Curious about upgrading?
Wondering where to start?
Complex questions that need answers?
Is there a better structure for you?
"They managed to navigate my complex expat income and even got my Google RSU income approved as well."
"I highly recommend Alcove to anyone looking for a mortgage broker who is responsive, trustworthy, and truly cares about their clients. Thanks again to the whole team for making the process such a positive experience!"
"As founders, we're constantly jumping between things so having a partner that handled the details & made the process super clear made the buying process breezy for us. Very happy with the experience!"
“It almost felt like it was his responsibility to make it clear to me, not my responsibility to understand it.”
“I've been pretty much fully leveraged the whole time. So the sounding board on that, in terms of what was achievable, what wasn't — I think trust is just built along that.”
"Alcove has been a great partner. They look after my audience properly, keep things simple, and deliver real value. I’ve got full confidence referring clients knowing they’ll get honest, straightforward advice."
"Property is one of the biggest financial decisions people make. Alcove stood out because they take a strategic approach to lending - helping clients structure property and debt decisions in a way that genuinely supports their broader financial plans."
Adapted from audio. This article is a written adaptation of the original podcast episode. Sources and dates are shown with each figure.


Co-host of The Elephant in the Room. Real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
A career sales agent explains the quote trap, the fee scale that exposes what an agent really thinks your house is worth, and why he sends unanswered offers to the vendor's solicitor.
It's not often that I read something written by a sales agent that has me spitting out my teeth, thumping the table and saying, hell yeah. Normally I'm annoyed at sales speak, the unconscious bias and the lack of nuance. But property isn't all about bricks and mortar, it's about people.
And who better than a selling agent to make observations about the often absurd way in which buyers and sellers respond to different market conditions.
Welcome to the elephant in the room. This is the podcast where we love to talk about the big things in property that never usually get talked about.
I'm Veronica Morgan, real estate agent, buyer's agent and buyer's agent mentor, co-host of Foxtel's Location, Location, Location Australia, author of Auction Ready and co-host of Your First Home Buyer Guide.
And I'm Chris Bates, mortgage broker, recently ranked number five in Australia out of over 18,000 brokers in the annual MPA Top 100 Mortgage Broker Awards. Before we get started, I need to let you know that nothing we say here can be taken as personal advice.
We always recommend you engage the services of an appropriate and experienced professional.
Today we're joined by Sydney real estate agent David Murphy, who has come to our attention not through his record-breaking sales nor via pithy Insta reels, but through some old-fashioned wordsmithing in weekly emails that cut through the crap. No other agent has had their email shared around my team with the same frequency.
A genuine career agent, David Murphy started in real estate at the tender age of 19 and he set up his own business in 2007 with the goal of being the leading independent agency in Mossman.
David's weekly emails provide a humorous yet sharp perspective on what's going on in his market, and it usually boils down to some predictable yet rarely acknowledged human behavior. For example, in one December 2022 email, he refers to the slowdown of the market, and I quote, "'Low activity isn't a bad thing.
It means no one is panicking, but it's frustrating. The mathematical formula is unrealistic sellers plus cautious buyers equals real estate agents curse and drink more wine.'" Well, welcome David. We're looking forward to a conversation about what goes on at ground level in the property market. Thank you very much.
And thanks for having me on the show.
David, it's a really, I guess, refreshing, you know, what people really want from agents is that, you know, truth and honesty and real matter of fact, I find. So obviously some people want the opposite, right? They want you to tell how amazing their property is.
But, you know, has this been your approach since day one, back when you were 19? Or have you sort of grown to be this more matter of fact and frank about the way that you approach things? Look, I think there's a bit of both.
When I came into real estate, which was now nearly 25 years ago, on my first day, the people that I started working with had me as a dummy bidder at an auction. And I was 19 and it was day one in real estate. And I was thinking...
How on earth, like, how does this work? And I think I started to develop a bit of a sense of when I walked into people's living rooms pitching for business that if we just called it the way that it was, that most people really, really responded well.
The newsletter started as an internal memo that I used to just send out to the staff as a bit of a joke, and we'd have a crack at local competitors. And then a few years ago, my office manager said, we really need to get this out there.
And we were really surprised at the level of engagement. We do get complaints. I think a lot of agents subscribed in our database, not as agents, but they really let us have it.
But what we find, honestly, is that there's a real hunger out there for people just to kind of hear it the way it is. And real estate's got so much spin that I think
Like Chris, I read some of your posts on LinkedIn and I notice it's authentic and people engage with it because it's honest. People don't want to hear about the red hot market when the auction clearance rates is up 50, 55%. So yeah, it's been a really interesting journey.
The newsletter has turned into a bit of a car that I don't know how to drive because we've now got over 20,000 subscribers and there's pressure every week to come up with something funny. But
Um, we literally have a think tank on a Friday morning and say, what are we seeing out there and, and talk about it. And, and most of the time sort of, sort of hit the mark.
It's so funny because it's like often think you could write a comedy script about, I mean, I guess there is that, what's that thing set in Tasmania called, but that's not quite the same, a proper comedy script about all the things that happen in a real estate agency and all the silly things that people say and all the dialogue that gets said.
You talk about spin and as you're talking, I keep thinking about the way, and look, I've done, I'm guilty. I've been a sales agent as well. It's like you talk about a growth corridor and you're really talking about development. You're not talking about capital growth.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
You know, you're talking about spring is seller's market. No, it isn't. It's buyer's market. It's just, you know, spring has sprung. It's a selling season. It's actually, there's nothing in that for vendors really. It's good to hear actually that you've had that level of response to your emails. 20,000 subscribers, huge.
Yeah.
Do you say that, so I'm guessing then, because I was going to ask, do you say the same things in your listing appraisals? But it sounds like this is the newsletter has sort of evolved from what you've been doing as opposed to the other way around. Yeah, that's true.
I think that we kind of knew we were onto something when after the GFC, when I'd started the business, that we were getting called in and we weren't being pitched against other agents. We were just being called in for discussions. Yeah. And people actually just cared about what we said.
We don't win all of the listings and the business that we pitch for, but we are often called in to have just a meaningful sort of valuable discussion.
So the newsletter, as silly as it is sometimes, I think really is just a response to, look, I go into living rooms all the times and I hear what some of the other agents say to people. And it's just there's such a disconnect between the profession and consumers that
I often say to team members here when I'm training them, don't try and be one of these superstars, just be yourself. Just sit down with people and be honest, and you'd be amazed at the response you get.
But if you think about it yourself, if you call in three agents and two of them are there with a pen, trying to force you to sign something and someone else is there trying to figure out what you're trying to achieve. Should you be selling? Is this the right time?
You're going to win the business or you're going to win the client. And that's not hard work. It's actually easier.
What do you think, David, the BS test? We had a vendor advocate on, we haven't done, just recently. And she was sort of, you know, whole business around vendor advocacy in Melbourne. And, you know, I was kind of like, she's a BS test sort of thing.
You know, she can sort of hear what the agent's saying. I know that's just agent talk, right? They're talking nonsense. And, you know, this is a strategy you might want to.
You know, for that type of, you know, the typical sort of over, you know, buying the listing, you know, for people who are thinking about selling, how do you really, like, how can you identify that type of agent very early on?
