Posted
4 November 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
October 17, 2020
Episode
146
 ·
68
 min
The show

The Elephant in the Room

Chris Bates is a co-host on this podcast with Veronica Morgan. It's a deep dive into what really goes on in the world of real estate.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Veronica Morgan
Veronica Morgan
Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor

Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.

Guest
Kym Nitschke
Kym Nitschke
Chartered accountant, Nitschke Nancarrow Accountants

Kym Nitschke the ‘jack of all trade’ regales the team on the exciting trials and tribulations of an accountant on the quest to discover the best ways to structure property portfolios.

Kym Nitschke on Structure, Yield and Getting the Order Wrong

Adelaide accountant Kym Nitschke joins Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates to trace how chasing rent on his first two units cost him five years. The conversation runs from family trusts and land tax thresholds to his own loan, which he calls his Dumbo.

Transcript
Veronica Morgan

I heard a joke the other day that made me laugh. What did the accountant's wife say when she couldn't fall asleep? Darling, tell me about your work.

Why am I the only one laughing? Okay, and yet we find accountants very interesting when we want to know how to save tax or how to best structure our investments to protect our nest egg from the risks of business going bad or being sued.

Kym Nitschke

I think the number one tax planning strategy, and you touched on it before, Chrissie, is You know, make money on your house because it's tax free. The government hasn't taxed that yet.

The other opportunity that I see that people overlook is if you're in small business, there's such a golden opportunity to own your own office in a business.

Welcome to The Elephant in the Room. This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about. I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent, co-host of Foxtel's Location Location Location Australia and author of Auction Ready.

Chris Bates

And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker. Before we get started, I need to let you know that nothing we say on here can be taken as personal advice. We always recommend you engage the services of a professional.

Don't forget that you can access the transcript for this episode on the website as well as download our free full forecast report. Which experts can you trust to get it right? The elephant in the room dot com dot au.

Veronica Morgan

You know, it takes a village to buy a property. We need mortgage advice, legal advice, property advice, tax advice, and financial advice if you really want to get it right. It's an impossible task to find all of this in one advisor.

The best path is to find an expert in each field who has a respect and understanding of the other disciplines. Accountants are a good example. They have to know about aspects of the law and financial planning in order to excel in their own field.

But what about their role in helping property owners and investors? Today we're asking accountant Kim Nitschke to tell us about his work and we think you'll find it more interesting than the accountant's wife. Kim runs Nitschke Nankaro Accountants, a firm with over 1200 individual and business clients.

As a fellow chartered accountant qualified in financial services and mortgage broking, Kim offers holistic financial advice. He's also a property investor and a licensed builder.

Now, that's certainly a unique skill set and we're keen for some insights today on what property owners and investors should be thinking about as we seek to build wealth. Thank you for joining us today, Kim.

Chris Bates

pleasure thanks for inviting on the show thank you kim um coming from the accounting side of uh property investing how do you think that you look at things a little bit differently than say all the other specialties in terms of your mindset when you think about property investing uh well um i guess you know you think that me being an accountant i've picked down and i'd spreadsheet up every property that i buy but

Kym Nitschke

I guess my number one focus when I'm looking at properties for myself and for my clients is capital growth. I've really discounted the whole rental side of things.

And also with that, when I'm looking at properties, I'm also looking at what structure should people buy them in. You know, when they come to me and they say, oh, what structure? Should I buy this property in? Should I buy it in a trust or my own name or my wife's name?

The next question I'll go back to them with is also, well, how am I going to hang on to it? What do the returns look like? What do you actually want to do with it?

So when I do it, I try to, and then I look at loans and all sorts of options and try to roll everything into one pretty much as if I was doing it for myself.

Chris Bates

So, I mean, the structure is an interesting point. I mean, what do you think? Do you think many property investors or many property people do a lot of thinking before they put it into different structures or they just go and sign the contract and hope that that's the best option?

Kym Nitschke

I think sadly everyone rushes in and, you know, they're so desperate to get the property and they don't even think about structures and then they sort of come to people like myself when it's too late.

Veronica Morgan

That's a really good point, actually, that quite often, and I've heard a number of accountants say that, that clients do go to them instead of asking them for advice at the early stages when they could actually make a real difference.

They sort of come after the event and particularly with structuring, for instance, you already signed a contract and that's already in a certain entity. I'm curious too, though. You've said you disregard yield. You know, you've sort of decided that that's not part of it.

And it's unusual to hear a numbers person say that because usually, you know, there's a lot of fixation on the yield. And I'm curious to the journey that led you to that point.

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, I guess it goes back to my first property. I used to work at PricewaterhouseCoopers and I had a brilliant manager and we'd sit down and we'd brainstorm and he would sort of –

and then renting them out. And that was sort of like his side hustle. So I blindly followed him down that track and I raced out and bought two units in a little suburb outside of Adelaide in a town called Little Hampton. And I didn't really get all the fundamentals right.

I remember I paid $60,000 for each unit. So it was two out of a group of three, and I was getting $120 a week rent. And I thought it was Christmas. It was positive cash flow. Everything was fantastic. But I didn't get all the fundamentals right.

And what was actually happening was down the road at Mount Barker, they were releasing hundreds and hundreds of blocks of land.

So the problem was that my tenants shortly after I bought the property moved out and then instead of paying me $120 a week, they could get a brand new place on a big block of land for $170 a week.

So my model sort of fell down and what I found myself doing, um, was, uh, we love this story. So I must have been on to like second or third lot of tenants, but I remember going to the Mount Barker Caravan Park one night, knocking on their door.

They'd moved out of my place. They didn't get the new house. These people were a different story to that initial situation that I told you, but still similar. And I begged them to drop the rent, $20 a week and have them move from the caravan park back into my units.

You know, so I think that having that fixation on the rent, you know, I went from 120 to 100. My whole model went out the window and that was the faster that I was on and it took me five years to get out of that.

And in the end, it's funny talking about this now, but I actually ended up leaving PricewaterhouseCoopers and going and working in an underground mine in Cobar.

And I tripled my wage, but that was to sort of dig myself out of this hole that I dug myself with the property sort of journey that I was on. Wow.

Chris Bates

So you had a rent, pretty glaringly obvious some of the fundamentals now, but hindsight is such an easy thing, right? Like you can go back in time, but you had a rent reduction. Did you have a capital reduction on those units as well? Just out of curiosity.

So were there, did they fall in price? I did.

Kym Nitschke

Well, when you say fall, After five years of doing everything I possibly could to get those units to work, the model was broken. It was busted. I had my mum and dad over there helping me with gardening and I'd reduce tenants and let them have dogs. It was just a disaster.

I'd get phone calls from the police in the middle of the night. So I just had to get out of them. And after five years, I got my money back.

Veronica Morgan

Right, so that's a loss. Because that's an opportunity cost.

And you're in sanity, of course. And you had to go and work in a mine to pay for it.

So you had a very, very early lesson then in the perils of chasing yield over growth and also, as you say, the fundamentals. And so how did you then start learning about the fundamentals? I mean, I guess we'll get to, you know, what you do in the professional sense in a moment.

It's just too good a story to not follow at this point.

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, well, it's funny because I went up to Cobar and I was knocking on people's doors trying to get a job.

and um there were three mines in the town and they'd shut down one of them and i was knocking on people's doors trying to get a job and they'd say oh what trade have you got mate and i say well i've got two degrees and they'd sort of turn around and go but half the town out of work and you're coming to me with debris they're useless out here you need a trade mate um anyway so

It was funny. I had this beautiful real estate agent managing the properties for me. She went to the St. Vincent de Paul's and got all this furniture and decked them all out while I was up there and got these people in there.

