, airfares could go up.

But I guess on the flip side of the ledger, that uncertainty maybe just caused demand in Australia a bit too. Are you seeing any of that in New South Wales?

Chris Bates

Look, I think obviously stuff in Middle East, we're recording this Wednesday morning just for our listeners. A lot could happen between Wednesday and Sunday, good and bad.

And I think, yeah, it's pretty, I mean, it's pretty worrying, but I mean, I think the, obviously we've had lots of different issues over the last 10, 15, 20 years and, you know, how it relates to property in Australia. Yeah.

isn't sort of just uh you know obvious right and even inflation you know like you might think that energy prices go up but then do consumers confidence drop and do we start to spend less and you know and so there's always a um a lot going on here i do think it's something to be sort of i mean how does australia appeal now on a global standard i mean you wouldn't i mean be pretty scary if you're in dubai right now for example and um

Does it change our migration longer term? Do we seem as more of a safe haven? Do Aussies move back? So I think issues like this have all these sort of second and third order sort of consequences. I think

I mean, on another story I've been tracking this week is obviously the AI's been a lot in discussion, you know, big layoffs, SwasTech, you know, Block. I think others have been laying off a lot of stuff.

You know, there's a big business summit AFR and everyone's talking up AI and, you know, there's a lot of fear obviously with, you know, OpenClaw, which is sort of a new sort of AI system. I've been looking at that a bit again this week. Yeah.

And just even using the tools, just some of the advancements I feel like it's made in recent, particularly on, say, Claude in the legal space, but even just allowing us as a business to build workflows and dashboards and stuff like that, which were very expensive and impossible to build before.

So I don't know. I think that's a story that we're just going to have to keep watching all the way through this year. you know, I do feel like it's spiked again in terms of the worry.

If you look at the share prices of people like Atlassian and lots of other tech businesses to show that that SaaS model is really under pressure. And a lot of businesses in the tech industry are sort of on that model. That was their sort of business model.

So, I mean, there's definitely been some issues with credit over in the US. I think in the UK, there's been some issues with, you know, a mortgage fund going under, etc. So, You know, there's definitely also a little bit of financial stress going around the world. And I mean, cortality, right?

The monthly came out sort of for February. I think Perth was up 2.3% in February. And Brisbane and Adelaide were all sort of booming as well. So, you know, over 1% in the month. So it's really strong growth around the country.

And we see definitely, you know, strong applications for the last four weeks. In February, it was kind of, you know, not far off what we were probably seeing in August, September last year. We definitely saw a big drop in October, November, December.

But, you know, February in particular was quite a strong month for us in applications. I reckon broader lending.

Pete Wargent

Yeah. Well, you made some really good points there. Yes. Because all of the. International headlines are focused on Middle East and so on. But actually, there was market wobbles going on well before that. There was credit card delinquencies and defaults in the US. Private credit was a worry.

Then the mortgage MFS collapse in the UK and people worried about the contagion potentially. And also all the job cuts that are either being caused by AI or AI being used as an excuse for contagion. job cuts, whichever way that directionality runs.

So there's a bit of sort of fear that we're at this sort of peak of a stock market cycle anyway, even before the Iran stuff kicked off. And yeah, I think back in the housing market, yeah, I had a read of the cotality report. Obviously, the mid-sized capitals, Adelaide, Brisbane, Perth, still

sort of surging along. I think in Sydney and Melbourne, prices were actually flat over the past three months.

But then when you dig into the stats a bit closer, the most affordable houses and the most affordable parts of the market are performing relatively well, but not so much at the top end of the market, which kind of makes sense, I suppose, if you think about the 5%

deposit scheme for first home buyers. There's a lot of activity at those sort of lower price levels and probably some investors there too. So I think a bit of granularity.

Sydney and Melbourne maybe not done anything over three months, but it probably doesn't feel like that if you're playing in the bottom end of the market.

Chris Bates

Yeah. I mean, we do a lot of first-time buyers, absolutely love helping them. And a lot have obviously entered over the last, because of the 5% deposit scheme, but it's not all roses for them, to be honest.