What's some of the questions you'd probably ask if you were selling and, you know, and what's some of the things that you would want to know, you know, that you're picking the right agent?
it's a really good question because i think most of the problems come about when people call in three trained charming sales people into their living room and then try and choose which one is the most charming um or the least the least smarmy exactly exactly actually it's funny you say that there was a research thing done about 10 years ago and i think the results of it were that the majority of people chose the real estate agent they disliked the least which i found quite tragic um
But I think the whole quote trap where people get called in or agents get called in and ask, how much is my house worth?
Normally, the issue, and I don't want to sound like I'm standing in front of agents, but I do know what it's like when you really want to win a listing and you know that if you tell the truth, you're not going to win the listing because the other guys are going to be in there talking higher numbers.
But I do think that as a seller, you can find ways to... sort of debunk what the agent's really thinking. And I think things like sliding scales on fee are very revealing. I think if you say to an agent, look, it's great that you think my house is worth three million.
Everyone else thinks it's worth two point five. I want three. So if you can get me three, I'm happy to pay you two and a half percent, where an average fee might be, say, two percent.
But then if you say to the agent, would you be interested in a tiered payment schedule or a sliding scale? And they say, yeah, absolutely.
It's always very telling if you tell the agent to design that scale and present it to you, because in that scale, it'll tell you what the agent thinks your house is worth. Now, it happens to me all the time.
The problem with the newsletter is I get people that call in and read it and go, all right, mate, well, you're still a real estate agent and I have to do that.
But it is a very good sort of way to tell, oh, I see the agent really thinks it's worth about 2.7, not three. I think that's a good start.
I love that because the problem is that everyone plays a part in this, right? The owner is being flattered. And I know, I remember I was a sales agent. I know I've had friends list properties. We do vendor advisory work as well.
I get the pull to go with that person who, and inverted commas, believes in my property. Oh, totally. It's irresistible. Look, I sold my house last year and I said to a colleague, get some people through it. And if they offer me this, I'll give them the keys.
And one of my colleagues, Bindi, brought a bunch of people through. The third person that came through offered me that number. And I was like, get another $100,000. And she was like, you're doing what we see all the time. And of course, she didn't get it.
We sold the house and it all worked out well. But I think it's very hard when you're trying to value your own home and your future. Like if I sit in front of you and say, I can get you $3 million, you do want to believe it. And that's where it gets tricky.
And I do empathize with sellers a lot where They go, look, David, we trust you. We feel like you're being completely straight with us. But if the other guy can get us that because he believes in it. And that is a tricky space to sort of to pull apart.
What's your thoughts, David, around the things that are wrong with the property, the compromise the buyers are ultimately going to make? In a hot market, buyers make lots of compromises, right? The compromise is, if I don't buy now, I'll never buy, sort of in their mindset, right?
So in this market, though, everything's telling, right? The veil's been lifted, the stairs, the road, the noise, the privacy, et cetera.
how do you sort of approach that like let's say you you know the property is sellable i guess every agent thinks every property seller bought a certain price but how do you how do you deal with those up front rather than you know later on in the campaign when you know oh we're not selling it for what you said because people aren't well that you could we knew that at the start that people weren't going to like that um so why are you bringing my price down so how do you deal with things that are wrong with the property from a buyer's point of view um with the seller
That's another good question. I think it's very difficult to call someone in. It's that whole like, do I look good in this dress thing, right? You can't win no matter which way you go with that.
I will say this year that we've won a lot of the sales that we've won, we've actually been the second agent because we've sat in front of people and said, it's not worth that because the stairs. I mean, the point you make is a very good one.
We're in a far more discerning market now and
um uh there's that saying that when what is it when desperation rises standards fall and we're in a market now where people will walk away and go it doesn't have a fence down the southern boundary and you think well i can get you a fence you know it's a 10 grand but um i look i think the way that i try to deal with it is to talk to people explain that being objective when they're selling their property actually adds value to the process because
Real estate full of so many paradoxical moments where like when your house goes on the market first, you'll generally get your best offers. But when your house has gone on the market first, you've just been through two and a half months of decluttering, getting in stylus.
You don't want to give it up on the first week. You kind of want to see who else is out there. But I think if a seller can enter the market with an agent that they know is being honest enough with them when they're looking to hire.
that they're probably going to be hiring someone that when they're on the market is going to be able to guide them through the process. And look, trust, it's so shmarmy to sit in front of someone as an agent and say, look, it's really important that you trust your agent.
But I've got clients I've worked for now three or four times and they call me up and say, we want to move in March. What do you think? The market's the market. We all know that. If you get lucky, you could get an amazing price.
But I think you do need to understand the shortfalls of your property before it goes on the market because If you waste time on market or on stage, as I often say to clients, downloading negative feedback, it can cost you in the end. So, look, it's not easy.
It's not easy to have a mortgage and sit in front of someone and think, if I fumble the ball here, I'm going to lose an $80,000 fee. And, you know, the guy down the road at X, Y and Z real estate is going to win the listing.
But it's a bit of a leap of faith. And I think that most people are unlucky in the area that I work in. pretty switched on, pretty commercial, and they recognise it and they can smell the BS when it's in front of them.
But look, even this morning, my assistant said to me, we didn't get that one in Neutral Bay and it's a $3 million property and I know it'll sell for what we think it'll sell for. In fact, can I tell you a funny story? But that doesn't pay you though, right?
So that doesn't get you paid. And that must be the hard thing from an agent. You sort of miss out on it. You know someone's overquoted it. You know they're going to get the sale for a price that you've told.
But the person selling it will go, oh, David told me it was going to sell for $2.75. But the commission has gone to the agent that overquoted it. That must, as an agent's being honest out there, is that sort of how do you deal with that?
Well, you often get them next time around, like six or seven years down the track. It's interesting. I was just thinking about something. I went to a realestate.com think tank a couple of years ago and they said to me and a bunch of agents, how do we make this website more consumer friendly?
And I sort of put my hand up being a bit naive and said, why don't you track the agents with what they quote on day one for the property's worth? And then form a ratio or some sort of indicator that, you know, Veronica's 90% accurate or David's 85% accurate.
And the room erupted like all the agents like, oh, you know, there's no way we'd do that. But I mean, how good would that be if you're looking online and you could sort of tell? So the price issue is tricky.
I love that. The room erupted. No way we're going to do that. I mean, I've sat in some real estate briefings as well. You know, I've been around 20 odd years and I still remember one about underquoting. It was bringing in the new underquoting laws back in 2016.
And just like people were tripping over themselves to ask questions like, how can we get around it? How can we get around it? Do you know what? I'll say one thing about that.
I've been thinking about that a lot recently because recently we got the microscope put on us by Fair Trading because the prices have fallen. So our price guides have changed and there's been a couple of occasions where the property has looked like it's being underquoted, but it's not.
We just don't have any interest in the house.
but i look i think that when buyers start their buying journey they have an unrealistic picture of what they can buy and when sellers start their selling journey they generally have an unrealistic picture of what they'll get and agents live in that space in between um and thank god because if people weren't unrealistic they'd probably be transactions you know made left right and center where people would just be like
Yeah, okay, I'll take that. That's a fair price where agents have to manage it. So it's tricky. Like having just bought and sold, I paid more than I wanted to. I didn't get that extra 100 grand. Objectively, we did all right.
It's funny you say that because it was one of my issues with a lot of these real estate, the new prop tech solutions that supposedly deal with this lack of trust in the industry.
