Posted
13 November 2026
5 min read

Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.

Episode released
January 13, 2026
Episode
19
 ·
41
 min
The show

Street Secrets

Chris Bates talks with Australia's top buyers agents to discuss specific postcodes and the streets that matter.

Listen on your favourite platform
Chris Bates
CEO

Co-founder of Alcove.

Guest
Cathy McGowan
Cathy McGowan
Buyer's Agent and Founder, McGowan Property Buyers

Let's walk away from this one.” – Cathy McGowan Buying property in Sydney’s North Shore and Hills looks simple from the outside—desirable schools, leafy streets, and strong demand.

Cathy McGowan On Buying In Sydney's Hills And North Shore

Cathy McGowan has spent more than 30 years in property and 14 as a buyer's agent across Sydney's north and north-west. She talks through why clients so often buy in a suburb they had not considered, and what she checks before exchange.

Transcript
Chris Bates

Most good buyer's agents work out what true value, fair market value looks like. And that's what people expect of a buyer's agent. I think the things they don't expect are things like, let's walk away from this one. Oh, but we like it.

And I'm like, yeah, you like it, but these are its flaws and I think we can do better. Our motto is buy without regrets. If you can buy a property that will serve you for 10 years as opposed to three years, that will serve you well. That's something...

Buying a great property today, that's not just what it's about. It's also getting something that could be ripe for improvement when the time is right for that investor or for the next buyer. You think about, right, lifestyle, what's important to you? How do you get to work?

What do you need for your family? What amenities like parks and shops? Then you look at the budget.

Welcome to Street Secrets. I'm Chris Bates and my mortgage broadcast is 2013. And in this podcast, we're going to be interviewing Australia's leading buyers agents, ones with decades of experience, have the local insider knowledge on the street, and can really help you with your buying process.

No matter whether you're a first home buyer, upgrade or investor, in this podcast, you'll get access to Australia's leading buyers agents' minds every week on a Thursday. What's the word on the street?

Welcome to Street Secrets. I'm Chris Bay. Super excited to do the episode today with Cathy McGowan. I've known Cathy for a long time, worked with her at her old firm she used to work at, but also her new firm, McGowan Property Buyers.

She's been working in the buyers agency space for a long, long time and specializes in sort of the north to the northwest part of Sydney. Thanks so much for joining us today, Cathy. Thanks for having me, Chris. Kathy, obviously we know each other, but some people listening to this might not.

And I think it's really valuable just to understand your sort of journey into the sort of real estate buyer's agency world, what you're doing prior, how long you've been doing it. Yeah. And just the journey so far.

So interestingly enough, well, I've had a real estate license now for over 30 years and I've been a BA for 14. My journey started work experience in a real estate office in year 10. So I always had this thing about property.

But then when I did my HSC, I got a little bit nervous about doing, say, maybe land economics and going down that path. So I chose, I guess, what I thought a safer option.

So I did a Bachelor of Business and I did a double major in accounting and finance, thinking I'd probably go into the finance field. Got caught up in the chartered accounting world, worked for a big full firm, realised that wasn't my path.

So got out of that pretty quickly after a couple of years. and went off and did my full-time real estate license, which took a year back in those days. It was a TAFE course, so I worked part-time in sales and did that as well.

So I got my license, did about four years in sales in the Northwest, in the sort of semi-rural area around Durrell. And then I, as I said, did that for four years during a recession in my 20s. It was pretty tough going, but I learned a lot.

I then took an interesting path, and this was with Fair Trading. Office of Fair Trading had a role going as an investigator, a lot of trust audits, that sort of thing. And I thought, oh, well, the accounting background sort of worked, the real estate background.

So I tried that for a couple of years, which was quite interesting. out and about checking out real estate offices, talking to licensees, not so much busting them, but educating them as to what they were doing right and wrong.

Then moved over to the Real Estate Institute and worked there for like 11 years. doing initially membership based PR work, so in and out of real estate offices for four to five days a week, helping with professional development, all that sort of stuff.

So that gave me a really good insight into real estate practice. and a lot of connections with real estate officers all over the state. We used to move around. I used to look after most of the state. So then I went into the complaint and dispute mediation path again.

So getting members of the public, they used to write to REI back in those days and the Institute used to handle complaints. So again, I got to see a lot of dissatisfaction from all sorts of consumers, whether they were buyers, landlords, sellers, tenants.

So again, I opened my eyes to what needed improving in the industry. I had a lot of friends buying property at the time, asking me lots of questions. I started investing and buying my own property in early 20s, did a couple of subdivisions and a couple of rebuilds and things.

So I was pretty across that space. And it made me think, wow, there's a real need for people to help buyers. And back then there were very few buyers agents. So it was on my radar.

And then I got to a point after about 11 years with REI where I thought I'm going to investigate being a buyer's agent. So I contacted one of the original buyer's agents, Jackie Parker at House Search Australia, who was located sort of in the area that I live.