So Jack and my team really helps a lot of them sort of get set up, help them figure out what the right lending option is, help them understand buffers and how to protect themselves and help them think longer term. And then I sort of jump in and

So to help them think through the decision and then who, you know, if they're going it alone or whether they're going to go use a buyer's agent, like, you know, what's a, what's a good property for them to sort of head down towards, not an actual location, but it's really hard.

You just chat to them and they're all really struggling because Most of the stuff on the market that's sitting there is just really average. It's high density apartments. And a lot of investors are bailing out of assets that have really underperformed for them. And they've got building issues.

And they have no confidence in wanting to hold these properties. And they're like, I'll offload this because I don't think it's a good asset. But first-time buyers are basically buying all the poor assets from the investors. And there's occasionally a good property comes on where...

You know, someone's looking to upgrade from that into a house perhaps, or someone's died or divorced, or someone's just retiring and they just want to sell down their portfolio. Like, absolutely, they come on, but they get to the open home and every other person's been looking at it.

It's like a seagull to a chip effect. And everyone's like... And then the price guide, you can actually see this... you see the price go jump and jump and jump because the agent's getting offers at the first open. And so I think there's the two-speed market.

There's obviously the higher end, the housing market, which is very low listings. And then the bottom end is beating to its own drum. And investors and first-time buyers are really pushing it up. But I don't think it's all good results.

I do think there's people who are having to buy poor assets just because of FOMO right now.

Pete Wargent

Yeah, we've certainly seen that on the Sunshine Coast. I get first-time buyers with a budget of, let's say, $750 to $850 and they want to buy a house. And they do come up occasionally, but two problems. One is they usually need a lot of work.

And the other thing is when you get an affordable or more affordable house, there's so many people at the open home. Sometimes these headline figures don't show the granularity of what's going on on the ground.

So I think there's a few other news stories during the rounds this week, but let's rip into our two sort of major segments. So if you're not familiar, Chris and I just go through the big property news stories each week.

And if you've got time, stick around at the end because we do your listener Q&A and some of the questions are pretty interesting this week. So let's start with this first story, Chris. It's been a sort of rumbling theme for the past few weeks.

Capital gains tax and potentially negative gearing reforms up for discussion. So I think you often see in the lead up to a budget, some ideas get floated, some of them get shot down and others seem to gain some traction. It sort of popped up in the news this week.

The Labour Party is not ruling out negative gearing reform. Some of the suggested moves, maybe a cap on the number of properties that people can negatively gear. I always, these sort of arbitrary rules that I don't like. I mean, it's been a while since I did my

tax exams but that doesn't make sense to me because you could get one person negatively gearing a 20 million dollar house and somebody else might have two negatively geared properties worth a couple hundred thousand and the number of properties doesn't really always necessarily reflect the substance of the situation so

And again, this is where you get the sort of two speed rules that favour the more affluent. So, yeah, anyway, that's one suggested option. Also, the capital gains tax hike has been discussed a little bit. I saw a friend, Ben Kingsley, a picker, did a YouTube video on this this week.

He talked about the whole capital gains tax issue. from start to finish. And yes, in some certain circumstances, we do have issues with investors crowding out first-time buyers and fighting over the same properties. And ideally, that's not really what you want from a functioning market.

You want investors to add to the housing stock, which they do. I guess if you think about new builds, probably... Usually over half of those are sold to investors, particularly in the apartment space.

But, you know, we do have periods in the cycle where you get investors sort of knocking first-time buyers out of the market.

I suppose the bigger picture question for people who are participants in the market, Chris, is potentially we're going to get some changes come in the budget in the middle of this year. I assume if you saw changes to capital gains tax and negative gearing, that would be grandfathered.

The modeling usually seems to suggest not that much of an impact on prices and rent. But do you think that's how things would actually play out in the real world?

Chris Bates

Look, I do. I think particularly because they'll make changes, they'll highly likely grandfather, you know, people who have purchased in the past. And so you won't see this mass exodus of, you know, investors out of the market. But I do think you will, you know, it's basically a negative, right?

You know, disincentivized sort of investors to enter because they know they're going to pay more taxes. But I think it's going to be, if they're going to reform it, reform it to get the...

You know, the result you actually want, you know, there's a, you know, how I've said this so many times, Charlie Munger, you know, change the incentive, change the behavior. So you have to dramatically change the incentive. And, you know, you did a blog, Peter, around building approvals, right?