And it's what they've failed to understand is just because an AVM says a property is worth something does not mean the vendor is going to accept that and does not mean the buyer is going to pay that. And that's really where the role of a good agent comes in.
But I've noticed quite a lot what happens in a market that turns down. So I've definitely noticed this at sort of the beginning of COVID and I certainly noticed this in the second half of 2022 is
You get agents who use fear to encourage vendors to list now because obviously it's in an agent's best interest to you list now. It's not in my best interest as a sales agent to say, oh, wait till next year.
I think that, you know, there'll be less stock in the market or be better conditions or whatever.
And so you hear this peddling and I'm quite surprised even from agents that I've respected that really pushing this idea that next year the market's going to fall off a cliff and all this sort of stuff.
What do you think, what goes through your minds when you hear that sort of dialogue from sales agents to potential vendors? We're hearing that like a huge increase in that. In fact, I saw a property the other day and I think the auction's about four days before Christmas Day.
And when I spoke to the owners, they rang me and said, do you think it's too deep into the Christmas season? Like it's three or four days before Christmas. It's pretty deep in the Christmas season. Hell yeah. Again, I think that the issue here is that
It's been a leaner year for real estate agents.
I know our sales figures are down sort of 20 to 25% on last year. So I think there are a lot of agents that have had a pretty tough year.
I'm not asking for everyone to sort of feel terribly sorry for them, but I think that that is a driving factor for why agents, it's very competitive at the moment. Every year when the December media cycle starts, I always hear this next year is going to be the year.
It's like the media just turns towards a very speculative stage about what next year may or may not be.
And every year, Q1 of the new year, I've seen, and I might be wrong because of the rates and there's all these other factors, but I've seen the market actually come back with a little bit more life. Yeah.
and outperform q4 of the year before so i'm not an economist i often say to clients i can't i can't predict what will happen but i think of an agent sitting in front of you right now saying there's still time for an auction campaign this year um it's it it makes no sense to me to step into this market the market's exhausted it's been a long year and i think with all the rate rises
You're dealing with a very – I hope you agree with that, Chris. Like, I do read your articles and I like the fact that they're data-driven and direct. But what we're seeing is a market that needs a reset, needs a break.
And I just think that consumers – to answer your question, Veronica, I think that consumers just need to be aware of if an agent's coming into your house pushing for a listing and a sale – they're looking for a commission.
If they're not talking options, they're looking for a commission. I've been there. I mean, I've got the luxury of age now where I'm, you know, in my 40s and I've had a fairly good career.
So it does come with time that you can afford to sit in front of someone and say, listen, you know, maybe you should wait, you know. And I think back when I was 22, 23, sitting in living rooms going, no, no, no, the market's going to crash next year. There's the bird flu.
There's like all these different things. Yeah, the Y2K, the bird flu. There's always something. But I think based purely on supply and demand, I'm very bullish medium to long term of property in Sydney.
And I think if people are in no need to sell, it's a buyer's market at the moment. There's no need to entertain it. Yeah.
I mean, that's sort of Asian. You have to think you're a pretty good actor though, right? Because, you know, one minute you, you know, you walk in, you're sitting in the lounge room, right? And you're like, market's going to collapse, right?
Next minute, you leave the front door, jump in your car, go to an open home. And now you've got to be like, oh, what a great room to buy. And so you'd have to be like almost bipolar in a sense to be able to play both of those things realistically.
And that's, I think from a long-term point of view, they're the agents that are gonna crash and burn because they gotta get it wrong. It's the same in financial planning world. I was that.
I was reading the wrong things early days, being an advisor, reading the wrong newsletters, listening to the wrong, going to the wrong events, et cetera. And you think that marketing proves, shows that financial advisors can outperform markets. That's what we were told. That's what the whole sales industry is.
Then you realize after a few years, hang on a sec, I've made it wrong three or four times. Actually, there's index funds just to perform, outperform, and you get those learnings. But that abundance mindset, I think,
um will carry you through long terms where veronica said oh it's not in their interest what is actually in your interest to be frank and play the long game um it's the only way you're going to survive um yeah and you only get better results i think the north shore um mindset though every community's got um you know different people right different cats i guess the north shore sort of mindset such a long-term generational wealth
What are some of the things that people who don't know that marketplace that really perpetuate it and sort of give it sort of stability, you know, parents and the kids reinvesting?
And how does that all sort of play out that people just don't understand the power of, you know, established markets to hold their value versus, say, new markets where people are much more flippant? Yeah, it's a good point.
I think that the main thing is established wealth because I think when the market changes, what I've noticed for listeners that don't know, I'm based in sort of Mossman Cremor neutral way, very lucky in that space because it is a very affluent area.
when the market changes significantly locals buy the property like they you know if someone lives on spencer road in mossman and all of a sudden a semi that used to be 2.4 million is now 1.9 you know somebody who's been on the street for 30 or 40 years will have the equity to buy that because they know that in you know two three years time it'll be back um
I've got this theory that like after a couple of glasses of wine that Australia being relatively newly settled, we've got a blind faith in settlement and in property and that underpins the market.
I think at the end of the day, we all believe that if you've got a decent house on a decent street over time, it'll go up. And it's fair call to think that because if you look historically, the numbers sort of support it. But I think...
areas like the low and offshore of Sydney, there's so there's hardly any new property being built. There's all this pressure there from locals, from people returning from overseas. There's always a market. Even now, when I talk about it being a buyer's market, We're only playing 15% off the highs of last year.
It's not a bad market. It's just not quite what it was. So the observation that I've made around here over the years is because it's quality property, people know or they collectively believe that medium to long term wise, the property will keep going up in value.
And in a sense, that creates a false bottom in the market that everyone on the street goes, I wouldn't sell at the moment. There's no way I'd take $2 million for this place. So I feel like there's that self-sourcing element, but it's true. There's only a limited number of houses.
We're in a beautiful city in a beautiful country in a great part of the world and a lot of people want to live here.
But that's sort of the definition of market value, isn't it? A willing seller meets a willing buyer. And, of course, if you've got unwilling sellers, they don't need to meet the market, then, of course, that's why you've got that floor.
Yeah.
It is interesting, though, because you still, and I remember being a sales agent, I remember you still got to deal with sort of know-it-alls that turn up to your open houses and trying to tell you it's all going to fall through the floor.
It could be wishful thinking because they're not in the market themselves. Oh, yeah, people that didn't buy before 2016. Yeah, yeah.
There's always that person who will never get in the market because it's never good enough for them. I guess what frustrates you the most about buyer behaviour and some of those lines that they'll trot out and they don't realise that they're not the only person to have said that?
Yeah, look, I think buyers have had a bit of a comeback this year. They've sort of been treated badly for the last two years and sort of humiliated at auctions.
I know my sister-in-law went through six months of turning up and attending auctions on the northern beaches and just getting absolutely, you know, it was actually terrible because she was going through a lot.
I think buyers have come back in this market in 2022 with a bit of revenge up their sleeve and turning up to auctions.
And we had an auction two weeks ago, in fact, where we had three registered buyers and three other buyers that didn't register, but they just heckled the auction because it didn't get to reserve. And, you know, they loved it.
And I was kind of standing there thinking, how much time do you have on your hands if you're doing this on a Saturday morning?
Look, I think what buyers need to sort of be mindful of is, particularly if it's for a home, you don't win by going in and being... difficult with the agent. I know a lot of agents are difficult to deal with and having just been through it, I totally empathize with that.