And eventually I got a job working on a mine as a labourer. And it tripled my salary compared to the accounting job. And I was so nervous and dejected in the interview that I couldn't speak. I was so down and dejected.

And as I was driving up there too, my mum put $300 in my console in my car and said, don't tell dad.

Looking back, they were just such great moments in my journey because you build on that. And that was the real trough that I went through.

But, you know, fast forward six months, I was back on my feet. I paid the debts down. I had tenants in there and we offloaded those properties. I've got, well, I got the money that I paid back five years later, less all the agent's fees and everything.

I was down, but sold that one. I had another property up the road, which was a house, which I split two blocks off on the side. I sort of didn't really kill it on that either because I didn't sort of factor in all the fees and charges with getting extra titles.

And, you know, I had this beautiful house on a big block and when you, You scrunched it all down and took a block off either side. You know, you discount the actual price that you get for the house.

Veronica Morgan

This is fantastic because it's just, you know, we see it all the time and it's just that you've actually done it. And I know you've got a Dumbo for us as well and we haven't even got to your Dumbo yet. So this is personal.

Kym Nitschke

I know. But can I just finish off the story please? Please.

So it was bizarre because I got all my money back and I had $50,000 left over. And my mum and dad had given me $20,000 when I turned 21. I must have been 26. And I was like, what do I do? I'm off this property thing. I just hate it.

It makes me feel sick. You know, I just had that 50 grand. I was just, what do I do? I couldn't think of anything worse than going to property. So I just had a break and caught my breath for six months. And then I read this amazing book called Seven Steps to Wealth.

My sister gave it to me. It's by John Fitzgerald. I don't know whether anyone's mentioned it before.

And that changed my life because it went from chasing rental returns to buying properties on big blocks of land as close as you can to the city, buying properties that developers will knock on your door in 10 years' time and want to bash down and build units on them.

and maximizing all of your rental deductions and depreciation and all of that sort of stuff. But it was just, it was written by a real estate agent who retired in his early twenties or thirties up in Queensland, but he just wrote it in really easy to understand steps.

And then I got back on the property wagon. I was getting engaged, so I needed to find a house. So I was sort of forced back into it. But this time, the second time, my second attempt, I did it the right way. I got all my fundamentals right.

And it just took off from there.

Chris Bates

Wow.

So when you say your fundamentals, right? You know, if you could go back to your first units and you didn't buy those two or you didn't go for that, the big house and then on the great block and then devalue your main asset by cutting up the block.

which we see quite common in oil where people think it's a great idea to put their block and it's like, well, now you've just destroyed your demand, you know. No one's going to want a nice house on a small block. So what would you do now?

If you were going back to the start, would you still go down this sort of strategy which sounds buying land that developers will want or do you just believe in buying good houses, for example, and holding them? What's your sort of strategy?

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, so now I try to get the fundamentals right. So I try to buy...

um when i'm buying a property um uh the worst house in the best street but i sort of have now like um a number of factors that the house has to meet like i think it's you know i used to go to those property seminars in the early 90s where it's basically you go out and you buy a house it's going to go up in value but i don't subscribe to that model anymore i think you've got to be clever and from all of my experiences i came up with my own set of rules and i was like i was never going to break those rules ever again so

I try to buy properties now that I sort of more or less need, like a house or a beach house or an office, and I try to roll in the fact that, well, if it doesn't go up in value, I'm still going to use it anyway.

And I also try to think, well, what are the growth areas?

Like, for example, one property I bought in Mount Barker, I could see that the local was buy low back then, it's Coles now, but they were expanding and they were buying up every street of houses, bulldozing them and extending the car park out.

So I didn't have to be a rocket scientist to work out that in, you know, five to 10 years, they were going to push out towards the main road. So I thought, well, why don't I just buy something in the mix of where that car park's heading?

And, you know, that'll be a great rental property and it's sort of like development potential down the track. And if I go in there and I fix it up and get some tenants in there, I'll get sort of like half decent return on my investment as well.

And so I bought that in 96. In 2000, so four years later, I had developers knocking on my door offering me three times what I paid for it.

Veronica Morgan

So that's a great story. But there's an element of risk in that too, isn't there? I mean, there could have been – it may never have happened the way you foresaw it.

The major employer of the town, you know, may have decided to up sticks and go elsewhere and the supermarket doesn't need to expand or – Do you know what I mean? There's quite a lot. And so buying also with that long, I mean, we're always talking about a long lens.

You know, you need to buy a property with a long view, but you're buying it with a long view, all right, but there's also the, you need an upside in order to make it sort of come off, right? What if the upside hadn't come off?

What was your exit strategy or what were your contingency plans?

Kym Nitschke

Well, I just sort of knew that that town was actually going ahead in leaps and bounds because remember I knew that all those blocks of land were being released in that town as well. So I was thinking that CBD has got to grow. It can only go one way.

I was happy even if that development didn't come off to have that in my portfolio 10, 15 years down the track. You know, I'm always looking at... You know, is this place that I'm looking at buying into, do I want to have it in my property in 10 or 20 years' time?

Will the value in 10 or 20 years' time of that place be higher than it is today? That's my asset test. And I could say, hand on my heart, with that Mount Barker one,

yes um it definitely would but i mean you could say i got lucky but i mean with all my properties i feel like i get lucky but i just sort of choose underdeveloped areas that i think are what is the gentrification that sort of work where they're underdeveloped but all the yuppies are moving in and the artists and

And all of those guys are sort of taking over the coffee shops and the disused warehouses and things like that. And you sort of get a feel for it. This is on the up.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, yeah. And obviously, I mean, I've seen people, even myself, I've identified areas and think, right, that's going to go. And then it's 20 years later, it's going. You know what I mean? So you do have to sort of go buy and be able to hold it.

Kym Nitschke

for that absolutely like this is the long game there's no such thing as making money overnight you know that that was a 10 20 year plan i've still got that property and what i paid for it i'm now getting rent every year off of that

Chris Bates

Yeah, it's interesting. So a couple of years ago, a client came to me and she had these two apartments in Parramatta and they were getting, this is when the boom in Sydney was sort of going nuts and developers were running out of options and they were like, let's just get apartments in Parramatta.

And they were getting some, developers were basically speaking to Strata and they were starting to throw, you know, big numbers on these apartments. And then bang, the boom finished. And so she still got the apartment, but there's no developers anywhere in the site.

And so it's an interesting one because at the time I was like, wow, you can get, you know, 20, 30% more than what you sell on the market. That's a great result. And then she's held on. But now it's a case of what do you do with the apartments now?

They're not great investments. Developers don't want them. It's an oversupply issue. And so I guess it's a real timing thing, isn't it? You've got to... really, you know, everything's got to be right and you've got to hope that the economy keeps going, et cetera.

So there's a little bit of a risk in that, into that sort of strategy. Yeah, yeah, there is. Absolutely.

Veronica Morgan

So what do you see as some of the biggest mistakes?

Like you said earlier that the problem with your clients is that they often come to you after they've already made all these decisions and you're there to supposedly mop it up a little bit and help them save tax and whatever it is that they expect of you.

What do you see as the biggest mistakes that keep coming past your desk over and over again?

Kym Nitschke

Well, I did a lot with doctors and I think the first meeting is always just trying to deconstruct a property mess that they've set up. Usually they've got, let's just think of one example.

This is not my Dumbo, but this is a customer that's in Canberra. He lives in a really expensive house that he can't afford. Um, you know, he's bought two apartments down the road through some off the plan deal.