And I said, how about letting me have a crack at this? So I contracted to her for 11 years.

exclusively to her and then three years ago decided to give it a go on my own so I started my own agency and three years later really happy with where it's going really happy with you know lots of repeat and referral work predominantly I don't advertise all my works comes to me really so pretty happy with that

When someone's got a lot of experience, it's a big answer, right? And I think you've highlighted, you've seen a lot, right, over that 30 years from the agency side to as an agent to working as a buyer's agent for a long, long time, 15 years. And a shout out to Jackie.

I mean, like you said, she's one of the original buyer's agents. A lot of training and would have been a great person to work alongside for so long. And I think a lot's changed over that sort of 15 years in buyer's agency.

But I think longevity really matters just through transactions and actually doing deals and actually looking at properties. That's where you get your learnings. And so I think that's thanks so much for sort of explaining that. I think obviously you cover quite a broad reason, more like the north to the northwest.

Can you sort of just maybe give us an understanding of those markets, how they've shifted, where they're sort of at in 2025 and how it's sort of moved over the years? So I cover the north and the northwest, but I'm probably doing most of my work in the northwest.

So that includes the hills district, but it's not exclusively the hills. So there's pockets like the northern suburbs, like Cherry Brook, as well as West Penner Hills that, you know, people often don't consider the hills, but they don't consider it the North Shore either. So there's a traditional North Shore line.

So, you know, I do service that as well.

definitely seen a lot of changes in terms of the the demographic we've got a lot of downsizes traditional older folk living in those areas and i'm certainly sort of i've helped many of them move out of their you know not move out of their homes but help them relocate into into other properties a lot of expats coming back particularly for the north shore but we're seeing this transition a little bit from people

particularly from the Upper North Shore, considering parts of the hills now. So whilst people go, oh, that's a really big area to service, a lot of people say, look, I'd like to be here, but, you know, it allows me to sort of throw that other angle in.

Like, so they go, oh, we like Wurundjeri, for instance. Wurrunga to Tarahumara. But then when you suggest I be considered West Pennant Hills or Cherrybrook, and particularly now with the Metro, you know, people go, Oh, I hadn't really thought about that.

And so people covering all of those areas allows me to give clients a broader perspective, I guess, of their options that they may not have considered themselves.

Certainly in the Northwest, we're seeing, you know, a change is it's been a bit of growth in parts of the Northwest, a lot more units coming in. So particularly around Castle Hill, there's a lot happening in that Northwest Bella Vista area.

So again, with that, we're getting more international new immigrants in, if you like. so that the Indian population, if you like, is changing in that space, as well as a few more Asian buyers as well than what we've traditionally seen.

Some of them are coming from traditionally wanting that North Shore, and some of the pricing now in the hills is comparable to parts of the North Shore, to be honest. So I think it's good to work in both spaces.

And because I've been around for so long, you know, I'm still well connected with sort of all the agents in those spaces. Yeah, that's a good answer. So I think you're right. Obviously, we love local area speciality.

I think it's getting cut through learning suburbs and streets and agents and what the locals love and the danger zones and what sells well in hot markets and down markets. So I think there's so much value in that.

But that doesn't mean that you can't cover multiple markets if you've been doing a long time. And I think when you have active worked in those

north shore to the like you said that pennant hills area is often forgotten about i would say you know and i think the metro you know it's obviously been live for a number of years that was a game changer it was such a particularly now the other parts of it are opening up you know down to the southwest and more cbd offices or stops but you mentioned a really good point i think you know in that sort of upper northwest area you know with house and land packages and apartments changing with all the

the government, but that's also happening on the North Shore as well, right? Like around the Calaras and et cetera. Is that one of the real value adds you? Because some people are very tied to location.

I really want to be in this pocket because I went to school there or my parents are up the road. But a lot of buyers, it's really trying to help them figure out the pocket that suits them in their life. Is that one of the main things you do?

So the amount of clients, if I go back to their original inquiry in the suburbs, they say that they want to buy in to where we end up. I want to do that comparison. And I'll give you an example.

I had a first time buyer come to me last year with a they said, look, we've been looking for a few weeks. I hadn't been looking for long. We've found this townhouse in Hornsby we think we like, but we're not quite sure because we haven't looked very much.

Would you look at it for us? And I said, look, sure, I can do a valuation negotiation service. It was going to auction in about a week, I think.

And I said, look, if you don't end up buying it, I'll rebate the retainer fee into a full search for you, which they were on board with. I went and had a look at it and I sort of came back to them and I said, what are your priorities?

Because I didn't particularly like the townhouse. It was... quite close to the station. I said, has being to the station really important for you? And they said, no, not really. And I said, well, you're buying this property that's really close to the station. Terrible off-street parking. It's overlooked.

It's got... Are you planning to have a family? Because the yard was all over the place. And they're like... well, actually, yeah, we're pregnant. And I'm like, okay, well, that changes things.

Because now we've got to talk about, you know, daycare and who's commuting to school down, who's commuting to the city, who's going to drop off at daycare, all those sorts of things, what school looks like in the future. So we decided to do a full search.

And I suggested, I said, look, for your budget, you know, you could actually buy a better asset in a suburb like Cherrybrook.