But if the agent that you don't like or have been pretty tricky with lists the house that you do like, you're in a really tricky position because it scares me sometimes how much power agents have in the process because they're the conduit between the market and the vendor. And
You know, what I see sometimes at open houses is buyers come in, be openly critical of a property, talk the price down and sort of walk out the door like they, you know, have just won the day.
And then a week later, that agent's got the house they want and they put themselves into a tricky spot. But again, I understand it because I think if you look at underquoting and people literally like I bought a house, I bought a house last year.
And the price guide was 20, I think 22% below what we had to pay to buy it. Now we knew it was under, but my partner at the time, she was like, oh my God, I can't believe we can afford this property. And I'm like, we can't, like we're getting played.
But then I got into a bidding war and she was so invested in buying the house that I was in this really, it was a good learning. Cause I was like, gosh, like, Now we have to buy it.
And for people that miss out at auctions, it always makes me think when you look at an auction, there's always that celebration for the person that wins. But there's normally two or three people left in the garden that are gutted. Yeah. It's a really difficult...
a difficult a difficult thing to deal with so i think look this what i see a lot of is buyers now coming back being like oh this is our market and you guys are going to suffer and you're going to have to sell that range over and all that sort of stuff and um i don't drive a range over by the way just just for the record
I do like them. I do like them. Isn't Maserati the new thing? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
I was going to say. It's a Lamborghini SUV. David, I mean, I guess, on that though, with the liking the agent and not liking the agent, I mean...
How do you feel about agents actually putting preference to the buyer that they ultimately do like or the buyer that, you know, maybe it's not that obviously there's a vendor interest, right?
But if they can get a vendor around that money and then also sell it to the buyer that they like or the buyer that they think deserves it the most,
How active do you reckon that is in the market where, you know, maybe they go back to them for the final offer or maybe they, you know, give them access a bit earlier so they can get their ducks lined up versus some other buyers or, you know, maybe you give them a bit of extra information that really puts, you know, encourages them to make an offer.
How do you think that plays out in the market and how important it is to get the agents on your side? Do you think that there is a benefit there? I think it's a really, really good question that raises some very tricky issues.
I think a lot of agents will favour buyers that have a property to sell. Yes.
And look, to be honest, what I don't want to come off here is that I'm not perfect and we've got it wrong before and we don't win all of our business.
So I don't want to sit here and sound like the white knight of real estate that's going to come out and sort of save everyone. But I think if you're... Their awareness is really valuable in the market.
And if a purchaser walks up to an agent and says, I really like this property and we own the one around the corner, it might be a semi or whatever it is. And if you help me get this, we'll give you our listing. That is a really...
tricky thing that happens in the market, and we see a lot of it. And I think it's important for a seller to understand that when their agent's communicating to them who they are, where are they coming from, are they sold? If not, are they talking to you about selling their place?
It's fine if they are. But I think it's information as a seller that you should have.
because you're right chris sometimes processes get accelerated because the agent will go well hang on if i sell it to him we'll get the one around yeah that's two deals um the owner will never not um and i think this is where the prop tech things that you talk about veronica that are coming into the mix and one will come along i'm sure that um that disrupts the industry i'm sure like it just feels like an industry that's right for it um to give
people full visibility. But yeah, that's the biggest thing I've come up against where I will often say to a friend who's trying to buy a property, did you make the offer? Yes. Did you put it in writing? Yes. Have you had a response? No. I'm like, send the offer to their solicitor.
And they're like, why would I do that? I don't want to annoy anyone. And so you need to make sure that offer gets to the owner. And look, most of the times it does, but once in a while it doesn't. And you've uncovered that this particular agent is shepherding someone.
And yeah, I guess they're just things that you sort of need to be aware of. Can you cut the agent out, though? The agent gets a bit pissed off with that, though. Oh, yeah. And the agent's like, hang on a sec. You know, I was just getting back to you.
I was just speaking to the vendor. And then it all feels like you're almost put to the bottom of the pile then. Is that a risky strategy sometimes to play? Totally risky. And do you know what? I think that it is risky because you don't want to disenfranchise that agent.
But, I mean, if you've made an offer and three days later you haven't had a response. Yeah. Either that agent is lazy or something's not quite right. But look, there are a lot of really, really good agents in the marketplace.
And over time, you start to see which agents have consistent performance and which ones will be helpful. And it's not a popularity contest. It's like if you're looking for a particular house and they can help you, then that's great.
But yeah, look, I have new staff that come into this office and I often say to them, real estate,
will knock your socks off you'll see things in property that you just wouldn't believe and it normally takes two weeks before they come up and be like oh my god i can't believe that you know this happened or yeah the reality show the reality show that's not lux listings with the guys cruising around in the bentley's the the real reality show would be very watchable i think
I'm on a personal mission to help more people make better property decisions. And you can find out all about what I'm working on at veronicamorgan.com.au.
And there you'll find resources for first home buyers, details about my buyer's agent mentoring program, access to suburb help for investors, or if you're looking to buy your dream home or an investment property in Sydney's inner west, eastern suburbs, or lower North Shore, you can connect with my team at Good Deeds Property Buyers.
And if you'd like a 30% discount plus free postage for my book, Auction Ready, How to Buy Property Even Though You're Scared Shitless and Yes, I'm a Potty Mouth, use the code ELEPHANT at the checkout, bronicamorgan.com.au.
If you're thinking about buying your first home, upgrading to a new one or purchasing an investment property anywhere in Australia, we would love to carefully guide you through this journey and importantly, get the finance right. Please reach out via our website, wealthful.com.au.
Don't forget that you can download our free full or forecaster report. Which experts can you trust to get it right? Theelephantintheroom.com.au.
It's the conversations that you have in those living rooms. It's the conversations when the auction is passing in. It's the conversations you have when, you know, you've got three buyers and you've just got to really...
It's all the sort of the story behind it, the lives that you're actually changing, I guess, and the stresses...
um and why they're selling and the story with the neighbor and everything like that that's i think the fun of real estate rather than the the glitz and glam of the money i guess but it's uh it's chris that's why i still do it i mean i often get asked by friends like you you've been doing this for 20 years like why do you still do it and um even as early as yesterday i went into a living room and met a woman who'd recently lost a husband and she it had been revealed to her that there were significant financial issues and i was like you
hang on hang on you don't need to sign up with an agent right now you need a good financial advisor you need an accountant you need you need like help and I was driving away from the house thinking I don't think I'll get that house because I feel like she's told me too much and I've noticed sometimes in my job that if someone opens up to you too much you won't get the gig because they'll go and they'll walk the dog with a friend and they'll be like oh my god I can't believe you told the guy that and
But the real estate's messy. I often say to friends it's like making sausages, that if you kind of knew what it was like working in a real estate office, you wouldn't do it because it's dealing with people going through divorce. It's going people in debt. It's really messy. It's not lux listings.
Look, it might be for those guys and good on them, but more often than not, I'm going home thinking about Dealing with someone who's, you know, just their relationships collapse. We've seen a lot of that this year.
I think of the sales that we've made this year, such a huge percentage were from divorce that it impacted the team. We're dealing with a lot of really, really tricky situations.
It is tough, and I think, too, from the trusted advisor perspective of a real estate agent, there's a small cohort of agents who see themselves as trusted advisors. There's also a cohort that think that they're trusted advisors, but they're not.