And, um, you know, the appreciation that deductions were amazing. He looked at some spreadsheets and it was going to cost him $5 a week, all of that. He fast forwarded five, 10 years time. And it's just, it's an absolute mess. And the problem, the reason he's coming to me is because financially,

he's hamstrung and he can't break out of his cycle. He's got tax bills coming out of his ears. And it's like, well, really the first thing that I would do is offload these properties, which I don't think I want to have in your portfolio in the next five to 10 years.

And they don't like to hear that. And even as far as like, your house is too big. I know it's great to have parties there on the weekend and impress all your friends, but really you can't afford it. The mortgage is strangling the daylights out of your cashflow. It's an interesting one.

Chris Bates

So he's probably on a great income. Yeah.

Kym Nitschke

Yeah. Phenomenal.

Chris Bates

Yeah. Yeah. And so he's got a great income and he's got top tax rate. So he's got 50% deduction on any loss and he still goes down positive cash flow property strategy. So he's got the ability to go buy great investments and he still falls for the positive cash flow.

And the reason is that he's, like you're saying, he's hemorrhaging money on his mortgage. And he's over...

i guess the kicker to this though is the house that he's got that it's too big for him is it a good investment so yes he'll struggle with the mortgage but at some point he'll sell that tax free and will that be a payday for him or is it just an expensive home there's potentially something flawed about it well the trouble is he's so comfortable there his wife will be devastated if he sells it he'll just stay put the best i can do is get him to offload the units that he's got

Kym Nitschke

and go again you know like i'm a great believer in that you know life's so short you've got to ride every possible wave that comes your way so if it was my model i'd be making money on my house i'd be buying a beautiful house that you can have all your friends around too but i'd be using my builder's license and renovating it and doing some artificial value add to that place while i'm there yeah

Veronica Morgan

That's me, though. A lot of people can't do that. Actually, I'm curious, too, because, I mean, you say you help a lot of doctors. So I'm presuming, you know, surgeons or doctors that have, you know, successful practices or GPs, for instance, yeah?

And quite often, you know, they spend, what, 12 years at university learning everything but business.

um everything but you know financial um things or financial smarts and yet they're highly intelligent and successful um do you think that they get themselves into a bit of a pickle because of that because that they sort of got this idea that um well it's overconfidence bias basically i'm you know i'm overconfident because i'm really successful i'm really clever so therefore they can't be too hard and let's face it most real estate agents don't need a degree so

Do you find that? Yeah, I do.

Kym Nitschke

I mean, I'm amazed at the financial problems that come across my desk from the people who are earning a million dollars plus. Like I had a conversation with a doctor friend of mine recently, and he can't live on 130,000 a month. Wow.

You know, but it's because they don't have any financial education in that

13 years that they're at university, and they come out, and they're very clever people, they're beautiful people, and they've got great personalities and they've got great business models, but it's so tough these days, the tax is so high, you find that they're all working two and a half days for ScoMo, and I don't care how much you like your job, that's for the birds.

They need to have this property investment vehicle, side hustle on the side, that's going up in value while they're sleeping.

Chris Bates

Yeah. The cash flow management for them is probably one of the biggest issues, right? Like, especially when they're running their own business, they've got to pay a big tax bill at the end of the year.

And, you know, there's big chunks of money hitting the bank account and all of a sudden they start living a lifestyle like all that's their money. But then...

they get behind the tax bill and they're you know 300 grand stew at the end of the year you know and do you find that's one of the biggest challenges they have is just managing the pure volume of cash hitting the bank account and segregating it and being wise oh yeah they're just a washing money and so it's just dripping through their fingers like all the kids are at private schools they're driving the latest mosquitoes

Kym Nitschke

Um, you know, the overseas holidays, the jewelry, the clothing, it's just that it's sort of that they get in this bubble where this, um,

socializing with all that social set where um you know the wives aren't working and there's a generalization or the husbands aren't working or whatever but they're just um yeah they're in a real trap financially a lot of these people when they get to retirement they've got nothing because they're just every dollar they've earned has been spent before it's actually been earned

Veronica Morgan

So they're trapped by this success then in a way. It's like they're spending, because I do know, I know that, you know, we've had a lot of, you know, medical clients where, you know, in the early days, they got quite a modest income. You know, they've been studying for a long time.

They don't start working until they're a lot older than everybody else. then they get a modest income, which is okay, but it's not amazing. And then when they specialize, it can ramp up quite substantially, quite quickly.

And if they're not keeping a modest lifestyle and sort of in using that extra money to invest, then they can get completely out of control because all of a sudden they go, yippee, I can finally let go of it because I've been working my butt off. And they do start spending something.

You can sort of understand behaviorally how that could come about.

Kym Nitschke

Oh, absolutely. They're so stressed out as well, unfortunately, with their work that they give us all of these treats. You should see my car park at the office. I've got the most amazing cars out there.

I said to one of my accounts the other day, I said, go and take a photo of all the cars in the car park out front. It just looked like the BMW dealership with M3s and X5s. It was just incredible out there. But none of them could afford it, unfortunately.

you know that's the conversation with the person having the meeting i said these guys in that meeting have got incredible cars and said yeah they can't afford it but they do it because that's they feel that's their entitlement they've worked hard and um that's what all their friends are doing and it's not the right way to go do you see there's a generational shift as well where maybe some of the younger doctors aren't following that same trajectory yeah i do um

Yeah, I think it's good in that way. Like they're coming through. The next generation, they're so much more astute. Like they don't smoke and drink like we did. They're at the gym every night. They're reading the Motley Fool every day. They're wanting to get their property portfolio set up.

I just take my hat off to them. And sometimes it's just giving them a pat on the back and saying, you're totally on track. Keep doing what you're doing. Here's a couple of tweaks, a couple of little, you know, they just want someone in their corner just to mentor them.

And just to tell them, you know, maybe just do things slightly different to what you've got in mind, but you've basically got this and just carry on and keep doing what you're doing. But yeah, there's definitely change. Absolutely.

Veronica Morgan

So of the older clients that you have, what would be the catalyst for them to come to you then? And to actually say, you know what, it's not working. Where have I gone wrong?

Kym Nitschke

I think that everyone gets to a point where, you know, it's when they hit 50, 55 and some of their friends are starting to retire and they're looking at their wife thinking, we should have that conversation about retirement, but I don't really know how we can do that.

We need to get someone professional on board. That's when I often get in or get called in or they'll be hiding their tax returns and have a massive debt. Often they're hiding it from their spouse.

Veronica Morgan

Oh, wow.

Kym Nitschke

They don't know. They're getting letters from the ATO saying you need to get your super fund up to date, your tax returns are behind. There's a lot of that out there and we sort of,

you know, help people because they're just, once you've been avoiding the tax office for so long, they actually have a real phobia about it. But the tax office is really quick. You can often work through it. But yeah, there's lots of people out there in those situations.

Sort of like a bit of a get in the sand. Yeah.

Chris Bates

Yeah, it's that, you know, that five years, the runway is getting shorter on them. They're getting tired and they're like, actually, I want to stop working. How do I kind of get through this transition? And then they just don't know how to figure it out.

And that's ideally where most people go and see financial advisors. But unfortunately, technically, they should have went and saw an advisor 10 years before that or 15 years or etc.,

And that's one of the reasons why I stopped working with that sort of pre-retirees because I just felt everything, the advice I had to do was damage limitation. How do I, you know, reach, because it's hard to take risks when you're getting five years out from retirement.