So I actually brought them for not that much more and they could afford it, a duplex as opposed to a townhouse in a better suburb with great schools, leafy spaces, big, big, way bigger yard, more practical home that they could literally raise a family in.

And they said to me, we hadn't even considered this suburb. And that's just one story, right? I've got multiple stories of clients like that.

And it's something that I really think a good buyer's agent adds value, being able to offer these paths for clients because they often don't know or they don't consider

the longer term ramifications of, well, if we buy this, we're going to outgrow it. Like, so what are our other options in maybe an adjoining suburb? Like West Pimble versus Pimble. West Pimble for many years was the poor cousin.

And then, you know, I've helped a lot of clients over the years buying West Pimble. Young couples who grew up on the North Shore couldn't quite afford it. Now West Pimble is gentrified. There's knockdown rebuilds. It's got a great community village feel.

So, you know, that's one of those other suburbs that's often was on people's outlier. but now has become, you know, really quite popular. In the hills, it's similar.

There's pockets like, you know, people say, I want to stick in the hills, but then I want to be close to the metro and they can't quite afford the hillside.

So the Kellyville, the Bella Vista, the Beaumont Hills, the hillside, but they go across literally the road and they're into the Blacktown Shire, but a suburb like Stanhope Gardens, for instance, where they are walking distance to the metro. They've got low maintenance blocks.

And that's the other thing that I've really noticed over the years, Chris. There's a lot more peak buyers now going, we don't want the big yard to maintain. We want lifestyle. We want to go cafeing on the weekend. going out and weekends away, we don't want a big lawn to maintain.

So a community title estate with smaller blocks, but they still get the benefit of a swimming pool and they pay $300 to $400 a quarter. For some of them, that's a really good option. So again, presenting those options.

And I've brought for a number of clients in that pocket as well, even though it's in the Blacktown side, not the hillside, the growth they have had because they walk to Metro, they walk to Kellyville Metro. So it's just an interesting space. So people don't know what they don't know, right?

And I know that's often said in this space, but opening up those opportunities, showing them what else is around and what their dollar may buy them that will give them longevity as well, I think, rather than having to

up and move again in a few years time when they have a baby and a family and then they've got two kids and all that sort of stuff. So I really explore that space and try at the onset with the brief to nail the brief. But it's always an evolving thing, too.

So it's not set in stone, but I do try to get it pretty sorted up front. But it is interesting where we end up buying for as to where sometimes the client thinks they want to live.

Yeah, I think that's a great sign of a great buyer's agent, to be honest, because you're right. Clients don't know what they don't know. They also they're just basing their search based on what they do know. Right.

And what they think they should buy rather than really sort of people are making transactions either the first time or not many times in their life. And I think the challenge is obviously talking a lot with first home buyers here with those scenarios and budgets really tight.

whether it's the bank or whether it's their cash or whether it's just their borrowing capacity, it's really tight and the market just price. So they're having to make compromises. They don't know what the compromises to make and they don't know what's out there. And I think you have a lot of value.

But I think that's equally at the next level, the upgraded market. I think they have lived in an area and they just think they've got to get a bigger house in that area. But they haven't really gone and driven through certain suburbs and they've shifted and they've changed over time.

know just sort of helping them explore alternative options i think you've highlighted a really interesting point to the hills how it will shift i mean you're right it was all big homes on big blocks potentially in the past but you know there is going to be some density but there's also some you know some good density i would say rather than you know really stacking it all together nice and tight and i think there is a you know real lack of that i guess within the hills area and you can still get good assets

in that space that, you know, a desire, but not just for first-time buyers and sort of downsizers as well. Oh, downsizers as well. I recently purchased something for a downsizer in that Norwest Bella Vista pocket that's become really popular with downsizers. So Mulford do a lot in that space.

And there's a lot planned in that space. So they're really sort of going to, you know, the shops are changing. There's a lot happening, a lot more green space, more units going in, but there'll be a lot of green space as well.

But what we're finding, a lot of the hills downsizers want to stay in the hills, but they don't want those traditional big blocks. So they're going into these developments and they're paying pretty big dollars for essentially town homes that are classified

I mean, they're not freestanding, but they're, you know, they'll pay between two and a half, closer upwards to three million for the better ones. And some of the apartments, the three better apartments in there are selling, you know, in similar sort of range. because they want to stay local.

There's a bit of state development as well going on in that space. And that's something that's, I think again, a lot of buyers don't understand, right? And this is something else as a good buyer's agent, you know, you don't just look at the 149 certificate in the contract.

A lot of buyers assume their solicitor will brief them on all those things that might be going on in the area, be they state government developments or local government developments, but they don't generally. So as a good buyer's agent, you know, you need to be aware of what's going on in your patch.

So whenever I'm working with a client, you know, I'm on the New South Wales government

portal checking what's going on what state significant developments are happening and there's a lot in that space at the moment like there's stuff happening around Cherrybrook that's all was proposed now it's all changed in the last couple of months so they're looking at densities of like another 10,000 homes in there and it's going to be you know not what was originally proposed about three years ago with the Todd developments

Same on the North Shore. All that's still changing and evolving. So in Bella Vista at the moment, there's two towers proposed, 40 stories each. So being across all of that, you can't expect buyers to be across all of that. And their legal advisors often aren't as well.