And we know this, we've spoken about hundreds of times that, you know, we cannot get projects out of the ground at the affordable level just because developers can't. make a profit.

And if you look at all the submissions, so this is all happening, you know, the Senate sort of meetings around it, there's been 80 odd submissions. And, you know, I think it's on the 19th of March, in a couple of weeks, they're going to sort of announce

you know, what that inquiry sort of suggests. And then in the May, they'll sort of announce what they're going to do about it probably. So, you know, in the next couple of weeks, we'll have a lot more clarity what the report sort of...

But if you look at all the different parties, those 80 submissions, they're all obviously talking about their own, you know, their own groups, right? You know, some people saying no change. Some are saying just make it 33%, you know, not a 50%. You know, some make it towards new housing. You know, some...

say, you know, the government should be trying to reduce taxes on new builds, you know, a couple hundred grand of taxes basically is in the cost of new builds.

So I think if they're going to make a change, like, you know, and it's not what I would do, would want for, you know, those people, investors, to be honest, because I don't think they'd be buying good assets, but

you should just make it almost CGT free if you buy a new apartment or new property, because that basically really encourages investors to look past buying established property because they go, well, I have to pay capital gains tax on that.

And maybe you up the capital gains tax for buying established and you basically remove it on buying new property. that would absolutely encourage investors to try to build new apartments.

Now, that wouldn't be great for those investors often because they'd be buying poor assets that aren't scarce, that often are going to be built, but they are going to funnel money that way. It's the same thing as negative gearing.

If you really wanted to encourage people to buy new housing, well, then you would just make it on that and remove it on established property. But

know i think that the issue of just sort of changing it um from 50 to 33 or anything like that it just brings more uncertainty to a market that is already really scared you know they're scared about higher interest rates they're scared about what's happening in the middle east right now this is just more uncertainty will just mean a lot of people will sit on their hands um and wait for certainty and i just think it's not what the market needs right now is more changes it's like when they always tinker with superannuation

They just create more uncertainty with people wanting to use superannuation long term, which defeats the purpose. So, yeah, I do think it's going to be a couple of weeks away till we hear what people say. But, you know, the government just always missed the low hanging fruit.

You know, a simple solution right now for a rental crisis. And we are in that. Rents are up sort of 30, 40, 50 percent depending on the location. We've got vacancy rates, you know, 1 percent around the country.

It's a rental crisis, and that's what's also causing a housing crisis because everyone's like, I don't want to rent anymore. Renting's really hard. I'll just buy. And I chat to first-home buyers. Often that is one of the reasons they want to buy is they just don't want to rent.

And there's millions of spare bedrooms around the country, but it doesn't make sense to rent your bedroom out. A, you've got to pay tax on the income, and two, it upsets your capital gains tax-free exemption on your home.

And it would make much more sense, I think, just straight away is to really encourage, and maybe even you give a bonus. Everyone who rents out a bedroom in their property actually gets a bonus and doesn't pay any tax on the income and it doesn't affect their capital gains tax.

That would help everyone with mortgages, it would help people in the rental supply. So things like that are just often forgotten about when, and even if you do encourage new housing, that lags three, four, five years at best. It's not going to be immediate.

Yeah, that's my frustration with this change is, yeah, okay, we might want to increase capital gains tax, and that's going to be good for inequality, and I get all that. But really, does the market want more uncertainty right now when investors are really been bailing just as much as they've been entering?

Pete Wargent

I think that's the key word in the development space, isn't it? The uncertainty. I think you mentioned the building approvals. They fell 15% seasonally adjusted in December.

Chris Bates

people were sort of expecting a rebound in January, but they fell another 7%, 14,500, uh, which is the lowest in over a year and a half.

Pete Wargent

I think that there's only one bright spot as far as I could say, which is Perth. And, uh, Yeah, for two years, building approvals have been picking up in Perth, but they're falling in Melbourne for houses, Sydney 649 houses only in January, which is basically zero if you think about demolitions.

And as you've said many times, yes, it's one thing that people might get an approval, but whether they even build it is a different story. units approvals falling in Sydney and Melbourne again.