They give the same advice to everyone, basically, and they think they're trustworthy, but they just don't even get it, that there is a bigger – There's a bigger picture, you know, involved.
And, you know, what you're talking about there about the advising people that, look, actually slow down, don't sell until you've got these other ducks lined up. That's quite holistic advice.
And certainly on the buyer's side of the equation, I find that frustrating too because we will do that same, exactly that same conversation with clients. Don't buy yet. Go and get these things sorted out before you buy. Yeah.
Unfortunately, like you say, they might go for a walk with someone who says, why did you tell them that? Oh, you need to go and talk to someone else and not tell them anything. But the reality is that people do need to share this stuff.
If they can find a trusted advisor, they do need to share those things so they do get good advice. It's rare to get that when you're not being paid for it because a sales agent only gets paid when you sell.
At least I can actually, you know, I do property strategy sessions and people might pay for my advice. But in our pre, you know, our sort of sales pitches, if you like, to potential clients, we're not being paid at that point, you know, and we are giving advice often slow down.
But then you will get unscrupulous operators who they don't even think they're unscrupulous. They just think that they've got a job to do and they're quite transactional in their thinking.
Yeah.
And they will swoop in and they'll go, no, no, no, no, no, you can sell, you can buy. And unfortunately, you can't protect people from that.
I'd love to be able to, but you can't because, you know, human beings and they will knee jerk and they will make decisions that aren't necessarily in their best interest. So that must be frustrating. I mean, it's always been frustrating for me.
And I've seen business not come our way because we've had a similar approach to you. But I've also seen people come back second time and I've also seen people refer us where they didn't choose us and wish they had.
So I know how that can come back if you do have a long-term view. But I am curious to know what are some of the things that do frustrate you the most about vendors? Because they will say stuff, won't they? And they will trot out these lines.
Well, I can tell you now, my partner had a baby last week. It was our first child. Congratulations. Stay with me, but I had to leave the auction to go to the hospital. Oh, wow. Yes, I was talking about the reality show.
But when I left the auction, I won't put all the numbers in because it would be too sort of easily identifiable. Okay. the parties were $200,000 apart on a $10 million property.
And when I was at the Royal North Shore, I was texting the team saying, is it done? Is it done? Is it done? And it's still not done. So that was a week and a half ago. And...
What I sometimes see with owners, the reason I tell that story is they become so fixated on a number that their friends might have told them or an agent might have told them or I might have told them.
I mean, I often say to people, I think it's worth this, but we obviously won't know. But vendors in particular, I think sometimes lose sight of why they're doing what they're doing. And in this instance, they want to retire.
They can retire now. And I think anybody who's been through life, you kind of see time is one of those things that it's only important when you realize when something happens. And I often try, I work with a lot of downsizes and say, guys, like, you don't have to sell.
But if you make this work, and you can go and spend time with the grandkids, get on with it. Like, you know, we've just seen the biggest property boom in the last 20 years. Why are you waiting on that? There's that.
Vendors that insist people take their shoes off before they come into their house. Oh, yes. Isn't that extremely frustrating? Because when you're running an open house and you've got 20 groups coming through, that's 40 shoes plus partners, plus friends. So that's not ideal.
Why do people put white carpet down is what I've got to ask. I mean, seriously, what a dumb decision. But, no, I agree. It's one of my bugbears. I always hate it when I wear the wrong boots out on a Saturday opening. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, it's a funny thing, open houses.
You get people to come in and use the bathroom mid-open. There's just things that I often tell my mum stories and she's like, oh, my God, I can't believe this happens. It happens all the time. It's just how it goes.
But look, to get back to your question, I think frustrations with vendors, look, normally it's fear, right? Normally there's something going on in the background that is preventing a decision.
Indecisiveness is obviously tricky. But, you know, again, I get it. Like when I sold my house last year, I got offered the money I wanted and took me three quarters of a bottle of wine and a long walk to accept the offer.
And it was confronting how difficult it was. So I think that, you know, it's so easy. Like I'm working on this deal I just mentioned to you before and my team is saying to me this morning, we any closer? I'm like, we're 50 grand closer, but we're still miles apart. But
you know, people are people, they'll make decisions. Those people will always sell with me. It might take another three months, but, you know, we'll get there. But yeah, I think price is probably the main thing where I think people say, I got a valuation for 4.5 million from the bank last year.
That's the number. And you sit with them and think and say, look, you've just had 7,000 people through the place. Like it's 4.1, you know?
But that'll probably be, or the other thing that I know Bindi would say, she's not here who works with me on every file.
Vendors that won't do any, make any effort to get the property ready for market is madness. It's madness. Most buyers have 15 to 20 minutes in your house and then they're forced to make a major decision.
If you don't put the time and energy into presenting your property, you are costing yourself money. And we see it. We see it often where people go, it's too hard.
It comes back in drives. Especially these days. When I first started in real estate, like only the very special properties were styled, you know. But now everything, you style a one-bedroom apartment, you know, like you practically style for rental now. So actually you probably don't have to for rental anymore.
It's funny you say that because it is funny you say that because we realised something in the office a couple of weeks ago that the sale properties that we sell that were styled and then the marketing that we use from those dead sale properties always lease. Like that, like straight away.
And so our rental department's kind of like, well, how do we get around it? And virtual styling is not popular because it's kind of weird.
It does look weird. Yeah. But I do think that people not investing a little bit of money into the presentation of the house, that's frustrating because you can see them losing money. Yeah. The whole anchoring to a price, I mean, it happened this morning with a client.
You know, it's a frustrating thing. He came to me like three, four years ago, you know, it was an apartment somewhere in Sydney, high density. After he purchased it, I was like, I could see the writing on the wall. I knew there was a lot more developments coming.
And it's just been a year, maybe 18 months trying to get them to upgrade, you know, a little baby and, you know, and it's tight, right? If they sell it at this price, they're only going to get this much cash because it hasn't gone up.
It's actually gone down in value over four years. And even now he's making offers and it's like 15 grand difference, you know, 2% difference to the sale price potentially. But it's so fixated to that number and it's like... And what's the opportunity cost to you? What's the benefit are you trying to sell?
What are you going to achieve? And I think it's so hard to shift your brain from the pain of life not working out or the situation not being what you want it to be to what it could become in the future and taking people on that journey.
David, as someone probably in one of the most competitive markets in the country, I've got to throw a bit of a curveball towards Veronica here.
What's your thoughts on the sort of the buyers agents and the evolution of that industry and the pros and cons and how to get the best result from a buyers agent for someone who would have been dealing with them for a long, long time?
You know, I'm really surprised how prevalent buyer's agents have become. I think earlier in my career, I thought, nah, you know, this won't be, this won't catch on. And again, I think the benefit of time, it's now a thing.
I think we did a calculation that about 20% of the transactions now that we do in our market involved, or there's a buyer's agent involved. So they're here to stay.
I've used a buyer's agent to buy an investment property in Queensland. I think that added a lot of value because I didn't know the market and he did and he was referred to me and I trusted him and it was a good experience.