So, you know, not to denigrate what they do, but buyers need to be proactive in that space at the moment, buying in these suburbs and not assuming that there's not some sort of significant development going on around them.

I as a BA will do that for my clients, but if they're going solo and they don't know this, and that's the other thing too, when they're looking at comp sales, they're often not looking at that level of detail, right? Why did that sell for that price?

Because it's part of a development site or it's going to be overshadowed by a development site. And that's the same on the North Shore at the moment, as well as in the hills. So it's just something that I guess where we do add a little bit of extra value.

Yeah, I do think the game has shifted a little bit since the olden days where you could sort of rely on the NIMBYism just to sort of win and development would be pushed to the greenfield states and high density pockets and you didn't have much to worry about.

But the world has shifted and I think wherever there has, you need to be basically factoring in that information, even though it's moving fast. You can't be putting your head in the sand.

I think the great buyers agents are looking at the pockets that they do service and going, how is this going to shift the livability of these suburbs? And how do I protect my clients and even potentially avoid certain pockets or really try to go to other pockets?

I think you've got to be across it, which it sounds like you are. I mean, what's some of the danger zones where if you think about your pockets where buyers don't know what they don't know and they buy and they're like, Oh, this is actually a little bit of black hole.

It's got noise or flood or whatever it is. What's some of the things that people often when they're buying the Northwest get wrong and then a few years later they switch on the light. I just wish I knew that before. Probably the rat runs. The school rat runs can be pretty significant.

I personally live in Durrell. We've got a lot of private schools. It's sort of my main big road in and out. And yes, certain times of the day, you just sort of avoid it. The other thing is flight paths. And the interesting thing is when the new airport opens,

part of the hills is going to be impacted. So that's not something that's on necessarily people's radar now, and they don't see that as an issue now, but it's going to be an issue in the future for parts of the hills. Bushfire zones is probably an interesting one.

We're really, you know, we're quite a green suburb, there's a lot of bush around and a lot of buyers think, oh, like whether they're doing knockdown rebuilds or significant renos, being in a flame zone, bushfire prone land. So there's a lot of cherrybrook that's impacted. There's certainly the rural part.

And I do buy sometimes semi rural properties as well. So I've brought a couple in Arcadia this year. One client wanted a vacant block to build and we searched for something that was non bushfire. It's the same in West Pimble, you know, bushfire. The bushfire is a big one.

I think school rat runs and I think these developments and units that are coming up. So even like main parts of Castle Hill that were traditionally quarter acre blocks, 1990s homes, there's pockets that one side of the street is all getting developed, but the other side's not.

And if you're on that other side, or the street behind, and your visitors can't get a park, you're living through construction. Schools is a big thing as well. As I said, schools, schools in the hills, a lot of people are moving to the hills because of the schools.

Chobrooke's one of those areas where it's pretty highly sought after for schooling. But again, there's certain streets where if you expect to get out of your driveway between 8am and 8.30am when all the mums are picking up or dropping off their kids and the same at three, then good luck to you.

So yeah, they're the sorts of things. It's probably similar to most areas, I expect. But, you know, a good BA is across all that. No, and I think that all really matters though. I think the, you know, knowing those things and they are different.

I do feel like, you know, they, you know, and they will change to different suburbs. I think you're right. Schools are such a big part of why people are moving there. They're trying to avoid the private school fees of the east or the north, you know, and they get, ah, similar lifestyle.

I'd have to pay, you know, 600 grand in costs. And I might as well put that into my house rather than to a private school. I mean, what are some of the locals just love and don't love? Like, you know, You mentioned bushfires and leafy, it's a sort of a catch 22.

You get the benefit of nicer climate outlook, being close to nature and connected, but then you've got the risk of the bushfire. But what are some of the things where you think the hills just hate that? They just don't like that type of property and they really struggle to sell.

Probably the units that are going in that aren't well located. So in that sort of parts of Kellyville, North Kellyville, they've put a lot of new units in. A lot of them are in the middle of nowhere. They're not near particularly North Kellyville.

some of them there's a small little shorter shopping center some of them are near that some aren't but they're definitely not connected well to transport transporting the hills is really important for people because even though there is a bigger work from home now but most people have kids that need commuting to sport commuting to school people are still commuting to work at least part of the week so traffic grinds

And some of these newer developments, certainly around that Kellyville, North Kellyville area, are quite concerning for people. And also the other issue is lack of transport. If transport's important to them, and that's why a lot of people have come to the hills now because of the metro.

But if you're not well located to the metro, how do we get there? And parking at the metro has become a real problem. So people are now looking at, well, I've got to get to the metro at 6am to get a parking spot.

literally by seven it's all gone so and then you can't necessarily park on the side streets because they've got limitations of four hours and things like that so that is one like you know transport is is something that if people are driving they want ease of driving if they're using public transport they need to be able to get to the public transport and that's the problem

So parts like North Kellyville, a lot of people aren't liking because of that reason. And the units that are going up there, like literally they're coming up and you're like, where are these units? How are they getting anywhere? And they just create a lot of extra traffic.