And yeah, I think if you think about the housing target of 1.2 million homes over five years, well, we're running at about 15,900 approvals a month. That's versus a target of 20,000. So we're just getting further and further behind. And all of that was before the interest rate hike in February. So

Yeah, it's not looking good. And yes, of course, you should never jump at one month of figures. But yeah, it's not just one month now. It's multiple months of poor data. And yeah, as you said, even an approval doesn't necessarily get built.

So yeah, I suppose talking about changing the tax system and the tax code into that environment is messy, potentially.

Owen Rask

I want to tell you a story about how the new Rask platform came to be. In 2025, everyone was still waking up to this idea that AI was going to have an impact on the world. And it wasn't until mid to late 2025 that it really hit me like a ton of bricks.

that time, I thought, what can I do with this new tool, this innovative technology? That set in motion what has now become a totally new Rask platform, which you can find at rask.au. It is 100% free to create an account and start using tools. But what did it actually do?

And what does it do for you? At Rask, we've produced thousands of podcasts. probably 20,000 articles were written on investing and all these different types of things like personal finance, superannuation, you name it. So we really needed a place where we could bring all of that together for the entire community.

That can be found at rask.au. Whether you're a retiree, a business builder, or a student of finance, you should go and check it out. But once we built the platform, we realized that that wasn't enough. So in 2026, we've decided to launch a new community known as the Rask Ultra community.

This is the deepest, most advanced part of what we do as a business and as a community of investors and builders. We want to build a network of people that can come together and share ideas in a new ecosystem that we've built just for you.

You can find out more, like I said, by googling Rask Ultra or by creating a free account at rask.au and see if Ultra is right for you.

Pete Wargent

Let's take a look at our second segment this week. The housing market pulse slowing a bit into 2026. So I saw Louis Christopher of SQM Research said he's going to put out a whole new range of forecasts for this year.

I guess we're only like eight weeks into the year or maybe 10 weeks and already all the forecasts in the bin by the sound of it. So I guess the change has been the increase in the cash rate target and the potential for more to come.

Westpac reported in their Housing Pulse report that, yes, the rate rise surprise has called sentiment in the housing market. If you look at auction clearances in Sydney and Melbourne, the pre-limit clearance rates are kind of 65% or so for Sydney, a bit higher for Melbourne now.

So I think there's more people looking to sell potentially in the big capital cities. So I think, Chris, you said lending volumes are still pretty high. But it seems to be filtering its way out to sort of regional markets in some cases.

First time buyers and a lot of investors being guided by buyers agents and their data driven analysis, if that's the right word, into some sort of cheap parts of the market. But if you look at Sydney and Melbourne anyway, the sentiment seems to have cooled a little bit.

Chris Bates

Yeah, it's funny. Louis Christopher does his boom and bust report every year, and we interviewed him in December, and I was going through the four scenarios. It's a good report, by the way. There's a lot of great data in there. There's always a great read every year.

um what i love about what he does is he doesn't just say it's going to perform at x percentage this year he does a full analysis gives you multiple scenarios because every year is unpredictable uh and he always rates himself after the year whether he got it right or wrong which not many economists do they they always uh forget to sort of mark their own homework but um

Yeah, it's funny. And he had like four scenarios. And basically there was a scenario which was rates are going to go up, rates are going to go up quite a few times in 2026. And that just was not a scenario he was considering when he wrote the report in mid 2025.

And we sort of joked and we sort of said, well, what about this scenario? He goes, yeah, I think I'm going to have to add another scenario on after he released the report. And

But I think that, you know, even though I'd be interested to see what he says when he does sort of release it, but, you know, it doesn't mean the rates are going up and prices are going to fall.

I mean, I do think you'll find that a lot of people in the housing market will just sit on their hands. It's been the same story since 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025.

you know, 2026, the housing market in our capital cities will just, everyone, it's just frozen up.

And, you know, obviously there's some markets a little bit more fluid than others, but often if you look at all those cities, they're at sort of low, all time lows in terms of how many people are turning over.

Apartments, townhouses, you know, villas, starter homes, where investors are often playing, regional locations, they're absolutely still turning over. And I do think though that they're also the ones that are going up in value. And I do think a lot more equity is getting built at that part of the market.