So it's all about dialing down, cutting cash flow, doing best with what you've got. And it's a really, it's a hard point. But they've been hiding their head in the sand for 10, 15 years, stressing about it.

um night after night thinking how am i going to solve this problem and then they go to someone like him and say can you solve it for me i guess you can say well i can make things better but i can't solve you know things overnight um

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, that's exactly right.

Chris Bates

So what are some of the things from a structuring tax point of view that I think that most property investors are missing? You know, obviously, you know, I get a little bit apprehensive when I hear the word trust with property investors, etc.

So what are some of the things that you think that people should be doing when they're not with their property investments?

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, I've got a couple of answers to that. I think that Um, personally, I love family trusts, um, with the corporate trustee. Um, there's a guy in LA, I know he was on Pilates. He was the property guru.

He had 56 companies and trusts and half of Adelaide. And he, he was, uh, um, I think he was, uh, was he the Greek or Italian, but it was from that, you know, first generation that moved out here, but absolutely cleaned up in the city.

did an amazing job and he's got these little signs, they're sort of like white boxes with blue capitals with polities written all over them. So it's been a bit of a iconic statement in Adelaide to drive around and see all of that. So he had 56.

I think that's where I want to aim. I've got 10 at the moment. But I love the structure because it's so flexible in so many ways. Like you still get all of the CGT discounts after you've held the property for 12 months. But you also get asset protection as well.

You can split income to a lower income earning, a member of the family provided they're over 18. So there's so many advantages. And then from land tax, it's also proven we've had massive land tax reform in South Australia.

It's proved to be the tried and true model that survived all of that reform because with the trust, effectively they get treated as having their own threshold for land tax.

So you can save if you, you know, rather than pulling all the properties together and having, you know, them worth five or six million, you split them across six or seven trusts, they all just creep over the threshold of, you know, 500 grand. So you only pay minimal land tax on each property.

Another thing that I think that people overlook, I think the number one tax planning strategy, and you touched on it before, Chris, is, you know, make money on your house because it's tax free. The government hasn't taxed that yet.

The other opportunity that I see that people overlook is if you're in small business, there's such a golden opportunity to own your own office in a business. And then if you own that for 15 years, you can sell that capital gains tax-free as well. You know what I mean?

If you're in for the long haul, what does that mean? You've got two principal places of residence, effectively.

Chris Bates

Yeah.

Yeah, if the COVID world didn't change the way we worked, as long as you've got a good office.

But you're right. I mean, even just running a business, there's all these other small business exemptions, right? That, you know, a lot of people don't even know about, you know, some, you know, in terms of, you know, the 15 year rule, the retirement exemption, et cetera. What are they?

Veronica Morgan

Because I haven't heard of either of them and I'm in small business. I'll talk to my accountant about this, Michael.

Kym Nitschke

Well, the 15-year exemption, basically, if you operate your business out of a building, it could be a warehouse or an office or anything like that, if you've operated there for longer than 15 years, there's no capital gains tax when you go to sell the property down the track.

But because we're in such an impatient world, people get in and get in within a couple of years. Well, if you rent it out, it doesn't apply either. So you've got to meet the criteria. But if you tick all the boxes...

There's so many opportunities for getting some leverage there with the tax planning.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, that was one.

Kym Nitschke

The other thing that I was going to touch on, I see it a lot. People buy, I don't know what your attitude on this is, but buying properties in superannuation funds.

Yeah, I think that was all the rage like five, 10 years ago, but it really seems to be on the rise now for a number of reasons. So it's really awkward for people to like,

The thing that people don't realise about superannuation funds is if you buy a property and you put it in there and it doubles in value, you can't borrow against that property in your super fund to buy property number two. There's standalone assets, which is bizarre.

And I can see why the government's done it, because they want to limit the risk exposure and they don't want you to be a property magnate via your super fund. But really, that is a self-limiting model. And the other thing with super funds is...

Banks are very uneasy about it now, so the interest rate's gone through the roof. And the set-up fees, the legal fees involved in setting up superannuation fund-owning property

Veronica Morgan

horrendous as well now so i'm not convinced that owning properties in superfund is a great way to go anymore i agree 100 and look i've got one in my super fund i bought it back in i don't know 10 years ago or so and um you know yeah the interest rate is now three times almost what i'm paying on another investment property outside of super

um and that is you know the bank does that bank that i'm with doesn't want to be in the business anymore and that's what they're doing so i have to then look at you know a lump sum payment basically to try to pay down that debt so then i can end up with debt free so it has changed my whole super strategy because of the regulation changes um and the bank's changes and you're right it's um it was a bit of a fad and what i come across a lot of people that have actually bought off the

right in their super, which is insane. Cause you know, super is like, you're only paying 15% tax anyway.

Kym Nitschke

This other thing that crops up to is where people have been given a holiday to go and look at a property for free in Queensland.

Veronica Morgan

I see.

Kym Nitschke

And it's like, what were you thinking? Why don't you just play for the holiday?

And, you know, go on to a local real estate agent and have a chat about properties. Not be sort of anchored to a property that you have to sign up on and you get a free holiday if you go up there.

Veronica Morgan

But that's the problem. It's the problem with anything free around property. And first home buyer grants is a classic at the moment. And I was talking to some people last night and they're not first home buyers. So they've been looking at...

established departments in the same area where there are new being sold and they're comparing the new to the established and saying oh my god the established is so much bigger and they're better finished and they're actually they've got views and the new ones are smaller and they're not as well finished and they have no view and yet they're the same price and so that's why the established one is worth more and I'm like well you are one of the very small percentage of people actually looking at both because the gift that the government's giving means that most buyers looking at that new stuff are

unaware that they get more for their money if they look elsewhere and I think it's a bit the same with super it's like this idea that you've been given something or all these trips up to Queensland you're given something it's like no you haven't oh my god that's an expensive holiday

Bye. Bye. Bye.

Love hearing your questions and we're planning more listener Q&A episodes. Please send your questions in. You can send them via the website, which is theelephantintheroom.com.au or directly via email to questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au.

Chris Bates

So holiday homes, you know, I think that COVID's kind of brought that back into something that people aspire to. You know, I can work from anywhere. Maybe I can do two weeks, two days in the city. I can have my beach house.

What are some of the tricky things from a tax point of view? You know, because obviously it all comes down to the quality of investment you're buying, isn't it? are you still buying lifestyle? Are you buying lifestyle plus investment returns?

But from a tax point of view, is there certain things that you would approach that in terms of how to best structure things like that?

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, well, I love holiday homes. And I think that's just such an important part of your lifestyle, you know, as you're developing as a property investor. And I'd certainly like to put holiday homes in my portfolio. I haven't got to that stage yet.

But just before we talk about structure, can we just talk about how I'd approach it if I was going down that track? Because I think that, you know, when we were sort of talking about this podcast, you were sort of talking about what are most mistakes that property buyers make.

And I think that, like, insider trading is not illegal in the property sector.

What I mean by that is, you know, if you drive down to your little local holiday destination, let's just say you live in Melbourne, you go down to Lorne, and you drive around and you look on realestate.com and Domain,

It's so hard and I don't like your chances if you just go to an auction and put your hand up and you're the highest bidder whether you're going to make money on that property. I like to do a lot more research than that and I would like to actually be on the front.

So what I would do is I'd drive down there, I'd park my car, I'd walk along the beach, I'd photograph all of the asbestos shacks on the front and then I'd send them to Veronica and say, can you knock on these people's doors and ask me if they want to sell it? Yeah.