So the locals sort of get fed up because it's like, well, now we've just got extra cars because even though they're in a unit, they still have a car, right? So there's this sort of mentality. And even when they build units near the Metro that

These families won't have cars, but they still do. Not everyone just goes on the Metro, right? So Castle Hill particularly, the locals really up in arms about that because even though the ones in Castle Hill, the units that are going up are well located to the Metro, people still have families.

They still drive. They still need to get their kids places. Not everything is accessible by the Metro. So the Metro is great, don't get me wrong. It's fantastic. But the reality of life is that most families still have a car and the roads haven't changed.

And the schools, they're not necessarily building the schools to meet up with the extra demand as well. So some schools are just overloaded with demandables. So that's going to change, but it's a slow process.

Do you find it's the hills has got just such a strong, there's a lot of wealth that sort of people have moved out there because they had flexibility work and they've sort of bought a house and then they've done all right.

Their careers have progressed over the years and they've invested and a lot of them just want to stay in their hills. And then the kids go, well, why would I leave the hills I've got?

you know, family and my babysitter's local and it has got that real strong, steady, you know, people just want to stay there and they go, I could, you know, I might want to go to the beach, but I don't want to downsize.

I'll be too far away from where the kids are going to be. They're never going to be able to afford the beaches. So I'm sort of stuck here as well, even though I potentially could move somewhere else. Is it just, you know, and then they go, well, where else would I go?

It's got everything I want. And so people sort of just stay there. Is that what happens? Yeah, and I've worked with a few clients in the last couple of years that it's exactly that scenario. They've wanted to stay because the kids have ended up buying close.

They've outgrown the big two storey again, the two storey house. If we had more single level homes, Everyone builds two story. The single level homes on a low maintenance block fly out the door.

I brought one recently in West Pennant Hills off market for a client and I said to her, if this came on market, it would be, I mean, we were fortunate. It was an elderly couple living there. It was a very genuine reason why it was off market. But those single level

conveniently located homes, the downsizer market is so strong in the hills for those. It's insane, really insane. Obviously agent relationships are really important with what you do.

What's your sort of approach to sort of making sure that you maintain and also grow those relationships and why do you think it gives you a bit of an unfair advantage over say new buyers agents entering the industry just because you've been doing it so long?

You know, look, I think it's about respect. You know, I respect they have a role to do. I always call them back. Like, you know, open homes, Monday my phone, if I've been out to lots of opens on the weekend, Monday my phone rings off the dial, I always return their calls.

You know, even if my client is not the property we're interested in, just courtesy, respect. Even during a negotiation, right, I respect they've got a job to do. They usually respect that I've got a job to do and we meet somewhere that works for all parties.

Over the years, you know, you do develop stronger relationships with some than others, but a lot of the hills agents and the North Shore agents that I work with have also been around a long time.

I had a situation many years ago where I had a North Shore agent hang up on me about three times and refused to let me into a property because she didn't work with buyer's agents. And I finally convinced her to give me a shot.

And it was actually in my more infancy in being a buyer's agent. I'd probably been a BA only for a couple of years. And I said, well, have I ever done anything wrong? Give me a go anyway. She finally let me in, sat me down, gruelled me.

She was an older lady, very anti buyer's agents because she'd had a really bad experience. So you've got to work with them. Some of them are a little bit more reluctant because they've had a bad experience with a buyer's agent. And unfortunately, at the moment,

I'm hearing more and more stories around that, which makes me very sad. But I do get opportunities because agents know that I respect them. They respect the role that they've got and I've got integrity. So I'm pretty transparent. I don't play coax and daggers.

They know when they work with me that I'm pretty upfront and they know if I say this is what we're doing, we're doing it. So I think that's what works and yeah. I probably misunderstand a lot of say, you know, they've got to come in heavy handed and play.

And I think the kind of forget you're going to get the agents on side, you know, not only to get access to the opportunities, but you know, to actually get prioritization in offers and actually get the benefits of the relationship.

I do think we've seen over the years, clients engage buyers agents that do rub agents up the wrong way. And they actually often get themselves further down the queue and don't get any preference because the, and agents know that those buyers probably won't be in business for long.

And so they're not interested in building the relationships with them because they're like, I just don't think. And so I do think it takes time. I do think you've got to build that trust and then you get the benefits of what you're getting.

But you do need to disarm them and build trust with them fast. Sometimes there's a new agent that you need to sort of educate. Yeah, yeah. And there are, there are, there's new agents in the hills that, you know, I might not have worked with before.

So I, you know, always sort of treat them, I guess, with the same level of respect that I would someone I've worked with before, explain to them that I've been around for a while, I'm not a newbie. And they generally go, oh, okay, great. Okay. Because You know, they also want to work.

Good agents want to work with a good buyer's agent, right? It helps them. You know, they're not hand-holding the buyer. You know, multiple times we have deals where, you know, there's myself and then there's usually competition because I only generally like to buy A-grade properties.