And then when confidence does return, that equity is going to get often re-leveraged back into, say, the housing market because people are going to want to buy homes and they're going to outgrow. So I think there's going to be almost this bottom-up. Boom. Often it's the other way around.

Often equity and wealth is built at the top in the housing market and then it's leveraged into the bottom. So the house price goes up and then people buy investments. But I think this is kind of the opposite.

I think this is often driven by a lot of first home buyers and investors rather than through their house going up.

Pete Wargent

Yeah, I think you're right. I mean, we're still really busy in Brisbane and I've spoken to some buyers agents in Melbourne who say there's a lot of competition, particularly at the lower end of the market.

But yeah, I think if you zoom out a little bit, yeah, a couple more rate hikes this year could certainly help. sort of calmed that sort of pulse in the market a little bit. The RBA released its financial aggregates this week.

And yeah, you can already see lending volumes are really high, but it's not accelerating in the same way that it was. I think that's the change. So yeah, I think buyers might need to be a little bit more judgmental about what they buy.

uh you know try and buy the right price of the right property instead of sort of piling in and desperation which is what we've seen at various points in recent years people just buying through sheer desperation and yeah maybe a few more listings do come on as the year goes on but at the moment it's still pretty tight depending on where you're looking

Chris Bates

Chris, we've got a couple of listener questions to go through this week. There's a couple of interesting ones, actually.

Pete Wargent

So I thought I'd leave a bit of time to cover these. So first question is from Henry George. So you could probably guess the fever of the question from the godfather of land value taxation. Hi, guys. I'm a regular listener. Enjoy the podcast.

In a recent episode on CGT reform, Chris brought up investors and landlords providing an important service to society and keeping rent costs low. However, as Pete touched on, any property purchased by an investor is likely to be removing a property from the pool available to first-time buyers, thus potentially creating additional renters.

This is an age-old debate on social media, I would add there. So can you explain how an investor using the current tax incentives, which is something we've already discussed today, to purchase an established property is increasing the overall housing supply and benefiting society.

PS, I saw on your website you have an interest in language. What languages do you speak other than English? I'll do the easy part first. I can speak German and French and strangely Tetan because I used to live in East Tabor for a few years.

I'm currently learning Tirolingo Spanish and it's incredibly slow. So I thought if I just stick with it, eventually it might start to...

sink in but it's very slow at the moment so yeah I mean this is so some years ago I was involved in writing a report on negative gearing reform and at the sort of headline level it seems simple a lot of the debate at the time is whether negative gearing should be allowed on new builds and not in the established market

I think the further I got into that report, the further down the rabbit hole you go, the messier these things get. So I think two things can be true at the same time. One is that most investors buy established properties.

The second thing is that most new builds, or at least about half of them, are probably built by investors, bought by investors, depending on the stage of the cycle. So when you see a high-rise apartment boom, it's very often the investors who are buying those. Obviously, some investors do build houses.

I'm currently doing sort of a project myself. But again, most investors, as you said, are in the established market. I think, yeah, there's a few sort of sub points before I come on to my main point.

One is that obviously some investors are actually also first-time buyers, first-time buyers, you know, people who rent best. So when you get into the granularity of it,

Yeah, it's not quite as clear cut sometimes as it appears because often some of the investors are quite young people who are just getting a toehold onto the ladder. I think what we've found when we run the reports on this is that investors tend to amplify the cycle these days.

So the home buyers are fairly consistent through the cycle, but the investors kind of come and go. And when investors come into the market, prices go up and construction suddenly booms. And then when investors exit, construction falls away again.

But yeah, I totally get your point because I've been to auctions and I've seen first-time buyers there with their parents eager to buy. And then somebody comes in as an investor, very cool, calm and collected, buys the property.

And it's a disappointing outcome for everybody, really, because somebody was hoping to get their first home. An investor just comes in and mops up another property. And that's what we don't really want to see. I think if you sort of zoom out and look at the bigger picture,

I would say, look, Australia is going to have a home ownership rate, if I guess, around 65%. We've traditionally had high home ownership rates in a lot of Western countries, particularly the Anglophile countries like New Zealand, UK, Australia, which means about 35% of the properties are going to be owned by investors.

That seems to be the kind of balance we're heading towards. You can push for higher home ownership rates, but that often equates to higher housing prices, seems to be the global trend.