You know what I mean? Like, and then you're wiping out all your competition because they don't know about what your plan is. And then when it comes on the market, if someone's interested in selling, um,

then you're in the box seat to be able to negotiate a really good deal. So I wouldn't sign the contract if I didn't think I was getting a $100,000 discount on settlement.

Veronica Morgan

Okay, so I've got something for you here. When you knock on someone's door, you've got to be prepared to pay a premium because unless it's pure luck that you happen to have just knocked on the door of the person that's just basically had a...

compelling reason that they want to sell and they want to sell quickly and they're going thank you god thank you god you just sent me an angel except for that that scenario which is highly rare most people when you knock on their door need to be enticed to sell because they're not thinking about selling typically in my experience that comes with a 20 percent at least 20 25 premium so how do you how do you yeah

How do you get around that premium? How do you get someone to part with their property for less than it might get on the open market?

Kym Nitschke

You're going to think I'm a bit out there when I tell you what I actually do. I actually do letter drawings.

Veronica Morgan

That's not out there. That's what real estate agents do day in, day out. That's their job. So how do you do it differently?

Kym Nitschke

I do it a bit differently. I handwrite mine. And I look up the owner's name and I do a personal letter to them. And I write something specific about their property in the letter. So for example, I would say, let's just use the lawn example. I'd work out all those properties.

Then I'd go and look up who owns those, pay 20 bucks a property to do a search. And then do a handwritten letter on the little, like, nice writing paper that I get from the news agency. It takes forever, but the strike rate is really, really high.

Like, you won't believe the numbers when I tell you, but it's like 20% contact rate.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, but then how many of those do you get to buy at $100,000 under? Yeah.

Kym Nitschke

Well, yeah, so when they do ring me, because they only think that I've written to them, so they'll ring me out of the blue and then I keep in my wallet a little A4 page with all the pictures of the houses that I've written to because when they say, because I'll say, it's Mr Jones here, I'll ring you back and it's like,

hang on, who's Mr. Jones? So it's like, can you just hold the line? And then like, okay, Jones, he's the third one down. There's a picture of his house. Then I can launch the conversation with him about it.

Of the 20% that contact me, I reckon that the majority of them are saying, well, it's not for sale, but if you offer me a price that I can't refuse, I'll consider it. Well, I'm not interested in those guys.

But what you find with the asbestos place on the beach with the grass at knee high and all of the gates are falling down and the sheds, gutters rusted off, they are generally owned by people in their 70s. And it's become a pain in the neck every time they go down there.

It's become a bit of an inconvenience for them. So you're actually solving their problem.

Veronica Morgan

It might be like one of those boats, you know, that's on the moorings. It's just covered in barnacles. It's just, you know, it's so difficult to go there. It just reminds them what they're not doing. And so they never go there, perhaps. Ah, dear.

So, okay, but talk about the structuring, apart from the fact that that's how you're going to go there, and I think you sort of do believe in miracles a little bit, I think, but, you know, apart from the fact you're going to go and find this miraculous owner who's miraculously ready and miraculously happy to take less than market value because they're not having agents knocking on their door telling it's worth more than that.

Assuming you've got that, then what? Then how do you advise clients to do this well?

Kym Nitschke

Okay. So then how would I own it? Is that what the question is?

Veronica Morgan

Oh, well, just what's next from the accountant. Rather than the client coming to you after they've done all this, you're the accountant guiding your clients through this process. What's next?

Kym Nitschke

Yeah. So then I would...

We'd make sure they've got their finance organised. Then we'd look at sort of cash flowing on what, you know, the place, if it's going to be a rental, well then if they want to get a tax deduction, it's got to be available for rent for the whole year.

If you know what I mean, if you want to do that. And then if you're going to block it out for say Christmas, well then you have to adjust all of your expenses to make that month private. You know what I mean?

But it's awkward to do Christmas because that's often your highest income earning month.

You know, if it's going to be private, it's going to be private. If it's going to be rental, it's going to be rental. It's hard to sort of have a mix of both, I guess.

Veronica Morgan

Well, and this is the thing, though. A lot of people do, you know, do that mix and then they say, well, Christmas is off limits because that's what I want to use it. Bugger that. But so that's quite common. You might have 60%, 40% for argument's sake.

Maybe it's available for rental and then you've obviously got to, you can only get the deductions on 60% of your expenses, correct? Yeah. What about the impact on capital gains tax? Because, of course, if you're buying a holiday home, that's 100% taxable. Well, it's 50% taxable because of the concession rate.

But you don't get a, you know, even if you only use it for yourself and you don't ever rent it out, you still got to pay CGT, right, when you sell it one day? Yes.

Kym Nitschke

Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah.

Veronica Morgan

So do they set it up in a company? Is that what you're saying?

Kym Nitschke

The first choice might be, depending on the situation, I've got a spouse.

potentially putting it in their name. But then if they've got a whole raft of properties in their name already or they're a high income owner in their own right, well then I'd probably go straight to a family, a corporate trustee with a family trust.

Because then that gives you all sorts of options down the track.

You might have, you know, the kids might be little now and then when they've grown up and you sell it because they want to get something bigger and better, well then you might be able to split income to the kids if they're over 18.

You know, the options just are sort of endless and if in doubt, always use a family trust.

Chris Bates

Do you think with property, you've done a bit of property development over the years. Do you think that what are some of the biggest tax mistakes they make when they're doing their feasibility sort of study?

Because I feel like most people miss one or two things on their feasibility, whether it's GST or capital gains tax or stamp duty or et cetera. What are some of the biggest tax mistakes property developments make? Because

The whole thing doesn't make sense if you take into consideration some of the things that they forget.

Kym Nitschke

Well, yeah. Well, hopefully those people, like, they've got all the fundamentals right. And, you know, these things, what actually happens is if they've got a great block and it takes –

you know, double the time to get it through council, double the time to get all the services and the subdivisions and everything done. What you generally find is the property's actually going up in value at a faster rate during that period of time anyway.

So generally in those situations, if a good deal, and they've overlooked some of those little costs, it comes out in the wash anyway, and their end result is actually higher than their expectations. With most of those structures, I would...

I would always use a unit trust in that situation because you've usually got a couple of parties and they're usually always arguing with each other or wanting to bring another party in. So the unit trust is very flexible, again, with a corporate trustee, but then I'd have their individual family trust underneath that.

But I guess probably the number one property problem that I see is people buying properties in companies. They're sort of focusing on that. 30% or 27.5% tax right now, but they don't get that 50% discount.

that's a big problem for people and they don't often realise that until we come to actually work out the tax on the sale.

Veronica Morgan

So I guess, I mean, you know, I heard an accountant once sort of saying that, you know, the company tax is, what, 27 and a half, but if you bought it in your own name, then you're going to be paying 45%, you know, tax on it, on half of it.

So that comes down, what, 22 and a half percent, right? So it's certainly marginally more, but then you get to save on, you save on land tax if it's under the threshold. Yeah. So all that in a wash and there's all those sort of numbers.

But, of course, that's relying on tax rates being somewhat predictable, right? But you mentioned earlier in the family trust that you get the same CGT benefits or concessions as you do if you buy on your own name. I didn't know that.

So is that – can you explain that better for us?

Kym Nitschke

Oh, sorry. Yeah, so the family trust – Yeah, once you've held a capital gains tax asset for longer than 12 months, they get the 50% discount when they're distributing to individuals.

Veronica Morgan

Right, so it's exactly the same as... Yeah, yeah, yeah.