So I say to my clients, we don't want to buy the property nobody else wants to buy because when it comes to resale, you want that property that everyone else wants to buy when you go to buy it, right? And when you're selling it, it's the same deal.

So generally there is competition around. And the good agent relationships that you have, like before I even make an offer, right, I'm asking all the questions upfront about who, what other buyers have you got on this? If I put an offer in, is it going to spark a competition war?

If so, like, are they downsizes? Are they first time buyers? All those questions. And if you've got a good relationship with the agent, they do really are pretty upfront. And I tend to be able to get pretty good intel on the buyer pool before we move forward with an offer.

And that's actually really important. I think that's where a lot of buyers go wrong. They just throw an offer out there and they don't ask any questions around that sort of stuff. And why would the agent tell them? Well, that's right. I mean, it's hard, right?

Even the knowledge itself is not enough, right? You're still a buyer versus an agent. You're not an industry, you know, other representing, you can sort of have a much deeper conversation that a buyer would never get to go and they wouldn't know it. building trust with the buyers is hard enough.

Trying to build trust with all the buyers in the market when you're representing a vendor, just impossible, right? And is that really in the vendor's interest anyway? To be sort of giving, being so transparent with buyers. And so you're only going to shoot yourself in the foot, which might, so it's really hard.

And I think that I think you've got to get access to the insider club, which is to have those conversations. I mean, you mentioned before, which I love, around that what they came in and what they bought were different.

What are some of the other intangibles when they get to the end and they're like, that was amazing, Cathy. I just loved it. I didn't expect this, but that was really, really valuable.

It's not just the typical things that people would think the value buys agents, but all those intangibles that they only realize after they've worked with you that they actually got.

You're right, like the strategy and the actual securing stuff, that's one really valuable thing because it's like, obviously, you know, most good buyer's agents go in and do all the due diligence and project manage all of that and work out what true value, fair market value looks like.

So we all, all the good buyer's agents obviously do that. The things, and that's what people expect of a buyer's agent. I think the things they don't expect are things like, you know what, I think we can do better than this property. Let's walk away from this one. but we like it.

And I'm like, yeah, you like it, but these are its flaws and I think we can do better. I know in one of my Google reviews, one of my clients said that. Kathy used to always say, no, I think we can do better than this property.

I think the other thing are things like when we purchase a property, I go and I take photos of all the inclusions. I test everything. Building inspectors often don't test if the air con works or the oven works or the range hood works, the pool equipment.

So I go in, take photos of all of that and test before we exchange. We come back to pre-settlement inspection. Things do go wrong at settlement. And this is where clients are like, oh, wow, we didn't expect this. I've had laundry cabinets removed. I've had ovens swapped out.

I've had an air conditioner that worked and then didn't work. A dishwasher that literally blew up as I pressed the on button at the settlement inspection. Pool cleaners swapped out, like all sorts of things. They're the things that buyers don't really think about, if you know what I mean.

They go, oh, we'll just cruise through the property, have a look. It looks pretty empty. That's fine. And look, a lot of these things get sewn up at the pre-settlement inspection, like cleanliness and lawn mowing and all of that sort of stuff, which is hard to push.

But if something has been swapped out or isn't working, that was working. But if you don't have proof that it was working when you purchased it, you sort of got no claim, right? There's value-add in that.

I think having a really good network of professionals that I work with, so building inspectors, incredibly important, really hard to find good ones. You know, I've had building inspectors that have just said, run from this property. Like, we've got the vendor report, looks

pretty okay but we get our guys in we've i've had situations where we've had termite active termites in properties this one particular property very popular was going to auction i got my guy there even though we had the vendor report i said not happy to rely on this report got our own guy in there he said kathy i think it's got active termites

So we then got some further investigations. It did. It had active termites. There were 10 other registered bidders at that auction. The agent did disclose to them that we had found active termites. The original inspector who did the vendor report went back out, still denied it. Other buyers got their guys out there.

Oh, no, we can't see anything. I think it's fine, right? We didn't purchase the property. It had a long settlement, however. And one of the other agents that worked in the area rang me because I sort of had the discussion with them at the time.

And she rang me and she said, you know that house that you didn't buy with the termites? Well, it's just settled, I think. And there's a truck, a builder's truck, literally ripping off the back half of that house because the termites had just destroyed it.

now my guy picked that up like i'm not saying like and others others don't so like we align ourselves with good people again when these settlements go wrong and you've got your recommended conveyance or solicitor on it you know things happen it gets sorted the one that i had recently with the oven that was an absolute

nightmare because they also left a heap of rubbish at the house and then the process of moving the oven out so they didn't even properly install it right so i get to the pre-settle inspection in the morning of day of settlement and again i always try to line up my settlements inspections on the day of settlement i don't do them a week in advance or days in advance like some do and the oven was half out of its spot and i'm like this isn't the same oven

You know, the solicitor literally spent her day and I spent a fair hunk of my day. I came back to the property three times to check, you know, on what was going on and making sure that everything got fixed and sorted. So they're the value add things, you know, that again, knowledge, experience,

experience, aligning yourself with good people. Again, brokers make all the difference. When we're particularly in a cool off in the hills, we still do quite a bit in cool off that everything's auction. I've got one cooling off today that will go through. But again, onto the broker.