I think if you're fairly commercial and you've got the time, you don't need a buyer's agent. That's my genuine feel because I think that the realestateanddomain.com is where most of the market is. Most off-market stuff's overpriced. I'm sorry, folks. I hate to say that, but
the whole off market thing, in my experience is someone that's too afraid to put a sign out the front because I think the neighbors will laugh at them. So the buyers agents often pitch this, I can get you the house that no one else knows about. Well,
The best houses are always, well, mainly, not always, but mainly do appear on market. So if you've got the time and you can find your own property, I think you don't need a buyer's agent.
If you are time poor and you are happy to pay for the service, there's value because it's someone on the ground. But I think people, again, need to be very mindful of the fact some buyer's agents don't even work Saturdays. They don't come to our Saturday opens. So they don't work Saturdays.
That's why I got out of being an agent because it's too hard. So if you're paying someone 2% on a purchase and they're not even going to the Saturday opens, what planet Anyway, that's a whole other thing.
My view is that there's a small percentage of people that really would benefit from having a buyer's agent. I think there's a fairly high percentage of people that would benefit from having someone to bid on their behalf at an auction.
Because if you don't know auctions and the first time you attend an auction, you're one of the registered parties, you are vulnerable. You're going into a very stressful situation. I bid all the time on behalf of clients. I've been doing this for half my life.
I still get super, super anxious before an auction. And it's not even my money. Like I'm walking up the driveway going, oh.
and like it's it's a very very sort of stressful process so i i would say to people out there that you know should you use a buyer's agent if you've got time to look probably not if you don't know what you're doing at an auction you should definitely pay someone to go and bid on your behalf or at least stand next to you because you will make decisions um on the auction floor um that you wouldn't have thought that you would make uh it's it's very very overwhelming
Before I sort of cut in there, which I will, of course, question for you, David, do you believe that every property is a good property as long as it's at the right price? No. Oh, that's good. That's good. Yes. I feel like I'm in trouble here. No, no, no, you're not.
Interestingly, what you've done for me. I was going to sit back here with a. No, no, no. Veronica's just opened a buyer's agent's business. No, no, no.
I'm not going to defend the use of buyer's agents per se, mainly because I think what you've done, you've described your experience of the buyer's agents you've worked with.
And what you've actually described to me is a sad indictment on the buyers' agents, particularly in the Lower North Shore anyway, because if the only pitch from them is the off markets, which you've said is mostly overpriced crap that basically wouldn't really cut it on the open market, and I totally agree.
I think that's just a very lame and obvious pitch for someone in terms of a value-add.
The real value, and then bidding at auction, sure, that's sort of overcoming the fear and the stress of a very pressure situation where you're out much, you don't really know what you're doing because you're unfamiliar with that environment and high sums of money.
But one of the things that you said earlier, which I wanted to pick up with, and you said you're scared sometimes, I think you used that word, about the amount of power a sales agent has at times. Yes.
you're the conduit between the buyer and the seller and unfortunately in my view most buyers agents aren't up to the task of actually meeting you and and fulfilling I guess some
What's the word? Bridging that gap between the power you have and the lack of power that the buyer has. That's where a really good buyer's agent makes their money. That's where they're worth it because they basically can interpret all that stuff that you know, all that power that you have.
They're like the whisperer. But there's very few with that level of skill, right? Yeah. I mean, quite frankly, I've been surveying buyer's agents because I've launched a mentoring program.
So this is perfect because the reason I've done so is because there's a real shortage of skills out there in buyer's agency because you can go and do a licensed course and
And, you know, until recently in New South Wales, you know, I could set up business as a buyer's agent without actually learning one thing about being a buyer's agent. And you've learned how to sell property.
You've learned how to put a property on through property management, but you haven't actually learned how to be a buyer's agent. So I guess what you're, as a sales agent, your insights there are really telling to me about really the caliber of buyer's agent out there. And I would agree with you.
that if that's all you're dealing with, that's what you're seeing out there in the marketplace, then yeah, buyers, if they've got the time and the energy and the inclination, would be better off not using one. Totally. Look, you touch on a really good point.
I think in real estate, on both sides of the coin, being real estate selling agents and buyers agents, the available training in the industry is pretty woeful. Most of it's about getting new business.
It's not about execution. And you're right about, I should make the comment, there are some very good buyers agents because they know how to read what the agent's doing. They really can play the game.
It's actually a bit sad to me that they are in some ways necessary in a landscape where it's like vendor advocacy. Isn't it a shame that there needs to be a business to help people to choose it? Someone in business.
But the training element is whenever I've gone to conferences in the past, most of the time it's about how to win new business, how to manage 10 campaigns, how to sell more advertising.
It's not like how to negotiate when you're stuck between a Scottish owner and a Chinese purchaser, which is the deal I just described before. Very challenging. But the actual...
the craft of being a buyer's agent i haven't seen anywhere where that's taught literally i've literally just finished a pilot program because it isn't taught anywhere yeah so selling agents should look out because i can tell you it's not just buyers agents a lot of selling agents couldn't negotiate their way out of a a corner yeah um they think it's all just price they won't look at terms like it's a
You get a well-educated person that comes into real estate that understands negotiation and understands communication and expectations management in the right way. They just run rings around a lot of the people that are in the industry. Yeah.
David, I'm not trying to different... Ah, so you go, Veronica.
No, I was about to say, as long as they can divorce themselves, because, I mean...
when you're a buyer it's your money and there's emotion involved even if you're an investor a lot of people say oh i'm not emotional about the purchase you know but sometimes fear drives that lack of emotion or the perceived like or attempted lack of emotion and so there's always emotion involved to a degree and i know myself i'm an expert right i i live and breathe this stuff when i'm buying a property it's extraordinarily stressful because it's my money you know and i treat other people's money with utmost respect
But it's still I don't have the emotional tie to their money that I have to my own. And I've made mistakes when I've left it to myself, you know, with my money and my ultra caution with my own money. And I should have thrown caution to the wind on a cup.
I should not have ever thrown caution to the wind. But there's two deals I know now that I will live forever regretting not buying those two properties and I could have bought them, you know. Yeah.
we all have those we all have those yeah yeah like i drive past many houses that i wish i'd bought and i'm like oh gosh yeah so david you've made a active choice not to go uh and last i'm sure you've been hunted and uh by bell by mcgrath by lj by reynon horn etc and you've made an active decision to not go down a franchise model or
become part of a big group what sort of drove in your i guess uh resilience to stay independent as a boutique because in the real estate age it's so prolific right like it's almost like people are hunting each other and it's all about the franchise but there's very few boutique players that sort of hold their ground um yeah what's the reason for that and why i guess you're passionate about it because you have to be just to stick around
Yeah, look, it's funny. I mean, in weaker moments, again, if I've had a couple of glasses of wine, I'll often say to friends, had I gone and joined McGrath 12 years ago, we'd be all sitting out in the back of my boat, blah, blah, blah.
Because, you know, I think the reality is that particularly during the boom when it was at full steam, the major franchises did amazingly well. And a lot of their top agents were super, very, very good agents. And they really...
revolutionized the business i mean i think credit to john mcgrath where it was due at the time real estate was very archaic and that business came along and and and lifted the bar and and it did but then it went you know obviously on its own journey um i nearly i nearly went and worked with with them way back when and i think the thing that made me nervous was the um lack of um
flexibility, like sitting in front of a client that, you know, maybe doesn't need to sell, but will sell if they get a certain number. But, you know, you don't have to rope them up into a $20,000 auction campaign. A lot of those franchise models are very, there's a prescribed formula.