Kym Nitschke

So it makes no difference. And then, you know, the beauty of that is, like, circumstances change and...

if you've got it in a partnership or you've got an individual's name that's fixed and that income needs to fall on their tax returns if it's as you know individual or it's partnership whatever whereas the beauty of the the family trust is you can split it to any family member providers and you know allowed for in the trustee yeah

It's really flexible and you get that discount as well. So they're a really good vehicle. The only problem with the trust is if it's negatively geared, those losses get trapped in the trust. And that's another trap people. So like, you know, people get excited about this whole negative gearing phenomenon.

um and then at the end of the year one they go where's my tax deduction go hang off it's in a family trust those those losses are locked in there until you make a game sometimes they're locked in there till you sell the property but um you know if there's another business that that person owns which is often the case if there's sole traders or business people they can tip money into that loss making trust and use up some of the losses that way there's other ways around it's just a

if there's salary and wage earners using a family trust to own their properties as a vehicle, sometimes those losses might get trapped in there and it might not be a great vehicle for them.

Chris Bates

Yeah, so it just increases their cash flow outlay every year for the properties. Most people are probably borrowing, if they've got a house, they're borrowing 105% of the purchase price.

Interest rates are very low right now, so even great properties, the cash flow isn't that bad because interest rates are 3%, they're not 5% or 6%. Oh, their rents are terrible now.

Veronica Morgan

Yeah, yeah. Rents have gone down substantially. Yeah.

Chris Bates

Yeah, well, if you've got a good tenant, you know, you're right. Like if you have to re-rent it out, a lot of rents haven't really dropped. But yeah, I mean, the cash flows aren't too bad because of low interest rates.

But if rates rise, for example, or, you know, they haven't got a tenant and they have this big loss, it does make one of the big negatives of that trust structure is that

You just have to keep outlaying everything rather than get this big kick in July every year to kind of top up your kitty. What about... Sorry.

Veronica Morgan

I was about to say too, because CGT is a bit complicated if you ever move out of your property for a period of time and then move back into it or if you actually rented it out before you moved into it. I mean, there's different ways in which it's calculated, isn't it? So...

And I guess a lot of people, I remember doing a CPD course on that at REI some years back. So I've got some understanding that there are differences, but that's obviously I'm not an accountant, so I don't know what those differences are.

But there is a difference in the options of how you calculate the gain, you know what I mean? And so can you just sort of talk through that for us as well?

Kym Nitschke

Well, moving in and out of properties, there's so many advantages to property ownership in the tax legislation.

So let's just say you own a property and it's your principal place of residence and then you decide that you're going to have a tree change and you move out to the country and rent a place for a couple of years and then you move back into your principal place of residence.

Well, like from when you move out of your principal place of residence, you've got six years that you don't have to pay capital gains tax and you can rent it out.

without any implications provided that you sell it in that six-year window or you move back into it and it resets for another six years.

Veronica Morgan

As long as you didn't buy another property to live in.

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, so as soon as you buy another property, well, that changes because you might lose the principal place of residence on the first place. So it is a little bit tricky.

It works well if you're moving overseas or something like that for a period of time or you've got a job in the country and come back, which does happen.

Veronica Morgan

But what if you rented out before you moved into it? Say you bought it before you needed it, you didn't upgrade, you didn't move in straight away. What happens there? And then down the track you go and sell it?

Kym Nitschke

These questions are getting harder and harder.

Veronica Morgan

I think you're the expert.

Kym Nitschke

I actually wrote an article in the property investment magazine recently on that.

Veronica Morgan

Can I say, please share the link if you want to as well. We're happy to share that link in the show notes.

Kym Nitschke

Okay, yeah, we'll put it in the show notes. Yeah, maybe it's probably best if you read that article.

Veronica Morgan

I know, but you can get a quick snapshot now, surely.

Kym Nitschke

Okay, well, I can't. I think I've just got to pass my mind back because I've sort of spent a couple of hours researching it.

I think if you originally buy it as a rental property, and don't quote me on this, and then you move into it and turn it into a principal place of residence, depending on what's happening with other properties, I think that you get that principal place of residence maybe from the time that you move in.

Can't. I have to. Yeah, okay. I'm not sure.

Veronica Morgan

Because then you've got to work out how the value is calculated and all that sort of stuff. So, yes, it would be really good if you could send us that link because I think that would be very useful for people to understand.

So I guess we're at that point in our chat and we ask you what your Dumbo is. We've had some of your personal ones, which have been fantastic. And I'm hoping you can trumpet a horrible pun. Well, it's not a pun, but a horrible name.

Kym Nitschke

Yeah. I hope I haven't painted too bleak a picture. Like my property portfolio is just amazing. It gives me this incredible life. You know, my life's worked out 10 times better than I ever imagined. Um, now that I've got all the fundamental, it just gets better and better.

I'm up to seven properties now. Um, and a lot of my mates are going into syndication with clients, but my bank never says no.

When I asked them for money, you know, they just sort of more or less, it's getting harder, but, um, it's just like, I have this model now where I buy all these old rundown, houses on arterial roads into Adelaide, and then I convert them into offices and then rent them out.

And that model just seems to work really well from a capital gains point of view. And then, you know, I'm not focused on rent, but the rent astounds me every time I rent them out.

Veronica Morgan

I have to step in, I have to ask you, when you said that they do astoundingly for capital gains, how is that measured? Because you're taking a residential property that's on a main road and you're presuming the zoning allows for it to be used as something different. Is that, yeah. Okay.

So then that's why, because of the zoning?

Kym Nitschke

So I'm specifically in the office zoning.

a lot of people they're living in office but as a residence and then I'm converting it dealing with the council and those people are moving out and they're on busy roads so the residential aspect of it is getting less and less attractive in the market you're getting out of buying them residentially sort of at a discount to market and then bringing them up to office and then renting them out at office rates right

Veronica Morgan

And you say that they work more as an office. You would be able to find another investor that would pay good money, that would give you what you rate as a good gain.

Kym Nitschke

Yes. Yeah. And that seems to be a really good model. And then, you know, when you move into the commercial space, the rule book's completely different to residential. Like it's all in favour of the landlord. It's just crazy. Yeah. Your tenant pays your council rates. Your tenant pays your water rates.

Your tenant pays your emergency services. They insure it. They have to renovate it and repair it, you know, like repaint it when they move out. They have to get the lawns mowed.

But with my residences that I've got, my residential properties, if my light bulb blows, they can go and get an electrician in to change it and send me the bill.

Veronica Morgan

Although there's more risk with commercial, which is one of the reasons that the banks, you know, that they view it as riskier because they tend to, you know, lend less money on commercial.

And obviously you've only got a particular type of tenant and if business goes bust, they go out and you might take your while to find another tenant for it. So your vacancy rates might be higher as well.

You know, so there's all this sort of swings and roundabouts, right? Yeah.

Kym Nitschke

Yeah, absolutely. And, you know, what you're saying is right. Like my bank, I lend 70% against these properties, but because I've got equity, it's not a risk. But if you're trying to move into that space, you don't have a lot of equity.

Well, that could be a limiting factor on how you get into it. And I have had offices which have been empty for two years. And it's... You know, that is a really stressful period of time. But then when it's rented out, a few days again.

Veronica Morgan

So you're like a big extra sketch. You know, your life is like you can decide it's horrible while it's happening, but then you just swipe and refresh because you sound very positive.

Kym Nitschke

Yeah. Well, yeah, it's, you know, that's the thing with property, isn't it? Like when you're starting out, it is a bit of a rollercoaster ride.

But once you get some, you know, you get some established tenants in, your rent's picking up and your debt's staying constant and your values, it just gets easier and easier.

Like every year I sit on the beach, you know, the beginning of January and just think, yep, another year down, all my properties have gone up in value.