Again, either brokers we recommend or if the clients, they often come to us with preapproval. So they've often already engaged a broker and sometimes the brokers are good and sometimes they're not so good. And so again, it's critical that we stay on top of the brokers as well and work with them.

And if we can recommend our own, obviously we do. I think you're right. These are things that often, you know, they're one percenters, but sometimes they're more than one percent, right? They're worth a lot to this transaction and they're a lot, you know, professionals.

Now, a lot of people misunderstand that, you know, I can get a building inspector, I can get a conveyance, I can get solicitor. Yeah, but can you get a good one, you know, one who's actually going to provide the value for their service?

Oh, 66Ws at 10 o'clock at night on a Saturday night. I've been able to do that. Good luck. The amount of deals I've done after hours with 66Ws. I had one last Friday night and we were getting gazumped. And again, luckily, you know to ask the right questions, right?

So we had offer and acceptance. I had the 66W in my inbox ready to send. We got offer and acceptance. client paid the deposit. I sent the 66. We're waiting on the contracts to come to us for exchange. Meanwhile, the other buyer upped the offer another 40,000.

And the owner was like, oh, well, we've got this. And I said, wait a minute, we've got offer and acceptance. I forwarded the 66W. We're a sure thing. You've got the deposit. We're just waiting on your contract. Has the other buyer got their 66?

W, they can get it in half an hour or so. And I said it's now 6.30 on a Friday night. How certain are you of that? Because if you're not, it's a pretty big gamble because my buyer is going to walk, you know, because they're just annoyed about getting gazumped, right?

So again, having those sort of contacts. and aligning yourself with good people, it makes a difference to getting a deal done often. A deal done. Oh, absolutely. Just picking up on a past point you do mention earlier on around, you know, I think we can do better. I mean, I love that line.

I think it's something I've heard for a few buyers' agents. I love when a client gets it back to me and says, oh, I spoke to Kathy or, you know, she said, oh, don't buy that property. I think we could do better. And, you know, I think the clients really respect that.

At first, they think, hang on a sec, can't believe she's saying not buy. And then three weeks later, they get something better and they're like, God, I'm so glad. And it's like a life-changing moment for them. And I think of many clients over the years.

But yeah, that's what a true trusted advisor does. So, you know, they really challenge clients. Thanks so much for coming on today, Cathy.

Obviously, we've worked for many years together, both before at House Search, you know, with Jackie, but also under your new business and you're buying the Northwestern Safe Hands with Cathy and the team. And so thanks so much for coming on. Thank you, Chris.

Thanks so much for listening today. We hope you got lots of value out of it. If you'd like to speak to our guests today, there's links in the show notes on how you can get in contact.

And if you're buying your first home, upgrading, renovating, or need any finance-related queries, obviously we'd love to help. There's links in the show notes to us as a mortgage broker, and we look forward to next week's episode.

Click any timestamp to jump.

Key takeaways

  • McGowan has held a real estate licence for over 30 years and has worked as a buyer's agent for 14, including 11 years contracted to Jackie Parker at House Search Australia.
  • Clients often buy somewhere other than the suburb they first named, such as a Cherrybrook duplex instead of a Hornsby townhouse once family plans were on the table.
  • She checks the New South Wales government portal for state significant developments, citing about 10,000 homes contemplated around Cherrybrook and two 40 storey towers proposed at Bella Vista.
  • Local risks she lists include school rat runs, bushfire prone land, future flight paths, and Metro car parks that fill by about 7am.
  • She asks agents about the buyer pool before making an offer, and relies on her own building inspector rather than the vendor's report.
  • Inclusions are photographed and tested before exchange, because ovens, air conditioners and pool equipment have been swapped out or stopped working by settlement.

How Did Cathy McGowan Become a Buyer's Agent?

Cathy McGowan told Chris Bates she has held a real estate licence for more than 30 years and has worked as a buyer's agent for 14 of them. Work experience in a real estate office in year 10 started it, but nerves after her HSC sent her into a Bachelor of Business. A couple of years in chartered accounting convinced her otherwise, so she did her licence and spent four years selling around Dural through a recession.

A stint as an investigator with the Office of Fair Trading followed, then 11 years at the Real Estate Institute in professional development and later in complaint and dispute mediation, where she saw dissatisfaction on all sides. She had also been buying property herself since her early 20s, including subdivisions and rebuilds. She approached Jackie Parker at House Search Australia, one of the original buyer's agents, contracted exclusively to her for 11 years, then started McGowan Property Buyers three years ago.

Why Do Buyers End Up in a Different Suburb?

McGowan covers the north and north-west, most work now in the north-west, including the Hills and pockets such as Cherrybrook and West Pennant Hills that sit between the Hills and the traditional North Shore line. Covering both lets her put a second option in front of a client who arrived fixed on one suburb. She describes downsizers, returning expats and more recent immigration into the Castle Hill and Norwest Bella Vista area, where some pricing is now comparable to the North Shore.