I suppose the question then is, if you're going to have, let's say, a third of the market is owned by investors, who does it? Do you have professional landlords, such as you do in the United Kingdom, where they own hundreds of properties?

Do you have institutional landlords, which is Labour's preferred policy, build to rent? Or do you have mum and dad landlords, which is the current model in Australia, where mum and dad's investors, the first bulk of them own one or two properties. They own a home and a rental or two.

There's arguments in all ways. I totally... I agree with your point that investors just buying up all the established housing in a suburb or a town that doesn't really benefit anybody and it creates a mismatch between what we want and what we need.

But yeah, I suppose in every sort of scenario where you do a reform, there's sometimes sort of second order consequences as well. So Chris, I've covered a lot of different points.

Chris Bates

Yeah, no, it's good. You took some of the points out of my mouth, so that's okay. I can add some more on top. Look, I think there's obviously a view that all our problems are down to investors in the market. I just don't think it's true.

I do think there's been times when investors have had an unfair advantage and have been able to build much bigger portfolios than they should have been able to sort of build. If I reflect back on 2013, 14, you could leverage 10, 12, 14 times your income.

You could get interest only loans for 15 years. You know, a very small income could go a long way and you could buy a lot of properties. And we saw huge portfolios. If you look at the stats, And don't believe all the nonsense on YouTube channels and Instagram and people building ridiculous portfolios.

The ones that have got those big portfolios are most likely making money through selling you a course or selling you buyer's agency services.

And often, just in recent times, they've been using like, you know, kind of getting around the lending rules with trust structures, but you need a lot of cash for that and dodgy account letters and stuff like that. So,

Building big portfolios of residential properties is ridiculously hard now because you can borrow five times your income and prices have gone up a lot. And so someone going and buying 10 investment properties just doesn't really exist in this marketplace. I'm just being frank.

And so the investors in the current marketplace, are they really... you know, dominating the market? No, like because, and where are they buying? Often not in capital cities, they're buying in regional towns. And they, because there's been a massive proliferation of buyer's agents in the market.

So I don't think investing in property, you look at sort of long-term own home ownership rates, It's not like it's gone from 70% owner-occupier to 50% owner-occupier and 50% investor. It's moved at the margins.

And I think what the rental supply really does provide is there's lots of people that don't want to buy and shouldn't buy because they're just chesting out a new city. They've just moved here. They've switched cities for work. They can't afford to buy. They're a single-parent family. They're a retiree. They're a divorcee.

They're moving for work. They're young, they still trying to figure out, get their jobs and careers up. We need a really fluid rental supply, not just because that's what we need in society, but also to attract talent to move here.

We've got a lot of people in universities bringing a lot of money into the world, the country as well. That's my belief around the rental supply. I do think investors always take the hit because it's an easy one to target. They're the problem. I don't think they're the problem.

And we'll just blame them for the reason for all our problems. And this is just because it's an easy target. No one's there to defend the investor.

But what you do is if you consistently sort of target the investors and make it anti-investor, you get the scenario we're in in 2026 where we've got vacancy rates at 2% and rents have jumped 40%.

So this isn't a good world because it targets, it hits the most vulnerable, the people who haven't got property, the people who need to rent that, you know, often, you know, the older generation and the single older generation. And so I think then that's not a good outcome either.

And if you think about Melbourne and Brisbane rents, they didn't do much for 15 years because there was a building boom. And that's kind of your point here. A lot of those investors went and bought all those new apartments. That was really good for the rental market.

And it was good for those cities because it created a lot of rental stock. The issue is that all those investors got really poor investment returns for 10, 15 years.

And so you've got to argue, like, did they just do a job for society or did they do a job, you know, get an outcome for themselves and their personal situation? And my worry is, is that investors aren't going to go back there.

You can see that investors have all sort of been aware of building issues and the poor performance of apartments. The next generation of investors are a little bit more savvy. They're not just going in blindly and going to seminars and signing up to off the plan. But you're right.

But if you just completely remove investors out of the market, you're just going to create a rental crisis. And the bigger the rental crisis is, the more people want to buy. And it's just going to kick the can down the road and push prices even higher for owner-occupier

Because people are going to, hey, I cannot, there's no way I can rent. There's no options. I just have to buy. And you're just going to increase owner-occupier demand. So I think it's extremely complex.