Veronica Morgan

You've got to be careful. You're sounding like a spruiker. Hey, now, you were going to give us a Dumbo. Come on, what's your Dumbo?

Kym Nitschke

Okay, sorry.

i'm getting sidetracked so the dumbo is me um i was with can we say banks names on this or just sure leave banks yeah whatever you want it's on you i was with um westpac for 20 years and i had my i was in private banking and um my manager would do a biannual review and just tell me look don't

don't ask for a cheaper rate because the rate you're on is one of the sharpest for anyone in your space. And so I just took that as gospel. And the thing with that particular bank is they charge, I think this might be in the commercial space.

And so I had my borrowings in the sort of commercial sector. They charge a lowish rate, but then a high line fee.

So I was sort of a bit...

Veronica Morgan

You mean a high line of credit? Did you mean high line or high loan fee?

Kym Nitschke

No, so, yeah, so low interest rate, but then they charge a high, like, bank fee. Right, got it. And so, you know, to look at the true interest rate, you have to collectively add them together.

Veronica Morgan

Mm-hmm.

Kym Nitschke

You know, with home loans it's much easier because you just look at what's your rate or what's your comparison rate.

So what happened was, so I didn't actually shop around for a rate and then a call centre from ANZ, a guy from the call centre at ANZ rang me up and said, oh, you know, would you be interested in us re-quoting your home loan? And I said, yeah.

And so he said, oh, well, how much is your home loan? But I told him, oh, wow, that's quite substantial. I'll put you on to the local branch manager. And then, so then he said, oh, it's too big for me. I'll give it to someone down the road.

So he rang me up and said, oh, look, you've basically sent all your finances in, we'll re-quote it. And so he rang me up and he said, I think I can save you half a cent. And I said, are you kidding me?

You know, I said, I've looked at what you're paying and I've rolled in all the line fees and everything. You're going to save, you know, tens of thousands of dollars if you move over to me.

So then I went back to my bank and I thought, you know, I've been around the block for months. I'll just leverage off that and say, look, you match it. And, you know, my manager was out on holidays. He said, oh God, what are you renting me for? He was really annoyed.

And then he said, yeah, I'll look at it when I get back. So I remind him two weeks later and he actually, right. And all he had to do was type into his computer and change a number. And I got the same, right.

And then the guys from ANZ rang me back and they said, no, no, you don't really understand how much money get your business. We'll go another quarter of a percent. And I was like, are you serious? I said, if you do that, I'll be so embarrassed.

We've got to go back to my old bank. I would just have to sign up. He said, I'll get the state manager to sign off on it. So he did that. And then lo and behold, I changed banks. But I feel like a dumbo because I've got my mortgage broken.

This was actually happening on my own.

Veronica Morgan

So this is like the mechanic's car.

The mechanic's car. But what's so amazing, though, is that, you know, like if you don't ask the question, the banks, it's not really in their interests to make sure you've got the best deal. It's just in their interest to make sure that you don't know that you can do any better, right?

Kym Nitschke

Well, that's the trouble with the banking model, isn't it, Chris? Like, you know, they make money set and forget and you ignore the refinance, lower interest rates request that you get from the customers all the time. Hopefully they just shut up and pay up. Yeah.

Chris Bates

So if you go to a broker, a broker gets paid the same amount, not affected by what rate you pay. So, you know, the trail commission and the upfront fee doesn't really matter. If they get you a better rate, it's all in your pocket.

But if you go to a private bank or a commercial bank, in terms of the way they're targeted as it's profit per client, And so they'll look at your, if they have to sharpen your radar, it comes out of their overall profit in terms of their client base.

And so then they're not really incentivized to give you a discount because it's actually affecting their KPIs.

And so unless you know what you should be paying and what's actually a really good rate in the marketplace, it's very hard to sharpen the bank up because the bank's saying, well, you know, they're kind of always getting on that apathy. So when we're dealing with private banks,

they will always come back with pretty average discounts. And then we have to say, hang on a sec, you know, we can get this with, you know, going retail. Well, this is what we can get from another private bank. You need to sharpen up.

And so private banks, you know, because their KPI is affected by what rate they offer. And so, yeah, you're right. When you're dealing direct with the banks, you're the one who's got to do the sharpening.

And that's one of the benefits of having that broker in the middle because they can say, actually, this is what you need to offer my customer to win them. So, yeah, we've seen that as well where people do get very loyal with the bank, very sticky with the bank.

You were there for 20 years and you were like, well, I've always been with Westpac. Westpac got my back. Well, no, Worthpacking is hoping that you just don't look at your home loan and don't ask any questions. And that's, especially in the last five years, discounts have moved a lot.

And so, you know, in the past there wasn't much of a difference, but now there's a huge difference between an old customer and a new customer.

Veronica Morgan

I think actually you and I, Chris, did an episode on this exact topic, I think back in March. So if anyone wants to go back and listen to that as to –

you know, the pros and cons of using a broker over a bank, then because I was coming across a number of clients who exactly that, they had high net worth, they'd been with their private banker for many years, they really had this sort of sense of loyalty.

And then they discovered that actually, you know, there was just so much more on offer for them if they just open up. And in fact, quite often those private bankers dropped the ball as well at critical times, which is why they ended up looking elsewhere. And then it was like, oh, my God.

this is nuts um so yeah just and like I had about three clients all the time you know having the same sort of thing happen so it was an interesting eye-opener Kim, that was a very interesting, entertaining chat.

As I suspected, you know, you are certainly not the accountant that would send his wife to sleep with the tales of what you do in a day. Thank you for joining us. As I said, please send that link through.

We'll include that and also a link to your business as well for anyone who feels like they would like to reach out to you. Okay, will do. Thanks for having me on the show, guys.

Chris Bates

Thank you, Kim. Good to chat. Cheers.

Veronica Morgan

We want to make you a better elephant rider. So this week's elephant rider training is...

Chris Bates

So we had a good chat with Kim and basically because he's based in Adelaide and we chatted to him a little bit offline around this as well, a lot of what's motivating him with his property strategy is... potentially limited capital growth by just buying buy and hold in Adelaide.

And so the markets he's in, he's thinking, well, where can I actually get some, you know, shorter sort of timeframe returns because I can't just go buy that property and let it sit and hold like I potentially would do in Sydney or Melbourne. And so I think that's,

it's one of the challenges of that strategy. We've had clients who have done amazing out of buying in areas of zoning and, but we've also had clients who have done developments and walked away with, you know, not even the money that they've spent.

So there's lots of risk with that strategy, especially if you're going with things like offices, like you've got to think about the COVID world we're in. Like, You've built a product that may no longer be needed, et cetera. You've got a high-rise retail in Paddington.

That would have been amazing five years ago, potentially not today, et cetera. So the commercial space, there is potentially a lot of big uplifts in it, but you've got to be really sure that the product that you're building is scarce, and if it's not scarce, then you're not going to get the return.

So, yeah, I think that's what's driving Kim's strategy. He's looking to make and manufacture returns rather than just buying lands and holding it because he's based in Adelaide.

Veronica Morgan

And he's clearly, the very fact that he's a licensed builder and he didn't mention actually where he got that qualification, but it must have been after his experience working in the mining industry.

You know, he's got an extra set of skills that allows him to do that and to manufacture that growth in those properties. And I think that's something to be mindful of as well.

Please join us for our next episode. We're talking all about financial autonomy. How does that differ from financial independence or financial freedom? So we're interviewing Paul Benson, who's the author of a book called Financial Autonomy. He's also a financial planner.