Her example was a first home buyer who asked her to check a townhouse in Hornsby going to auction, on a valuation and negotiation service with the retainer rebated into a full search if they did not buy. Proximity to the station did not matter to them, the parking and yard were poor, and they mentioned they were pregnant. The search widened, and they bought a duplex in Cherrybrook, a suburb they had not considered.

That Hornsby townhouse was heading to auction. Auctioneer Andy Reid has described the contract homework and body language that decide who wins on the day.

The pattern repeats. West Pymble was for years the poor cousin of Pymble and is now gentrified, and buyers who cannot afford Kellyville or Bella Vista can cross into Stanhope Gardens and still walk to Kellyville Metro.

Scenario Matrix: Where Buyers Started And Where They Bought
Buyer situationWhere they startedWhere the search wentReason given on air
First home buyers, pregnantTownhouse in HornsbyDuplex in CherrybrookBigger yard, schools, room to raise a family
Young couples raised on the North ShorePymbleWest PymbleCould not quite afford Pymble; suburb has since gentrified
Hills buyers wanting Metro accessKellyville, Bella Vista, Beaumont HillsStanhope GardensWalking distance to Kellyville Metro, low maintenance block
Lifestyle buyers avoiding upkeepTraditional large blockCommunity title estateShared pool, levies of $300 to $400 a quarter
Hills downsizersTwo storey family homeNorwest and Bella Vista town homesStaying local; $2.5m to close to $3m for the better ones

As described at 10:17 to 16:51. Figures as stated on air.

What Should You Check Around a Property Before Buying?

Much of the conversation was about what is changing around a property rather than the property itself. McGowan says she checks the New South Wales government portal for state significant developments on every job. She points to Cherrybrook, where plans shifted in the last couple of months to contemplate another 10,000 homes, and to Bella Vista, where two towers of 40 storeys each are proposed.

So being across all of that, you can't expect buyers to be across all of that. And their legal advisors often aren't as well.

Cathy McGowan, 18:08

She argues buyers looking at a comparable sale rarely ask why it sold for that number, when the answer can be that it formed part of a development site or will be overshadowed by one. The other hazards she lists are school rat runs, flight paths that will affect parts of the Hills once the new airport opens, and bushfire prone land.

Transport is the other pressure point. She says Metro parking has become a problem, with spots gone by about seven in the morning and four hour limits on side streets, and that units around North Kellyville are poorly connected to shops and transport. In Castle Hill, where the units sit close to the Metro, locals are still unhappy because families keep their cars.

How Do You Avoid Problems Between Offer and Settlement?

On agents, her position is respect and reliability. She returns every call, including the Monday run after a weekend of open homes. Early in her career a North Shore agent hung up on her three times and refused her entry because she did not work with buyer's agents. Because she generally buys A-grade property, she expects competition.

Before I even make an offer, I'm asking all the questions upfront about who, what other buyers have you got on this? If I put an offer in, is it going to spark a competition war?

Cathy McGowan, 31:23

She is equally firm about the people around a deal. On one property heading to auction she declined to rely on the vendor's building report, sent her own inspector, and active termites were found. The agent disclosed it to the other 10 registered bidders, other inspectors disagreed, and her clients walked. A local agent later rang to say a builder's truck was ripping the back half off that house.

She photographs and tests inclusions before exchange, because building inspectors often do not check whether the air conditioning, oven, range hood or pool equipment works, and she books the pre-settlement inspection on the day of settlement rather than days ahead. She also described after hours work on 66W certificates, including a Friday night when a rival buyer lifted their offer by $40,000 after her clients had offer and acceptance and had paid the deposit.

Feature Matrix: Inclusions Checked Before Exchange
InclusionWhat McGowan doesWhat she has seen go wrong
OvenTested and photographed before exchangeOvens swapped out, one half removed on settlement day
Air conditioningTested, as building inspectors often do notA unit that worked at purchase and then did not
DishwasherSwitched on at inspectionOne blew up when pressed at the settlement inspection
Pool equipmentTested and photographedPool cleaners swapped out
Laundry cabinetryPhotographed as part of the inclusions recordCabinets removed before settlement

As described at 33:48 to 34:56. Examples as stated on air.

I think the things they don't expect are things like, you know what, I think we can do better than this property. Let's walk away from this one.

Cathy McGowan, 33:24

Buying in the Hills or on the North Shore?

This episode is about the checks that sit outside the contract, from state significant developments to whether the oven still works on settlement day. If one of these pockets is on your list, what an investment property loan will and will not stretch to shapes the search before the inspections start.

Investment Property Mortgage Broker

Sources referenced: Street Secrets, episode 19, "Cathy McGowan | McGowan Property Buyers | Upper North Shore Sydney", released 2026-01-14. Host: Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: Cathy McGowan, buyer's agent and founder of McGowan Property Buyers. Figures are quoted as stated on air and have not been re-checked against current data.