And to be honest, I can't sit in front of someone and say, I reckon you should do this when I kind of know deep down, you shouldn't. And I always found that quite
We've only had a bit of interest from other... I think the newsletter has probably kept a lot of the franchises at bay because I don't really want to box in the hen house. But I think, look, being independent enables us... Like, we own the building that we're in.
I've got a team of really good people. They've all got families. We love sales. It's the best. Like, when deals are on and you can put them together, it's great. But I think...
Um, I think, I think having, being out of that high pressured sales formula allows you to be a little bit more human. Um, and to be honest with you, like, I don't want to, again, I don't want to sound like I'm trying to sound like the angel of real estate.
I just don't like if you live and work in an area, um, it's nice to be able to bump into people and they go, yeah, you know, he was good to work with. We made a mistake. We should have taken his advice. We didn't. But I think franchises can be quite limited.
And I think that's why now you see the rise of models like the agency, which has agents being able to work with a little bit more of their own sort of independence within that model. But for us, I mean, we We sort of love where we are.
We have Halloween at the office, Christmas at the office. The newsletter wouldn't get past, I'm sure, the editing suites of Bell and McGrath.
So, yeah, but I don't know, Chris, maybe one day if they come in and the helicopter over the top with the box of cash and they say, we're going to drive you out of town, then we'll talk. But I think independence just enables us to be, you know, completely independent of society.
of, yeah, the whole franchise model.
It sounds a little like independence really suits your personality. Like, you know, you do see these things, you do have a certain turn of phrase and you do have a, despite the fact you've been, you know, well and truly indoctrinated in the industry, you've been in it since 19...
25 years, like you haven't had a career outside of this industry, but you still do appear to have a perception of it or a view of it that is less, it's more, what's the word, it's more 360 degree. You know what I mean? You're not totally immersed in it.
You can't see it the way outsiders would see it. And I think that's what makes your newsletter quite refreshing because, you know, look, I've been in it 22 years as well, but, I mean, I was 31. I'm not giving away my, oh, I was in my 30s.
Very early 30s when I got into property. I was 17 when I got into property. You know, so I had some other perspective. But even so, in my early years, I remember, you know, rabbiting out and regurgitating the stuff that my colleagues were saying and I was learning.
And my friends from outside the industry were mocking me. And I'm like, that's healthy to be mocked when you say, at the end of the day, the market will determine the price, blah, blah, blah. All that stuff. Yeah, I mean, look, it's...
look i love the industry and chris touched on it before about the story um i i probably hopefully will get to a point where i can write a book and it's i the one thing i love about the job that i have is access to to people i've i've worked for supreme court judges i've done you know um i i didn't have a formal education my father died when i was quite young and i left school and went into real estate kind of because i had to like i kind of needed a job that could pay pretty well and
so it was at the time a bit of a i'll give this a crack and and so it wasn't it wasn't a it wasn't a destiny path but i think that working with people um when they're vulnerable um and it sounds cheesy but there's something really cool about working with um people when
like change is awful and and i think if you've bought and sold yourselves you know what it's like it's just it's not fun um but some of my best friends are former clients and they weren't good mates when we started out like one is a barrister and he always tells the story about when we met and he goes oh this bloke he was all swagger and all this and then over the sale of his home we really connected and just became good mates and you know recently did a trek together so i i
I'd say to people thinking about getting into real estate, that there's huge opportunity to come into the business and do well. And you can be yourself and you don't have to be a high pressure parrot, but you can't come in and do it in a year. Like it takes time.
It takes a long time to dislodge the dogs, to get rid of the top dogs selling 90% of the properties. But absolutely. I mean, same for here. I mean, You know, every time I meet a client, it's a bit more fun for me.
I do a lot of purchases, right, which is more about forward thinking. Let's make this happen. And you're probably dealing a lot more on the sale. So when things are happening that are forcing them to sell or, you know, it's a transition period. So it's a different end of the journey.
So, Dave, you've got, in that vein, a property Dumbo for us, a story that we can all learn from.
Yeah, so I thought about this and I actually talked to my colleagues and probably the best example I can give you is, this is from the buyer's side, a property Dumbo from the buyer's side, but we were selling a house for a lady who was in her early 90s and she'd been raised...
in this house. And she appointed us to sell it. We put it on the market. We had two purchases that wanted to buy it. One was an investment banker. One was a local mum with a couple of kids. And we got into a very competitive pre-auction bidding situation.
The investment banker on paper had a lot of tactical sort of prowess about negotiating. And he put an offer on the table that I'm sure you guys have heard the terms exploding bids. Like he put an offer on the table that blew up blew up at three o'clock that afternoon.
Otherwise he was walking away. And Joy, our vendor, Joy who's like this beautiful, beautiful older woman, all she cared about when I was selling the house was that her cat didn't get outside. And we,
We had that purchaser and then we had the other purchaser who offered $100,000 less but happened to bump into Joy on the street. And when I went down and sat down with her and said, here it is, These are the offers.
She looked at me and she said, I don't want to sell to him. I want to sell to the lady I met with the two little kids. And I said, no, that's madness. I'll be in trouble. Like, I can't sell the property for less. And she said, no, no, I'll ring my solicitor.
I'll let him know. You've told me everything, but I'm not selling to him. And I actually rang this. I hope I don't get in trouble for this. But I rang. I rang the purchaser and was like, mate, you need to back down. You need to unexplode your bid.
You need to take a very different sort of angle here because it's not going your way. And the property sold and sold to the other party. So I think the key learning for me or for the Dumbo thing is that you get more bees with honey.
It plays to be smart and not be heroic. And I think particularly when you're buying someone's home,
you're buying their story um yeah and how that trickles down to them often you know makes a big big difference to how it's perceived so yeah that'd be that'd be that'd be my uh that'd be my mate i've got one in a very similar vein a client of ours a very close client of ours um the owner was pretending she was a cleaner
And so they were buying the property and she sort of bumped into them pretending to be a cleaner and she judged who she was going to sell it on, how they dealt with her.
And the client was really nice and respectful and honored their presence and was, you know, smiley and things like that. She was dressed as a cleaner, had the stuff and everything. It was the owner.
um and generally when they the agent um sold the prop they said look she said i want to sell it to these guys as long as they're around the money and then they made an offer and she thought the offer was fair and she accepted it and then it was chaos for the agent um the person was offering more way more give them 150 grand more etc and then the vendor just held their price and just went ahead with the the deal with my client offered um
and so yeah absolutely people can sometimes vendors obviously just care about the price but um they wrote a letter in that situation as well explaining this is our situation um because they had a feeling that the house the owner might value that stuff just because yeah um the culture um
And so, yeah, sometimes it's not all about the money. It's the experience the vendor really wants out of the situation. Who makes an exploding offer to a 92-year-old woman and says, if you don't take it, I'm walking away? Like, she was like, mate, I've been here since both wars.
Like, it's kind of like...
I couldn't spend the $100,000. Well, this is the thing.
I actually, I caught up with her after the sale went through and she'd bought like a Dyson and she'd bought like this new grill and she was like minted, you know, because the house had sold for this huge price and she'd never had all this cash.
But yeah, I think the key learning in that is that... Men in particular, when they're negotiating, often sort of use aggression as an attempted tool and often it does not work. It's an interesting one.
And it's funny because sometimes our clients will say, aren't you going to put a deadline on the offer? I'm like, the deadline has to have some meaning.