But if you really want to try to create more housing stock, you need to give investors lots of wins for buying your property. So I reckon CGT free. I reckon no stamp duty. I reckon, you know, you might do a low land tax option. You might have to give them a grant.

You have to really just give them all these real benefits, bring back the old depreciation rules to allow these investors to want to buy new again, because I think a lot of investors just don't want to do it. There are very few investors at the margin who buy established houses and build townhouses.

You know, it's actually, you know, really hard to get finance for that.

A lot of people haven't got the risk appetite for it, but that would also make a lot of sense is if you encouraged the mom and dad or the dad and dad or mom and mom sort of, you know, investor to kind of buy old houses and build three level townhouses.

And you made that really attractive for them, you know, changes to GST, changes to CGT for them. I think you could also activate a lot of money going into sort of smaller builds. But that's not really attractive for a lot of investors.

And so they only have an option of buy established or buy new and they don't want new. So they're just going to go and buy established. So that would be my take, Pete.

Pete Wargent

I think history shows if you offer grants to people, they generally do take them up.

Chris Bates

So that's probably probably be the most effective way to stimulate construction.

Pete Wargent

would be to offer Grimes for new builds.

I think the problem with the two-tier negative gearing approach of negative gearing on new builds is you might get a sugar hit to the market for a year or two, but I think the problem would be because you're creating a two-tier market, who are they going to sell to?

Well, yeah. And then, you know, but as you said, we've had plenty of clients come to us over the past dozen years and they bought a couple of new apartments at some seminar or other and they can't sell them. Or at least they can't sell them without wrecking their lives financially. So there's...

There's some issues around funneling investors into high-rise apartments, particularly if you've got a two-tier system.

Interesting, you'd be interested to know, Henry George, I guess, on the LVT point, is that one of the reasons I've just observed, apart from the lending differences, is in the UK, where I'm from, is professional landlords can build large portfolios, largely because of the absence of land tax, whereas in Australia...

You can build up a few properties, but as Chris said, sooner or later, you're not going to get lending. And moreover, you'll start to pick up so much land tax that it just makes the whole process unfeasible anyway. So very few people build large resi portfolios in Australia for that reason.

So second question from Mr. Monopoly, not an unrelated question. I guess if I could turn the camera around, you'd see that I've got the AFL Monopoly board mid-game over here. The kids seem to enjoy playing a bit of Monopoly.

So my brother and I have inherited six commercial properties regionally located. Their compound growth rate varies between 2%. and 8.5% after tax without any unexpected expenses. Three of the six are at about 5%.

What factors would you consider in relation to whether to keep or sell them? We're thinking an index fund would be easier to manage potentially with better returns. So yeah, there's a few things. One is, yes, the tax implications.

Obviously, if you sell investment properties in the commercial space, you're going to have some capital gains tax to pay. So as an accountant, I sort of have an aversion to selling assets if they're performing okay, just because you're going to give rise to a large tax bill.

And the second thing is, yes, the time and mental energy involved in managing property. It might be less in a commercial property, versus REZI potentially, but not always. So the sort of index fund or ETF approach is certainly much more hands-off.

You might find the ups and downs or the gyrations of the market might be a bit more mentally taxing. So there is that factor. Yeah, I mean, if you're not sure, maybe a mixture is good for diversification. So maybe keep your best assets.

And if you've got some less good performers, which it sounds like you do, potentially, you could offload those. And then you've got a bit more of a balance across your portfolio, obviously, without knowing the specific circumstances. Chris, any thoughts when you get that kind of scenario?

Chris Bates

Uh, always the family sort of, I sort of think about that first, you know, what's the relationship with your brother and, you know, what's your personal situation, you know, what's their situation, you know, what would you do with the money, you know, like, well, how would that, what would you then change?

Like if you then had that money individually, how would then change your personal plan? Is there better options there, whether it's, you know, upgrading your home or whether it's paying off your mortgage and then allowing you to borrow, like, There's just a bit of life planning that has changed for you.