And we're having a really esoterical chat about philosophy of wealth and whether you should be investing in ethical funds and a whole bunch of

Stuff that we do bring it all back to property and about really the decisions that can lead to freedom and autonomy when it comes to property and your long-term future. So tune in for some great insights.

If you're looking to buy your dream home or an investment property in Sydney's inner west, eastern suburbs or North Shore, my team and I can help you buy without regrets. Reach out via my website, gooddeeds.com.au.

Chris Bates

If you're looking to buy your first home, thinking of upgrading into a new one or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, my team would love to carefully guide you on this journey. And most importantly, get the finance right. Reach out via our website, wealthful.com.au.

If you're a first-time buyer and you don't want to miss a step with this most important purchase, join me on Wednesday nights at 7.30pm Sydney time on the Home Buyer Academy Facebook page for live Q&A. Check out the website, homebuyeracademy.com.au. Every month.

My team hosts a webinar on what we are seeing at the banks, the best rates, changing policy and their service. We also share the latest insights we hear and read that are impacting the property market direction. Check out wealthful.com.au. Thanks for joining us. We'd love to see you again.

And remember, don't be a dumbo.

Click any timestamp to jump.

Key takeaways

  • Nitschke paid $60,000 each for two units renting at $120 a week, then lost the tenants to new houses at $170 a week down the road and took five years to get out.
  • He says clients sign the contract first and ask about structure later, when the entity is already fixed.
  • His preference is a family trust with a corporate trustee: the 50 per cent CGT discount after 12 months, income splitting to family over 18, and asset protection.
  • The trade-off he named is that negative gearing losses get trapped inside the trust until there is a gain.
  • He has cooled on property inside superannuation, because it is a standalone asset that cannot be borrowed against for the next purchase.
  • His Dumbo was 20 years of loyalty to one bank, until a rival's call centre found half a per cent, then another quarter.

Does Buying for High Rental Yield Work?

Nitschke's first purchase was two units at Little Hampton, outside Adelaide, bought while he was at PricewaterhouseCoopers. He paid $60,000 each, collected $120 a week, and thought it was Christmas.

Then hundreds of blocks of land were released down the road at Mount Barker. His tenants worked out they could rent a brand new place on a big block for $170 a week, and left. The competing stock sat a few kilometres up the road and was knowable in advance, the sort of shift Damian Collins tracks when he reads Perth's long flat stretch segment by segment. He drove to the caravan park one night and offered a former tenant $20 a week off to come back.

Unwinding it took five years. He left the firm, took a labouring job in an underground mine at Cobar that tripled his salary, then sold the units for what he had paid, less fees. A house he split two blocks off did not work either; he had not counted the extra titles.

From all of my experiences I came up with my own set of rules, and I was never going to break those rules ever again.

Kym Nitschke, 12:51

Which Ownership Structure Should You Buy Property In?

Nitschke said clients rush in, sign the contract without a thought about ownership, then come to him when it is too late. Morgan said other accountants tell her the same.

Asked which structure to buy in, he answers with questions of his own: how will you hang on to it, and what do you want to do with it. His preference is a family trust with a corporate trustee, and he holds ten of them.

What he likes is flexibility. The 50 per cent capital gains discount still flows through once an asset has been held longer than 12 months, income can be split to a family member over 18, and there is asset protection. He also said each trust is treated as having its own land tax threshold, so property split across six or seven trusts only creeps over about $500,000 each time.

The only problem with the trust is if it is negatively geared, those losses get trapped in the trust.

Kym Nitschke, 48:14
Feature Matrix: Ownership Structures As Discussed On Air
Structure50% CGT DiscountIncome FlexibilityDrawback Raised
Family trust, corporate trusteeYes, held over 12 monthsSplit to family members over 18Negative gearing losses trapped until a gain
Own or spouse's nameYesFixed to that person's returnLess useful if already holding a raft of properties or on a high income
CompanyNoNot discussedTax rate of 27.5% or 30%, but no 50% discount on sale
Unit trust, family trusts underneathNot discussedUnits held by each partyUsed where several parties develop together and may change
Superannuation fundNot discussedNot discussedStandalone asset, cannot be borrowed against for property two

As described from 29:00 to 48:14. Descriptions and rates as stated on air.

What Tax Concessions Can Property Owners Claim?

The one he says people overlook is owning the premises a small business trades from: operate there longer than 15 years and there is no capital gains tax on the sale, effectively a second principal place of residence. Rent it out instead and the criteria are not met.

He also set out the six year rule. From the day you leave your principal place of residence you have six years to rent it out and sell without capital gains tax, or move back in and reset the clock.

Superannuation is the structure he has cooled on. A property in a fund is a standalone asset, so doubling in value does not let you borrow against it for the next one. Morgan said the property in her own fund carries close to three times the rate she pays outside super.

I think the number one tax planning strategy is make money on your house, because it is tax free. The government hasn't taxed that yet.

Kym Nitschke, 30:49
Eligibility Matrix: Concessions Discussed and Their Conditions
ConcessionApplies ToCondition Stated
Main residenceGain on your own homeDescribed as tax free, and untaxed so far
50% CGT discountIndividuals, and trust distributions to individualsAsset held longer than 12 months
Small business 15 year exemptionPremises the business operates fromOperated there over 15 years; renting it out does not qualify
Six year absence ruleA former principal place of residence, rented outSell inside six years or move back to reset; buying another home to live in changes it
Land tax threshold per trustProperties split across separate trustsEach trust treated as having its own threshold, around $500,000

As described between 30:49 and 51:15. Figures and conditions as stated on air.

Why Do High Income Earners Get Property Wrong?

Much of his client work is with doctors, and he said the first meeting usually goes on deconstructing a property mess. One Canberra client lives in a house he cannot afford and holds two apartments bought off the plan on a spreadsheet that showed $5 a week. Ten years on, the mortgage is strangling his cash flow.

He put the pattern down to 13 years at university with no financial education in them. Bates added the cash flow version: large lumps land in the account, get spent as though they are income, and the tax bill arrives behind them. Nitschke said his office car park looks like a BMW dealership, with clients inside who cannot afford the cars out front.

The catalyst for older clients, he said, is turning 50 and watching friends retire, sometimes with returns unlodged and a debt their spouse does not know about.

How Do You Convert Houses Into Offices?

Nitschke is at seven properties now, buying rundown houses on the arterial roads into Adelaide that sit in office zoning, converting them and letting them at office rates. He buys at a discount because the busy road makes them less attractive as homes, and in commercial the tenant pays rates, insures the building and repaints it.

Morgan noted banks lend less against commercial because vacancies run longer, and Nitschke agreed he has had offices empty for two years and borrows at 70 per cent. Bates read it as manufacturing returns that only pay if the product is scarce.

His Dumbo was his own loan: 20 years with one bank, told at each review not to ask for a sharper rate, on a low rate with a high line fee that only shows when the two are added together. A rival call centre requoted and found half a per cent, then another quarter when he used it as leverage.

If you don't ask the question, it is not really in the banks' interests to make sure you have got the best deal.

Veronica Morgan, 60:15

Buying the Next One in the Right Name?

Ownership structure, land tax and the way the lending is set up all get settled before the contract, not after it. Our team works through how an investment property loan is set up against the entity you are buying in.

Investment Property Mortgage Broker

Sources referenced: The Elephant in the Room, episode 146, "How to structure your property portfolios", released 2020-10-18. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Kym Nitschke, chartered accountant, Nitschke Nankaro Accountants. Figures are quoted as stated on air and have not been re-checked against current data.