I'll put a deadline on the offer at 3 o'clock in the afternoon because you need to have that extra hour to go to the bank to get the money transferred so you can transfer the deposit. There's meaning behind that, but just threatening and posturing. And I have to confess, we've tried all that.
You know, I've been in this business long enough to have tried all those things, those tactics, and then it's like, you know, they don't work. They just get people offside.
And, you know, if you lose the purchase because you've been dick swinging, you know, or trying to, you know, it's like I've seen people at auction, you know, wait to the very last minute. You know, they're just holding out, holding out, holding out. Hammer falls, then they bid.
Imagine that conversation on the way home. Oh.
I bought a little house up the coast a few years ago and when I drove past, the sign was falling down and I rang the agent and I said, mate, and so this is me. And I rang him and said, did it go to auction?
He said, yeah, yeah, it went to auction about two months ago. And I said, what did it pass in at? And he's like, 800,000. Like, yeah, okay, well, we'll offer you 650. And he said, look, I'm just going to be honest with you.
If you want to buy this property, you're going to have to pay the ask. And for the next four weeks, I rang him every day, let him have it, deadline the offer and bid myself up. And we bought it for $800,000. That's gold. Well done.
And that agent, to this day, I always joke to him. I'm like, you played me like a fiddle because he didn't let his ego get into it. And I would bring him and go, they're crazy. He's like, if you want the house, this is the price. I love it.
And, you know, in the end, we paid it. Gold. Well, on that note, thank you so much. Yeah, thank you so much. Oh, pleasure. Thanks for having me on.
If you have a question that you'd like us to answer in an upcoming Q&A episode, you can send us a voicemail or written question via the website theelephantintheroom.com.au or you can email us directly at questions at theelephantintheroom.com.au.
If you like what you're hearing, please share this episode with others you feel would benefit. And while you're at it, why not leave us an iTunes review? Five stars would be great.
I know that sounds a bit cringy, but we have it on good authority that every review helps make it easier for other people to find out about us and hear what our amazing guests have to say.
David Murphy started in real estate at 19, nearly 25 years ago, and set up his own agency in Mosman in 2007. On his first day, he says, the people he worked with used him as a dummy bidder at an auction.
The weekly newsletter he is known for began as an internal memo to staff, part joke and part crack at local competitors, until his office manager said it should go out properly. It now has more than 20,000 subscribers, and he calls it a car he does not know how to drive.
His explanation is that real estate carries so much spin that people are hungry to hear it plainly. He tells new team members not to try to be a superstar, just to sit down and be honest. Complaints still arrive, often from agents sitting in his database who never identify themselves.
Murphy's view is that the trouble starts when a seller invites three trained, charming salespeople into the living room and tries to pick between them. He is candid about the incentive: when you badly want a listing, telling the truth can cost you it, because the next agent through the door will quote higher.
The majority of people chose the real estate agent they disliked the least, which I found quite tragic.
David Murphy, 7:07
The test he describes is a fee scale. If an agent says the house is worth three million when everyone else says two and a half, the seller offers a higher percentage for hitting three, then asks that agent to draw the scale and present it. The steps reveal the number the agent actually expects.
He took a related idea to a realestate.com.au think tank: track what each agent quotes on day one against what the property sells for, and publish an accuracy ratio. The room erupted. He also noted Fair Trading put his own agency under the microscope in 2022, after falling prices moved its price guides.
When buyers start their buying journey they have an unrealistic picture of what they can buy, and when sellers start their selling journey they generally have an unrealistic picture of what they'll get, and agents live in that space in between.
David Murphy, 15:34
Murphy argues a property's shortfalls are better aired before a campaign than halfway through it. The agency won a lot of sales in 2022 as the second agent, having told owners the price was not there because of the stairs. Buyers now walk away over a missing boundary fence, in a market he put at roughly 15 per cent off the previous year's highs. Updated: Sydney is in another correction, with values down 1.4 per cent in August 2026 and 7.1 per cent below their February 2026 peak, a steeper post-peak fall than the 6.6 per cent recorded over the same stretch of the 2022-23 downturn (Cotality, released 31 August 2026).
Presentation is his other bugbear. Vendors who will not lift a finger to get a property ready are costing themselves money, and the office has noticed that styled sale listings lease immediately on the same photos.
Most buyers have 15 to 20 minutes in your house and then they're forced to make a major decision.
David Murphy, 40:41
Asked whether agents favour particular buyers, Murphy said many favour one who has a property to sell. A purchaser who owns the semi around the corner and will hand over the listing is offering two deals rather than one. His point for sellers is to ask where a described buyer is coming from.
It scares him, he says, how much power a sales agent holds between the market and the vendor. Buyers who talk a price down loudly at an open home can find a week later that the same agent holds the house they want.
On offers, he tells friends who have written something and heard nothing for three days to send it to the vendor's solicitor. He calls that risky, but says either the agent is lazy or something is not right.
Murphy calculated that about 20 per cent of transactions in his market involve a buyer's agent, and used one himself for a Queensland investment purchase. He is blunt about the off market pitch, calling most of that stock overpriced, and unimpressed by anyone charging 2 per cent who skips Saturday opens. He separates searching from bidding, saying he still gets anxious walking up a driveway after bidding for half his life. Morgan's answer was that the value sits in bridging that power gap. The searching half is where the portals dominate, and Cameron Kusher took the hosts through what the biggest portal sees in its listing and search data as five capital cities pull in different directions.
The episode's property Dumbo came from a sale for a woman in her early 90s. An investment banker put an exploding offer on the table, expiring at three that afternoon; a local mother of two who had met the vendor in the street offered a hundred thousand dollars less. The vendor chose the mother, and Murphy rang the banker to unexplode his bid.
| Element | Figure as described | What it is meant to reveal |
|---|---|---|
| Agent's appraisal | $3 million | The number used to win the listing |
| Other agents' appraisals | $2.5 million | Where the rest of the market sits |
| Average fee mentioned | 2% | The going rate in the example |
| Fee offered for achieving $3 million | 2.5% | Bait for the agent to build a scale |
| Top step the agent then draws | about $2.7 million | What the agent privately expects |
As described at 7:58 to 8:52. Figures are the hypothetical ones used on air.
| Buyer's situation | Murphy's view on air | Reason he gave |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial, with time to search | Does not need one | Most of the market is on the portals |
| Time poor and happy to pay | There is value | Someone on the ground for you |
| Unfamiliar interstate market | Worked for him | Used one for a Queensland investment |
| First time as a registered bidder | Pay someone to bid or stand beside you | You are vulnerable and overwhelmed |
| Share of his local sales involving one | about 20% | His own calculation, so they are here to stay |
As discussed at 43:21 to 45:47. Views as stated on air.
This episode is a reminder that the agent in the room has their own incentives, and that the numbers quoted early are not always the numbers that settle. Sorting out what an investment property loan will actually support is what decides how you handle the quote you are given.
Investment Property Mortgage BrokerSources referenced: The Elephant in the Room Property Podcast, episode 261, "An Honest Real Estate Agent... No, Really!", released 2023-01-01. Hosts: Veronica Morgan and Chris Bates (Alcove). Guest: David Murphy, Sydney real estate agent and independent agency principal. Figures are quoted as stated on air. Figures marked as updated were re-checked on 10 September 2026.