And I personally would put everything on hold unless there's any... You might get a commercial specialist just to say, look, everything's fine. If you come back in 12 months' time, you've still got long leases, you've still got good assets. There's no rush here. And I think after a sort of...

this type of situation, I do think time allows you to think clearly, um, and you can rather sort of rush and regret it. And so I would firstly just say, is there any properties that are a bit of an issue that you need to sort of potentially take immediate action on?

Um, you know, is there any maintenance issues or tenant issues or, or something going to change? And if not, then maybe just think about how, what would you do if you did sell one, two, three or five or six, you know, and, um,

And then potentially try to think, well, and also how is it actually structured here as well? Like you've inherited them. Is it, you know, what structure is it in? You know, how does that affect your tax?

I think that would be a, you know, like how much growth is on some, you know, which ones are, you know, the ones you don't want to sell with CGT. So there's a bit going on here. And it's not just one property, but obviously.

Often in these situations, I think you need to slow down. And just because you own something doesn't mean you should continue to hold it. I think even you asking this question, what you do after that, that's down the line.

Because like, you know, like getting out of it and selling it, you know, trying to compare what you've got versus, you know, what you do with it. There's lots of options. Index funds is one option, you know.

You know, putting into your personal wealth, you know, releasing equity, buying resi or buying more commercial assets. That's like second, third level down the line.

The first thing is just having some really deep chats with your brother and life planning first, which is what a great financial advisor would do, I think, is they would just really get clear on your goals. And does that change your work prospects? Does it change family? Does it change?

There's lots of things that inheriting wealth does. And I don't think just trying to get an investment returns, often sometimes ignoring how that could benefit you in other ways as well as a family.

Pete Wargent

That's sound advice. Yeah, I think it's, as you said, it's always an extra dimension to consider when there's family or friends involved. So, yeah, good stuff. Thanks, Chris. So we've got national accounts due out this week at the time of recording.

So we'll have a bit more info on what's happening in the economy for you next week. But do send in your questions. Always keen to cover your listener Q&A, the segments at the end. So, Chris, any plans for this weekend?

Chris Bates

Daughter's birthday on Sunday, and I am having a birthday party on Saturday, so 25 kids doing gymnastics, and yeah, we'll see how that goes. What about yourself?

Pete Wargent

I'm actually going to stay in Brisbane for a few days. There's so many events on over the weekend and I've got to catch up with the team as well. So it's like a mini away break from us down from Sunny Coast.

So obviously football season is back and we're going to try and get the kids to a couple of the museums. We've got a couple of memberships at Queensland Museum and Spark Lab.

Chris Bates

So they always enjoy their time there.

Pete Wargent

So hopefully a nice few days down in Brisbane and then back to the grindstone next week in Sunshine Coast. So Thanks for tuning in everyone this week. Send any questions and look forward to chatting to you next time around.

Chris Bates

See you next week, Pete.

Thanks for tuning into the Australian Property Podcast. If you love the show, why not subscribe or leave us a review on Apple or Spotify.

Pete Wargent

And if you want to work with me, Amy, Pete or Chris, you'll find links in your podcast player to get in contact with us.

Owen Rask

Thank you for listening to this episode of the Australian Property Podcast. We're huge advocates of getting the right advice at the right time from the right people. That's why it's important to understand that this podcast episode contained general financial information only.

It is not designed to be specific or personalized to your financial, tax or legal situation. With property, the check sizes are pretty big. So it's important you get advice from a licensed and trusted professional before acting on the information you hear in RAS podcasts. Thanks again for listening.

I regret to inform you that chances are a lot of you will need financial advice. Since we started the Rask Advice business, I've noticed quite a few trends, but one of them is the importance of having confidence in what you're actually saving towards or investing towards.

A lot of people in the Rask community are very capable of managing their own money.

But when it comes to critical points in their life, like retirement, selling a business, scaling a business, getting married, buying your first home, so on and so forth, getting expert advice will actually save you from a bunch of mistakes and give you the confidence to know what it is you're doing and why you're doing it.

If you want to get matched with one of the trusted financial partners that we have, you can just head to rass.au slash financial planning, or you can get in contact with us on any of the RASC websites.

Not only does Rask itself provide financial advice, but we also have trusted partners if we're not the right fit for you. So we can help guide you in the right direction. And that in turn supports us to create more free financial education content like podcasts, courses, and so much more.

Click any timestamp to jump.